Contents10 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
If you want to rescue old cassettes, buy a tape deck with a USB output first and a portable player only after that. The reason is simple. A new Walkman plays back, nothing more, and the FiiO CP13 cannot even record. For archiving family cassettes, we therefore recommend the TEAC W-1200, and for listening on the go with wireless headphones, the WE-001 from We Are Rewind.
Listen, record or rescue?
Three wishes usually lie behind the search for a cassette player, and they call for very different devices. If you want to listen to childhood audio dramas on the train, you need a small player with a battery. If you want to record new mixtapes, you need a recording section with an input. And if you want to turn twenty shoeboxes full of tapes into files, you need a stationary deck that runs steadily for hours and has a digital output. There is no single device for everything.
These are the points we look at when comparing:
- Wow and flutter: This describes how much the tape speed fluctuates. Lower values mean less „wobble“ on sustained notes. TEAC specifies 0.25 percent (W.RMS) for its decks, and according to netzwelt.de, FiiO specifies 0.2 percent typical for the CP13.
- Tape types: Type I is normal ferric oxide tape, Type II chrome, Type IV metal. Most devices can play all three, but not every one can record on them.
- Noise reduction: According to TEAC, tapes that were originally recorded with Dolby B only sound close to the original with a matching playback circuit.
- Digital path: USB to the computer, USB flash drive, or nothing at all. This is what matters for archiving.
- Power: Built-in battery or power adapter. A glued-in battery is usually difficult to replace later.
FiiO itself points out on its product page that playback can damage old tapes. That applies to every device. Valuable one-of-a-kind tapes should therefore be digitized cleanly once and then put away in the cupboard.
Are you allowed to digitize cassettes?
For your own use, yes. Section 53(1) of the German Copyright Act (Urheberrechtsgesetz, UrhG) permits natural persons to make individual copies for private use on any medium, as long as they do not serve commercial purposes and the original was not obviously produced unlawfully. Transferring a purchased music cassette to your own hard drive falls under this. Passing copies on, selling them or putting them online does not: according to subsection 6, such copies may neither be distributed nor publicly performed. Your own recordings, such as voice tapes from your grandparents, are your business anyway.
Five cassette devices compared
| Model | Design | Tapes (playback / recording) | Digital and wireless | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FiiO CP13 | Portable, 1,800 mAh battery, around 310 g | Type I to IV / no recording | No Bluetooth, only a 3.5 mm headphone jack | Audio dramas and music on the go, wired |
| We Are Rewind WE-001 | Portable, 2,000 mAh battery, around 404 g | Type I to IV / via 3.5 mm input | Bluetooth 5.1 to headphones | On the go with wireless headphones, occasional mixtapes |
| We Are Rewind GB-001 | Cassette boombox with battery and speakers | Playback / recording with level meter | Bluetooth 5.4, aux and microphone inputs | Music in the room or in the garden |
| TEAC W-1200 | Dual deck, 43.5 cm wide, mains-powered | Type I, II, IV / Type I and II | USB to the computer, up to 48 kHz and 16 bits | Archiving cassettes, copying tapes |
| TEAC AD-850-SE | CD player and cassette deck, mains-powered | Normal, chrome, metal / metal playback only | MP3 to USB flash drive at 128 kbps | Digitizing without a computer |
FiiO CP13: cleanly built, with compromises in sound
FiiO made deliberate cuts with the CP13. Recording and auto-reverse are missing; in return, the manufacturer cites an enlarged copper flywheel with a diameter of 30.4 mm, a 4.2-volt motor and an aluminum housing. The battery is said to last more than 13 hours and charges via USB-C. The testers at netzwelt.de praise the build quality and operation, but call the sound „very modest“ and see the device as better suited to audio dramas than to music. We therefore see it as an attractive player for spoken-word content. It is not built for archiving.
We Are Rewind WE-001: cassette with a wireless link
The WE-001 sends the tape signal via Bluetooth 5.1 to headphones or speakers and can also record via a 3.5 mm input. However, the recording level cannot be adjusted, and according to the data sheet the headphone output delivers only 2 × 2 mW into 32 ohms. The reviewer at audioreviews.org describes the sound as warm and pleasant, but recommends headphones with high sensitivity. At 404 grams, it is noticeably heavier than the CP13. For people who switched to wireless listening long ago, this is the right way back to tape.
