Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
One pan for everything? There is no such thing, even if advertising likes to suggest otherwise. Eggs, fish and pancakes are easiest in a nonstick pan. Steaks, fried potatoes and high-heat searing call for stainless steel, carbon steel or cast iron, because these materials tolerate high heat and last for many years. Our advice for almost every kitchen is therefore an unmatched pair: a nonstick pan of 24 or 28 centimeters, plus an uncoated one made of stainless steel or carbon steel. And if you cook on induction, you need a magnetic base.
Six pans from stainless steel to diamond coating
| Model | Material | Oven (according to the manufacturer) | Who it’s for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fissler Original-Profi Collection frying pan 28 cm | 18/10 stainless steel, uncoated | up to 230 °C | Searing, longevity |
| WMF Profi Resist frying pan 28 cm | Multi-layer with aluminum core, nonstick with honeycomb structure | up to 250 or 260 °C | Everyday use, a bit more heat too |
| Le Creuset Signature frying pan 26 cm | Enameled cast iron, wooden handle | not specified | Braising, serving, heat retention |
| de Buyer Mineral B Element 28 cm | Carbon steel, treated with beeswax | not specified | Steak, fried potatoes, purists |
| Tefal Unlimited On 28 cm | Aluminum, titanium nonstick coating | not specified | Beginners, eggs and fish |
| Woll Diamond Lite 28 cm | Cast aluminum, diamond nonstick coating | up to 300 °C without handle | Pan and baking dish in one |
Read the table by material first. A nonstick coating releases delicate foods easily but does not like maximum heat. Stainless steel is durable and easy to care for but takes a little practice at first so that nothing sticks. Iron, often called carbon steel, gets better over the years but needs to be seasoned and maintained. Enameled cast iron holds heat for a very long time. It is heavy. Sometimes heavier than you think in the store.
Stove, size, handle
Induction only works with a magnetic base; the label usually reads „suitable for all stove types incl. induction.“ If the base diameter does not match the cooking zone, the cooktop may not detect the pan at all.
24 centimeters is enough for one or two people, 28 for families. High-sided pans and serving pans hold more and are also suitable for braising. Metal handles usually tolerate high oven temperatures; plastic and wood are more pleasant to hold but limit oven use. Some manufacturers offer detachable handles.
Dishwasher? Many pans are considered dishwasher-safe. Even so, manufacturers often recommend hand washing because it protects the coating. Carbon steel and cast iron never belong in there.
A set with 24 and 28 centimeter pans often costs less than two individual pans. But only buy sizes you will actually use. Two identical nonstick pans are a typical bad buy; one nonstick plus one uncoated pan covers far more dishes.
PTFE: what the BfR says about nonstick pans
Many nonstick pans have a PTFE coating. When used as intended, the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) does not expect any health impairments. However, PTFE can decompose from around 360 °C, which is why the BfR advises against heating empty nonstick pans to high temperatures. On induction and gas stoves, that happens quickly. With food in the pan, the BfR considers overheating very unlikely. If the oil smokes, that is a warning sign.
Fissler Original-Profi Collection: stainless steel for decades
Uncoated 18/10 stainless steel with a CookStar base for all stove types that also works on induction: that is how Fissler describes the frying pan. According to the manufacturer, it tolerates up to 230 °C in the oven. The series is made in Germany and is also available with a Novogrill texture in the base and as a set with a lid. Upper price range. In return, you rarely buy it twice.
WMF Profi Resist: nonstick behind a grid
A clever idea. On top of a three-layer PermaDur nonstick sealing sits a raised honeycomb structure made of Cromargan, which, according to WMF, is meant to make the coating more scratch-resistant. The multi-layer body with an aluminum core is induction-compatible. The pan can go in the dishwasher, but WMF still recommends hand washing. Mid price range, also available as a set with 24 and 28 centimeter pans.
Le Creuset Signature: heavy, slow, enduring
Enameled cast iron, made in France according to Le Creuset. According to the manufacturer, the 26 centimeter version weighs 2.32 kilograms; a helper handle makes lifting easier. Over time, the interior enamel is said to develop a patina. The manufacturer offers a 30-year warranty and recommends hand washing. It does not state an oven temperature for this model; if you want to put cast iron in the oven, you are better off looking at the frying and serving pans made entirely of cast iron. Upper price range.
de Buyer Mineral B Element: not for the convenience-minded
Carbon steel sheet about three millimeters thick, made in France according to de Buyer and protected against rust with beeswax. It works on all stove types, including induction. Before you cook in it for the first time, it has to be seasoned. Dish soap and the dishwasher are off-limits; after washing, dry it and oil it lightly. Buyers report that it can rust and food can stick if care is neglected. If you can live with that, you get a pan for high-heat searing in the lower to mid price range.
