Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
At the home improvement store, the propane heat cannons sit right next to the gas bottles, and they promise lots of heat for little money. According to the manufacturers‘ own specifications, though, they are simply too big for a normal single garage. In most hobby workshops, you are better off with a 3 kW electric heater such as the Trotec TDS 20 R: plug it into a Schuko outlet (the standard German household socket), no exhaust fumes, no gas bottle swaps.
Gas and three-phase power have their place. Just in larger rooms and with clear rules.
How big is the garage, really?
Volume comes first. A typical single garage measuring six by three meters with a height of 2.5 meters has around 45 cubic meters, a double garage about 90. This one figure carries more weight than any kilowatt rating on the packaging.
Is a normal outlet enough?
Up to 3 kW, yes. A normal Schuko outlet cannot deliver more. For the TDS 20 R, Trotec states a current draw of just over 13 amps on a 16-amp circuit. That leaves little headroom for a circular saw on the same circuit.
From 5 kW, an electric heater needs a 400-volt CEE outlet (a three-phase industrial socket). If the garage does not have one, the retrofit belongs in the hands of a licensed electrical contractor.
What about cables and clearances?
Trotec requires cable reels to be fully unwound and the extension cord to be chosen according to the connected load and length. A thin, half-wound reel at 3 kW is a fire risk.
Electric heaters need space too. For the TDS R series, Trotec specifies 50 centimeters from walls and one meter from flammable objects.
Why not just use gas or diesel?
A gas heat cannon burns propane directly in the room. The exhaust ends up in the air you breathe. In the operating manual for its TGH gas fan heaters, Trotec explicitly warns of the risk of suffocation and poisoning from carbon monoxide in the event of incomplete combustion and a lack of fresh air supply. The device also consumes oxygen, which can lead to oxygen deficiency in small rooms.
The requirements in the same manual are clear. The device must not be used to heat habitable rooms in residential buildings, must not run in the basement or below ground level, and must not be left unattended. A ventilation opening of 25 square centimeters per kilowatt is required, but at least 250, plus a minimum room size. For the smallest model with 10 kW, that is 100 cubic meters. On top of that, there must be 3.5 meters of free space in front of the device.
Set that against the 45 cubic meters of a single garage. Even a double garage does not quite meet this manufacturer’s specification. According to the manufacturer, gas heaters are intended for warehouses, construction sites, tents and large workshops, not for the hobby room behind the house. Diesel heaters with open combustion follow the same logic: Scheppach described its now-discontinued DKH20000 FLOW as suitable only for well-ventilated, non-enclosed spaces.
If you still work with gas despite all this, you should also set up a carbon monoxide detector. It is no substitute for ventilation. For rooms that only need to stay frost-free, an oil-filled radiator is the quieter solution without combustion.
Six devices, four types
| Model | Type and output | Connection | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trotec TDS 20 R | Electric fan heater, 1.5 / 3 kW, 411 m³/h | 230 V, Schuko plug | Single garage, hobby workshop |
| Scheppach EH3000 | Electric fan heater, 2 / 3 kW, thermostat 5 to 85 °C | 230 V | Small rooms up to 60 m³ according to the manufacturer |
| Trotec TDS 50 R | Electric fan heater, 4.5 / 9 kW, 844 m³/h | 400 V, CEE 16 A, 5-pin | Double garage, large workshop with three-phase power |
| Stiebel Eltron IW 120 | Infrared quartz heater, 0.4 / 0.8 / 1.2 kW, IPX4 | 230 V, wall mounting | Heat right at the workstation |
| Trotec TGH 11 E | Propane fan heater, 10 kW, 730 g/h | Gas bottle plus 230 V for the fan | Well-ventilated rooms from 100 m³ |
| Einhell HGG 171 Niro | Propane hot air generator, 17 kW, 1,000 m³/h | Gas bottle plus 230 V for the fan | Halls, buildings under construction, large tents |
Trotec TDS 20 R for the ordinary garage
Metal housing, two heat settings with 1.5 and 3 kW, plus a fan-only setting and a thermostat. Trotec explicitly lists garages and workshops as places of use. At 3 kilograms, the heater is quick to move around. A hobby workshop usually needs nothing more. A poorly insulated garage still will not feel cozy in January, though.
Scheppach EH3000, light and simple
Scheppach specifies 2 and 3 kW, a continuously adjustable thermostat and overheating protection. No other device in this comparison weighs as little: 1.85 kilograms. However, Scheppach itself only refers to enclosed rooms of up to 60 cubic meters. That covers a single garage. For a double garage, it is too small.
