Contents16 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
The light above the front door comes on when you are already searching for your keys. Or it switches on at night because the neighbor’s cat crosses the driveway. Neither is usually the device’s fault; it comes down to where it is mounted, how it is aligned and how it is set. For a typical front door, we consider a simple 230-volt sensor such as the ChiliTec CBM 65w from ELV (German retailer) sufficient, provided there is a neutral wire in the box.
This article covers classic sensors that switch an outdoor light directly. Battery-powered sensors for alarms and app automations are covered in our guide to smart motion sensors (in German).
Why does the sensor only react when I am standing right in front of it?
Because passive infrared sensors detect heat movement across the sensor best. If someone walks straight toward it, they hardly move between the detection zones. Steinel puts clear numbers on this in the data sheet for the IS 140-2: a range of 14 meters for movement across the sensor, only 3 meters when walking straight toward it. That is why ChiliTec advises in its instructions to mount the sensor across the walking direction.
Temperature plays a part, too. ChiliTec and RELTECH explicitly state their ranges for ambient temperatures below 24 °C. On a hot summer evening, the difference between a person and a warm house wall is smaller, and the sensor reacts later.
Surface or flush-mounted, two wires or three?
A surface-mounted sensor usually sits high up on the facade or under the porch roof and is supplied via its own cable. A flush-mounted sensor, on the other hand, replaces the existing light switch next to the door. That is convenient but affects the mounting height: according to the instructions, the ChiliTec 190° goes in at a height of 1 to 1.8 meters, which is where switches are anyway.
What matters is a look inside the box. Many old switch boxes have no neutral wire, only the live wire there and back. The only option here is a sensor with two-wire technology such as the ChiliTec 190°, which works with and without N. According to its instructions, the surface-mounted CBM 65w absolutely requires a neutral wire.
One more limitation that is often overlooked. Both ChiliTec sensors only replace a simple on-off switch, not a two-way or intermediate switching circuit and not a push button with an impulse relay.
Will it switch my LED light reliably?
The big wattage on the packaging usually applies to incandescent bulbs. For LEDs, the manufacturers state considerably lower values. With the Steinel IS 140-2, it is 1,000 watts resistive load, but only 250 watts for LED lamps above 8 watts and 100 watts for very small LEDs under 2 watts. For a 10-watt wall light, that makes no difference; for a row of floodlights, it does.
The other end is the minimum load. According to the manufacturer, the ChiliTec models switch from as little as 1 watt, so even a single small LED lamp. Which lamps are suitable outdoors is shown in our overview of LED bulbs.
How high to mount it and how to set it?
Most surface-mounted sensors are designed for 1.8 to 2.5 meters, the Theben theLuxa S180 for 2 to 4 meters, and Steinel names 2 meters as optimal. Mounted too high, a gap forms directly beneath the sensor. Steinel and Theben counter this with built-in creep-under protection.
Almost always, two values are set: the run-on time and the twilight threshold in lux. On the RELTECH RBWM1, it ranges from below 3 to 2,000 lux. For testing during the day, the instructions recommend choosing the sun setting; otherwise the lamp stays off and you go looking for a fault that does not exist. According to RELTECH, false triggers come from heat sources such as ventilation outlets, reflective surfaces and plants moving in the wind. A sensor aimed at the hedge by the driveway will switch on in every storm.
What protection rating does it need outdoors?
The second digit of the IP rating describes protection against water. IP65, as on the ChiliTec and RELTECH sensors, means protection against water jets, according to the Osram data sheet. Steinel states IP54, Theben IP55, and the Homematic sensor IP44. Under a deep porch roof, this matters less.
On an unprotected weather side, where driving rain and, in winter, snow hit the housing directly, we would choose at least IP54. A look at the temperature range is part of it: RELTECH specifies the RBWM1 for minus 20 to plus 40 °C, Theben the theLuxa S180 for minus 25 to plus 45 °C, and eQ-3 the Homematic sensor up to plus 55 °C. According to ELV, the housing of the CBM 65w is made of UV-resistant plastic, which counts on a sunny south-facing wall.
Can I connect it myself?
