Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Buying a Kettle Grill 2026: Charcoal, Kamado, Chimney Starter

Buying a kettle grill in 2026: size, grate, vents, kamado, chimney starter. Six models from Weber, Napoleon, Outdoorchef, Kamado Joe and Big Green Egg.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Contents13 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

It has stood by garden fences for decades: the 57 cm kettle grill. Not much about it has changed. It serves six to eight people, grills direct and indirect and costs considerably less than a ceramic grill. To get started, you cannot go wrong with the Weber Master-Touch GBS.

Things are different if you often cook low and slow or smoke. Then the Kamado Joe Classic Joe III and the Big Green Egg Large come out ahead because they hold the heat for hours. Either way, a chimney starter is part of the setup.

Why charcoal at all?

Charcoal requires more patience than gas. In return, you get high heat and real smoke flavor. If it needs to be quick and without embers, our gas grill guide (in German) is the better fit.

We have experienced firsthand how different gas grills turn out in practice: the Tepro gas grill from Lidl offered plenty of features but disappointed in build quality and customer service. The Enders Monroe Pro 4 SIK Turbo was well built and worth recommending despite scratches on the new unit.

Steel kettle or ceramic egg?

Enameled steel is light, heats up quickly and can do a lot. A kamado, on the other hand, is an egg-shaped ceramic grill that weighs many times as much, stores heat very well and uses surprisingly little charcoal for long cooks. In terms of size, a 57 cm diameter is considered the common standard. Kamados usually have a grate of around 46 cm, and while that sounds like less space, according to the manufacturers it is enough for about eight people because the lid almost always stays closed.

How do you recognize a well-designed grill?

You control the temperature with one vent at the bottom and one at the top, and a lid thermometer shows what is happening inside. Sounds trivial. But a lid hinge or a lid holder saves you from hunting for a place to put the hot lid.

A hinged grate lets you add charcoal while grilling. Stainless steel is easy to care for, cast iron stores heat but needs care against rust, and chrome-plated grates are inexpensive but wear out faster. As for ash, a closed catcher under the bowl is cleaner than an open pan; with a kamado, you remove it via a drawer or through the bottom opening.

Roasts, chicken or pulled pork need indirect heat. For that, the coals have to sit to the side or be shielded. Charcoal baskets, a charcoal ring, a funnel or a heat shield (diffuser) make this much easier.

Some grates have a removable center section for a pizza stone, wok or cast iron pan. That only makes sense if the grill is actually used that versatilely. If pizza is the focus, also take a look at our pizza oven buying guide (in German).

How do I get the coals going without lighter fluid?

With a chimney starter. A sheet metal cylinder with a handle, nothing more, and yet the most useful accessory of all. Charcoal or briquettes go in, with two or three fire starter cubes underneath. In its information sheet, Weber states about 15 to 20 minutes for lump charcoal and about 30 minutes for briquettes until the coals are ready.

Methylated spirits, gasoline and other flammable liquids are off-limits, as Weber also explicitly points out. According to Weber, a full chimney starter holds exactly the right amount for a 57 cm grill. You regulate the temperature via the amount of charcoal.

Six charcoal grills side by side

ModelType and grateSpecial feature according to the manufacturerBest for
Weber Master-Touch GBS E-5750Kettle grill, 57 cm, 2,342 cm²One-Touch cleaning, lid holder, GBS grateBeginners and families
Weber Master-Touch Premium E-5770Kettle grill, 57 cm, stainless steel grateLid hinge, charcoal ring with diffuserIf you also want to smoke
Napoleon PRO22K-LEG-3Kettle grill, 57 cm, cast iron grateGrate in three heights, Vortex heat controlIf you like cast iron
Outdoorchef Kensington 570 CKettle grill, 54 cm, chrome-plated grateSliding funnel for direct and indirectIf you want easy indirect grilling
Kamado Joe Classic Joe IIIKamado, 46 cmSlōRoller, grate on three levels, cartLow & slow with lots of features
Big Green Egg LargeKamado, 46 cm, 1,688 cm²Large range of accessories, 73 kgLong-term purchase

Weber Master-Touch GBS E-5750

If any 57 cm kettle grill counts as a classic, it is this one. Weber states 2,342 cm² of cooking area, a lid holder, a lid thermometer and One-Touch cleaning with a large aluminum ash catcher. The hinged grate accepts the inserts of the Gourmet BBQ System. Weber gives a ten-year warranty on the bowl and lid against rust-through and burn-through. That says a lot about the durability of this design.

