Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Most pillows are bought for their filling. Down sounds like a hotel, foam like orthopedics. Both miss the point. What matters is the height, and that depends on your sleeping position and shoulder width. Mostly on your side? Then a height-adjustable foam pillow such as the Emma Classic Stützkissen (support pillow) is the right fit. If the whole pillow needs to go in the machine on a hot wash, the considerably cheaper Paradies Softy Top is the more likely choice.
Step one: how do you lie at night?
A pillow should fill the space between the mattress and your head so that head and spine lie as close to a straight line as possible. That space varies greatly depending on your position. So there cannot be one pillow for everyone.
- Side sleepers need the most height, because the shoulder has to be bridged. Broad shoulders need more than narrow ones.
- Back sleepers get by with medium height. A pillow that is too high pushes the chin toward the chest.
- Stomach sleepers usually do best with a flat, soft pillow or put only a little under their head.
- The mattress counts too. On a soft mattress, the shoulder sinks in deeper, so the pillow can be flatter. How firmness and comfort zones are related is explained in our mattress guide.
The right height can rarely be determined in the store. That is why adjustability is the most important feature. Removable layers or a zipper for adjusting the fill are worth a lot. In issue 9/2025, Stiftung Warentest, the German consumer testing organization, examined fourteen cervical support pillows. Only four of them provided good support in every position; others could hardly be adjusted or not at all. The testers also often found the memory effect of viscoelastic foams only weakly pronounced in the lab. Expensive does not mean suitable here.
Step two: the filling
Down and feathers can be scrunched and shaped. More feathers give more support. More down makes it softer. If you choose goose, pay attention to where the filling comes from, for example a commitment that no live plucking is used.
Fiber pillows are light, inexpensive and usually fully washable. With fiber balls and a zipper, the fill can be adjusted precisely. Over time, however, the filling loses loft.
Foam pillows keep their shape the longest and are the usual design for cervical support pillows. Usually only the cover may be washed. The foam core stays dry. Some people find the material firm and warm at first.
Latex is elastic and springs back instead of slowly giving way. The well-known latex pillows from Dunlopillo that still show up on Amazon are no longer listed in the range on the manufacturer’s German and French websites. As long as no current model is properly documented, we are not naming one.
Step three, for allergy sufferers: the washing temperature
The allergy information service of Helmholtz Munich (Allergieinformationsdienst) recommends washable pillows and duvets for people with a house dust mite allergy. According to this source, a wash at 60 °C every three months is enough. Mite-proof covers, known as encasings, can reduce the amount of allergens in the bed if an allergy already exists. For prevention, on the other hand, the service does not recommend them, because convincing studies are lacking.
That leads to a practical rule. With foam pillows, only the cover is washable, at 40 °C for Emma and Tempur according to the manufacturers. If you depend on 60 °C, you need a fully washable fiber or feather pillow or an encasing over the foam core. These sources do not say whether feathers or fiber are fundamentally better for allergy sufferers. If you have symptoms, the question belongs in a doctor’s office, not in the pillow aisle.
Five pillows compared
| Model | Filling | Care according to manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Emma Classic Stützkissen | Foam, 3 layers, 2 removable | Cover 40 °C, do not wash core | Side sleepers, also back and stomach sleepers |
| Emma Classic Flauschkissen | Microfiber in several layers | Cover 40 °C | Back and stomach sleepers |
| TEMPUR Shape SmartCool | Viscoelastic foam, contoured wave shape | Cover 40 °C, not in the dryer | Back and side sleepers who like it firm |
| Paradies Softy Top medium | Fiber balls, fill adjustable via zipper | Whole pillow up to 60 °C, dryer-safe | Allergy sufferers, budget-conscious buyers, all positions |
| allnatura Daunen-Kopfkissen Ansara | Goose feathers and down, 85/15 or 70/30 | Fully washable | If you want a moldable natural pillow |
Emma Classic Stützkissen
Three foam layers in a 40 × 80 cm format, two of them individually removable. Emma advises side sleepers to use two or three layers, back and stomach sleepers one or two. The cover is washable at 40 °C, the core is not. Emma states that the pillow received the grade „good“ (1.7 on the German school-grade scale) from Stiftung Warentest (issue 9/2025). This is the most straightforward way for most side sleepers to reach the right height. The manufacturer also offers a 30-night sleep trial.
