Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
An evening in the backyard, the briquettes are glowing, and the stew needs to go into the pot. Whether that works out depends less on the brand than on the bottom of the pot. If you mostly cook over embers, briquettes or in a fire bowl, choose a Dutch oven with legs. If the pot will mostly sit in a kettle grill, on a kamado or in the kitchen oven, a flat bottom is the better fit.
And the size? For four to eight people, a pot of around six liters is enough, such as the Petromax ft6.
Legs or a flat bottom: first the fire, then the pot
A pot with three legs stands directly over the embers without smothering them. That is how Valhal Outdoor describes its models with legs, and that is the idea behind the design. On a grill grate or in the oven, however, the legs get in the way. Valhal explicitly advertises its pots without legs for kamado and oven use, and Petromax sells its flat versions with the suffix „-t“ (for example, ft6-t).
Then there is the lid. It needs a high rim so that the briquettes stay on top. With Petromax, the lid itself stands on three legs and can be turned over and used as a skillet in the embers; according to the manufacturer, it will not tip over.
How many liters for how many people?
The manufacturers state numbers of people, and they are surprisingly close to one another. For the ft6, with 5.5 liters in the pot and 1.5 liters in the lid, Petromax speaks of four to eight people. Valhal Outdoor also states four to eight for 6.1 liters, and eight to fourteen people for 8 liters. Petromax itself writes that these are guideline figures that depend on appetite. In its FAQ, the ft6 is matched to a family of two adults and two children.
Our take: if you want to bake bread or braise a whole roast, plan on the generous side. But too big comes at a price. According to Valhal, a six-liter pot already weighs 8.3 kilograms, and every size up needs more briquettes.
Briquettes on top, briquettes below
Here the manufacturers differ in the details, not in principle. For soups and stews, Petromax recommends two thirds of the briquettes under the pot and one third on the lid. For baking bread and cakes, it is the other way around. For the ft6, the Petromax instructions state 24 briquettes for 160 to 180 °C, 14 of them on top and 10 below.
Lodge calculates a little differently. For baking, the manufacturer recommends three parts on top and one part below; for roasting, equal amounts on top and below. With Lodge, cooking, braising and frying are done from below only. Lodge arranges the bottom coals in a circle a good centimeter inside the rim of the pot, and the top coals in a checkerboard pattern. If you need to add more, keep the ratio the same.
A thermometer with a probe takes the guesswork out of it. Some pots have a notch in the rim for this. Which models are available is covered in our guide to grill thermometers.
Seasoning and lid lifters
According to the manufacturers, all the pots here come pre-seasoned. Petromax advises simply rinsing the pot with warm water the first time and drying it thoroughly. You should re-season as soon as rust appears: coat thinly with fat, put it in the oven without the lid at about 180 °C for around one to two hours, then let it cool slowly. Despite the pre-seasoning with natural oil, Valhal recommends regular care with its own wax.
You cannot do without a lid lifter. A lid loaded with embers is heavy and hot, and the ash should not fall into the food. Camp Chef includes a lifter with its Deluxe pots, and Petromax also sells the ft6 in a set with one. With Lodge, it is sold separately.
Six Dutch ovens available on Amazon.de
| Model | Capacity according to the manufacturer | Bottom | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Petromax Feuertopf ft6 | 5.5 l pot, 1.5 l lid, 4–8 people | with legs (flat: ft6-t) | Families, embers and fire bowls |
| Petromax Feuertopf ft9 | 8–14 people | with legs (flat: ft9-t) | Groups, club parties |
| Lodge Camp Dutch Oven L12CO3 | 6 quarts (around 5.7 l), 12 inches | three legs | Anyone cooking by Lodge’s briquette chart |
| Camp Chef Deluxe DO-10 | 6 quarts, 10 inches | lid with legs, lifter included | Anyone who wants everything in one box |
| Valhal Outdoor VH6.1L | 6.1 l pot, 2 l lid, 4–8 people | flat, thermometer opening | Kettle grill, kamado, oven |
| Valhal Outdoor VH8L | 8 l pot, 2 l lid, 8–14 people | flat | Big gatherings at the grill |
Petromax Feuertopf ft6
The ft6 (Feuertopf means „fire pot“) is Petromax’s middle size and the sensible starting point for most families. The lid stands on three legs and doubles as a skillet when turned over. Petromax offers it on its own and as a starter set with a lid lifter, care paste and scraper. If you prefer cooking in the grill, choose the flat version ft6-t with the same capacity.
Petromax Feuertopf ft9
One size up, according to the Petromax listing for dishes for eight to fourteen people. Too much pot for everyday use. For summer parties and camps, the size fits, as long as there are enough embers.
