Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Half past two in the morning, the mare is about to foal, and the stable is twelve minutes away by car. For exactly this situation, with no Wi-Fi and often no outlet in the right place, we consider the Reolink Go PT Ultra the best-suited of the cameras compared here. It connects over cellular, distinguishes animals from people and, according to heise, the German tech publisher, runs entirely without a cloud. A boarding stable with boarders, however, is a different case from your own run-in shed behind the house: there, data protection law comes first, then the technology.
Keeping an eye on the horse or securing the tack room?
These are two tasks, and they call for almost opposite things. If you want to check on an animal, you need a good live image on the couch at any time. Alarms only get in the way. If you want to protect saddles, you want the opposite: quiet as long as only horses are moving, and a notification as soon as a person shows up.
That is why detection matters more than resolution. Many battery cameras wake up via a heat sensor, and in our assessment, a horse in its stall is, for a sensor like that, a warm body that is constantly moving. Without a filter, this drains the battery and floods your phone with notifications. According to heise, the Go PT Ultra distinguishes people, vehicles and animals, and separate zones can be set for each type. According to ELV, a German electronics retailer, the EZVIZ EB8 specifically filters out animals. That suits the tack room and is a poor fit for the foaling stall.
None of these cameras interprets a horse’s behavior. They show a picture, nothing more. They will not alert you to colic, and the check on foot remains.
Dust, moisture, frost: what a stable demands of a camera
The German property insurers‘ guideline VdS 2067 on electrical installations in agriculture names dust, moisture and chemical vapors as stresses, plus the high fire load from hay and straw. In fire-hazard locations, it requires at least IP 4X for electrical equipment, and IP 5X where there are dangerous amounts of combustible dust or fibers. The first digit stands for dust protection. All five cameras below exceed this with a 6 in that position.
The typical weak point is therefore not the camera but the power supply. The housing keeps dust out; the small plug-in power supply on the beam above it, as a rule, does not. If a camera is to stay plugged in permanently, the outlet belongs on a circuit with a residual current device of no more than 30 mA, as the guideline requires. That is a job for a qualified electrician. Route cables out of the animals‘ reach. Because of rodents, the guideline also advises against running cables in places that are hard to keep an eye on. This is exactly where the battery has its advantage: no cable through the hay. Where to put the mount is covered in our guide to mounting security cameras (in German).
Cold is the second limit. The two Reolink models are rated down to minus 10 degrees, Imou, EZVIZ and Eufy down to minus 20 degrees. For a drafty outdoor stable in January, that can be the deciding factor. In the documentation for these cameras, we found no commitment regarding resistance to ammonia.
And at night? We would stick with the infrared image and switch off white light and siren. The Imou AOV PT, for example, activates siren and spotlight according to its data sheet as soon as it detects an intruder. In a stable full of flight animals, that is not a good default. What color night vision can do technically is explained in the guide to security cameras with color night vision.
Wi-Fi all the way to the stall, or straight to cellular?
If the stable is next to the house, 2.4 GHz is often enough, which according to heise offers the greater range. How far the signal reaches is best measured beforehand with your phone at the stall. Help with weak reception is in our guide to Wi-Fi for security cameras (in German). If the stable is out of town, the SIM card is the only option. Then first check whether your network reaches the location, and specifically inside the stable, not in the yard.
Data usage is often underestimated. Heise measured around 1.3 GB per hour of 4K live view for the Go PT Ultra; in economy mode, 1 GB lasts 3.5 hours. Our sample calculation for foaling season: checking in three times for ten minutes every night for four weeks. That comes to 14 hours. In 4K, that is around 18 GB; in economy mode, around 4 GB. So the data plan should match the season. The battery sets a limit too: in continuous live streaming, according to heise, it lasted about eight hours. The solar panel has to go outside, and Reolink’s cable is four meters long. The basics of SIM plans are in the guide to security cameras with a SIM card.
When boarders, the farrier and stable hands are in the picture
The guidance of the Datenschutzkonferenz, the conference of German data protection authorities, does not address horse stables specifically, but its principles can be applied. Data protection law only does not apply when a private individual films for purely personal or household purposes, with no connection to a profession or business. In our understanding, a boarding operation does not fall under this. What follows from that:
- Consent rarely holds up. It must be voluntary and verifiable, and merely entering a marked area is expressly not enough. In practice, the vet and visitors do not sign anything.
- A sign belongs in front of the monitored area, at eye level, with the name and contact details of the person responsible. A complete information sheet must also be available.
- Recordings are deleted as soon as they are no longer needed. 72 hours is generally considered permissible; beyond that, the burden of justification grows.
- The microphone has to go. According to the guidance, the audio function must be irreversibly disabled, otherwise Section 201 of the German Criminal Code comes into play. Check before buying whether the model allows this.
- Employees must not be monitored. Permanent work areas are generally off-limits, break rooms and staff rooms always, and in an employment relationship, consent is regularly considered not voluntary.
A stable aisle that is mucked out every day is therefore likely the worst spot. It is better to aim the view narrowly at a single stall. According to the guidance, storage rooms may be monitored outside operating hours to solve thefts, which comes fairly close to the tack room at night. A public live stream for the boarders is ruled out as soon as people are recognizable. And if you are a boarder who wants to hang your own camera at the stall, clear it with the operator first. When in doubt, the data protection authority of your German state will answer the question more bindingly than any guide.
