Contents10 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A weekend planned, a bag bought for three weeks at the beach. You end up hauling air around and still hunting for your toothbrush. No mistake happens more often with toiletry bags. Usually one with three to five liters, a hook for hanging and a lining you can wipe clean with a damp cloth is enough. Among current brand-name models, the Samsonite Stackd Toilet Kit meets this need most directly, because it also comes with a removable, transparent bag for liquids.
Think about the bathroom at your destination first, then the bag
Free shelf space is rare in hotel bathrooms. Kettle brochures sit by the sink, and the vacation rental has no shelf at all. So where does the bag live during the trip? That question matters more than any design.
- Size in liters: About 2 liters is enough for a toothbrush, razor and travel sizes. 5 liters also holds a hairbrush and large bottles. More than 7 liters is usually only needed by families who pack everything into one bag.
- Hanger: A hook that fits over doors and towel rails is worth more in a small hotel bathroom than any extra compartment. A simple loop, on the other hand, needs a wall hook.
- Water-repellent: The outer material keeps splashes off. A smooth inner lining matters more, because leaked shampoo ends up on the inside, not the outside.
As for compartments: fewer is faster. A dedicated toothbrush compartment and a few mesh pockets are enough, because too many small compartments make the bag heavy and packing slow. And the shape? Flat bags disappear into your suitcase, while standing models can be used open on the counter.
If an electric toothbrush is coming along, measure the charger beforehand. Many toothbrush compartments are cut for manual toothbrushes. Which models come with a travel case is shown in our toothbrush guide.
What really applies to carry-on luggage
The German Federal Police (Bundespolizei) summarizes the EU rules on its page „Flüssigkeiten an Bord“ (liquids on board), published on November 17, 2025. According to it, liquids may only go into carry-on luggage in containers with a capacity of no more than 100 ml. These containers must go into a transparent, resealable bag with a capacity of up to one liter, and each passenger may bring only one such bag. What counts is the capacity, not how full it is. So a half-empty 200 ml tube stays behind.
According to the German Federal Police, anything that is liquid, gel-like, creamy or pasty at room temperature counts as a liquid. Toothpaste, hair gel, perfume and shaving foam are named explicitly. At security, the bag must be taken out of your luggage and presented separately. Medications and special foods needed during the journey are exempt from the quantity limit, but the need must be credible, for example through a prescription or a doctor’s note. Different rules may apply outside the EU.
So the toiletry bag itself is no problem in carry-on luggage. Its contents are. A separate clear bag that you can pull out at security without opening the whole bag is practical. Manufacturers usually don’t say whether an included bag stays within the one-liter limit. When in doubt, a regular zip bag with a stated liter capacity will do.
Five toiletry bags and cosmetics cases compared
| Model | Size | Hanger | Special feature | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Samsonite Stackd Toilet Kit | 16.8 × 24.3 × 9.5 cm, 0.3 kg | Loop/hook | Removable clear bag | Air travel with carry-on luggage |
| Bellroy Hanging Toiletry Kit | 3 liters | Retractable aluminum hook | Stands, hangs or folds open flat | Hotel bathrooms without shelf space |
| Bellroy Toiletry Kit | 1.8 liters | not specified | Magnetic toothbrush compartment | Light luggage, short trips |
| Herschel Chapter Travel Kit | 5 liters | not specified | Waterproof zipper | Anyone looking for lots of space for little money |
| Tumi Alpha Hanging Travel Kit | 30 × 20.5 × 10.25 cm | Integrated hook | Ballistic nylon | Frequent flyers with a big budget |
Samsonite Stackd Toilet Kit
According to Samsonite, the Stackd measures 16.8 × 24.3 × 9.5 cm and weighs 0.3 kg. It has a hanging loop with a hook, a mesh pocket, a front pocket and a detachable, transparent zippered bag for liquids and cosmetics. That exact combination is what most competitors lack. One buyer complains that there is no mesh between the compartments and that the full bag opens awkwardly when hanging. On Amazon, the 24.3 cm version is currently unavailable (as of November 9, 2026); offered there instead is the slightly larger 26 cm Stackd in navy.