Tefal Unlimited On: the red dot shows the heat
Aluminum with a titanium nonstick coating that, according to Tefal, also withstands metal spatulas. A Thermo-Signal dot in the center turns deep red when the cooking temperature is reached. Given the PTFE notes above, that is practical, because it keeps the pan from heating empty for longer than necessary. Dishwasher-safe, induction-compatible, made in France. Lower to mid price range, also available as an Ingenio set with a detachable handle.
Woll Diamond Lite: a pan that can also go in the oven
Cast from aluminum in the Saarland region of Germany and sealed with a five-layer diamond nonstick coating. Without the detachable handle, it is oven-safe up to 300 °C according to Woll; it is also available with a fixed handle. The dishwasher and all stove types including induction are no problem. Woll offers a 25-year warranty on the body and three years on the sealing. Mid price range.
Which pan belongs in which kitchen
For eggs, fish and newcomers, the Tefal Unlimited On with its temperature indicator is enough. If you want the nonstick pan to last longer than a year, take the WMF Profi Resist. The extra cost of the Woll Diamond Lite is only justified if you really use the detachable handle and also use the pan as a baking dish.
For uncoated, there is hardly any way around the Fissler Original-Profi Collection: long-lasting and easy to care for. The de Buyer Mineral B Element is made for steaks and high heat, provided you don’t shy away from maintenance. And the Le Creuset Signature? Lovely for braising and serving. In everyday use, simply heavy.
More for the kitchen: our overview of stand mixers (in German) and the guide to air fryers (in German).
Whether carbon steel, cast iron or nonstick suits your stove and kitchen is explained in the guide to woks, including instructions for seasoning.
Frequently asked questions
Which pan material is suited to what?
A nonstick coating releases delicate foods easily but does not like maximum heat. Stainless steel is durable and easy to care for but takes some practice at first. Carbon steel gets better over the years but needs to be seasoned and maintained. Enameled cast iron holds heat for a very long time but is heavy.
What size pan do you need?
24 centimeters is enough for one or two people, 28 for families. High-sided pans and serving pans hold more and are also suitable for braising. Two identical nonstick pans are a typical bad buy; one nonstick plus one uncoated pan covers far more dishes.
Are PTFE-coated pans a health concern?
When used as intended, the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) does not expect any health impairments. However, PTFE can decompose from around 360 °C, which is why the BfR advises against heating empty nonstick pans to high temperatures. If the oil smokes, that is a warning sign.
Can pans go in the dishwasher?
Many pans are considered dishwasher-safe, but manufacturers often still recommend hand washing because it protects the coating. Carbon steel and cast iron never belong in the dishwasher; the de Buyer Mineral B is dried and lightly oiled after washing.
Does every pan work on induction?
No, induction only works with a magnetic base. The label usually reads "suitable for all stove types incl. induction." If the base diameter does not match the cooking zone, the cooktop may not detect the pan at all.
Which pan can also go in the oven?
According to Woll, the Woll Diamond Lite is oven-safe up to 300 °C without its detachable handle, so it also doubles as a baking dish. The Fissler Original-Profi Collection tolerates up to 230 °C. Plastic and wooden handles limit oven use, while metal handles usually tolerate high temperatures.
Sources
- Fissler: Original-Profi Collection frying pan
- WMF: Profi Resist frying pan 28 cm
- Le Creuset: Signature cast iron frying pan
- de Buyer: Mineral B carbon steel pan 28 cm
- Tefal: Unlimited On pan 28 cm
- Woll: Diamond Lite cast pan 28 cm
- BfR: questions and answers on cookware with PTFE nonstick coating (in German)
Where to buy
- Fissler Original-Profi Collection Stielpfanne 28 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- WMF Profi Resist Stielpfanne 28 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Le Creuset Signature Bratpfanne 26 cm (kirschrot)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- de Buyer Mineral B Element 28 cm (5610.28)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Tefal Unlimited On 28 cm G25906Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Woll Diamond Lite 28 cm 1528DPICheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
