Contents14 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A communication system has to suit your own group. Otherwise it is a bad buy, no matter how good the data sheet looks. If you ride alone or as a pair, you don’t need an expensive mesh flagship. If, on the other hand, you regularly ride with five or more people, there is hardly any way around mesh, and from the same brand as everyone else. Touring riders are usually on the safe side with the Sena 60S, and in Cardo groups with the Packtalk Edge. If you want to spend less and pure mesh is enough, the Sena Spider ST1 is an option.
Mesh or Bluetooth: what does my group need?
Classic Bluetooth intercom links helmets like a chain. That works well for two to four people, such as rider and passenger or a regular pair. If a rider in the middle falls behind, the chain breaks. For the 50S, Sena states a maximum of four participants for Bluetooth intercom.
Mesh works differently. Every device relays the signal, and the group organizes itself. Sena states up to 24 participants for Group Mesh, and for Open Mesh with six channels even a practically unlimited number. For its DMC mesh devices, Cardo states 15 or up to 31 riders, depending on the source.
The catch: mesh is not a shared standard. Sena lists only its own models as mesh partners for its devices. For other brands, Sena’s 60S manual describes the „Universal Intercom“ feature, which works with headsets from other manufacturers, provided they support the Bluetooth hands-free profile. No more than one third-party headset can connect directly with the 60S this way. So ask your fellow riders what they have in their helmets before you buy.
How far does the signal really reach?
Not as far as the data sheet says. The manufacturer figures apply in open terrain: Sena states 2 km for the 60S, Cardo up to 1.6 km between two riders for the Packtalk Pro. In forests, in town or behind crests, that shrinks considerably. With mesh, the group can spread out further because every device acts as a relay. For Open Mesh, Sena calculates up to 8 km, but with at least six riders spaced 1.6 km apart.
Will the battery last a full day’s ride?
With the 60S, yes. Mesh does use more power than Bluetooth: for the 60S, Sena states 17 hours of mesh versus 24 hours of Bluetooth intercom. That covers a long day’s ride. Several days without a power outlet, no.
Navigation, music and conversation at the same time?
The keyword is „Audio Multitasking.“ It lets you hear navigation prompts and music while a conversation is running. According to the manual, the 60S automatically lowers the music during a conversation; you set how much in the app.
It is loud under a helmet. The German automobile club ADAC cites around 84 to almost 95 dB(A) at 100 km/h, depending on the helmet. Larger speakers help with intelligibility but do not replace hearing protection. And in winter gloves, a large rotary dial is easier to hit than three small buttons. Also check your helmet, because the speakers have to fit into the ear pockets. How to find a helmet with good pockets and quiet acoustics is explained in our motorcycle helmet guide.
Are you allowed to make phone calls on a motorcycle?
Yes, with restrictions. Under § 23 (1a) of the German Road Traffic Regulations (StVO), anyone driving a vehicle may only use a phone or navigation device if it is neither picked up nor held for that purpose and only voice control and read-aloud functions are used, or a brief glance is enough. A helmet headset that you operate by voice command or a button on the helmet meets the first condition, because the phone is not held. Pulling the phone out of your jacket pocket does not. The ADAC writes that calls via a Bluetooth headset are allowed, whereas taking the phone in your hand is prohibited.
A second point is often overlooked. § 23 (1) StVO requires that vision and hearing are not impaired by devices. If you turn the music up so loud that sirens and horns get drowned out, you are on thin ice. Other countries have their own rules.
Six current communication systems compared
| Model | Connection | Manufacturer specs | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sena 60S | Mesh 3.0 (and 2.0), Bluetooth, Wave | 2 km, 24 participants, 17 h mesh, IPX7, 40 mm speakers | Touring riders in changing groups |
| Cardo Packtalk Pro | DMC mesh, 2nd generation, Bluetooth | up to 1.6 km, 45 mm JBL speakers, crash detection, 13 h, IP67 | High-mileage riders with a Cardo group |
| Cardo Packtalk Edge | DMC mesh, 2nd generation, Bluetooth | up to 1.6 km, 40 mm JBL speakers, 13 h, IP67, magnetic mount | Cardo riders who don’t need crash detection |
| Sena 50S | Mesh, Bluetooth, Wave | 2 km, 24 participants, 13 h mesh, rotary dial | Sena groups on a smaller budget |
| Sena Spider ST1 | Mesh only | 2 km, 24 participants, up to 18 h, rotary dial | Group riders who don’t need Bluetooth intercom |
| Interphone U-Com 16 | Mesh 2.0, Bluetooth | up to 24 devices, swappable battery, IP67 | Budget-minded groups happy to swap batteries |
Sena 60S
Sena’s current top model communicates via Mesh 3.0 and switches to Mesh 2.0 in the app so that older Sena devices can keep up. According to the manufacturer, two complete helmet kits with speakers and microphone are included, which saves money when switching between a summer and a winter helmet. Sena now also offers a 60S EVO with Bose tuning and slightly longer talk time. It is missing from the table because we could not reliably confirm an offer for it on Amazon.
