Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Ten in the evening, the neighbors are asleep, and the guitar should still sound like rock. This is exactly the scene that decides which amp is right for you. If you practice almost exclusively at home, you mainly need a good headphone output and a sound that holds up at low volume. For beginners who want to play with others later on, we consider the Boss Katana-50 Gen 3 the most sensible buy: according to the manufacturer, it can be throttled down to 0.5 watts and still has enough headroom for the first rehearsal.
First, figure out where you play
The wattage on the box says little about whether an amp fits your life. A 50-watt combo can be more pleasant in an apartment than a 20-watt tube amp, because it can be turned down cleanly. Conversely, a tiny battery-powered cube is no use if the drummer is standing next to you.
That is why an honest look at your everyday routine pays off. Do you practice at night? Then headphone operation is the most important feature. Check whether the manufacturer lists a cabinet simulation for this path; it recreates the speaker that is missing in headphones. For the Katana-50 Gen 3, Boss explicitly mentions a simulation using impulse responses, and for the Katana-Mini X a cabinet simulation with stereo effects.
A word about your hearing. The German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) points out that noise-induced hearing damage cannot be cured, because destroyed hair cells in the inner ear do not grow back. For workplaces, a daily limit of no more than 85 dB(A) applies, and for headphones, the agency recommends moderate volume. With a guitar in your ears, the same holds true.
And the neighbors? In 2018, Germany’s Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) ruled that making music at home is a socially acceptable leisure activity that must be tolerated within limits. As a rough guideline, the court named two to three hours on weekdays and one to two hours on Sundays and public holidays, in each case outside the usual quiet hours. The case concerned a townhouse, not a rented apartment. If you want to play longer or later, reach for headphones.
Modeling, tube or app?
Modeling amps digitally recreate the sound of various amplifiers and effects. Six of the seven devices below work this way. A tube amp, by contrast, works with real tubes in the preamp and power amp. To keep it usable in small rooms as well, Marshall builds power reduction into the Origin20. The app-based amps from Positive Grid and Boss move part of the operation to the smartphone. Convenient, as long as the phone is charged.
A typical mistake is buying a first tube combo without a headphone jack for an apartment. For the Origin20 Combo, Marshall lists no headphone output, only speaker outputs and a DI output. If you have to practice quietly at home, you then need a second device.
Seven amps side by side
| Model | Type | Key specs according to manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boss Katana:GO | Plug-in headphone amp | 10 amp types for guitar, 3 for bass, battery about 5 hours, Bluetooth, USB-C, 65 g | Headphones only, on the go and at night |
| Positive Grid Spark GO | Mini amp with battery | 5 watts, 2-inch speaker, 33 amp and 43 effect models, battery up to 8 hours, 346 g | Travel, desk, app fans |
| Boss Katana-Mini X | Battery-powered practice amp | 10 watts, 5-inch speaker, battery about 10 hours, Bluetooth audio, 2.7 kg | Simple operation without an app |
| Positive Grid Spark 2 | Modeling with app | 50 watts, two 4-inch speakers, looper with drum patterns, optional battery | Practicing with backing tracks and songs |
| Yamaha THR30II Wireless | Desktop amp | 30 watts stereo, battery about 5 hours, built-in wireless receiver, 4.3 kg | Living room, stereo sound, wireless |
| Boss Katana-50 Gen 3 | Modeling combo | 50 watts, 12-inch speaker, power adjustable down to 0.5 watts, USB-C, 11.6 kg | Beginners with band plans |
| Marshall Origin20 Combo | All-tube combo | 2× EL34, 3× ECC83, switchable 20/3/0.5 watts, 10-inch Celestion, 13.9 kg | Tube sound, rehearsal room |
Boss Katana:GO
No speaker, headphones only. The 65-gram plug goes straight into the guitar and, according to Boss, offers ten amp types for guitar, three for bass and more than 60 effects per mode. Via Bluetooth, you stream music to play along with, and via USB-C it records on a computer. According to the manufacturer, the battery lasts about five hours.
Positive Grid Spark GO
A 5-watt mini amp with a 2-inch speaker that also works as a headphone amp. According to Positive Grid, the Spark app provides 33 amp and 43 effect models, plus features for playing along. It is not meant for the rehearsal room. For the hotel room, it is.
Boss Katana-Mini X
Three basic sounds (Clean, Crunch, Brown), each with one variation, so six sounds in total, plus Bluetooth audio and a battery good for about ten hours. That is not much choice, but every knob is right on the device. If you do not want to pick up a smartphone to practice, you can do without one here.
