Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
With an offset smoker, what you are mainly buying is steel. Thermometer, cover and side table can be added later; the wall thickness of the body cannot. For a garden with room for a 1.5-meter-long unit, we consider the Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Wild West the most well-rounded choice: 6.35-millimeter steel pipe, a 70 by 38.5-centimeter grate and 140 kilograms according to the manufacturer. If you regularly cook for larger gatherings, take the Longhorn with one meter of grate length.
Why does wall thickness matter more than grilling area?
The principle is old and simple. The fire burns in the side firebox, heat and smoke travel across the cooking chamber and leave it through the chimney at the other end. The meat never sits over the embers. For this slow cooking, Joe’s Barbeque names 90 to 160 °C, ideally 100 to 130 °C, and that for hours.
At such low temperatures, mass is what counts. A body made of thick steel stores heat and compensates when you open the lid, add wood or a cool wind picks up. Thin sheet metal follows every fluctuation immediately. You then end up at the air vent more often than you would like.
Joe’s Barbeque builds two types of construction. The Silver Edition models are made from 5 mm steel plate that is cut, rolled and welded; the manufacturer itself describes them as an alternative to steel pipe. The other models consist of pipe with a 6.35 mm wall thickness, from which the lids are cut out and flanged back on. According to the manufacturer, this makes them seal particularly tightly. If a data sheet only says „solid steel“ or „heavy gauge,“ the most important number is missing. Ask for millimeters.
How much cooking space and how much footprint do you need?
All five models below have a 16-inch pipe, which is just over 40 centimeters in diameter. The difference lies in the length. The short versions offer a 70 by 38.5-centimeter grate in the cooking chamber, around 2,700 cm². Longhorn and Chuckwagon reach 100 by 38.5 centimeters, about 3,850 cm², and in return need almost two meters of space lengthwise.
Then there is the weight. Between 110 and 260 kilograms rest on four points, two of which are iron wheels. On a lawn, a unit like this sinks in, and on loose gravel it is hard to push. A paved or concrete spot is the better foundation. Before ordering, also measure the path from the garden gate to the spot, including steps.
How do you hold 110 degrees for an entire day?
With air, not with fuel. The air intake on the firebox determines how strongly the fire burns, and the damper on the chimney how quickly heat and smoke escape. According to the manufacturer, Longhorn and Chuckwagon have a „Dual Damping System“ with double control. A pellet grill takes this work off your hands with a controller; an offset smoker does not. That is the real character of the device.
The lid thermometer measures at the top of the lid, while the meat sits lower. A wireless thermometer with a probe at grate level and a second one in the core shows what is actually happening. Our guide to grill thermometers compares suitable devices.
For fuel, Joe’s Barbeque names beech and fruitwood or charcoal. For outdoor fires, the German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) recommends dry, well-seasoned and untreated wood; painted wood or wood treated with preservatives can release highly toxic dioxins and furans when burned. Pallets, construction lumber and stained offcuts therefore do not belong in the firebox.
In fairness, this belongs here too. According to the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) form, among other things, during incomplete combustion, travel with the smoke to the food and are deposited more heavily the longer it sits in the smoke. The BfR recommends waiting out the heavy smoke phase after lighting and catching fat so that it does not drip into the embers. The German Environment Agency recommends a good air supply to prevent heavy smoke. For the smoker, that means a fire that burns with enough air, rather than wood that smolders away.
What do neighbors and courts say about the smoke?
An offset smoker does not smoke for an hour but for half a day. There is no fixed number of permitted barbecue evenings. In the German state of North Rhine-Westphalia, Section 7 of the State Immission Control Act prohibits burning outdoors insofar as it may endanger or significantly disturb the neighborhood; Section 9 protects nighttime quiet from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. Other German states have their own rules, and then there are the lease and the house rules.
Courts decide case by case. On July 29, 2002, the Higher Regional Court of Oldenburg ruled (13 U 53/02) that in cramped conditions a neighbor does not have to tolerate intensive nighttime barbecuing. On four evenings a year, however, barbecuing until midnight was reasonable, and a complete ban would go too far. Position the smoker so that the chimney does not point at the bedroom window next door. A quick word in advance often helps more than any ruling.
Five offset smokers from Joe’s Barbeque compared
All models come from RUMO BBQ GmbH, a German manufacturer in Treis-Karden on the Moselle. The figures are manufacturer specifications.
| Model | Grate cooking chamber / firebox | Body | Weight, dimensions (L × W × H) | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Tradition | 70 × 38.5 cm / no grate | 5 mm sheet steel | 110 kg, 150 × 80 × 160 cm | Getting started, smoking only |
| Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Classic | 70 × 38.5 cm / 40 × 38.5 cm | 5 mm sheet steel | 130 kg, 150 × 80 × 160 cm | Smoking and direct grilling |
| Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Wild West | 70 × 38.5 cm / optional 40 × 38.5 cm | 6.35 mm steel pipe | 140 kg, 150 × 80 × 157 cm | Families, compact gardens |
| Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Longhorn | 100 × 38.5 cm / 48 × 38.5 cm | 6.35 mm steel pipe | 200 kg, 195 × 85 × 165 cm | larger gatherings, lots of food |
| Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Chuckwagon | 100 × 38.5 cm / 50 × 38.5 cm, plus 5 round grates | 6.35 mm steel pipe | 260 kg, 200 × 90 × 200 cm | Festivals, clubs, permanent spot |
16″ Tradition: the sheet steel entry model
The manufacturer itself calls it its entry-level model. The body is made of 5 mm sheet steel with a coating heat-resistant up to 800 °C, the cooking chamber has stainless steel grates with 5 mm rods, and according to the manufacturer assembly takes just seven screws. There is no grilling grate in the firebox. If you only want to smoke, you do not need one.