Bellroy Hanging Toiletry Kit
Its centerpiece is a retractable aluminum hook that, according to Bellroy, centers itself and fits over most doors, towel rails and shower screens. The bag stands upright, hangs or folds open flat. At the top there is a compartment for larger bottles, at the bottom a main compartment with a magnetic closure, plus a slim sleeve for a manual toothbrush. The lining is water-repellent and wipeable. On Amazon, there is also a larger Plus version with 8 liters.
Bellroy Toiletry Kit
The classic, lie-flat version is slim: 1.8 liters according to the retailer. The toothbrush goes in a compartment with a magnetic closure, smaller items in mesh pockets, and the lining can be wiped clean with a damp cloth. That is enough for a weekend. Not for a family vacation.
Herschel Chapter Travel Kit
At 5 liters, the Chapter is the roomiest bag in this field below the premium tier. Herschel lists a waterproof zipper, a zippered front pocket and an interior mesh pocket. A Weather Resistant version with a TPE coating is also available. Herschel doesn’t mention a hook, so the bag stays on the counter. On Amazon, it is priced well below Bellroy, Samsonite and Tumi.
Tumi Alpha Hanging Travel Kit
Tumi uses ballistic nylon for the Alpha series and specifies about 30 × 20.5 × 10.25 cm. The bag folds open into several compartments and has an integrated hook, a main compartment with a wraparound zipper and two zippered mesh compartments. Solidly made. For most travelers, though, it is still a lot of money for a toiletry bag that essentially does the same job as the Bellroy hanging model.
How we would decide
- Often traveling with carry-on only: Samsonite Stackd, because the liquids bag is already included. Check its size against the one-liter rule.
- Small hotel bathrooms: Bellroy Hanging Toiletry Kit with its sturdy hook.
- For light, short trips, take the Bellroy Toiletry Kit.
- The Herschel Chapter offers lots of space at a low price, as long as you can do without a hook.
- Traveling for work, and the bag should last a long time? Tumi Alpha, if the budget allows.
Two things rarely belong in a toiletry bag but are often forgotten. A small mirror for hotel bathrooms with poor lighting, with tips in our makeup mirror guide. And the question of whether the hotel provides a hair dryer. If not, our hair dryer guide helps you choose a travel model.
Frequently asked questions
How big should a toiletry bag be?
About 2 liters is enough for a toothbrush, razor and travel sizes. 5 liters also holds a hairbrush and large bottles. More than 7 liters is usually only needed by families who pack everything into one bag. A bag that is too big means hauling air around.
Which liquids are allowed in carry-on luggage?
According to the German Federal Police (Bundespolizei), only containers with a capacity of no more than 100 ml, packed in a transparent, resealable bag of up to one liter. Each passenger may bring one such bag. What counts is the capacity, not how full it is, so a half-empty 200 ml tube stays behind.
Does toothpaste count as a liquid on a plane?
Yes. According to the German Federal Police, anything that is liquid, gel-like, creamy or pasty at room temperature counts as a liquid; toothpaste, hair gel, perfume and shaving foam are named explicitly. Medications and special foods for the journey are exempt from the quantity limit, but the need must be credible.
Is a hanging toiletry bag worth it?
Free shelf space is rare in hotel bathrooms, and vacation rentals often have no shelf at all. A hook that fits over doors and towel rails is worth more there than any extra compartment. A simple loop, on the other hand, needs a wall hook. The Bellroy Hanging Toiletry Kit has a retractable aluminum hook.
What should I look for in compartments and material?
More important than a water-repellent outer material is a smooth inner lining, because leaked shampoo ends up inside. As for compartments: fewer is faster; a toothbrush compartment and a few mesh pockets are enough. For electric toothbrushes, measure the charger beforehand, as many compartments are cut for manual toothbrushes.
Sources
- German Federal Police: Flüssigkeiten an Bord (liquids on board, in German)
- Samsonite: Stackd Toilet Kit
- Bellroy: Hanging Toiletry Kit
- Bellroy: Toiletry Kit
- Herschel: Chapter Travel Kit
- Herschel: Chapter Travel Kit Weather Resistant
- Tumi: Alpha Hanging Travel Kit
Where to buy
- Samsonite Stackd Toilet KitCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Samsonite Stackd Toilet Kit (24,3 cm)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bellroy Hanging Toiletry KitCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bellroy Toiletry KitCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Herschel Chapter Travel Kit (schwarz)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Tumi Alpha Hanging Travel KitCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
