Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Most cycling jackets do not fail because of the rain, but because of sweat. Pull a watertight rain jacket over a thick sweater and after twenty minutes you arrive wet from the inside. That is why it pays to briefly understand the technology behind it. Our first choice for commuters is the ROCKBROS Fahrradjacke (cycling jacket), which the retailer describes as waterproof, windproof, breathable and reflective. If you only want to keep out the wind, the lightweight TVI windbreaker for women is the cheaper option.
Windproof is not waterproof
Two properties are often mentioned in the same breath in product names. They have little to do with each other.
On the bike, wind is the underestimated opponent. Vaude calculates that 0 degrees with a 20 km/h headwind feels like roughly minus 5 degrees. Below 10 degrees, the wind clearly increases heat loss. The manufacturer distinguishes between fabrics that block around 80 percent of the wind while still letting plenty of air through, and fully windproof fabrics with a built-in membrane. The first suit fast rides on which you sweat a lot. The second suit cold, windy days and slow commuting.
For the cold season, the ADFC (German cyclists‘ association) recommends the layering principle: several thin layers instead of one thick jacket, with a windproof layer on the outside, such as a softshell. When it rains, a rain jacket goes on top or takes its place.
What the water column really measures
To determine the water column, the fabric is clamped under a cylinder 10 centimeters in diameter, which is then filled with water. What is measured is the height at which the first drops push through. Under the German DIN standard, a material counts as waterproof from 1,300 millimeters.
That sounds like a lot. On the bike, it is not much. On your backside on a wet saddle, under the backpack straps and on your forearms at the handlebars, water presses on the fabric with weight behind it. That is why outdoor manufacturers state far higher values for their jackets. Vaude, for example, specifies at least 10,000, 15,000 or 20,000 millimeters for its membranes, measured using the Japanese method JIS L 1092 B. Values from different test methods cannot be compared directly. So check whether a method is stated at all.
The ROCKBROS jackets below mention neither a water column nor a standard in their names. „Waterproof“ there is a retailer claim without a number. For a shower on the way to work, that need not be a problem. For an hour of steady rain, we would not rely on it.
Membrane, coating and the sweat problem
There are two ways to make a fabric waterproof. A coating is inexpensive but less abrasion-resistant and less breathable. A membrane is a semipermeable film that keeps droplets out and lets water vapor escape. It costs more and needs care. For membrane jackets, manufacturers distinguish between two-layer, two-and-a-half-layer and three-layer constructions. In a three-layer laminate, the outer fabric, membrane and lining are bonded together; this is considered the most watertight and most breathable construction.
Breathability is the figure you should trust least. Vaude deliberately publishes no values for its own membranes, because the test methods are inconsistent and only measure the membrane, not the finished jacket. The ADFC gives more practical advice: heat builds up under waterproof clothing, so do not dress too warmly underneath.
And one more thing. The water-repellent finish on the outside wears off. Vaude recommends refreshing it before intensive use and after every wash. Once rain no longer beads off, the outer fabric soaks through, and even an expensive membrane can then no longer release vapor.
Being seen
In November, it is dark on the way home. The ADFC advises light-colored clothing and reflective elements on the body. A black jacket without reflective strips is the worst choice in the evening, even if it looks best in the store. Good lights on the bike do not replace it, but they complement it.
Six jackets compared
All properties according to the retailer’s product names at ROCKBROS, without measured values. Prices are shown automatically from the retailer data.
| Model | Weather protection according to retailer | Special feature | Best for | Offer (affiliate link) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ROCKBROS Fahrradjacke wasserdicht, winddicht, reflektierend | waterproof and windproof | reflective | Commuters in the fall | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROCKBROS Herren Fahrradjacke 3-Schicht | windproof | three-layer, reflective | cold, dry days | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROAD TO SKY Regenjacke faltbar | rain jacket, windproof | packable, unisex | tours, rain gear in the bag | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROCKBROS Fahrradjacke Herren Wasserdicht Atmungsaktiv | waterproof | no further details | everyday riding in showers | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| ROCKBROS Herren Winter Fahrradjacke mit Fleecefutter | windproof | fleece lining | winter, short distances | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
| TVI Fahrradjacke Damen Windbreaker | windbreaker | lightweight | women, transitional seasons | View at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROSVoucher code ROCKBROSEU5 at ROCKBROS until 31.12., terms at the retailer |
ROCKBROS Fahrradjacke wasserdicht, winddicht, reflektierend
According to the retailer, this jacket (waterproof, windproof, reflective) covers all three points that count in the fall: rain, wind, visibility. A water column is missing, as are details on the membrane or seams. As an everyday jacket for showers and headwinds, it is still the best match for what commuters need from October to March.
