Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Whether VHS tapes can be digitized at home is not decided by the grabber. It is decided by the VCR. If there is still a deck in the basement that outputs a clean picture and sound, a small video digitizer without a computer is enough, and for that we consider the dnt Grabstar AV V2 the most convenient solution. Without a working VCR, a digitizing service is usually the only option.
Step 1: Do you still have a VCR?
Every grabber in this guide is only the receiver. Playback has to come from a VCR or camcorder, and Hauppauge even states it explicitly on the product page: the playback device is not included. So test the VCR beforehand with a cassette you do not care about. If it chews the tape, the picture freezes or the sound hisses, even the best grabber will not rescue anything. A family video that tears in the process is gone.
No VCR, ten cassettes, no desire to deal with cables? Then send the tapes out. Ask beforehand whether billing is by actual playing time or per cassette, whether you get an MP4 file or only a DVD, and how the originals are returned insured. You should not pay for blank sections of tape.
Step 2: SCART, RCA or S-Video?
Turn the VCR around. Many European decks only have a wide SCART socket, but the grabbers expect RCA, meaning the yellow jack for the picture and red and white for the sound. In between goes a SCART adapter that must be switched to output. August includes such an adapter with the VGB400, and reflecta with the VideoCapture Set as well. With the Grabstar AV V2, you will find only an RCA cable in the box. In that case, you have to buy the adapter separately.
If your VCR has an S-Video jack, use it. With S-Video, brightness and color run separately over their own wires. According to dnt, this produces less interference than the combined composite signal, and the picture becomes sharper and more color-accurate. The sound still needs the two RCA plugs.
Step 3: With or without a computer?
Devices without a computer record directly to a USB stick or memory card. That is convenient, because a three-hour tape also runs for three hours in real time and no laptop has to sit next to it for that long. USB grabbers for the PC allow more control over format and editing but require software and a compatible operating system. If you already record modern consoles or cameras via HDMI, do not confuse the two: a capture card for HDMI (in German) usually has no analog input for the VCR.
How good can the result get?
As good as the tape. No better. All devices here record PAL at 720 by 576 pixels, and dnt explicitly advises against expecting more: the analog source material has a very low native resolution, and according to the manufacturer, higher recording resolutions add no value. Anyone advertising a grabber with 4K is selling pixels without content.
A clean VCR, the S-Video cable and patience bring more. Expect several gigabytes per cassette. For an entire family collection, an external SSD for video and backup (in German) is a tidier place to keep it than a bundle of USB sticks.
How long do video tapes last?
Not forever. The guide „Magnetic Tape Storage and Handling“ from the US Council on Library and Information Resources gives magnetic tapes a life expectancy of ten to thirty years, with thirty years considered the upper limit there, including for video tapes. A cassette from the early nineties has therefore already passed that span. The guide takes the second problem just as seriously: playback devices become obsolete faster than the tapes.
Until they are transferred, the Library of Congress advises: cool, rather dry at about 35 to 40 percent humidity, not in the attic and not in a damp basement. Speakers, motors and televisions generate magnetic fields, and the tapes should be kept away from them.
Five video digitizers compared
| Model | Computer needed | Inputs | Records to | Who it’s for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dnt Video-Digitalisierer Grabstar AV V2 | no | RCA, S-Video | SD/SDHC, USB stick, USB hard drive | large collections without a PC |
| August VGB400 | no | RCA (SCART adapter included) | USB, microSD up to 64 GB | a few tapes, small budget |
| reflecta VideoCapture Set USB | yes, Windows or Mac | RCA, S-Video (SCART adapter included) | Computer | Mac users |
| Hauppauge USB-Live2 | yes, Windows | RCA, S-Video | Computer (MPEG-2) | Windows users who want to edit |
| August VGB100 | yes, Windows | RCA, S-Video | Computer | older Windows computers |
dnt Video-Digitalisierer Grabstar AV V2
The Grabstar records MP4 files in H.264 to an SD card or USB stick up to 512 GB and, according to the manual, also to a self-powered USB hard drive up to 2 TB. Above 4 GB, it automatically splits a recording into several files. On the 8.9-centimeter display, you can see what is currently playing, and playback can also go to the TV via HDMI. Practical touches are the auto-stop after 60, 90, 120 or 150 minutes and the signal monitoring, which pauses when there is no picture and can be switched off for damaged tapes. Annoying: without power, the device forgets the time, and if you do not want timestamps in the picture, you switch that overlay off in the menu. According to dnt, Mac and Linux users should format the storage with FAT32.