16″ Classic: with a hot plate on the firebox
Same sheet steel, same cooking chamber, but sandblasted and with stainless steel grates in the firebox too. There you can grill directly over the embers, and a pot of beans or sauce sits on the hot plate in the firebox lid. That makes it 20 kilograms heavier than the Tradition and considerably more versatile.
16″ Wild West: pipe instead of sheet steel
Our recommendation for a normal garden. The footprint matches the Tradition, but the body is made of 6.35 mm thick steel pipe, the stainless steel grates have 6 mm rods and the fire grate 16 mm rods. A grate for the firebox is only available as an accessory. For 140 kilograms, you get the construction that Joe’s Barbeque calls „the original,“ without the length of a Longhorn.
16″ Longhorn: one meter of grate
The extended version of the 16″ Special. The grate in the cooking chamber measures 100 by 38.5 centimeters, and the firebox is larger and carries a hot plate. The unit comes fully welded, so there is nothing to assemble. At 200 kilograms and almost two meters long, it needs a permanent spot that it will not leave again.
16″ Chuckwagon: with a smoking tower
In addition to the Longhorn-format cooking chamber, there is a vertical chamber with five round grates 38.5 centimeters in diameter, which can be used for smoking or keeping food warm, plus a second thermometer. Two meters tall, 260 kilograms heavy. For a family, that is clearly too big. For club festivals or a barbecue team, it makes sense.
Offset smoker or a pellet grill after all?
Honestly, this is the first question to ask before buying. A pellet grill holds the set temperature via a controller and feeds the fuel itself, so you can devote yourself to other things for hours. An offset smoker requires you to keep an eye on fire and air and add wood regularly. If that feels like work to you, you will be happier with the pellet grill; models for that are in our guide to pellet grills and smokers (in German). If tending a wood fire is exactly what you are after, you will be satisfied with the offset.
Factor in accessories right away: heat-resistant gloves, a poker for the embers, a cover against rain. Which of these prove their worth is shown in our guide to grill accessories (in German).
How we would decide
- You mainly want pulled pork, ribs and brisket at 110 °C and have little space: 16″ Wild West.
- You want to get started with the simplest possible construction and grill on a second unit anyway: 16″ Tradition.
- Steaks over the embers and smoking with one unit: 16″ Classic, or the Wild West with the optional firebox grate.
- Regular large gatherings, permanent spot available: 16″ Longhorn.
- Club festival, barbecue team, smoking and keeping warm at the same time: 16″ Chuckwagon.
- You do not want to add wood and would rather control things at the push of a button: pellet grill instead of an offset.
Frequently asked questions
Why is wall thickness so important in an offset smoker?
At low cooking temperatures, mass is what counts. Thick steel stores heat and compensates when you open the lid, add wood or the wind picks up. Thin sheet metal follows every fluctuation immediately. If the data sheet only says solid steel, the most important number is missing: ask for millimeters.
Which spot is suitable for a heavy smoker?
A paved or concrete one. The models weigh between 110 and 260 kilograms and stand on four points, two of them iron wheels. On a lawn, a unit like this sinks in, and on loose gravel it is hard to push. Also measure the path from the garden gate to the spot.
How do you keep the temperature constant in a smoker?
With air, not with fuel. The air intake on the firebox determines how strongly the fire burns, and the damper on the chimney how quickly heat and smoke escape. A wireless thermometer with a probe at grate level shows more than the lid thermometer, which measures at the top of the lid.
Which wood can go in the firebox?
Joe’s Barbeque names beech and fruitwood or charcoal. The German Environment Agency recommends dry, well-seasoned and untreated wood, because treated wood can release dioxins and furans when burned. Pallets, construction lumber and stained offcuts do not belong in it.
Offset smoker or pellet grill?
A pellet grill holds the temperature via a controller and feeds the fuel itself. An offset smoker requires you to keep an eye on fire and air and add wood regularly. If that feels like work to you, you will be happier with the pellet grill.
What do neighbors and courts say about the smoke?
There is no fixed number of permitted barbecue evenings; German courts decide case by case. In cramped conditions, the Higher Regional Court of Oldenburg considered four evenings a year until midnight to be reasonable. Position the smoker so that the chimney does not point at the bedroom window next door.
Sources
- Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Tradition (RUMO BBQ)
- Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Classic (RUMO BBQ)
- Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Wild West (RUMO BBQ)
- Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Longhorn (RUMO BBQ)
- Joe’s Barbeque Smoker 16″ Chuckwagon (RUMO BBQ)
- Joe’s Barbeque: How it works, temperatures, construction types
- German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment: Questions and answers on grilling (June 2026)
- German Environment Agency: Grilling in an environmentally friendly and healthy way
- German Environment Agency: Campfires and fire bowls (choice of wood)
- State Immission Control Act of North Rhine-Westphalia, Sections 7 and 9
- Higher Regional Court of Oldenburg, ruling of 29.07.2002, 13 U 53/02 (report by Rechtslupe)
Where to buy
- Joe's Barbeque Smoker 16 Wild WestCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Joe's Barbeque Smoker 16 TraditionCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Joe's Barbeque Smoker 16 ClassicCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Joe's Barbeque Smoker 16 LonghornCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Joe's Barbeque Smoker 16 ChuckwagonCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