ROCKBROS Herren Fahrradjacke 3-Schicht
Three layers sounds like a membrane laminate. The retailer, however, does not call this men’s jacket waterproof, only windproof, breathable and reflective. Read it as a softshell for cold, dry days.
ROAD TO SKY Regenjacke faltbar
The most expensive jacket here and the only one explicitly sold as a rain jacket and as packable. It belongs in your jersey pocket or handlebar bag and comes out when the sky clouds over. It is not meant to keep you warm; wear your usual layer underneath.
ROCKBROS Fahrradjacke Herren Wasserdicht Atmungsaktiv
The plain men’s version (waterproof, breathable) without any mention of reflective elements. If you already use a safety vest or a reflective backpack cover, you can save money here.
ROCKBROS Herren Winter Fahrradjacke mit Fleecefutter
Fleece inside, windproof outside. Pleasant for short trips in freezing weather, quickly too warm on long rides with climbs. In that case, better a thinner jacket and a sweater underneath that you can take off.
TVI Fahrradjacke Damen Windbreaker
Light and inexpensive, for crisp mornings in spring and fall. According to its name, it is not intended for rain. A windbreaker of this kind fits rolled up in a jersey pocket and, on the descent after a climb, keeps the headwind off your sweaty back. On fall rides, that is exactly where you get coldest, not in the rain.
Which jacket for which ride?
If you ride to work every day, whatever the weather, take the waterproof and windproof jacket with reflectors and rather wear one layer less underneath. If you ride for sport, combine a windproof softshell such as the 3-Schicht (three-layer) jacket with the packable rain jacket in your bag. And if you only have short trips in the depths of winter, you can go for the fleece model. If you still feel cold despite everything, there is the jacket with battery heating, which we discuss in a separate guide.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between windproof and waterproof?
The two properties have little to do with each other. Windproof fabrics keep out the headwind, which according to Vaude makes 0 degrees at 20 km/h feel like roughly minus 5 degrees. A fabric only becomes waterproof through a coating or a membrane.
What water column does a cycling jacket need?
Under the German DIN standard, a material counts as waterproof from 1,300 millimeters; on the bike that is not much, because the saddle, backpack straps and your posture on the handlebars create pressure. Vaude states at least 10,000 to 20,000 millimeters for its membranes. Values from different test methods cannot be compared directly.
Membrane or coating: which is better?
A coating is inexpensive but less abrasion-resistant and less breathable. A membrane keeps droplets out and lets water vapor escape, costs more and needs care. Three-layer laminate is considered the most watertight and most breathable construction.
Why do you get wet from the inside in a rain jacket?
Usually it is sweat. Heat builds up under waterproof clothing, which is why the ADFC (German cyclists' association) advises against dressing too warmly underneath. If the water-repellent finish also wears off, the outer fabric soaks through and even a membrane can no longer release vapor.
How do you dress properly for cycling in winter?
The ADFC recommends the layering principle: several thin layers instead of one thick jacket, with a windproof layer on the outside, such as a softshell. When it rains, a rain jacket goes on top or takes its place.
What should you look for in terms of cycling jacket visibility?
In fall and winter, the ride home is often in the dark. The ADFC advises light-colored clothing and reflective elements on the body. A black jacket without reflective strips is the worst choice in the evening. Good lights on the bike complement the jacket but do not replace it.
Sources
- Vaude: When is a rain jacket waterproof?
- Vaude: Clothing for cycling in winter and in the rain
- ADFC: The right clothing in cold weather
- ADFC: Accessories and clothing for everyday riding
- ADFC: Tips for cycling in winter
Where to buy
- ROCKBROS Fahrradjacke wasserdicht, winddicht, reflektierendView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROCKBROS Herren Fahrradjacke 3-SchichtView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROAD TO SKY Regenjacke faltbarView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROCKBROS Fahrradjacke Herren Wasserdicht AtmungsaktivView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- ROCKBROS Herren Winter Fahrradjacke mit FleecefutterView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
- TVI Fahrradjacke Damen WindbreakerView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.