We Are Rewind GB-001: the cassette boombox for outdoors
A device for the patio, not for your jacket pocket. The GB-001 has Bluetooth 5.4, an aux input, a microphone input, bass and treble controls, and needle meters for the level. In its review, TechRadar highlights the powerful bass, but criticizes somewhat reserved upper mids and a battery indicator that only lights up when the battery is almost empty. It is no good for digitizing, but fine for making mixtapes at the kitchen table.
TEAC W-1200: the deck for the archive
From ten cassettes upward, there is no way around a real deck. The W-1200 has two independent transports, plays normal, chrome and metal tape, and records on normal and chrome tape. At the back there is a USB output that, according to TEAC, delivers to the computer at up to 48 kHz and 16 bits; you will also need recording software such as Audacity. According to the manufacturer, the noise reduction is equivalent to Dolby B but only works during playback. The ±12 percent pitch control on transport 1 is handy for dictation and lecture tapes. TEAC specifies the frequency response as 30 to 15,000 Hz on chrome tape and 30 to 13,000 Hz on normal tape (each ±4 dB). At 4.6 kilograms in the European version, it needs a permanent spot on the shelf.
TEAC AD-850-SE: cassettes to a flash drive, no computer needed
No computer is required here. The AD-850-SE combines a CD player and a cassette deck and writes tape, CD or line input directly to a USB flash drive as MP3, sorted into folders by source. For archivists, the bit rate matters, and according to TEAC it is fixed at 128 kbps. That is enough for audio dramas in the car; for a music archive, we would prefer the W-1200 with lossless recording on a computer. The deck only plays back metal tape, and the pitch can be adjusted by about 10 percent.
How we would decide
- Preserving family cassettes, live recordings, entire collections: TEAC W-1200 with a computer, recorded as WAV files.
- Digitizing without a computer, results for the car stereo: TEAC AD-850-SE.
- On the go with wireless headphones, the occasional tape of your own: We Are Rewind WE-001.
- On the go with wired headphones, mainly audio dramas: FiiO CP13.
- Cassettes in the living room or garden through speakers: We Are Rewind GB-001.
If you want to tackle your vinyl records after the cassettes, you will find models with a USB output in the turntable guide (in German). And for the finished files, a small MP3 player for on the go is often handier than any Walkman.
If the box also contains videotapes, the guide digitizing VHS can help.
Frequently asked questions
Are you allowed to digitize cassettes?
For your own use, yes. Section 53(1) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) permits individual private copies as long as they do not serve commercial purposes. Passing them on, selling them or putting them online is not permitted under subsection 6. Your own recordings, such as voice tapes from your grandparents, are your business anyway.
How do I digitize cassettes without a computer?
With the TEAC AD-850-SE. It writes tape, CD or line input directly to a USB flash drive as MP3, sorted by source. According to TEAC, the bit rate is fixed at 128 kbps. That is enough for audio dramas in the car; for a music archive, the W-1200 with a computer is the better choice.
Can the FiiO CP13 record?
No, FiiO deliberately left out recording and auto-reverse, and there is no Bluetooth either. In return, you get an aluminum housing and, according to the manufacturer, more than 13 hours of battery life. netzwelt.de praises the build quality but calls the sound modest. It is better suited to audio dramas than to music.
What should you look for when buying a cassette player?
What matters is wow and flutter, meaning how much the tape speed fluctuates, which tape types (Type I, II and IV) it can play and record, a playback circuit for Dolby B tapes, the digital path via USB, and the power supply. A glued-in battery is usually difficult to replace later.
Which cassette player suits music in the garden?
The We Are Rewind GB-001 cassette boombox with battery and speakers. It has Bluetooth 5.4, aux and microphone inputs, and bass and treble controls. TechRadar highlights its powerful bass. It is no good for digitizing, but fine for making mixtapes.
Can old tapes be damaged by playing them?
Yes, FiiO points this out itself on its product page, and it applies to every device. Valuable one-of-a-kind tapes should therefore be digitized cleanly once and then put away in the cupboard rather than played over and over.
Sources
- FiiO: CP13, product page and specifications
- TEAC: W-1200, features and specifications
- TEAC: AD-850-SE, features and specifications
- netzwelt.de: FiiO CP13 review
- audioreviews.org: We Are Rewind WE-001 Review
- TechRadar: We Are Rewind GB-001 review
- German Copyright Act (Urheberrechtsgesetz), Section 53
Where to buy
- TEAC W-1200Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- TEAC AD-850-SECheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- We Are Rewind WE-001Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- FiiO CP13Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- We Are Rewind GB-001Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