Weber Master-Touch Premium E-5770

According to Weber, the Premium version adds a hinged lid, a stainless steel grate and an enameled charcoal ring with a stainless steel diffuser plate. With this ring, the kettle grill becomes a usable smoker for low temperatures. Weight according to the manufacturer: 24 kg. There is a mount for the iGrill thermometer. You buy the thermometer itself separately.

Napoleon PRO22K-LEG-3

Four legs instead of three. That is the first thing you notice. More important are the cast iron grates, which according to Napoleon can be hung at three heights, and the cone-shaped Vortex heat control in the bowl. This lets you change the distance to the coals without rearranging the charcoal. Napoleon states a ten-year limited warranty.

Outdoorchef Kensington 570 C

Outdoorchef handles indirect heat with a funnel under the grate. According to the manufacturer, a slider switches between direct and indirect, and during indirect cooking the entire grate area remains usable. The chrome-plated grate measures 54 cm and folds up for adding charcoal. One damper at the end: Outdoorchef itself currently cannot deliver the grill from its online shop. So check the retailer’s offer before buying.

Kamado Joe Classic Joe III

Ceramic, a 46 cm grate and, according to Kamado Joe, a temperature range of about 107 to 398 °C. The SlōRoller insert is designed to distribute heat and smoke evenly, and the „Divide & Conquer“ system offers three levels with half-moon grates. Add to that the Air Lift hinge, Kontrol Tower top vent, an ash drawer and a steel cart with casters. Around 127 kg. So decide on its spot beforehand.

Big Green Egg Large

No kamado is better known. For the Large, Big Green Egg states a 46 cm grate, 1,688 cm² of cooking area, a height of 84 cm and a weight of 73 kg, enough for eight people. The stand, side tables and inserts usually cost extra, though. If you register your Egg, you receive a lifetime warranty; Big Green Egg publishes the terms online.

How we would decide

Families and newcomers should go for the Weber Master-Touch GBS E-5750, plus a chimney starter and charcoal baskets. If you want to smoke occasionally, spend a little more on the Premium E-5770 with charcoal ring and diffuser. Cast iron and variable grate height speak for the Napoleon PRO22K-LEG-3, and indirect grilling without rearranging the coals for the Outdoorchef Kensington 570 C, provided you can still get it.

A kamado is a purchase for years and for people who really do low and slow. The Kamado Joe Classic Joe III comes fully equipped, the Big Green Egg Large with the largest range of accessories. For the occasional sausages, either would be overkill.

Each of these grills needs a chimney starter such as the Weber Rapidfire and fire starter cubes. Not lighter fluid.

Which grate size suits your household and what a kamado weighs is covered in the ceramic grill guide.

Frequently asked questions

Kettle grill or kamado: what is the difference?

Enameled steel is light, heats up quickly and can do a lot. A kamado is an egg-shaped ceramic grill that weighs many times as much, stores heat very well and uses little charcoal for long cooks. It is worth it for people who really do low and slow.

What size should a charcoal grill be?

A 57 cm diameter is considered the common standard and serves six to eight people. Kamados usually have a grate of around 46 cm, but according to the manufacturers that is enough for about eight people because the lid almost always stays closed.

How do you light charcoal without lighter fluid?

With a chimney starter: charcoal or briquettes go in, with two or three fire starter cubes underneath. Weber states about 15 to 20 minutes for lump charcoal and about 30 minutes for briquettes. Methylated spirits, gasoline and other flammable liquids are off-limits.

How do you recognize a well-designed kettle grill?

By vents at the bottom and top, a lid thermometer and a lid hinge or lid holder. A hinged grate lets you add charcoal while grilling, and a closed ash catcher is cleaner than an open pan. Charcoal baskets or a charcoal ring make indirect grilling easier.

Can you smoke on a kettle grill?

Yes, with the right accessories. According to Weber, the Weber Master-Touch Premium E-5770 comes with a charcoal ring and diffuser plate, which turns the kettle grill into a usable smoker for low temperatures. For very long cooks, kamados hold the heat better over hours.

Which cooking grate is the right one?

Stainless steel is easy to care for. Cast iron stores heat but needs care against rust, as with the Napoleon PRO22K-LEG-3 with its grate in three heights. Chrome-plated grates are inexpensive but wear out faster.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.