Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
With kids‘ audio players, a bad buy rarely shows at the checkout. It shows two years later, when a shelf full of figures or cards fits exactly one device. For a child between three and seven who will mostly listen to ready-made audio stories, parents, in our assessment, usually end up with the Toniebox 2. Your own music, recordings from the grandparents, as little cloud as possible? Then the hörbert deserves a closer look.
The box itself is the smaller part of the bill. What matters is how content gets onto the device and what it costs in the long run.
Step one: figure, card or chip
Figures (Tonies) are the easiest for toddlers to grab and to collect. Cards (tigerbox, Yoto) are flat and travel-friendly. Kekz relies on small magnetic chips that click directly onto a pair of headphones. The systems are not compatible with each other, not a single one.
Step two: what does new content cost?
With Tonies, tigercards, Yoto cards and Kekz chips, you buy each piece of content individually, according to the manufacturers. The tigerbox also offers the streaming service tigertones as a subscription. The hörbert is different. There, you copy your own MP3 files onto the memory card; preloaded cards are available as accessories.
Depending on the system, your own recordings go through a Kreativ-Tonie (a figure you fill with your own audio), a Wildcard, a Make-Your-Own card or a built-in microphone. The methods differ widely, especially on the question of whether a cloud is needed.
Step three: internet, volume, data
Almost all boxes need Wi-Fi for setup and for loading a piece of content for the first time. After that, they play stored content without internet. According to the manufacturer, only Kekz works entirely without Wi-Fi and Bluetooth.
On volume, we take a clear position. A limit that parents set and the child cannot get around is a must. Check whether it also applies to headphones.
Boxes with an app and an account talk to the manufacturer’s servers. How much data that involves was examined by the University of Basel in 2024 across twelve connected toys. According to the university’s announcement, the Toniebox tested at the time recorded when which figure was placed on it, stopped or skipped, and sent this data to the manufacturer. It performed poorly on encryption of its data traffic. The announcement does not say whether this still applies to the Toniebox 2. The manufacturer has told the media that it uses the data only for the listening experience.
What follows from this? If you want to avoid usage data as far as possible, choose a box that works without a manufacturer account. For all the others, read the privacy policy beforehand.
Six kids‘ audio players and their key specs
| Model | Content via | Your own content | Without internet | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Toniebox 2 | Figures (Tonies) | Kreativ-Tonie, up to 90 minutes | yes, after the first playback | ages 1 and up according to the manufacturer, audio story collectors |
| tigerbox Touch Plus | tigercards and streaming (tigertones) | Wildcard | yes, for paired cards and downloads | older children, large selection by subscription |
| hörbert 3.0 | Memory card, 9 playlist buttons | MP3 and built-in microphone | yes | families with their own music collection |
| Yoto Player (3rd generation) | Cards | Make-Your-Own card | yes, after loading | multilingual families |
| Yoto Mini (4th generation) | Cards and favorites button | Make-Your-Own card, recordings via app | yes, 64 GB storage | on the go, ages 3 and up according to the manufacturer |
| Kekz Starterset Premium | Magnetic chips on the headphones | Wunderkekz, up to 90 minutes according to retailer information | yes, without Wi-Fi and Bluetooth | car, travel, siblings in the same room |
Toniebox 2
According to the manufacturer, the second generation plays all existing Tonies, including the old ones. That protects a collection you already have. The box only needs Wi-Fi for setup, the first time a new Tonie is placed on it, and for loading a Kreativ-Tonie, which holds a maximum of 90 minutes of your own content. New additions are Tonieplay games, which also require a Tonieplay Controller, plus a night light with timer and a wake-up light. Parents set the maximum volume via the app.
One limitation remains. Your own content only works with an account and the Toniecloud.
tigerbox Touch Plus
Touch display, Bluetooth for headphones and the streaming service tigertones, which comes as a trial in the starter set. Purchased tigercards also play offline after the first pairing. According to retailer information, a Wildcard holds a good 120 minutes of your own recordings or MP3s. According to tigermedia, parents limit the volume in profiles and, since an update, also directly on the device. If you do not plan to renew the subscription, it is best to find out beforehand what will remain on the box without tigertones.
hörbert 3.0
A wooden box with nine colorful buttons. It is the counter-model to the figure collection. Each button controls its own playlist, which parents fill with MP3 files from a computer, tablet or smartphone. According to the manufacturer, the current version has a built-in microphone, Bluetooth and internet radio and is made in Germany. Settings are made via the browser on your home Wi-Fi; the product page does not mention a manufacturer account. There is nothing here for children to collect. For some families, that is exactly the advantage.
