Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
7:15 a.m., and the windows are white. Engine on, fan on setting four, and a peephole gets scraped clear with a store loyalty card. When it comes to ice, it doesn’t get any more expensive than that, and the mistake is not made at the checkout. If you park outdoors, your money is therefore best spent first on a windshield cover that stops ice from forming in the first place. Next come a proper scraper for the side and rear windows and, for very cold mornings, a de-icer spray as a backup.
What the German road traffic regulations require
Under Section 23 (1) of the German road traffic regulations (StVO), the driver is responsible for ensuring that their view is not impaired by the condition of the vehicle. Frozen windows are part of that. ADAC makes clear that a peephole in the windshield is not enough; the side windows, headlights, turn signals, taillights, license plate as well as the hood and roof must also be clear. According to ADAC, the peephole can mean a fine of between ten and thirty-five euros, and after an accident, partial liability as well.
Leaving the engine idling while you scrape is no shortcut. Section 30 (1) of the StVO expressly prohibits running vehicle engines unnecessarily. ADAC cites a fine of up to eighty euros for it. The legal alternative to warming up the engine is a parking heater, which ADAC expressly mentions for cars without a garage.
Cover, scrape, spray: in that order
If the car spends the night in the open, the cover comes first. It only protects the windshield, however; the side and rear windows still need scraping.
Then the blade. ADAC recommends plastic with a toothed edge for thick ice and a smooth edge for wiping off. It advises against metal because it can scratch glass and paint. Brass is a special case. Suppliers such as Murska advertise that brass is softer than glass. Whether a window gets scratched depends mainly on dirt, though: according to ADAC, grains of sand under the blade act like sandpaper, no matter what material the blade is made of.
Finally, the spray. De-icer spray works with alcohol. Look for a product that does not leave streaks, and pay attention to the hazard warnings: both sprays mentioned here are flammable.
Keep away from hot water. ADAC warns of stress cracks; lukewarm water freezes again immediately.
Six helpers against ice that are currently available
| Model | Type | Key data according to the manufacturer or seller | For whom |
|---|---|---|---|
| Walser Premium Thermo-Scheibenschutz (Art. 16554) | Windshield cover | two sizes (approx. 147 × 120 and 157 × 126 cm), four layers with aluminum coating, mirror covers, flaps that go in the door | Street parkers |
| Murska Eiskratzer A054 (L&P Car Design) | Hand scraper | 90 mm brass blade, rubber lip, fits in the glove compartment | Small cars, thick ice |
| Murska Eiskratzer A055 (L&P Car Design) | Long scraper | 370 mm long, 90 mm brass blade | SUVs, vans, minibuses |
| NIGRIN 71320 Eisschaber mit Handschuh Komfort | Glove scraper | 120 mm scraping edge, ice-breaker teeth, thickly lined glove | Anyone who leaves the house without gloves |
| SONAX ScheibenEnteiser 500 ml (03312410) | De-icer spray | safe on paint, rubber and plastic, said to protect against icing up again | Backup in the trunk |
| LIQUI MOLY Scheibenenteiser 500 ml (6902) | De-icer spray | gentle on plastic, rubber and paint, spray bottle with stop setting | Backup, high-mileage drivers |
Walser Premium Thermo-Scheibenschutz
Four layers, an aluminum coating on the outside, and flaps on the left and right that are clamped between the door and the frame. According to Walser, the mirror covers of this Thermo-Scheibenschutz (thermal windshield protector) hang on an elastic band so they do not get lost. Good. Those covers in particular otherwise tend to end up in the gutter. Measure your windshield beforehand, because retailers do not name the sizes consistently, though the centimeters are consistent.
Murska A054 with brass blade
A small scraper from Finland, with a brass blade and a rubber lip for wiping off. In a comparison by the magazine Auto Motor und Sport (issue 02/2025), it received a „befriedigend“ (satisfactory). Many retailers also sell imitations bearing the Murska name. L&P Car Design should be listed as the seller.
Murska A055 in long
The same blade, but on a 370-millimeter handle. On tall vehicles, that is no luxury: anyone who has to stand on the running board to reach the middle of the windshield otherwise scrapes at an angle and with too much pressure.
NIGRIN 71320 with glove
A plastic scraper (Eisschaber mit Handschuh, ice scraper with glove) with a 120-millimeter-wide edge, ice-breaker teeth and a thickly lined glove sewn on. More comfort than technology. Buyers praise warm hands but also mention a poorly finished edge. If you have your own winter gloves, you don’t need this model.
