Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet
This page in 6 more languages

DeutschNederlandsFrançaisItalianoEspañolPolski

Key Safe: Combination Lock or App for Caregivers and Guests

Key safes for home care services, vacation guests and tradespeople: when a combination lock is enough, when an app-controlled box helps, and how the box stays securely on the wall.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Master Lock 5401EURD key safe with combination lockImage: ELV (Pressebild)
Contents11 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

The home care service arrives at 6:30 in the morning, the vacation guests do not land until around midnight, and the tradesperson has announced „sometime in the morning.“ In every case, someone needs a key without you standing next to them. For most households, a mechanical key safe with four combination wheels such as the Master Lock 5401EURD is enough. An app-controlled box is only worth the effort when constantly changing people need to get in.

If no key is to be handed over at all, a smart lock with a code keypad is the alternative. Which keypad suits which lock is covered in the smart lock keypad guide.

One thing up front. A key safe is a compromise between convenience and security, not a miniature vault. Keep that in mind and you will choose the location more wisely and not buy more technology than necessary.

Combination wheel, app or no key outside the door at all?

There are three approaches. A mechanical key safe opens with a fixed code that you set yourself. It needs no power and no connection. Its weak point is in people’s heads: anyone who knows the code once knows it until you change it. Smart boxes, by contrast, give every visitor their own code that expires after a number of days or after one opening, and they keep a log. In return, they depend on batteries.

The third approach is the most radical. With an electronic door lock and a keypad at the door, there is no key outside at all. That does, however, require your lock cylinder to be suitable for a retrofit lock. What to watch for is covered in our smart lock guide.

When buying, these points matter most:

  • Interior size: a car key with a remote does not fit in every box. Measure the thickest bunch of keys that needs to go in.
  • Mounting: good boxes are screwed through the back wall from the inside, and the screws are hidden when the door is closed.
  • Weather protection: a cover over the combination wheels keeps dirt and rain out. Even so, ABUS, Burg-Wächter and igloohome only intend their boxes for sheltered outdoor areas.
  • Emergency opening for electronic models: check beforehand how the box opens when the battery is dead.

What do insurers and the police say?

This is where it gets uncomfortable. On July 5, 2023 (case no. IV ZR 118/22), Germany’s Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) upheld the so-called extended key clause in German home contents insurance. If a thief opens the home with a genuine key that was stolen beforehand, it only counts as an insured burglary if you did not make the theft of the key possible through negligence. That case was about a bag in a car, not a key safe. But the logic hits exactly this question: if someone gets at the key in the box without force, you may have to prove that you were careful.

Whether your insurer considers a box on the outside wall sufficiently careful is governed solely by your policy terms. Ask in writing before you install it, and keep the answer.

A sober assessment comes from Switzerland. According to an April 2025 report by Swiss broadcaster SRF, simple key safes can be opened with everyday tools in a few minutes, and smart models are said to be no more robust. In that report, the crime prevention officer of the Vaud cantonal police advises mounting the box out of sight, changing the code regularly, never attaching a name or address to the key, and not leaving a key in the box during longer absences. We would sign off on those four rules. The manufacturers of the boxes presented here do not name a certification for break-in resistance in their documentation.

Six solutions compared

ModelOpeningPower and emergencyBest for
Master Lock 5401EURD4 combination wheels, 10,000 codesno power neededFamily, home care service, neighbors
Burg-Wächter Key Safe 30 SB4 combination wheels, protective coverno power neededas above, with a cover over the wheels
ABUS KeyGarage One 7876-digit code or smartphone2 × AA, compartment accessible from outsidechanging services, many keys
Master Lock 5441EURDBluetooth or keypad codeCR123A, emergency power via 9-volt batterysmall rental, log wanted
igloohome Keybox 3PIN (also time-limited) or Bluetooth4 × AAA, emergency power via USB-CVacation rental without Wi-Fi
Nuki Keypad 2 NFCCode, fingerprint, NFCBattery, at least 12 months according to NukiHouseholds with a Nuki Smart Lock

Master Lock 5401EURD

According to the data sheet, behind it is an aluminum housing with a concealed hinge and a reinforced inner compartment, and the four-digit combination can be chosen freely. Inside, the box measures 6.4 × 9.2 × 3 cm; that is enough for a few house keys, but a bulky car key gets tight. A cover protects the wheels, and mounting hardware is included.

Keep one thing in mind. Master Lock does not know your code and cannot reset it. If it is forgotten and the box is mounted, according to the manufacturer a locksmith has to step in, at your expense.

