Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
You buy a dresser by its runners, not by its front. For a bedroom with 80 centimeters of free wall, we consider the Rauch Flipp with five drawers the most sensible choice, because it comes with full extension, self-closing and soft close. If you want solid wood and are just setting up a child’s room, take a look at the Pinolino Natura in beech. And whichever model it ends up being: it needs to be screwed to the wall.
What happens under the drawer
In the furniture store, your eye goes to the color and the handles. In everyday life, what counts is how far the drawer comes out. An example from the IKEA data sheet: the HEMNES dresser with eight drawers has an interior depth of 43 centimeters, while the drawer extends 29.4 centimeters. So around 14 centimeters stay inside the cabinet. That is exactly where the socks you never find end up later.
Full extension pulls the drawer out all the way to the back panel. Rauch explicitly lists this for its Flipp series, along with undermount runners that run beneath the drawer bottom and cannot be seen from the outside. Self-closing means the drawer pulls itself shut over the last few centimeters. Soft close slows it down as it does so, so nothing slams. Sounds like comfort. It is, but not only that: a damped drawer that closes itself is less often left standing half open. One more word on the drawer stop. For HEMNES, IKEA describes drawers with a pull-out stop, meaning they do not fall out of their guides. That is something different from an interlock that prevents several drawers from opening at the same time.
Particleboard or solid wood: less of a matter of faith than you might think
Particleboard has a bad reputation that it only partly deserves. For the Flipp, Rauch says it uses a virgin-wood particleboard called Woodmax with the rating „Schadstoffarm“ (low in harmful substances); the surface is a printed decor. Rauch publishes the load limits for each furniture part in a separate table. If you plan on heavy stacks of laundry, check there.
Solid wood is more forgiving. Scratches can be sanded out, and an oiled surface can be re-oiled. In return, the wood moves, it is heavier, and „solid“ rarely means that every part is solid. The HEMNES, for example, is made of solid pine according to IKEA, but the back panel and drawer bottoms are hardboard. That is common and not a defect. You just should know it before letting the word „solid“ guide you.
Our position: for a bedroom where the dresser stays in the same place for ten years, well-made particleboard is enough. Solid wood plays to its strengths where furniture grows with its owners, moves house and picks up marks. In other words, in a child’s room.
No dresser without wall anchoring
A dresser looks heavy and stable until several drawers are open. Then the center of gravity shifts forward, and the pulled-out drawers act like a lever. IKEA describes this in its guide to anti-tip restraints and names children between one and seven years old as particularly at risk. According to IKEA, an uneven floor, the edge of a rug or heavy objects on top of the dresser also increase the risk.
How serious this is was shown by the 2016 recall. On June 28, 2016, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) announced that IKEA was recalling around 29 million chests and dressers in the U.S., including about 8 million MALM, plus 6.6 million in Canada. Without wall anchoring the furniture was unstable, and children had died. Customers could choose between a refund and a free anchoring kit.
What follows from this? Pinolino requires the Natura to be anchored to the wall, suited to the wall material. That is exactly where things often go wrong. The anchors supplied do not fit every wall; in wood, according to IKEA, screws are used without anchors. With drywall or masonry you are unsure about, it is better to ask a professional than to drill on a hunch.
How many drawers does one person need?
More drawers do not mean more space, they mean more compartments. Five drawers over a height of 100 centimeters make for shallow drawers for underwear, socks and T-shirts. Sweaters and bed linen need taller ones. If you want to store both, measure a folded stack beforehand and compare it with the interior dimensions the manufacturer lists. Shirts and jackets remain the wardrobe’s job; what belongs in there is covered in our wardrobe guide.
Then there is depth. The models below range from 42 to 54 centimeters deep. In front of a bed or in a narrow hallway, ten centimeters decide whether you can still get past comfortably when a drawer is open.
Five dressers, sorted by design
Rauch Flipp with five drawers
Our recommendation for most bedrooms. According to the model list, the drawers run on undermount runners with self-closing and soft close, and the model page lists full extension and height-adjustable feet. The latter helps on old floorboards, which are rarely level. Rauch gives a ten-year manufacturer’s warranty under its own terms. The glass overlay on the front and top is optional; if you dislike fingerprints, go for the decor front.