SONAX ScheibenEnteiser
For the ScheibenEnteiser (window de-icer), Sonax recommends first sweeping off loose snow, then spraying evenly and wiping off the loosened ice; with thick layers, you spray again. According to the manufacturer, the product protects against icing up again and is compatible with paint, rubber and plastic. Some buyers mention a film on the glass. A clean cloth is therefore part of the kit.
LIQUI MOLY Scheibenenteiser
Spray on, let it work briefly, wipe off with a rubber lip. Liqui Moly describes the Scheibenenteiser (window de-icer) as gentle on plastic, rubber and paint. The bottle is labeled as highly flammable and an eye irritant. After use, the nozzle is turned to stop, according to the manufacturer.
What suits which parking spot
If the car stands outside every night, the Walser cover plus a simple scraper for the sides and rear saves the most minutes in the morning. With a garage and only occasional frost, a Murska A054 in the glove compartment is enough for a small car. SUV or van? Then the Murska A055, so you can reach the middle of the windshield without contortions.
We see the NIGRIN 71320 for cold hands and short trips; otherwise, the glove is a surcharge without benefit. Sonax or Liqui Moly are suitable as a backup for thick layers of ice when you are short on time. Sprayed every morning, spray ends up costing more over time than a cover.
A word about the windshield wipers: never tear frozen wiper blades loose. They suffer, and the dirt on them ends up as streaks on the glass. Cold mornings are also hard on batteries; if the starter struggles, our overview of the car battery charger helps. More on tires for ice and snow can be found in the winter tire guide.
Frequently asked questions
Is a peephole in the windshield enough?
No. Under Section 23 of the German road traffic regulations (StVO), the driver is responsible for ensuring that their view is not impaired. According to ADAC, the side windows, headlights, turn signals, taillights, license plate as well as the hood and roof must also be clear. A peephole can mean a fine, and after an accident, partial liability as well.
Can I leave the engine running while scraping ice?
No, Section 30 of the StVO expressly prohibits running vehicle engines unnecessarily, and ADAC cites a fine for it. The legal alternative to warming up the engine is a parking heater, which ADAC expressly mentions for cars without a garage.
Which ice scraper won't scratch the glass?
ADAC recommends plastic with a toothed edge for thick ice and a smooth edge for wiping off, and advises against metal. Murska advertises that brass is softer than glass. Whether scratches appear depends mainly on dirt, though: according to ADAC, grains of sand under the blade act like sandpaper.
Can I pour hot water on a frozen windshield?
Keep away from hot water. ADAC warns of stress cracks in the glass, and lukewarm water freezes again immediately. Never tear frozen wiper blades loose either, because they suffer, and the dirt on them ends up as streaks on the glass.
Is de-icer spray worth it?
As a backup for thick layers of ice when you are short on time. De-icer spray works with alcohol, and both sprays mentioned are flammable. Look for a product that does not leave streaks and keep a clean cloth handy. Sprayed every morning, spray ends up costing more over time than a cover.
Which ice scraper suits SUVs and vans?
For tall vehicles, the Murska A055 with its 370-millimeter handle helps. Otherwise, anyone who has to stand on the running board to reach the middle of the windshield scrapes at an angle and with too much pressure. When buying, make sure L&P Car Design is listed as the seller, because there are imitations bearing the Murska name.
Sources
- StVO Section 23 (other duties of drivers)
- StVO Section 30 (environmental protection, unnecessary idling of the engine)
- ADAC: Scraping ice
- ADAC: Letting the engine warm up
- ADAC press: Removing ice and snow before driving
- Walser: Premium Thermo-Scheibenschutz
- SONAX: ScheibenEnteiser 500 ml
- LIQUI MOLY: Scheibenenteiser
- Auto Bild: Murska ice scrapers
- t-online: Auto Motor und Sport ice scraper comparison
Where to buy
- Walser Premium Thermo-Scheibenschutz (Art. 16554)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Murska Eiskratzer A054Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Murska Eiskratzer A055 langCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- NIGRIN 71320 Eisschaber mit Handschuh KomfortCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- SONAX ScheibenEnteiser 500 mlCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- LIQUI MOLY Scheibenenteiser 500 mlCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
