Black Friday week runs until November 30: our pick in each buying guide
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,750 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Hair styling for men: paste, wax, pomade or clay? How hold, shine and washability relate to each other, and which product suits which hair.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026

Editorial selection based on research, not tested by us. Reasons and limitations are in the text.

Contents11 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

With their first jar of pomade, most men look at hold and shine. In the shower that evening, they find out what they overlooked: some products come out with one wash, others are still in your hair the next morning. If you want to wear your cut natural and without shine, a water-based matte pomade such as Hey Joe Matt is a good place to start. According to the manufacturer, it washes out without residue in a single wash.

If you are after the combed look with shine, reach for the Strong from the same line. And for short hair with plenty of texture, there are clays that hold more firmly. More on that shortly.

Wax, pomade, paste, clay: does the name even mean anything?

Less than the tins suggest. Taft sells a product called Forming Clay and describes it on its own website as a hair styling paste. Hey Joe calls its clay product „Genuine Hair Pomade Matt Clay,“ putting pomade and clay in one name. Still, the terms work as a rough guide: pomades are mostly aimed at combed styles such as a side part or a quiff, pastes and clays at a matte, tousled result. Waxes sit somewhere in between.

The information on hold and finish is more reliable than the name. Hey Joe grades its pomades from medium-high to high hold and states for each whether the result is shiny or stays matte. Information like this is easy to compare within one brand. Between two brands, only roughly, because every manufacturer applies its own standards.

What washes out in the shower?

This is where the products really differ. According to the manufacturer, the three Hey Joe pomades in this overview are water-based and can be removed with a normal hair wash without leaving residue. On its product pages, Schwarzkopf makes no statement about washability for Taft Forming Clay and got2b Phenomenal Texture Clay. With products containing a lot of wax or petroleum jelly („Petrolatum“ on the packaging), expect to shampoo thoroughly, possibly twice.

Taking a look at the ingredient list makes sense anyway. In early 2026, Öko-Test, a German consumer magazine, had hair gels for men tested and criticized, among other things, residues of mineral oil aromatic hydrocarbons (MOAH), some of which are considered carcinogenic. According to Öko-Test, the source is mostly petroleum-based fats and waxes. If you want to avoid them, look for names such as Paraffinum Liquidum, Petrolatum or Cera Microcristallina. Öko-Test also criticized synthetic polymers, which form a film around the hair for staying power and are in some cases poorly biodegradable. The study covered gels, not the products presented here.

How much hold does my hair need?

More hold is not automatically better. Fine hair is quickly weighed down by a very strong product, while thick hair needs some reserve. Our rule of thumb: if a quiff made of 6 to 8 centimeters of thick top hair is supposed to stay up until the end of the workday, reach for the strong version. For a short, loose cut, medium-high hold is usually enough.

How you apply it also changes the effect. Hey Joe and got2b recommend first rubbing a small amount between your palms and then working it in. According to Hey Joe, the result is shinier in damp hair. Use a little. You can always add more, but you cannot take any out.

If the cut itself is past its best, even the strongest tin will not help much. If you trim your own hair between two barber appointments, you will find tips in our guide to the right hair clipper (in German).

Five styling products for men compared

ModelHold and finish (according to the manufacturer)Base and washing outBest forOffer (affiliate link)
Hey Joe Genuine Hair Pomade Mattmedium-high hold, mattewater-based, washes out without residue in one washall hair types, natural look without shineAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Hey Joe Genuine Hair Pomade Strongstrong hold, dries to a medium-firm finish, shine in damp hairwater-soluble, washes out in one washcombed styles with shineAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Hey Joe Genuine Hair Pomade Matt Clayhigh hold, mattewater-based with white clay, washes out without residuelots of texture while keeping washing out easyAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
got2b Phenomenal Texture Claystrong hold, matte, defined finishvegan, no manufacturer statement on washing outmatte, textured looks, 100 mlAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Taft Forming Claystrong, remoldable hold, mattifyingvegan, no manufacturer statement on washing outdeliberately undone looks, 75 mlAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Want a second opinion before buying?Ask via WhatsApp

Hey Joe Genuine Hair Pomade Matt

According to the manufacturer, the white pomade is water-based and provides medium-high hold for a finish without shine. Hey Joe says it is suitable for all hair types. It is removed with a single wash and is not supposed to leave any residue. The jar holds 100 ml. For thick, unruly hair with a tall quiff, we would go one level stronger.