Emma Classic Flauschkissen
The softer sibling (Flauschkissen, roughly „fluffy pillow“) is made of microfiber and comes in 40 × 80 and 80 × 80 cm. Here too, removable layers change the height. Emma itself sees the pillow mainly for back and stomach sleepers and refers side sleepers with broad shoulders to the support pillow. An honest note. It is worth taking seriously.
TEMPUR Shape SmartCool
The Shape is a classic cervical support pillow with a wave shape and a firm feel. Tempur sells it in sizes S, M and L (50 × 31 cm, height 8/5 to 11.5/8.5 cm) and as a wider Queen version. According to Tempur, the size depends on shoulder width: S up to about 44 cm, M up to 50 cm, L above that. The cover is washable at 40 °C. If you are used to softer pillows, plan for a period of getting used to it. And if you turn a lot at night, a firm wave shape remains a matter of taste anyway.
Paradies Softy Top medium
This fiber pillow is priced well below the foam models. It is filled with polyester fiber balls, half of them recycled, and the cover is made of organic cotton. Filling can be removed through the zipper. According to Paradies, the whole pillow is washable up to 60 °C and may go in the dryer. If you want more support, Paradies offers the Softy Top fest (firm) version with a 4 cm high side gusset.
allnatura Daunen-Kopfkissen Ansara
The Ansara (a down pillow) is filled with goose feathers and down, either in an 85/15 ratio for more support or 70/30 for a softer pillow. The cover is made of unbleached cotton. Allnatura gives an assurance that the filling does not come from live plucking and describes the pillow as fully washable. Allnatura does not state a washing temperature online. So check the label before the first wash.
Your path to the right pillow
Side sleepers should start with the Emma Classic Stützkissen and adjust the layers to their shoulder width. If you like firm contoured pillows, the TEMPUR Shape SmartCool is the alternative, with the size also chosen by shoulder width. In most cases, however, we find the extra cost over the Emma hard to justify.
Back and stomach sleepers should go for the Emma Classic Flauschkissen or the Ansara with 70/30 filling. With a house dust mite allergy or a tight budget, the Paradies Softy Top medium is a good option, because it can be washed completely at 60 °C.
Still unsure about the height? Choose a model with removable layers or a zipper. And keep an eye on the return periods.
Frequently asked questions
Which pillow suits side sleepers?
Side sleepers need the most height because the shoulder has to be bridged, broad shoulders more than narrow ones. For the Emma Classic Stützkissen, the manufacturer advises side sleepers to use two or three foam layers. With the TEMPUR Shape, size S, M or L depends on shoulder width.
What pillow height do back and stomach sleepers need?
Back sleepers get by with medium height; a pillow that is too high pushes the chin toward the chest. Stomach sleepers usually do best with a flat, soft pillow or put only a little under their head. The mattress counts too: on a soft one, the shoulder sinks in deeper.
Why is an adjustable pillow a good idea?
The right height can rarely be determined in the store. Removable layers or a zipper for adjusting the fill are therefore worth a lot. In issue 9/2025, the German consumer testing organization Stiftung Warentest examined fourteen cervical support pillows; only four provided good support in every position, and others could hardly be adjusted or not at all.
Which pillow is suitable for a house dust mite allergy?
The allergy information service of Helmholtz Munich recommends washable pillows; according to this source, a wash at 60 °C every three months is enough. With foam pillows, only the cover is washable. So you need a fully washable fiber or feather pillow or an encasing. If you have symptoms, have the question clarified by a doctor.
Down, fiber or foam: what is the difference?
Down and feathers can be shaped; more feathers give more support. Fiber pillows are light, inexpensive and usually fully washable, but lose loft over time. Foam pillows keep their shape the longest, but usually only the cover may be washed. Some people find foam firm and warm at first.
Sources
- Emma: Classic Stützkissen
- Emma: Classic Flauschkissen
- Tempur: Shape SmartCool pillow
- Paradies: Softy Top medium
- Paradies: Softy Top fest
- allnatura: Daunen-Kopfkissen Ansara
- Stiftung Warentest: Cervical pillows tested (issue 9/2025)
- Allergieinformationsdienst: Preventing house dust mite allergy
- Dunlopillo: Accessories (pillow range)
Where to buy
- Emma Classic StützkissenCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Paradies Softy Top mediumCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Emma Classic FlauschkissenCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- TEMPUR Shape SmartCoolCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- allnatura Daunen-Kopfkissen AnsaraCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
