Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A bare light bulb in the middle of the garage ceiling. That is what many hobby workshops look like, and anyone standing at the workbench there is working in their own shadow. For a single garage or a basement room, two 150-centimeter LED vaporproof fixtures are a solid foundation, for example the Ledvance Damp Proof 1500 with 46 watts. A UFO-style high-bay light, by contrast, is really only needed if you have to light a tall hall.
How bright does it need to be? The ASR A3.4 gives figures
For commercial workplaces, the German Technical Rule for Workplaces ASR A3.4, published by the German Federal Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (BAuA), sets minimum values. It applies to businesses with employees, not to your private garage. It still works as a benchmark, because it is organized by task. The May 2023 edition includes these values, among others:
- Car repair shops: 300 lux, color rendering Ra at least 80
- Work at the workbench, gluing, assembly: 300 lux, Ra 80
- Work at woodworking machines such as sawing, routing or turning: 500 lux, Ra 80
- Sanding, painting, joinery: 750 lux, Ra 80
- Welding: 300 lux, Ra 60; fine assembly work: 500 lux, Ra 80
Each figure refers to the average illuminance in the area of the workstation. The rest of the room may be darker, but not arbitrarily so: with 300 lux at the workstation, the rule requires at least 200 lux in the surrounding area, and from 500 lux at least 300 lux. Values above 500 lux only have to be reached on the surface where work actually takes place. An additional light above the workbench is therefore explicitly provided for.
Run the numbers once. Lux is lumens per square meter. A garage measuring six by three meters has 18 square meters, so for 300 lux, 5,400 lumens would have to reach the floor. But some of the light ends up on the walls and ceiling, and every fixture loses output over the years. A single fixture with just over 6,000 lumens is therefore cutting it close. Two give you a reserve. In the end, only a lux meter on the workbench will tell you whether it is enough.
Lumens, Ra, IP65: what counts in the data sheet
With LEDs, watts tell you almost nothing. What matters is the luminous flux of the entire fixture in lumens, specifically the value from the technical data sheet. Phrases like „up to“ on the packaging are not data sheet values.
At least as important is the color rendering index. Under light with a low Ra, wood tones, paint colors and cable insulation look different than in daylight. The ASR requires Ra 80 for most workshop tasks and additionally states that flicker must not create accident hazards through the stroboscopic effect. At a circular saw or lathe, that is no minor detail: a saw blade that appears to stand still under flickering light is dangerous.
For garages and basements, IP65 has become the norm, meaning dust-tight and protected against water jets. That protects against sanding dust and condensation. A detail for woodworkers: Ledvance specifies a limited surface temperature for its Damp Proof according to DIN EN 60598-2-24 and describes it as suitable for fire-hazard locations. The electrical connection belongs in the hands of a qualified electrician, which is also what Ledvance’s safety instructions say.
High-bay light, vaporproof fixture or continuous light line?
The elongated vaporproof fixture is built for rooms with a normal ceiling height. It spreads the light widely across the area. Mount several in a row and you get a continuous light line. For that, the fixture needs through-wiring so the cable can run from one fixture to the next. The Ledvance Damp Proof is prepared for this, and a second cable entry is included.
High-bay lights concentrate a lot of light in a round body and belong under high ceilings. Ledvance explicitly specifies areas with high ceilings for its Highbay UFO. In a garage with a height of 2.40 meters, such a light is out of place in our view: it hangs just above your head and concentrates its light on a small area.
Five workshop lights compared
| Model | Type and luminous flux | Color rendering, protection | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ledvance Damp Proof 1500 46W 840 | Vaporproof fixture, 150 cm, 6,400 lm, 4,000 K | Ra above 80, IP65, IK08, through-wiring possible | Garage, basement, woodworking shop, continuous light line |
| Philips Ledinaire WT060C L1500 | Vaporproof fixture, 150 cm, 5,600 lm, 4,000 K | CRI above 80, IP66, IK08, protection class II | Garage and basement with splashing water, easy installation |
| Müller-Licht Aqua-Promo 2/150 | Batten fixture with two G13 LED tubes, 2,200 lm each | Ra from 80, IP65, protection class II | Basement room, if you want to replace tubes yourself |
| Ledvance Highbay UFO 80W 865 | High-bay light, 9,300 lm, 6,500 K, 110° | Ra above 70, IP65 | Tall halls, barns, storage |
| Brennenstuhl WL 550 | Hand lamp with 5 m cable, 570 lm, 6,500 K | IP65, IK07, three brightness levels | Work under the car, in the engine bay, in a cabinet |
Ledvance Damp Proof 1500 46W 840
With 6,400 lumens at 46 watts, Ledvance specifies a luminous efficacy of 139 lumens per watt. According to the data sheet, the color rendering index is above 80, and the manufacturer gives the values for flicker and stroboscopic effect as Pst LM at most 1 and SVM at most 0.4. Add to that IK08, a three-pole terminal for cables up to 2.5 square millimeters, stainless steel clips and a five-year manufacturer’s warranty. Because it is protection class I, it requires a connected protective earth conductor. For a workshop with machines, it is our first choice.