Hey Joe Genuine Hair Pomade Strong

The Strong is the shiny sibling. According to the manufacturer, it is water-soluble and creamy, provides strong hold and dries only to a medium-firm finish. According to the manufacturer, it is dermatologically tested. In damp hair, it gives more shine. Watch out when ordering: „Strong“ and „Super Strong“ are different products.

Hey Joe Genuine Hair Pomade Matt Clay

If you want more grip than the Matt offers, this is where you end up. According to the manufacturer, it is based on white clay, the hold is high and the result matte. Even so, the formula is water-based and is said to wash out with a light wash without leaving residue. Hey Joe recommends applying it to dry hair. In damp hair, it produces a slight shine.

got2b Phenomenal Texture Clay

According to the manufacturer, the clay delivers a matte, defined finish with strong hold. The formula is vegan, and the tin and lid are recyclable. Schwarzkopf states 86 percent ingredients of natural origin, with water at 60.1 percent included in that figure. It is applied to dry hair. The manufacturer describes the scent as powerful. If you are sensitive to fragrance, you should know that.

Taft Forming Clay

On Amazon it is listed as „Taft Paste Forming,“ at the manufacturer as Forming Clay. Taft describes a paste for undone looks with strong, long-lasting and remoldable hold and a mattifying effect. The formula is vegan, and the jar holds 75 ml. Put the ingredient lists side by side and something stands out: the first six ingredients are the same as in the got2b clay, including Japan wax, carnauba wax and a synthetic film former. If you are torn between the two, it is best to decide by scent and tin size.

Which tin suits which head?

  • Natural, matte look that washes out easily: Hey Joe Matt.
  • Side part or quiff with shine: Hey Joe Strong.
  • Short, thick hair with plenty of texture, easy washing out important: Hey Joe Matt Clay.
  • Tousled, matte short haircut with firm hold: got2b Phenomenal Texture Clay or Taft Forming Clay.

If you are putting together your basic kit anyway, you will find suitable additions in our guide to the men’s grooming set (in German). And if you blow-dry before styling, our hair dryer guide explains what matters when it comes to temperature and attachments.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between pomade, paste, wax and clay?

Less than the tins suggest. Taft itself describes its Forming Clay as a paste, and Hey Joe calls one product both a pomade and a clay. As a rough guide: pomades are aimed at combed styles such as a side part or a quiff, pastes and clays at a matte, tousled result, and waxes sit somewhere in between. The information on hold and finish is more reliable.

Which hair styling product washes out easily?

According to the manufacturer, the three Hey Joe pomades in the comparison are water-based and can be removed with a normal hair wash without leaving residue. Schwarzkopf makes no statement on this for Taft Forming Clay and got2b Phenomenal Texture Clay. With products containing a lot of wax or petrolatum, expect to shampoo thoroughly, possibly twice.

How much hold does my hair need?

More hold is not automatically better. Fine hair is quickly weighed down by a very strong product, while thick hair needs some reserve. If a quiff made of 6 to 8 centimeters of thick top hair is supposed to stay up until the end of the workday, the strong version is the right fit. For a short, loose cut, medium-high hold is usually enough.

How do you apply pomade correctly?

Hey Joe and got2b recommend first rubbing a small amount between your palms and then working it in. According to Hey Joe, the result is shinier in damp hair; clays are better applied to dry hair. Use a little: you can always add more, but you cannot take any out.

Which ingredients should you watch for in styling products?

In its test of hair gels for men, Öko-Test (a German consumer magazine) criticized, among other things, residues of mineral oil aromatic hydrocarbons, which mostly come from petroleum-based fats and waxes. If you want to avoid them, look for Paraffinum Liquidum, Petrolatum or Cera Microcristallina in the ingredient list. The study covered gels, not the products presented here.

What is the difference between Taft Forming Clay and got2b Phenomenal Texture Clay?

Less than you might think: the first six ingredients in the lists are the same, including Japan wax, carnauba wax and a synthetic film former. Both are vegan and offer strong, matte hold. The differences lie in the tin size, 100 ml for got2b and 75 ml for Taft, and in the scent, which got2b describes as powerful.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Still undecided?

Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.

Share this guide