Burg-Wächter Key Safe 30 SB

The German alternative, with a sliding cover over the four combination wheels. The manual is refreshingly specific: mount with the hinge at the bottom, fix it with a 6 mm drill bit and wall plugs, and choose an inconspicuous, sheltered spot with enough light. The factory code is 0-0-0-0, and it is changed using a reset pin while the box is open. Here, too, the manufacturer says: if the code is lost, the box can no longer be opened.

ABUS KeyGarage One 787

Designed for whole bunches of keys. ABUS states room for up to 20 keys, three car keys or 30 cards, plus two hooks. It opens with a six-digit personal code or via an invitation to a smartphone, managed through the HomeTec Pro Bluetooth or ABUS One apps with an event log. The keypad is illuminated, and you change the two AA batteries from the outside. Remote access is only available with the separately sold Bridge One. In the data sheet, ABUS promises security updates until at least May 2027, which you should factor in for a purchase meant to last many years.

Master Lock 5441EURD

Master Lock’s smart wall box opens via the app or with a primary code on the keypad. Power comes from a CR123A cell. When it runs low, the box notifies you by email, in the app or with a yellow light. If it is completely dead, the manual says to hold a 9-volt battery against contacts on the underside and then open the box. Practical, as long as you remember that such a battery must not be kept inside the box.

igloohome Keybox 3

Built for hosts. Codes can be issued permanently, for a time period, for one-time use or on a recurring basis, without the box needing to be online. According to the data sheet, the compartment measures 108 × 87 × 27 mm inside, the box weighs about one kilogram, and the housing is made of zinc and aluminum alloy. Four AAA batteries are said to last up to twelve months; when the set is empty, a USB-C port provides emergency power. After several incorrect entries, the keypad locks. Despite IP66, igloohome recommends a sheltered mounting location, and the batteries are only rated from −10 to 50 °C. Where winters regularly bring double-digit sub-zero temperatures, that gets tight.

Nuki Keypad 2 NFC

Strictly speaking, not a key safe but the route without a key. The keypad controls a Nuki Smart Lock; according to Nuki, the Matter-capable models Ultra, Pro, Go and the fourth generation. Up to 200 time-limitable codes and 20 fingerprints are possible, plus opening via NFC with a phone or watch. Protection rating IP54. If the keypad is stolen, Nuki replaces it in exchange for a copy of the police report and the invoice. Without a smart lock on the door, it is of no use to you.

Who should choose what?

  • Home care service and family with fixed people: Master Lock 5401EURD or Burg-Wächter Key Safe 30 SB. No battery that dies at the wrong moment. Change the code as soon as a staff member leaves.
  • Vacation rental with many guests: igloohome Keybox 3. Every guest gets their own code that expires on its own, and you do not have to reset anything after a stay.
  • Many keys, several services: ABUS KeyGarage One 787, because according to ABUS the compartment holds up to 20 keys and the log shows who was there and when.
  • If you already use a Nuki Smart Lock: Nuki Keypad 2 NFC instead of a box. Then there is no key hanging outside at all.

And no matter which model: a key tag with your address has no place in any box. If you also want to keep an eye on the front door, you will find advice in our video doorbell guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a mechanical and a smart key safe?

A mechanical key safe opens with a fixed code and needs neither power nor a connection, but anyone who knows the code knows it until it is changed. Smart boxes give every visitor their own code that expires, and they keep a log. In return, they depend on batteries.

Does home contents insurance pay out with a key safe?

That is governed solely by your policy terms. In 2023, Germany's Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) upheld the extended key clause: a burglary using a stolen genuine key is only covered if the theft was not made possible through negligence. Ask in writing before installing and keep the answer.

How secure is a key safe?

It remains a compromise between convenience and security. According to a report by Swiss broadcaster SRF, simple key safes can be opened with everyday tools in a few minutes, and smart models are said to be no more robust. The Vaud cantonal police advise a hidden location, regular code changes, no name on the key and an empty box during longer absences.

What should you look for when buying a key safe?

First measure the thickest bunch of keys, because a car key with a remote does not fit in every box. Good boxes are screwed through the back wall from the inside. A cover over the combination wheels keeps dirt out, and with electronics, the emergency opening when the battery is dead matters.

What happens if you forget the code?

With mechanical boxes, it gets annoying. Master Lock does not know the code and cannot reset it; then, according to the manufacturer, a locksmith has to step in, at your own expense. Burg-Wächter also states that the box can no longer be opened if the code is lost.

Is it possible to have no key outside the door at all?

With an electronic door lock and a keypad, there is no longer a key outside. The Nuki Keypad 2 NFC controls a Nuki Smart Lock with up to 200 time-limitable codes and 20 fingerprints. The prerequisite is that your lock cylinder is suitable for a retrofit lock.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.