Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Fish in a garden pond rarely freeze to death. They suffocate. Under a closed sheet of ice, no more oxygen can get into the water, and the decomposition gases from rotting plant matter stay trapped. What they need is an opening in the ice. For shallow ponds and long periods of frost, a pond heater with a thermostat switch such as the Oase IceFree Thermo 330 is the most reliable way; in deep ponds and mild regions, an inexpensive foam ice preventer is often enough.
Why the hole in the ice matters and the ax stays in the shed
Oase describes the problem clearly in the usage notes for its ice preventers: when dead plant matter decomposes, it produces decomposition gases that harm aquatic animals and pond plants. A closed sheet of ice keeps these gases in the water, and oxygen exchange no longer takes place. So an ice preventer is not meant to warm the pond. It is meant to keep a window open.
The reflex of breaking the ice with a hammer or ax after a cold night does harm. Velda warns that the vibrations from chopping the ice are very dangerous for pond fish. Oase, too, writes in a press release that anyone who takes an ax to the ice after hard frost puts their fish at risk. The fish stay at the bottom, where according to Oase the temperature remains around four degrees Celsius, and need to be left in peace there.
Depth matters too. Velda recommends at least 80 centimeters for fish ponds so that the fish can overwinter safely. Feeding in winter should be sparing: according to Velda, at most once a week when the water is colder than five degrees Celsius, and then with sinking winter food.
Foam, heating or air bubbles: the three approaches
- Foam ice preventers float on the water without electricity and keep an opening free beneath them. That works as long as the frost stays mild. Pontec gives minus 10 degrees Celsius as the limit for its model.
- Pond heaters are floating heating elements with 200 to 330 watts. According to Oase, they keep an area open down to minus 20 degrees Celsius and only warm the water locally. That costs electricity, because 330 watts in continuous operation add up to just under eight kilowatt hours a day.
- Aerators pump air through a hose to an air stone. According to Velda, the bubbles keep the spot above them free of ice, drive out harmful gases and bring oxygen into the water. The pumps only need a few watts.
One detail is often overlooked when buying. Velda advises against pumping water from the bottom to the surface, because that cools down the entire pond. For aerators, in our view, that means: do not place the air stone at the deepest point, where the fish are resting.
Power at the pond: nothing works without an RCD (German: FI-Schutzschalter)
Water and mains voltage are a dangerous combination. In the instructions for the IceFree Thermo devices, Oase requires the device to be protected by a residual current device with a rating of no more than 30 milliamperes. Extension cords and power strips must be suitable for outdoor use and splash-proof, and plug connections must be protected from moisture. According to the manufacturer, the electrical installation itself is a job for a qualified electrician. And before you reach into the water, disconnect all devices in the pond from the power supply.
Six ice preventers and pond heaters compared
Oase IceFree Thermo 330
According to Oase, the integrated thermostat switch turns the heater on at freezing point and off again above it. That saves electricity on mild days. Nobody has to keep an eye on the weather forecast. Oase gives minus 20 degrees Celsius as the operating limit and emphasizes that deeper water layers do not cool down. According to the manufacturer, how large the open area becomes depends on the output and the outside temperature, not on the size of the pond. Some buyers had expected a smaller hole.
Oase IceFree Thermo 200
Technically the little brother, with one crucial difference: according to the instructions, it heats continuously, without a thermostat switch. If you leave it plugged in all winter, you also pay on days above freezing. It only makes sense if you switch it on and off yourself when there is frost. Otherwise, it quickly uses up its small price advantage over the 330.
Oase IceFree 4 Seasons
Instead of heating, according to a specialist retailer’s data sheet, this small pump moves warmer water from the depths to the surface and thus keeps a small area open. Around 5 watts, so economical. In summer, it serves as a water feature. However, Oase requires a water depth of at least 80 centimeters, and it has no frost monitor. Since Velda warns specifically against circulating water from the depths, this device only belongs in truly deep ponds.
Velda Eisfreihalter Diskus mit Luftpumpe
A complete set (an ice preventer disc with air pump) consisting of an air pump, ten meters of air hose, an air stone and a floating disc. The air bubbles keep the spot open and exchange gases at the same time, which is exactly the goal in winter. In buyer reports, however, you can also read that the open area shrinks in hard frost. Where double-digit sub-zero temperatures are common, a heater is the safer choice.