Lodge Camp Dutch Oven L12CO3
The classic American camp oven: twelve inches in diameter, six quarts, three legs and a lid with a rim for the coals. According to Lodge, it seasons its cast iron with vegetable oil. The advantage lies in everything around it, because Lodge’s briquette guidelines are tailored to exactly these sizes. The price on Amazon.de varies widely by seller, so comparing before you buy is a must here.
Camp Chef Deluxe DO-10
Camp Chef ships the Deluxe series with a 23-centimeter lid lifter. Here, too, the lid has legs and works as a skillet. At six quarts, the DO-10 is family-sized, but at ten inches it has a smaller diameter than the Lodge. Whether the pot itself stands on legs is not clear from the manufacturer’s information; a look at the product photos settles it.
Valhal Outdoor VH6.1L
The flat version, intended for people who cook more on the grill than over a campfire. The pot holds 6.1 liters and the lid another two. A cutout for the thermometer probe is built in. On Amazon.de, you will mainly find this version without legs; the model with legs is called VH6.1L+.
Valhal Outdoor VH8L
Eight liters with a flat bottom, according to Valhal for eight to fourteen people and intended for kamados and ovens. It only fits if the grill is big enough. Measure the grate beforehand.
How we would decide
- Cooking over embers or in a fire bowl, four to eight people: Petromax ft6 with legs, ideally with a lid lifter right away.
- Cooking in a charcoal kettle grill or in the oven: a flat pot such as the Valhal VH6.1L or the Petromax ft6-t.
- Large groups: Petromax ft9 or Valhal VH8L. That means considerably more briquettes and weight.
- If you want to cook by American recipes and briquette charts: Lodge L12CO3, and budget for a lid lifter separately.
We do not recommend buying an in-between size „just in case.“ A pot that usually stays half empty just adds weight and still needs the full amount of embers.
Frequently asked questions
Dutch oven with legs or without?
A pot with three legs stands directly over the embers without smothering them. On a grill grate or in the oven, however, the legs get in the way. Valhal explicitly advertises its pots without legs for kamado and oven use, and Petromax sells flat versions with the suffix "-t".
What Dutch oven size for how many people?
For the Petromax ft6 with 5.5 liters in the pot, the manufacturer states four to eight people, and Valhal says the same for 6.1 liters. For 8 liters, Valhal states eight to fourteen people. Petromax calls these guideline figures that depend on appetite.
How many briquettes go on top of and under a Dutch oven?
For soups and stews, Petromax recommends two thirds under the pot and one third on the lid, and the reverse for baking. For the ft6, the instructions state 24 briquettes for 160 to 180 °C, 14 of them on top and 10 below. For baking, Lodge recommends three parts on top and one below.
Do you have to season a new Dutch oven?
According to the manufacturers, all pots in this comparison come pre-seasoned. Petromax advises simply rinsing it with warm water the first time and drying it thoroughly. You should re-season as soon as rust appears: coat thinly with fat, then put it in the oven without the lid at about 180 °C for around one to two hours.
Do you need a lid lifter for a Dutch oven?
You cannot do without one. A lid loaded with embers is heavy and hot, and the ash should not fall into the food. Camp Chef includes a lifter with its Deluxe pots, Petromax also sells the ft6 in a set with one, and with Lodge it is sold separately.
Does it make sense to buy a bigger Dutch oven just in case?
We advise against it. A pot that usually stays half empty just adds weight and still needs the full amount of embers. According to Valhal, even a six-liter pot weighs 8.3 kilograms, and every size up needs more briquettes. If you want to bake bread or braise whole roasts, plan on the generous side.
Sources
- Petromax: Feuertopf (Dutch oven)
- Petromax: ft6 starter set
- Petromax: The right Dutch oven size
- Petromax: Seasoning cast iron
- Petromax: Cooking with a Dutch oven
- Lodge: How Many Coals to Use
- Lodge: 12 Inch / 6 Quart Camp Dutch Oven
- Camp Chef: Deluxe Dutch Oven
- Valhal Outdoor: VH6.1L+ with legs
- Valhal Outdoor: VH6.1L without legs
- Valhal Outdoor: VH8L without legs
Where to buy
- Petromax Feuertopf ft6 (mit Füßen, ohne Zubehör)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Petromax Feuertopf ft9Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Lodge Camp Dutch Oven L12CO3Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Camp Chef Deluxe Dutch Oven DO-10Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Valhal Outdoor Dutch Oven VH6.1LCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Valhal Outdoor Dutch Oven VH8LCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