Yoto Player (3rd generation)
Yoto works with cards that are inserted at the top and includes a Make-Your-Own card for your own recordings and MP3s. According to retailer information, the 32 GB of internal storage holds several hundred hours for offline use. Podcasts and radio are unavailable without internet. The app lets you set separate volume limits for day and night as well as for headphones. Since mid-October 2026, Yoto has already been selling the 4th generation in its own shop, with 64 GB and a green dial for up to 20 favorites. On Amazon, the third generation is still available and entirely sufficient for most families. Many starter sets on Amazon contain English cards. Appealing for bilingual families, less so for others.
Yoto Mini (4th generation)
The small Yoto is new and belongs in a backpack rather than on a shelf. According to the manufacturer, it weighs 185 grams, is protected against water and dust to IP67 and lasts up to 16 hours. Headphones can be connected by cable or Bluetooth, with the volume limited by default. It reads the same cards as the large player. It does lack a night light, though. If you already own a Yoto Player, the Mini gives you a second box for travel without building a second card collection.
Kekz Starterset Premium
Not a box, but wireless headphones for kids. According to the manufacturer, the content is stored in the device and unlocked by a magnetic chip on the ear cup. No Wi-Fi, no Bluetooth, no app. The volume is limited in three levels to a maximum of 85 decibels. That works well in the back seat on long drives. As the only box in the kids‘ room, Kekz is less suitable, because only one child can listen at a time.
Which family, which box?
Toddler, ready-made audio stories, grandparents who like to bring something along: here, a lot speaks for the Toniebox 2. The figures are made for very small hands and are easy to buy as gifts. The collection will grow, though, and you should plan for that.
- School-age child with a big appetite for listening: tigerbox Touch Plus with tigertones, provided you accept an ongoing subscription.
- Your own music, little cloud, long device life: hörbert 3.0. You invest time in playlists instead of money in figures.
- Bilingual family or lots of homemade content: Yoto Player, supplemented by the Yoto Mini for on the go.
- Car and travel: Kekz as an addition, not as a replacement for a box.
At six or seven, a device of their own often comes up for discussion anyway. Our guides to kids‘ tablets (in German) and kids‘ smartwatches cover the next step. For creative children, a kids‘ camera can be a good complement to recording their own audio stories.
Frequently asked questions
Are Tonies, tigercards and Yoto cards compatible with each other?
No, not a single system works in another device. Tonies are figures, tigerbox and Yoto use cards, and Kekz uses magnetic chips on the headphones. A bad buy often only shows years later, when a shelf full of content fits exactly one device.
What do kids' audio players cost in the long run?
With Tonies, tigercards, Yoto cards and Kekz chips, you buy each piece of content individually, according to the manufacturers. The tigerbox also offers the tigertones subscription. With the hörbert, you copy your own MP3 files onto the memory card. The box itself is the smaller part of the bill.
Do kids' audio players need a permanent internet connection?
Almost all boxes need Wi-Fi for setup and for loading a piece of content for the first time; after that, they play stored content offline. According to the manufacturer, only Kekz works entirely without Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. On the Yoto, podcasts and radio are unavailable without internet.
What about data privacy with the Toniebox?
In 2024, the University of Basel found that the Toniebox tested at the time sent usage data to the manufacturer. The announcement does not say whether this applies to the Toniebox 2. If you want to avoid usage data, choose a box without a manufacturer account, such as the hörbert, and read the privacy policy beforehand for all the others.
Can you play your own recordings on kids' audio players?
Yes, but the methods differ widely: Kreativ-Tonie with up to 90 minutes, Wildcard on the tigerbox, Make-Your-Own card on the Yoto, or the built-in microphone on the hörbert 3.0. On the Toniebox, your own content only works with an account and the Toniecloud.
What should you look for in a volume limit?
A limit that parents set and the child cannot get around is a must. Check whether it also applies to headphones. On the Yoto, separate limits can be set for day, night and headphones; according to the manufacturer, Kekz limits volume to a maximum of 85 decibels.
Sources
- tonies: Toniebox 2
- tonies: How the Toniebox works
- tonies help: Toniebox 2 settings in the app
- tigermedia help center: tigerbox software versions
- hörbert for kids
- Yoto Player
- Yoto help: Volume limiter
- Yoto Player 4th generation
- Yoto Mini 4th generation
- ifun.de: Yoto Player 4 and Mini 4
- Kekz (brand page at Rossmann, German drugstore retailer)
- University of Basel: Smart toys create behavioral profiles of children (08/26/2024)
Where to buy
- Toniebox 2 (Starterset mit Kreativ-Tonie, Pink)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- tigerbox Touch PlusCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- hörbert 3.0Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Yoto Player 3. GenerationCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Yoto Mini 4. GenerationCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Kekz Starterset PremiumCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