No. ChiliTec, RELTECH and eQ-3 stipulate in their instructions that only a qualified electrician may install it. The reason is not bureaucracy but danger to life on the 230-volt mains. For the Homematic sensor, eQ-3 also requires a type B or C miniature circuit breaker rated at no more than 10 amps. If you are calling an electrician anyway, have them check at the same time whether there is a neutral wire in the switch box.
Which sensors are worth considering?
| Model | Detection | Load and protection rating | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChiliTec 360°-PIR-Aufputz-Bewegungsmelder CBM 65w | up to 360°, 10 m | LED 1 to 600 W, IP65, with N | Front door, corner of the house |
| ChiliTec 190°-Unterputz-PIR-Bewegungsmelder | 190°, 9 m | LED 1 to 200 W, IP65, 2- or 3-wire | Replacing the switch by the door |
| RELTECH Bewegungsmelder RBWM1 | 180° plus 360° downward, 12 m | LED 600 W, IP65 | Entrance with a landing |
| Steinel IS 140-2 | 140°, 14 m crosswise | LED up to 250 W, IP54 | Driveway, targeted zone |
| Theben theLuxa S180 WH | 180°, 12 m | LED up to 500 W, IP55 | High mounting, several lights |
| Homematic IP Bewegungsmelder mit Schaltaktor außen HmIP-SMO230 | 180°, up to 20 m | LED 200 W, IP44 | Homematic IP households |
| Osram SMART+ Bewegungsmelder mit Solarmodul | up to 9 m | does not switch a load, IP65 | No cable, SMART+ WiFi only |
ChiliTec 360°-PIR-Aufputz-Bewegungsmelder CBM 65w
Our recommendation for the front door, a surface-mounted 360° PIR sensor. Flat, and with a mounting adapter it also fits on an outside corner; according to ELV it has a range of 10 meters, a run-on time of 10 seconds to 15 minutes and an LED load from 1 watt. On a wall, it naturally only uses part of its 360°. Downsides: it needs a neutral wire, it is set only with small rotary controls, and the manufacturer says nothing about creep-under protection.
ChiliTec 190°-Unterputz-PIR-Bewegungsmelder
This flush-mounted 190° PIR sensor sits in a 60-millimeter switch box and can be set to permanent light or off when there is a party on the patio. It also works without a neutral wire. At switch height, it detects up to 9 meters according to the instructions, but only handles 200 watts of LED.
RELTECH Bewegungsmelder RBWM1
A main sensor covering 180° and a small additional sensor on the underside that looks down all around. According to ELV, the small sensor is suited to mounting above the entrance, where you would otherwise go unnoticed directly beneath the sensor. According to the instructions, wall and ceiling mounting are possible. The same manufacturer’s RPIRDE2 ceiling sensor, on the other hand, is listed by ELV for indoor use.
Steinel IS 140-2
The classic for the driveway. The sensor head swivels 180° horizontally and 90° vertically, and masking shutters let you narrow down the zone precisely, for example to keep the sidewalk out. According to the data sheet, several sensors can be linked by cable. Steinel gives a three-year manufacturer’s warranty.
Theben theLuxa S180 WH
For higher mounting up to 4 meters and larger loads. Theben states 500 watts of LED, zero-crossing switching that is gentle on the relay, and a teach-in button that adopts the current brightness as the threshold. According to the data sheet, standby consumption is around 0.9 watts.
Homematic IP Bewegungsmelder mit Schaltaktor außen HmIP-SMO230
This outdoor motion sensor with a switching actuator bridges both worlds. Like a classic sensor, it switches the connected light, but it also reports motion and brightness by radio. According to eQ-3, three individually adjustable zones are meant to mask out passersby or cars. According to the manufacturer, it cannot be operated without an Access Point or hub. IP44 and a 200-watt LED load are the weakest values in the field.
Osram SMART+ Bewegungsmelder mit Solarmodul
Not a 230-volt sensor, but a wireless sensor with a rechargeable battery and solar cell. It does not switch a light directly; it sends notifications and controls compatible SMART+ Wi-Fi products. A solution if there is no cable at that spot and the light is already smart. For everything else, we only list it for completeness. Smart outdoor lights with their own sensor are compared in our guide to smart outdoor lighting.