August VGB400
The VGB400 also needs no computer and writes MP4 to USB or microSD. There is no display; for monitoring, a TV hangs on the HDMI output, and the cable is not included. Storage is limited to 64 GB, and there is no S-Video input.
reflecta VideoCapture Set USB
The stick registers with the computer as a USB camera and, according to reflecta, needs no driver. You can record with the Windows Camera app or QuickTime, so on a Mac as well. The included editing software only runs on Windows. A SCART adapter, RCA and S-Video cables are included.
Hauppauge USB-Live2
Hauppauge specifies 4:2:2 sampling at 25 frames per second in full PAL resolution. Recording is in MPEG-2 with the Hauppauge Capture software, which is only available as a download and is activated online once. Hauppauge lists Windows 11, 10 or 7 as supported systems; the manufacturer does not list Mac.
August VGB100
A simple USB 2.0 grabber with composite and S-Video inputs. August lists Windows XP to 10 as supported systems and provides instructions for manual driver installation on its help pages. If you use Windows 11, you are better off choosing one of the other devices.
How we would decide
- VCR available, many tapes, no computer at hand: Grabstar AV V2, plus a SCART adapter.
- A few cassettes, VCR with SCART: August VGB400.
- Recording on a Mac: reflecta VideoCapture Set USB.
- Recording on Windows and editing afterwards: Hauppauge USB-Live2.
- No working VCR or very valuable tapes: a digitizing service.
As soon as the files are done, they belong in two places, for example on a hard drive and on a NAS for photo and video backup (in German). And if there are also music cassettes in the same box: what you need for those is covered in our guide to cassette players and tape decks (in German).
Paper prints, albums and slides are covered together in our guide digitizing photos (in German), including time estimates and services.
Frequently asked questions
Can I digitize VHS tapes without a computer?
Yes, devices like the dnt Grabstar AV V2 or the August VGB400 record directly to a USB stick or memory card. That is convenient, because a three-hour tape also runs for three hours in real time and no laptop has to sit next to it. You still need the VCR for playback.
How do I connect a VCR with SCART?
The grabbers expect RCA (composite) connections, while many European VCRs only have SCART. In between goes a SCART adapter that must be switched to output. August and reflecta include one; with the Grabstar AV V2, you have to buy it separately. If the VCR has S-Video, use that jack.
Does a higher recording resolution give better VHS pictures?
No. The result will be as good as the tape, not better. All devices in the comparison record PAL at 720 by 576 pixels, and dnt explicitly advises against expecting more. A clean VCR, the S-Video cable and patience bring more.
How long do VHS tapes last?
Not forever. A guide from the Council on Library and Information Resources gives magnetic tapes ten to thirty years, with thirty considered the upper limit. Until they are transferred, store tapes cool, at about 35 to 40 percent humidity, and away from speakers and motors.
What should you clarify with a digitizing service?
Ask beforehand whether billing is by actual playing time or per cassette, whether you get an MP4 file or only a DVD, and how the originals are returned insured. You should not pay for blank sections of tape.
Which VHS grabber works with a Mac?
The reflecta VideoCapture Set USB registers as a USB camera, needs no driver according to reflecta, and records via QuickTime on a Mac as well. The included editing software only runs on Windows. Hauppauge and August list only Windows for their USB grabbers.
Sources
- dnt: Grabstar AV V2 operating manual (PDF)
- dnt: Grabstar AV V2 data sheet (PDF)
- ELV: dnt Video-Digitalisierer Grabstar AV V2, retailer information
- August: VGB400
- August: VGB100
- reflecta: VideoCapture Set USB
- Hauppauge: USB-Live2
- CLIR: Magnetic Tape Storage and Handling, chapter Life Expectancy
- Library of Congress: Care, Handling, and Storage of Audio Visual Materials
Where to buy
- dnt Video-Digitalisierer Grabstar AV V2View at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- August VGB400Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- reflecta VideoCapture Set USBCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Hauppauge USB-Live2Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- August VGB100Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