Cardo Packtalk Pro
Cardo’s flagship comes with 45 mm JBL speakers and crash detection, which according to Cardo notifies a stored emergency contact. This feature is the real reason for the Pro. Without it, you get almost the same technology with the Edge.
Cardo Packtalk Edge
The Edge uses the same DMC mesh as the Pro but has 40 mm speakers and no crash detection. The magnetic mount lets you remove the device quickly with gloves on. According to Cardo, you can also use the USB-C port for charging while riding. The cheaper Packtalk Neo is technically closely related but has a click-in mount and, according to Cardo, a shorter warranty.
Sena 50S
The predecessor of the 60S is still in the lineup and offers mesh, Bluetooth intercom for four riders and speakers with Harman Kardon tuning. With 13 hours of mesh, the battery is noticeably smaller, and at 2.5 hours, the charging time is longer.
Sena Spider ST1
A pure mesh device with a large rotary dial. Classic Bluetooth intercom is missing, but it still connects to your phone for music, navigation and calls. According to Sena, it works with the brand’s mesh devices, while older Bluetooth-only headsets are left out. For group riders in a Sena circle, this is the cheapest way into mesh.
Interphone U-Com 16
The device from the Italian brand Interphone (Cellularline) combines Mesh 2.0 and Bluetooth. Its swappable battery is unusual: a spare battery in your pocket extends the runtime on long tours. Depending on the source, the manufacturer’s range figures vary between 1 and 1.6 km. Buyers in forums report good range but also charging problems. An alternative. Not the first choice.
Inexpensive Bluetooth devices from FreedConn, such as the FX series, can also be found on Amazon. The figures for range, battery and water protection vary widely between listings, and reliable manufacturer data is missing. That is why they are not in the table. For occasional rides as a pair, they may be enough.
So which device should it be?
- Your friends ride with Sena: Sena 60S, or on a smaller budget the 50S or the Spider ST1.
- Your friends ride with Cardo: Packtalk Edge. The Pro only if crash detection is worth the extra cost to you.
- Just rider and passenger: A mesh device is not a mistake, but not necessary. Bluetooth intercom is enough if both devices work well together.
- Multi-day tours without power: Interphone U-Com 16 with a second battery or a device that can be charged while riding.
In winter, the headset does not belong in a cold garage. Follow the storage instructions in your device’s manual. What else to do before the break is explained in our article on storing your motorcycle for winter (in German).
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between mesh and Bluetooth intercom?
Bluetooth intercom links helmets like a chain and works for two to four people; if one rider falls behind, the chain breaks. With mesh, every device relays the signal and the group organizes itself. Sena states up to 24 participants for Group Mesh, Cardo 15 or up to 31 riders, depending on the source.
Does Sena work with Cardo in mesh?
No, mesh is not a shared standard. Sena lists only its own models as mesh partners. Through the Universal Intercom feature, the 60S connects with headsets from other manufacturers, provided they support the Bluetooth hands-free profile, but directly with no more than one third-party headset. So ask your fellow riders before you buy.
How far does a motorcycle communication system reach?
Not as far as the data sheet says, because the figures apply in open terrain: Sena states 2 km for the 60S, Cardo up to 1.6 km for the Packtalk Pro. In forests, in town or behind crests, that shrinks considerably. With mesh, the group can spread out further because every device acts as a relay.
Will the battery last a full day's ride?
With the Sena 60S, yes: Sena states 17 hours of mesh and 24 hours of Bluetooth intercom. That is not enough for several days without a power outlet. For multi-day tours without power, the Interphone U-Com 16 with its swappable battery and a second battery is a good fit, or a device such as the Packtalk Edge, which according to Cardo can be charged while riding.
Are you allowed to make phone calls on a motorcycle via headset?
Under § 23 (1a) of the German Road Traffic Regulations (StVO), this is permitted as long as the phone is neither picked up nor held. A helmet headset operated by voice command or a button on the helmet meets this requirement; pulling the phone out of your jacket pocket does not. At the same time, your vision and hearing must not be impaired, so the music must not be so loud that sirens and horns get drowned out.
Is the Cardo Packtalk Pro worth it over the Edge?
Only if crash detection is worth the extra cost to you. According to Cardo, it notifies a stored emergency contact. Otherwise, the Edge offers the same DMC mesh, 40 mm speakers instead of 45 mm and a magnetic mount that can be removed quickly with gloves on.
Sources
- § 23 StVO (German Road Traffic Regulations), gesetze-im-internet.de
- ADAC: Phones at the wheel, rules and fines
- ADAC: Hearing protection for motorcyclists
- Sena 60S, manufacturer page
- Sena 60S, user guide (PDF)
- Sena 50S, manufacturer page
- Sena Spider ST1, manufacturer page
- Cardo Packtalk Pro, manufacturer page
- Cardo Packtalk Edge, manufacturer page
- Cardo: Packtalk Neo and Edge compared
- Interphone U-Com 16, manufacturer page
Where to buy
- Sena 60SCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Cardo Packtalk ProCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Cardo Packtalk EdgeCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Sena 50SCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Sena Spider ST1 (Einzelset)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Interphone U-Com 16Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
