Contents10 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A wireless alarm system reports a break-in. It cannot prevent one. If you buy a large kit for an apartment whose patio door can be pried open with a screwdriver, you have spent the money in the wrong place. For a solid system without a mandatory subscription, the Homematic IP Starter Set Alarm is a good choice; if you want a monitoring center, take a look at Bosch.
Locks first, then the siren: the police’s position
On its K-Einbruch website, the German Police Crime Prevention program (Polizeiliche Kriminalprävention) makes it clear: coordinated mechanical security measures come first. An alarm system is an addition because it significantly increases the intruder’s risk of being discovered. For smaller residential properties, the police consider systems of class A or grade 2 sufficient; they do not recommend grade 1. According to K-Einbruch, planning and installation should be handled by a qualified installation company.
The police are even clearer about pure smart home solutions. On their own, they are not a consistent, reliable intrusion detection system, the site states; for burglary protection, K-Einbruch recommends alarm systems certified to the German standard DIN VDE 0833 with smart home functions. The devices in this guide are DIY systems. They can warn and deter. They are no substitute for window locks and a burglar-resistant door lock.
The statistics show why mechanical security carries so much weight. According to K-Einbruch, based on the German Police Crime Statistics (PKS), 44.9 percent of residential burglaries in 2025 did not get past the attempt stage. The police attribute this partly to security hardware.
How a system like this is put together
At the center sits the hub. It only gets interesting when the router or the power fails. According to the manufacturers, Homematic IP and Bosch trigger an alarm even without internet, and Ring and Ajax have backup batteries in the hub.
Then there are the sensors on doors and windows. Each kit usually includes only one or two contacts, so count beforehand how many ground-floor windows can be reached from outside. The systems differ most in their motion detectors, especially when it comes to pets: some ignore animals up to a certain weight, others only up to a certain height, and the Abus basic kit not at all.
You can hear the siren in the hub in the stairwell. On the street, hardly at all. An outdoor siren costs extra.
And finally, the app and subscription. Which functions only work for a monthly fee should be clarified before buying; with Ring, according to the manufacturer, this even includes arming the system remotely.
One point is often underestimated. K-Einbruch warns that a system with frequent false alarms loses its credibility. If you have a dog or cat, you should therefore look at the motion detector first and everything else second.
Five wireless alarm systems compared
| Model | In the kit | Siren and backup operation | Pets | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homematic IP Starter Set Alarm | Access point, motion detector, window contact, alarm siren | at least 90 dB at 1 m, alarm even without internet | not specified | Beginners without a subscription |
| Bosch Smart Home Alarmsystem S | Controller II, Door/Window Contact II Plus, Smoke Detector II as siren, Universal Switch II | alarm even without internet | Motion Detector II (sold separately) ignores movement below 70 cm | Anyone who wants a monitoring center |
| Ring Alarm Set M (2nd gen.) | Base station, keypad, contacts, motion detector, range extender | 104 dB at 30 cm, battery up to 24 hours | under 22 kg at 2.1 m height | Alexa and Ring households |
| ABUS Smartvest Basis-Set | Hub, opening detector, motion detector, remote control | 90 dB in the hub, backup batteries | Basic detector not pet-immune | Small budget, Abus cameras |
| Ajax StarterKit Cam | Hub 2, MotionCam, DoorProtect, SpaceControl | no siren in the kit, battery up to 16 hours | up to 20 kg and 50 cm | Larger houses, professional installer |
Homematic IP Starter Set Alarm
An access point, a motion detector with a 12-meter range, an optical window contact and a battery-powered alarm siren with at least 90 dB at one meter: that is what comes in the kit from eQ-3 (item number 153348A0). According to the data sheet, the devices communicate directly with each other. That is why the alarm goes off even without internet, and even if an intruder destroys the access point, the other devices remain active. The app is free. The manufacturer says nothing about pet detection. For households with a dog, that is the weak spot.
Bosch Smart Home Alarmsystem S
The heart of the system is the Controller II. The smallest package has no motion detector, and the Smoke Detector II serves as the indoor siren. Bosch sells the Motion Detector II [+M] separately; according to Bosch, it covers up to 13 meters and can ignore movement below a height of 70 cm. But you choose Bosch for Security+. For a fee, a monitoring center staffed around the clock complements the system and, in the event of an alarm, involves contact persons, the police or the fire department. Two months are included with the kit as a voucher.