Rauch Flipp narrow
The same hardware at a width of 40 centimeters. It works well as a nightstand substitute next to a wide bed or in the hallway for hats and scarves. IKEA points out that unanchored dressers are a danger to children regardless of model and size. This one belongs on the wall too.
Rauch Flipp, 160 centimeters with doors
Five drawers in the middle, with doors on the left and right featuring soft close and 16-millimeter-thick shelves. For two people sharing one dresser, that makes for clear territories. If you only use drawers anyway, you are better off buying two narrow dressers, which you can rearrange later.
Pinolino Natura breit
Solid beech, oiled with a hard oil based on linseed oil, three drawers with Self-Soft-Close and an open compartment. The changing top is removable, after which you are left with a dresser that can stay on in a teenager’s room. Without the top it is 54 centimeters deep, with the top 78. Pinolino cites the European standard DIN EN 12221-1 and requires wall anchoring.
Pinolino Natura extrabreit
The large version (extra-wide) with six drawers across 140 centimeters. The changing top can be mounted on the left, in the middle or on the right. It is delivered in two boxes weighing 42 and 44 kilograms. Carrying them up to the third floor on your own? Not a good idea.
How we would decide
- Bedroom, one person, about 80 centimeters of wall: Rauch Flipp with five drawers.
- Narrow alcove or hallway: the Flipp at 40 centimeters, anchored without fail.
- Two people, one wall: the Flipp at 160 centimeters with doors.
- Nursery during the diaper-changing years: Pinolino Natura breit, or the extra-wide version if you have lots of baby clothes.
- Solid wood for an adult bedroom: look closely at which parts are really solid.
If you are also looking for a matching wooden bed to go with the dresser, you will find advice on wood types and finishes in our wooden bed guide.
Frequently asked questions
What is full extension on a dresser?
Full extension pulls the drawer out all the way to the back panel. Without it, part of the drawer stays inside the cabinet: on the IKEA HEMNES with eight drawers, that is around 14 centimeters, which is exactly where the socks you never find end up. Rauch explicitly lists full extension for its Flipp series.
Particleboard or solid wood: which is better for a dresser?
For a bedroom where the dresser stays in the same place for a long time, well-made particleboard is enough. Solid wood is more forgiving and scratches can be sanded out, but it is heavier and moves with humidity. It plays to its strengths in a child's room, where furniture grows with the child and moves house.
Does a dresser have to be anchored to the wall?
Yes. When several drawers are open, the center of gravity shifts forward and the dresser can tip over. IKEA names children between one and seven years old as particularly at risk. Pinolino requires wall anchoring for the Natura, suited to the wall material.
Which wall anchors do I need for the anti-tip restraint?
That depends on the wall; the anchors supplied do not fit every wall. In wood, according to IKEA, screws are used without anchors. With drywall or masonry you are unsure about, it is better to ask a professional than to drill on a hunch.
How deep should a dresser be?
The models in the comparison are between 42 and 54 centimeters deep. In front of a bed or in a narrow hallway, ten centimeters decide whether you can still get past comfortably with a drawer open. The Pinolino Natura with its changing top is 78 centimeters deep.
Which dresser suits a nursery during the diaper-changing years?
The Pinolino Natura breit in oiled beech has three drawers with Self-Soft-Close and an open compartment. The changing top is removable, after which it can stay on in a teenager's room. With lots of baby clothes, the extra-wide version with six drawers fits.
Sources
- Rauch: Flipp model series
- Rauch: Flipp model list (PDF)
- Pinolino: Natura breit changing dresser
- Pinolino: Natura extrabreit changing dresser
- IKEA: HEMNES dresser with 8 drawers
- IKEA: Anti-tip restraints for furniture
- CPSC: Recall of MALM and other dressers (2016)
Where to buy
- Rauch Flipp, 5 SchubkästenCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Rauch Flipp, schmalCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Rauch Flipp Kombikommode 160 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Pinolino Natura breitCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Pinolino Natura extrabreitCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.











