Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Bad devices are rarely the problem when it comes to garden irrigation. More often, people buy the wrong system. A single hose on an outdoor tap does not need a controller for solenoid valves. In most gardens, an irrigation timer attached directly to the tap is enough, and here the new Gardena smart Water Control is, according to the manufacturer, the most flexible way to get started. It works via Bluetooth without an extra device. Later, it can move into the smart home with the Gardena Gateway.
First decision: the tap
Wireless features and voice control come later. First, the down-to-earth points count, because they decide whether the device switches reliably in summer. Most outdoor taps are 26.5 mm (G 3/4) or 33.3 mm (G 1). Gardena rates its devices for 0.5 to 12 bar, Eve the Aqua for 1 to 5 bar. If your tap is fed by a high-pressure domestic water pump, check this beforehand.
Second decision: one line or two, wireless or hub
Lawn and beds rarely need the same amount of water. Two outlets on one device save you a second timer.
Bluetooth only works within range; Gardena cites about 10 meters for its Bluetooth controller. Remote access from your vacation always requires a hub in the house. A rain pause via the app is standard. What really saves water is a sensor or a weather connection that skips scheduled runs.
And the battery? Gardena and Hozelock describe a lockout that prevents new watering from starting when the battery is low. A valve that stays open is the most expensive failure there is in the garden.
Frost, Matter and two farewells
An irrigation timer is a summer device. For the smart Water Control, Gardena writes that frost and ice at temperatures below zero can damage irrigation devices; the smart app therefore issues warnings based on the weather forecast. Eve states an operating temperature of 4 °C and above for the Aqua. Our advice: before the first frosty night, unscrew it, drain the water, remove the batteries and store the device somewhere frost-free. That applies to all the models here.
A lot gets promised in the smart home. Neither Gardena nor Eve mentions Matter on the product pages of the irrigation timers presented here. The Eve Aqua communicates via Thread and Bluetooth and works with Apple Home. Gardena connects its smart devices to Apple Home, Alexa and Google Home via the Gateway. If several systems need to work together, we explain the basics in our article on choosing the right smart home hub.
Two well-known names are deliberately missing. According to its own website, Kärcher no longer carries the WT 5 and SensoTimer ST 6 irrigation timers in its current range. And Hozelock announces in its app that the Cloud Controller will stop working at the end of April 2027. Buying one new makes no sense.
Six irrigation timers and controllers side by side
| Model | Control | Key specs according to the manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gardena smart Water Control (19033-20) | Bluetooth app or smart app with Gateway | 3 cycles/day via Bluetooth, 36 with smart app; 0.5–12 bar; 3 × AA | Most gardens with one line |
| Gardena smart Dual Water Control (19034-20) | as above, two valves | two zones with their own schedules; 0.5–12 bar; 3 × AA | Lawn and beds separately |
| Gardena Bluetooth water control (1889-20) | Bluetooth, about 10 m | 3 cycles/day; sensor port; 9 V battery | App without Gateway, with soil moisture sensor |
| Eve Aqua | Bluetooth and Thread, Apple Home | up to 7 times/day; 1–5 bar; IPX4; 2 × AA | iPhone households |
| Hozelock Sensor Controller Plus (2214) | Buttons, daylight sensor | schedules by sunrise and sunset; 2 × AA | Anyone who does not want an app |
| Rain Bird ESP-BAT-BT | Bluetooth app, controller for valves | 1, 2, 4 or 6 stations; rain sensor port; 4 × AA | Permanently installed systems in a valve box |
Gardena smart Water Control
According to Gardena, the new generation with the number 19033-20 works with either the Bluetooth app or the smart app. Without the Gateway, three watering cycles a day are possible; with the Gateway, up to 36, plus weather data, frost warnings and connection to Apple Home, Alexa and Google Home. The appeal lies in the path in between. You buy something simple today and upgrade when the lawn becomes more demanding. However, the Gateway costs extra and needs a stable internet connection.
Gardena smart Dual Water Control
Technically the same concept, but with two valves. According to Gardena, each gets its own schedule. If you run a sprinkler and a drip hose from one tap, you save yourself a splitter and a second timer. For a single hose to the patio, however, it is overkill.
Gardena Bluetooth water control
The older model remains in the range. Its advantage is easily overlooked: a port for the Gardena soil moisture sensor. If the soil is still moist, the scheduled run is canceled. Three cycles a day and just under eight hours of run time are enough for home gardens. There is no remote access; the app only connects when you are near the tap.