Ring Alarm Set M (2nd generation)
According to Ring, the base station contains a siren with 104 dB at 30 cm, plus a battery that lasts up to 24 hours; the keypad remains usable for that long. The motion detectors ignore pets under 22 kg, but only at the lowest sensitivity and a mounting height of 2.1 meters. Things get tricky with the subscription. According to Ring, remote control from the app and the cellular backup require a paid subscription. Without a subscription, considerably less of the smart system remains than the packaging would suggest.
ABUS Smartvest Basis-Set
The Smartvest kit FUAA35001A contains a hub with an integrated 90 dB siren, an opening detector, a motion detector and a remote control. Abus states the expansion limit as 32 wireless components and four cameras. Pet owners can’t do much with the included detector; Abus itself refers to the pet-immune motion detector FUBW35010A. No system in this comparison is simpler. For a rented apartment, that is often enough.
Ajax StarterKit Cam
Ajax comes from the professional side of the market. The Hub 2 manages up to 100 devices, connects via Ethernet and cellular in parallel and, according to the data sheet, is rated security grade 2 under EN 50131. When an alarm is triggered, the MotionCam sends photos for verification, according to Ajax within nine seconds. There is no siren in the kit; it has to be bought separately. Ajax is designed to be connected to an alarm receiving and monitoring center; if you plan to do that, it is best to have the system set up by a professional installer.
Which system suits which home?
In an apartment, without a subscription: the Homematic IP Starter Set Alarm, supplemented with a second window contact. If someone should respond at the house while you are on vacation, the Bosch alarm system with Security+ is an option. Where Ring cameras or Alexa are already in use, Ring Alarm is the obvious choice, with the subscription factored in from the start.
With a dog up to 20 kg, Ajax or Ring are options, each with exactly the mounting height the manufacturer specifies. On a tight budget, that leaves ABUS Smartvest, with the additional pet-immune detector if you have pets.
Models for keeping an eye on the outside are presented in our article on outdoor security cameras. How to bring alarm, heating and lighting under one control is explained in buying a smart home hub. Bosch and Abus also integrate smoke detectors, so the overview of smart smoke detectors (in German) is a good fit for expanding your system.
If you also want to see what is happening on your property, the guide to pan-tilt security cameras covers models that automatically follow people.
Without internet, faults and alarms are reported via cellular; what the 2G shutdown means for this is covered in the guide to the GSM auto-dialer (in German).
Frequently asked questions
Does a wireless alarm system replace window locks?
No. On its K-Einbruch website, the German Police Crime Prevention program (Polizeiliche Kriminalprävention) puts coordinated mechanical security measures first. An alarm system is an addition because it increases the risk of discovery for intruders. According to K-Einbruch, 44.9 percent of residential burglaries in Germany in 2025 did not get past the attempt stage, partly thanks to security hardware.
Which alarm system works without a subscription?
With the Homematic IP Starter Set Alarm, the app is free and the devices communicate directly with each other. With Ring, according to the manufacturer, remote control from the app and the cellular backup require a paid subscription. Which functions only work for a fee should be clarified before buying.
Which alarm system suits households with a dog?
Ajax ignores pets up to 20 kg and 50 cm, Ring pets under 22 kg at a mounting height of 2.1 meters and the lowest sensitivity. The Bosch Motion Detector II ignores movement below 70 cm. Homematic IP gives no information on pet immunity, and the basic Abus detector is not pet-immune.
What do the police say about smart home alarm systems?
Pure smart home solutions on their own are not a consistent, reliable intrusion detection system, according to K-Einbruch. For burglary protection, the German police recommend systems certified to the German standard DIN VDE 0833. For smaller residential properties, systems of class A or grade 2 are considered sufficient; the police do not recommend grade 1.
Why are false alarms a problem?
K-Einbruch warns that a system with frequent false alarms loses its credibility. If you have a dog or cat, look at the motion detector first and everything else second. Some systems ignore pets by weight, others only by height.
Sources
- K-Einbruch: Alarm systems
- K-Einbruch: Smart home
- K-Einbruch: Home page with Police Crime Statistics 2025
- Homematic IP: Starter Set Alarm
- eQ-3: HmIP-SK7 data sheet
- Bosch Smart Home: Alarm system
- Bosch Smart Home: Motion Detector II
- Ring: Alarm Set M
- Ring: Alarm (2nd gen.), help
- ABUS: Smartvest Basis-Set
- Ajax: Hub 2
- Ajax: StarterKit Cam
- Ajax: MotionProtect
Where to buy
- Homematic IP Starter Set AlarmView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELVCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bosch Smart Home Alarmsystem SCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Ring Alarm Set M (2. Gen.)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- ABUS Smartvest Basis-Set FUAA35001ACheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Ajax StarterKit CamCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de