Philips Ledinaire WT060C L1500
According to the data sheet, the Philips fixture delivers 5,600 lumens at 46 watts and, with IP66, is even somewhat better protected against water. It weighs only 0.7 kilograms and is protection class II, meaning two connection wires without a protective earth. Philips rates it in repair class D: not designed for repairs, and the LEDs cannot be replaced. With a rated lifetime of 50,000 hours, that is acceptable.
Müller-Licht Aqua-Promo 2/150
This housing contains no permanently installed LEDs but two LED tubes with G13 bases. Müller-Licht specifies 2,200 lumens per tube, so 4,400 in total. That is less than the two integrated fixtures. On the other hand, a faulty tube can be replaced individually. For a basement room with a workbench, that is enough; for a garage with a circular saw, we would rather go for the Ledvance.
Ledvance Highbay UFO 80W 865
The technical data sheet lists 9,300 lumens for the fixture, 6,500 kelvin and a beam angle of 110 degrees. The color rendering index given there is above 70. For a car repair shop or woodworking, the ASR calls for Ra 80. As base lighting in a tall barn or a storage area, the light works; for painting or fine work, we advise against it.
Brennenstuhl WL 550
Not a ceiling light, but a supplement for spots the ceiling light cannot reach. Brennenstuhl specifies 570 lumens, three levels at 100, 40 and 10 percent, an extendable hook and five meters of H05RN-F rubber-sheathed cable. With IP65 and IK07, it can handle splashing water and a knock on the concrete floor. The manufacturer does not state a color rendering value. If you would rather keep both hands free, take a look at our headlamp guide.
How we would light the workshop
- Single garage or basement workshop with machines: two Ledvance Damp Proof 1500, parallel to the workbench, not directly above it, so that you are not standing in your own shadow.
- Double garage or long workshop: three to four fixtures as a continuous light line with through-wiring.
- Basement or wash area with splashing water: Philips Ledinaire WT060C with IP66.
- Hall from about four meters high: a high-bay light as base lighting, with a second light with Ra 80 at the workbench.
- For every workshop: a hand lamp such as the Brennenstuhl WL 550 for dark corners.
Good light does little if the work surface is not right. You will find suitable models in our workbench guide (in German), and if you work there in winter, you will find tips in the workshop heating guide (in German).
If your workshop still has fixtures with fluorescent tubes, they can often continue to be used with LED tubes. How to identify the starter and ballast is explained in the guide LED tube instead of fluorescent tube.
Frequently asked questions
How bright should a workshop be?
The German workplace rule ASR A3.4 applies to businesses but works as a benchmark: 300 lux for car repair shops and work at the workbench, 500 lux at woodworking machines, 750 lux for sanding and painting. This refers to the workstation itself, and an additional light above the workbench is explicitly provided for.
How many lumens do I need for a garage?
Lux is lumens per square meter. An 18-square-meter garage therefore needs 5,400 lumens on the floor for 300 lux. Because some of the light ends up on the walls and ceiling and fixtures lose output over time, a single fixture with just over 6,000 lumens is cutting it close. Two give you a reserve.
Why is color rendering important in the workshop?
Under light with a low Ra, wood tones, paint colors and cable insulation look different than in daylight. The ASR requires Ra 80 for most workshop tasks. Flicker must not create accident hazards, because a saw blade that appears to stand still under flickering light is dangerous.
Vaporproof fixture or high-bay light for the garage?
In a garage with a normal ceiling height, the elongated vaporproof fixture, as it spreads the light widely. High-bay lights concentrate a lot of light in a round body and belong under high ceilings. At 2.40 meters, such a light hangs just above your head and only illuminates a small area.
What protection rating does a workshop light need?
For garages and basements, IP65 has become the norm: dust-tight and protected against water jets. That keeps out sanding dust and condensation. For rooms with splashing water, the Philips Ledinaire WT060C even offers IP66. The connection should be made by a qualified electrician.
How do I arrange workshop lights correctly?
In a single garage, two vaporproof fixtures parallel to the workbench, not directly above it, so that you are not standing in your own shadow. In longer rooms, three to four fixtures as a continuous light line with through-wiring. For dark corners, add a hand lamp such as the Brennenstuhl WL 550.
Sources
- BAuA: ASR A3.4 Lighting and visual contact, May 2023 edition (in German)
- Ledvance: Damp Proof DP 1500 46W 840 IP65 GY, product data
- Ledvance: Damp Proof 1500 46W 840, product description
- Ledvance: Highbay UFO 80W 865 IP65 Black, product data
- Signify: Ledinaire Waterproof WT060C LED56S/840 PSU L1500, data sheet
- Müller-Licht: LED batten fixture Aqua-Promo 2/150 (in German)
- Brennenstuhl: LED workshop light WL 550 (in German)
Where to buy
- Ledvance Damp Proof 1500 46W 840Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Philips Ledinaire WT060C L1500Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Müller-Licht Aqua-Promo 2/150Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Ledvance Highbay UFO 80W 865Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Brennenstuhl WL 550Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