Eve Aqua
Eve clearly builds the Aqua for Apple Home. According to Eve, the schedules are stored on the device itself, so watering continues even without an iPhone or internet. For remote access and automations, you need a HomePod or Apple TV as a home hub. Android users are in the wrong place here, and so is anyone with water pressure above 5 bar.
Hozelock Sensor Controller Plus
No app, no wireless connection, no accounts. According to the manufacturer, the Hozelock aligns watering with sunrise and sunset using a daylight sensor and thus adapts to the season. According to the instructions, after a battery change it needs about six hours to recognize the daylight pattern. If all you want is reliable watering in the morning and evening, this simple solution is enough. In price, it stays well below the Gardena smart models.
Rain Bird ESP-BAT-BT
Not a tap timer, but a battery-powered controller for solenoid valves in the ground. Rain Bird lists four programs with eight start times each, a rain delay of 1 to 14 days and a direct port for the RSD-BEX rain sensor. According to the data sheet, the batteries last three to five years. It makes sense for pop-up sprinklers in the lawn. If you are also planning a robotic mower without a boundary wire (in German), it is best to plan sprinkler heads and mowing times together right away. It is not suitable for a hose on the tap.
The path in three questions
Are there permanently installed sprinklers with a valve box in the ground? Then the Rain Bird ESP-BAT-BT. Everyone else stays at the tap.
There, the question is the smartphone. Without an app and on a tight budget, the Hozelock Sensor Controller Plus is enough. If Apple Home is a given, go for the Eve Aqua. If you want to save water without a Gateway, take the Gardena Bluetooth water control with the soil moisture sensor.
That leaves the number of lines. One tap, one line, maybe smart home later: Gardena smart Water Control. Lawn and beds separately: Gardena smart Dual Water Control.
If you sit in the garden in the evening anyway, you can bundle irrigation with smart outdoor lighting in a single app. It is not necessary, though.
Frequently asked questions
What should you look for when buying an irrigation timer?
First, the tap: most outdoor taps are 26.5 mm (G 3/4) or 33.3 mm (G 1). Then the water pressure: Gardena states 0.5 to 12 bar, Eve 1 to 5 bar for the Aqua. After that, what counts is the number of watering lines and whether you need remote access.
Can you control an irrigation timer while on vacation?
Only with a hub in the house. Bluetooth only works within range; Gardena cites about 10 meters for its Bluetooth controller. For remote access, the Gardena smart Water Control needs the Gateway, and the Eve Aqua needs a HomePod or Apple TV as a home hub.
Does an irrigation timer really save water?
A rain pause via the app is standard. What really saves water is a sensor or a weather connection that skips scheduled runs. The Gardena Bluetooth water control has a port for this, for the soil moisture sensor: if the soil is still moist, the scheduled run is canceled.
What happens to an irrigation timer in winter?
According to Gardena, frost and ice can cause damage, and Eve states an operating temperature of 4 °C and above for the Aqua. Before the first frosty night, unscrew it, drain the water, remove the batteries and store the device somewhere frost-free. That applies to all the models presented.
Is there an irrigation timer without an app?
The Hozelock Sensor Controller Plus works without an app, wireless connection or accounts. According to the manufacturer, it aligns watering with sunrise and sunset using a daylight sensor. After a battery change, it needs about six hours to recognize the daylight pattern.
Does the Eve Aqua work with Matter or Android?
Neither Gardena nor Eve mentions Matter on the product pages of the devices presented. The Eve Aqua communicates via Thread and Bluetooth and is clearly built for Apple Home; Android users are in the wrong place there. Gardena connects its smart devices to Apple Home, Alexa and Google Home via the Gateway.
Sources
- Gardena: smart Water Control (19033-20)
- Gardena: smart Dual Water Control (19034-20)
- Gardena: Bluetooth water control (1889-20)
- Gardena: smart system FAQ (smart home connection)
- Eve: Eve Aqua
- Hozelock: Sensor Controller Plus
- Hozelock app: notice on the end of the Cloud Controller
- Rain Bird: ESP-BAT-BT, technical specifications (PDF)
- Kärcher: WT 5 irrigation timer (no longer in the range)
Where to buy
- Gardena smart Water Control 19033-20Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.deView at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: Coolblue
- Gardena smart Dual Water Control 19034-20Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Gardena Bewässerungssteuerung Bluetooth 1889-20Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Eve AquaCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Hozelock Sensor Controller PlusCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Rain Bird ESP-BAT-BTCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