Five cameras for stables without network cables
| Model | Connection | Protection rating, cold | Detection | Storage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reolink Go PT Ultra | 4G | IP64, down to −10 °C | People, vehicles, animals | microSD, 32 GB included |
| Reolink Go PT Plus | 4G | IP67, down to −10 °C | People, vehicles | microSD, 32 GB included |
| Imou AOV PT 5MP | 4G and 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi | IP66, down to −20 °C | People | microSD up to 512 GB |
| EZVIZ EB8 4G | 4G | IP65, down to −20 °C | People, vehicles | microSD up to 512 GB |
| Eufy 4G LTE Starlight | 4G | IP67, down to −20 °C | People | 7.3 GB built in |
Reolink Go PT Ultra
Heise recommends it among the cellular cameras, and for the stable, the animal detection with zones is the main argument. With a 355-degree pan range, it covers several stalls, and 4K helps when zooming in. The solar panel is included. The data on the card is stored unencrypted, and the app does not show data usage. Heise ran the cameras outdoors; a stable was not part of it.
Reolink Go PT Plus
Technically the sibling, with lower resolution and better sealing: IP67 instead of IP64. Heise calls the recordings good and the notifications reliable. Heise describes the detection for people and vehicles, which is enough for the tack room. Depending on the version, the panel costs extra.
Imou AOV PT 5MP
According to its data sheet, it is the only one here that supports both Wi-Fi and 4G. Handy if the farm Wi-Fi does reach the stable later. The always-on technology assembles time-lapses from scheduled single frames, which suits nighttime checks. We are not aware of any independent measurements of this camera, which is why it is not at the top.
EZVIZ EB8 4G
The solution for protecting the tack room and the farm entrance. It pans 340 degrees, charges via USB-C and, according to ELV, largely ignores animals. It is not intended for alarms about animals. Here too, the information is based on the retailer.
Eufy 4G LTE Starlight
A large 13,000 mAh battery, operation down to minus 20 degrees, and a clear consumption figure from Eufy: around 500 MB per month with ten live streams and 25 recordings a day. The internal storage is tight, and it has no speaker.
Three stables, three answers
Your own horses, a remote stable, concern for the animal: Reolink Go PT Ultra. Cold outdoor stable or shelter with sustained frost: Eufy 4G LTE Starlight. Farm with Wi-Fi within sight and the wish to switch over later: Imou AOV PT 5MP. That leaves the boarding operation. There, we would first sort out the sign, the deletion period and the image section, and buy afterward.
The owner is liable for damage a horse causes to others even without fault; what an insurance policy for this should cover is explained in the guide to horse owner’s liability insurance (in German).
Frequently asked questions
Which security camera is suitable for a horse stable without Wi-Fi?
A camera with cellular and a battery, such as the Reolink Go PT Ultra. According to heise, it distinguishes people, vehicles and animals, pans 355 degrees and comes with a solar panel. Check beforehand whether your network actually reaches inside the stable, not just the yard.
Why do horses trigger false alarms on battery cameras?
Many battery cameras wake up via a heat sensor, and a horse in its stall is a warm body that is constantly moving. Without a filter, this drains the battery and floods your phone with notifications. For watching the animals, separate zones for each detection type help; for the tack room, a camera that filters out animals, such as the EZVIZ EB8.
Which protection rating does a camera in a stable need?
The German guideline VdS 2067 requires at least IP 4X in fire-hazard locations, and IP 5X where there are dangerous amounts of combustible dust. All five cameras compared exceed this with a 6. The weak point is more likely the plug-in power supply; the outlet belongs on a residual current device of no more than 30 mA.
How much data does a 4G camera in a stable use?
Heise measured around 1.3 GB per hour of 4K live view for the Go PT Ultra; in economy mode, 1 GB lasts 3.5 hours. Four weeks of foaling season with three ten-minute checks per night add up to 14 hours, so around 18 GB in 4K or around 4 GB in economy mode.
Can you put up a camera in a boarding stable?
Only with data protection law in mind, because a boarding operation is not purely private use. You need a sign in front of the area, an information sheet, short deletion periods and a permanently disabled microphone. Employees must not be monitored. Boarders should clear their own camera with the operator first.
Does a stable camera detect colic?
No. None of these cameras interprets a horse's behavior; they only show a picture. The check on foot remains. At night, we recommend the infrared image and switching off white light and siren, because in a stable full of flight animals, an automatic alarm is not a good default.
Sources
- Datenschutzkonferenz: Guidance on video surveillance by non-public bodies
- VdS 2067: Electrical installations in agriculture
- heise best lists: wireless security cameras, LTE models
- Imou: AOV PT 5MP data sheet
- ELV: EZVIZ EB8 4G/LTE
Where to buy
- Reolink Go PT UltraCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Reolink Go PT PlusCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Imou AOV PT 5MPView at ImouAvailable in Germany: Imou
- EZVIZ EB8 4GView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Eufy 4G LTE StarlightCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