Trotec TDS 50 R needs three-phase power
On its higher setting, the TDS 50 R heats with 9 kW, three times as much as the small model, with no exhaust fumes at all. According to the data sheet, it requires 400 volts and a five-pin CEE plug with 16 amps. If that outlet is already in the workshop, this is the cleanest solution for larger rooms. If it first has to be installed, the installation belongs in the calculation.
Stiebel Eltron IW 120 warms the workbench
An infrared heater does not warm the room air. Its heat hits surfaces and people in its beam, and that suits anyone who spends hours tinkering in the same spot. Stiebel Eltron specifies three settings up to 1.2 kW and IPX4 splash protection and describes the heater for indoor use and sheltered outdoor areas. According to retailers, it comes without a plug, so the wall connection should be done by an electrician. It will not heat an entire garage.
Trotec TGH 11 E: gas with clear limits
10 kW from a bottle of propane or a propane-butane mix, piezo ignition, flame failure protection and overheating protection, according to the manufacturer. The fan also needs electricity. With a minimum room size of 100 cubic meters and a 250 square centimeter ventilation opening, it belongs in halls, workshops with a roller door and buildings under construction. According to these specifications, it has no business in a cluttered single garage.
Einhell HGG 171 Niro for large areas
Einhell states a nominal heat output of 17 kW, 1,000 cubic meters of air per hour and a consumption of just over 1.2 kilograms of gas per hour. An 11-kilo bottle is therefore empty after around nine hours. The device is designed for operation in Germany and Austria. If you need to keep a hall or a building under construction dry and warm, you get a lot of output here. In a private workshop, it would be oversized.
Which device for which room?
- Single garage or hobby basement with a Schuko outlet: Trotec TDS 20 R. The Scheppach EH3000 is the lighter alternative for small rooms.
- Large workshop with a CEE outlet: Trotec TDS 50 R. Plenty of heat without a gas bottle and without exhaust fumes.
- Just one fixed workstation: Stiebel Eltron IW 120, permanently mounted on the wall.
- Hall, construction site, tent with good ventilation: Trotec TGH 11 E or Einhell HGG 171 Niro, never in living spaces and never in the basement.
If you work in a cold garage on winter evenings, you need light as well as heat. Our overview of cordless work lights fits right in.
Frequently asked questions
Is a normal outlet enough for a workshop heater?
Up to 3 kW, yes; a Schuko outlet cannot deliver more. For the TDS 20 R, Trotec states a current draw of just over 13 amps on a 16-amp circuit, which leaves little headroom for a circular saw on the same circuit. From 5 kW, an electric heater needs a 400-volt CEE outlet, which a licensed electrical contractor can retrofit.
Can you use a gas heat cannon in a garage?
According to the manufacturers' specifications, it is too big for a normal single garage. For its TGH gas heaters, Trotec requires a room of at least 100 cubic meters for the smallest 10 kW model plus an adequate ventilation opening, and warns of carbon monoxide. Not in living spaces, not in the basement, not unattended. A single garage has around 45 cubic meters.
How big is the volume of a garage?
A typical single garage measuring six by three meters with a height of 2.5 meters has around 45 cubic meters, a double garage about 90. This figure carries more weight than any kilowatt rating on the packaging. The Scheppach EH3000, for example, is only intended for rooms of up to 60 cubic meters, according to the manufacturer.
When does an infrared heater make sense in a workshop?
An infrared heater does not warm the room air but surfaces and people in its beam. That works if you spend hours working in the same spot. The Stiebel Eltron IW 120 offers three settings up to 1.2 kW and IPX4 splash protection, but according to retailers it comes without a plug. It will not heat an entire garage.
What should you keep in mind when running an electric heater?
Trotec requires cable reels to be fully unwound and the extension cord to be chosen according to power and length; a half-wound reel at 3 kW is a fire risk. For the TDS R series, Trotec specifies a clearance of 50 centimeters from walls and one meter from flammable objects.
Sources
- Trotec: operating manual for the TDS 20 R / TDS 30 R / TDS 50 R electric heaters
- Trotec: original operating manual for the TGH 11 E / TGH 16 E / TGH 31 E gas fan heaters
- Einhell: HGG 171 Niro (DE/AT)
- Scheppach: EH3000 electric fan heater
- Scheppach: DKH20000 FLOW diesel heater (no longer available)
- Stiebel Eltron: IW 120 infrared quartz heater
Where to buy
- Trotec TDS 20 RCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Scheppach EH3000View at scheppachAvailable in Germany: scheppachCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Trotec TDS 50 RCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Stiebel Eltron IW 120Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Trotec TGH 11 ECheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Einhell HGG 171 NiroCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