Heissner Smartline Teichbelüfter HLT200
For this pond aerator, Heissner specifies 200 liters per hour at 2.5 watts, plus an air stone. According to the manufacturer, the pump helps keep an opening in the ice in winter. The restriction that the pump is not intended for outdoor installation also comes from the manufacturer. So you need a garden shed or a protected box near the pond, and the power cable is only 1.5 meters long.
Pontec PondoPolar
The classic made of foam, in two parts, without electricity. According to Pontec, gas exchange takes place through ventilation slots, and weighted with sand it sits stably in the water. Pontec gives minus 10 degrees Celsius as the limit. For a deep pond in a mild region, this is a sensible, very inexpensive solution. For shallow ponds stocked with fish in cold regions, it is not enough on its own.
How we would decide
- Fish pond under 80 centimeters or a harsh location: Oase IceFree Thermo 330. The thermostat switch limits electricity costs, and the operating limit of minus 20 degrees Celsius covers harsh winters as well.
- Small pond, power available, keeping an eye on costs: Velda Diskus or Heissner HLT200, if the pump can be kept dry. In severe frost, the hole tends to stay small.
- Deep pond, one device all year round: Oase IceFree 4 Seasons, keeping the minimum depth in mind.
- Without a power connection and in a mild winter, the Pontec PondoPolar is enough as an inexpensive starting point. During prolonged frost, check it in addition.
We only recommend the Thermo 200 if you want to switch it yourself anyway.
If more things in the garden need to stay frost-free, suitable devices are covered in our guide to frost protection heaters for greenhouses. The same applies to every device at the pond as there: outdoor power only via a protected outdoor socket.
What happens to underwater lights in winter and when they need to come out of the water is covered in our guide to pond lighting.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a garden pond need a hole in the ice in winter?
Fish rarely freeze to death; they suffocate. Under a closed sheet of ice, no more oxygen gets into the water, and decomposition gases from rotting plant matter stay trapped. An ice preventer is not meant to warm the pond, but to keep a window open for gas exchange.
Is it okay to break up the ice on the pond?
No. Velda warns that the vibrations from chopping the ice are very dangerous for pond fish, and Oase also advises against it. The fish stay at the bottom, where according to Oase the temperature remains around four degrees Celsius, and need to be left in peace there.
What is the difference between a foam ice preventer, a pond heater and an aerator?
Foam ice preventers float without electricity and work in mild frost; Pontec gives minus 10 degrees Celsius as the limit. According to Oase, pond heaters with 200 to 330 watts keep an area open down to minus 20 degrees Celsius. Aerators pump air to an air stone and only need a few watts, but the open area can shrink in hard frost.
How much electricity does a pond heater use?
330 watts in continuous operation add up to just under eight kilowatt hours a day. According to the manufacturer, the Oase IceFree Thermo 330 switches on at freezing point via its thermostat switch and off again above it, which saves energy on mild days. The Thermo 200, by contrast, heats continuously unless you switch it yourself.
What do you need to consider when connecting power at the pond?
Oase requires protection by a residual current device (RCD) with a rating of no more than 30 milliamperes. Extension cords and power strips must be suitable for outdoor use and splash-proof. According to the manufacturer, the electrical installation is a job for a qualified electrician, and all devices must be disconnected from the power supply before you reach into the water.
How deep should a fish pond be for winter?
Velda recommends at least 80 centimeters so that the fish can overwinter safely. Oase also requires this depth for the IceFree 4 Seasons pump because it moves water from the depths to the surface. According to Velda, when the water is below five degrees Celsius, feed at most once a week with sinking winter food.
Sources
- Oase: Instructions for use, IceFree Thermo 200/330
- Oase: IceFree Thermo 330
- Oase: IceFree 4 Seasons
- Oase Teichbau (German specialist retailer): IceFree 4 Seasons, technical data
- Aquapond (German specialist retailer): IceFree 4 Seasons
- Oase: Press release on the hole in the ice in winter
- Velda: Pond maintenance in December
- Velda: Fish pond
- Velda: Ice Preventer & Aerator Disc
- Heissner: Smartline Teichbelüfter 200 l/h
- Pontec: PondoPolar
Where to buy
- Oase IceFree Thermo 330Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Pontec PondoPolarCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Velda Eisfreihalter Diskus mit LuftpumpeCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Heissner Smartline Teichbelüfter HLT200Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Oase IceFree 4 SeasonsCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Oase IceFree Thermo 200Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.