Positive Grid Spark 2
The larger Spark has 50 watts, two 4-inch speakers with horns and a looper with drum backing. Via USB-C, it works as an audio interface, and Bluetooth plays songs. Positive Grid sells the battery, good for up to twelve hours, separately. If you do not like playing without an app, this is the right choice; if you want knobs on the device, the Katana is the better fit.
Yamaha THR30II Wireless
An amp that looks like a living room radio and plays in stereo: 30 watts on the power adapter, and 15 watts on battery according to the manual. The built-in receiver works with a separately available wireless transmitter, which does away with the cable to the guitar. You set tones on the device or in the THR Remote app, and a tuner is built in. At 4.3 kilos and with two small speakers, it is built for the desk and the sofa. In our view, it does not replace a combo for band rehearsals.
Boss Katana-50 Gen 3
The combo with a 12-inch speaker has six amp types, each with one variation, and five effect sections. What matters for an apartment is the power switch: standby, 0.5 watts, half power and full power. According to Boss, the sound stays punchy even at low volume, and for the first band rehearsal the 50 watts are there. Bluetooth is only available with an additional adapter, and 11.6 kilos is not something you carry around casually.
Marshall Origin20 Combo
The only true tube amp in this list. Two EL34s in the power amp, three ECC83s in front of them, one channel with gain boost and a tilt control. According to Marshall, the Powerstem power reduction lets you switch between 20, about 3 and about 0.5 watts. Marshall does not list a headphone output. That makes it a device for people who are allowed to play loud. For beginners in a rented apartment, we advise against it.
How we would decide
- You practice almost exclusively at night or on the go: Boss Katana:GO and good closed-back headphones, for example from our guide to studio headphones.
- You want a small speaker without technical clutter: Boss Katana-Mini X.
- You learn with songs and backing tracks from the app: Positive Grid Spark 2, or the smaller and more portable Spark GO.
- You play in the living room and like it wireless: Yamaha THR30II Wireless.
- You are starting out and want to play with others soon: Boss Katana-50 Gen 3.
- You have a rehearsal room and want tubes: Marshall Origin20 Combo.
No guitar yet? Our guide to electric guitars with an amp explains neck profile, scale length and complete sets. If you want to record without using the amp as an interface, you will find help in the guide to audio interfaces (in German).
For seven-string metal, we have reviewed a guitar from Japan: the ESP E-II Horizon FR-7.
Frequently asked questions
How many watts does a guitar amp need at home?
The wattage says little. A 50-watt combo can be more pleasant in an apartment than a 20-watt tube amp if it can be turned down cleanly. The Boss Katana-50 Gen 3 switches between standby, 0.5 watts, half power and full power.
What is the difference between a modeling amp and a tube amp?
Modeling amps digitally recreate the sound of various amplifiers and effects. A tube amp works with real tubes in the preamp and power amp. To keep it usable in small rooms, Marshall builds power reduction to 20, about 3 and about 0.5 watts into the Origin20.
Which amp is suitable for practicing with headphones?
Look for a cabinet simulation on the headphone path; it recreates the missing speaker. The Boss Katana:GO plugs directly into the guitar and works with headphones only. For the Marshall Origin20 Combo, the manufacturer does not list a headphone output, so it is not suited to quiet practice in an apartment.
How long am I allowed to play guitar in an apartment?
In 2018, Germany's Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) named two to three hours on weekdays and one to two hours on Sundays and public holidays as a rough guideline, outside the usual quiet hours. The case concerned a townhouse, not a rented apartment. If you play longer or later, reach for headphones.
Does an app-based amp make sense for beginners?
For learning with songs and backing tracks, yes: the Positive Grid Spark 2 has a looper with drum patterns and plays songs via Bluetooth. A lot of the operation happens on the smartphone. If you prefer knobs on the device, the Boss Katana-Mini X or the Katana-50 work without an app.
How do I protect my hearing while practicing?
The German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) points out that noise-induced hearing damage cannot be cured, because destroyed hair cells in the inner ear do not grow back. For headphones, the agency recommends moderate volume. For workplaces, a daily limit of no more than 85 dB(A) applies, and with a guitar in your ears, the same holds true.
Sources
- Boss: Katana:GO
- Boss: Katana-Mini X
- Boss: Katana-50 Gen 3
- Positive Grid: Spark GO
- Positive Grid: Spark 2
- Yamaha: reference manual THR30II Wireless, THR10II Wireless, THR10II (PDF)
- Marshall: Origin20 Combo
- German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt): hearing damage
- German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof): press release 171/2018, trumpet playing in a townhouse
Where to buy
- Boss Katana-50 Gen 3Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Boss Katana GOCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Positive Grid Spark GO (schwarz)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Boss Katana-Mini XCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Positive Grid Spark 2Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Yamaha THR30II WirelessCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Marshall Origin20 ComboCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