Which sensor for which location?
- Front door with a neutral wire, high on the wall: ChiliTec CBM 65w.
- Replacing the switch next to the door, often without N: flush-mounted ChiliTec 190°.
- Entrance where the area directly under the sensor matters: RELTECH RBWM1.
- Long driveway where the sidewalk should stay masked out: Steinel IS 140-2.
- Several floodlights, mounting above 2.5 meters: Theben theLuxa S180.
- Homematic IP in the house: the SMO230; otherwise, a simple sensor is the better choice.
If you want a picture along with the light, our guide to the floodlight camera (in German) will help.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the motion sensor react so late?
Passive infrared sensors detect movement across the sensor much more easily than movement straight toward it. For the IS 140-2, Steinel states a range of 14 meters for crosswise movement, but only 3 meters when walking straight toward it. So mount the sensor across the walking direction. On hot evenings, it also reacts later.
What if there is no neutral wire in the switch box?
Then the only option is a sensor with two-wire technology such as the flush-mounted ChiliTec 190°, which works with and without N. According to its instructions, the surface-mounted CBM 65w absolutely requires a neutral wire. Both ChiliTec sensors only replace a simple on-off switch, not a two-way or intermediate switching circuit.
Does a motion sensor also switch LED lamps?
Yes, but with lower limits than for incandescent bulbs. With the Steinel IS 140-2, it is 1,000 watts resistive load, but only 250 watts for LED lamps above 8 watts. According to the manufacturer, the ChiliTec models switch from as little as 1 watt, so even a single small LED lamp.
At what height should a motion sensor be mounted?
Most surface-mounted sensors are designed for 1.8 to 2.5 meters, the Theben theLuxa S180 for 2 to 4 meters. Mounted too high, a gap forms directly underneath; Steinel and Theben build in creep-under protection. Flush-mounted sensors sit at switch height of 1 to 1.8 meters.
What causes false triggers in motion sensors?
According to RELTECH, heat sources such as ventilation outlets, reflective surfaces and plants moving in the wind. A sensor aimed at the hedge by the driveway will switch on in every storm. With the Steinel IS 140-2, the zone can be narrowed down precisely with masking shutters.
Can I connect a motion sensor myself?
No. ChiliTec, RELTECH and eQ-3 stipulate that only a qualified electrician may install it, because of the danger to life on the 230-volt mains. The electrician can check at the same time whether there is a neutral wire in the switch box.
Sources
- ELV: ChiliTec 360° PIR surface-mounted motion sensor CBM 65w
- ChiliTec: CBM 65 operating instructions (PDF)
- ELV: ChiliTec 190° flush-mounted PIR motion sensor
- ChiliTec: Flush-mounted PIR 190° operating instructions (PDF)
- ELV: RELTECH RBWM1 motion sensor
- RELTECH: RBWM1 data sheet (PDF)
- RELTECH: RBWM1 instructions (PDF)
- ELV: RELTECH RPIRDE2 motion sensor
- Steinel: IS 140-2 white
- Steinel: IS 140-2 data sheet (PDF)
- Theben: theLuxa S180 WH
- Theben: theLuxa S180 WH data sheet (PDF)
- ELV: Homematic IP outdoor motion sensor with switching actuator
- eQ-3: HmIP-SMO230 data sheet (PDF)
- eQ-3: HmIP-SMO230 operating instructions (PDF)
- ELV: Osram SMART+ motion sensor with solar module
- Ledvance: SMART+ WiFi Outdoor Motion Sensor data sheet (PDF)
Where to buy
- ChiliTec 360°-PIR-Aufputz-Bewegungsmelder CBM 65wView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELVCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- ChiliTec 190°-Unterputz-PIR-BewegungsmelderView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELVCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- RELTECH Bewegungsmelder RBWM1View at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Homematic IP Bewegungsmelder mit Schaltaktor außen HmIP-SMO230View at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELVCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Osram SMART+ Bewegungsmelder mit SolarmodulView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Steinel IS 140-2 (weiß)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Theben theLuxa S180 WHCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
