Contents9 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Dropping a glass tabletop at the neighbors‘, knocking over a pedestrian with your bike, losing your girlfriend’s apartment key. It sounds like trivial stuff, and most of the time it is. Just not always. Anyone who culpably causes damage to others is liable for it under Section 823 of the German Civil Code (BGB), and the Verbraucherzentrale (the German consumer advice center) points out that there is no upper limit. A serious injury can result in costs for a lifetime. That is why it calls personal liability insurance indispensable.
Among consumer advocates, there is little dispute about whether you need it. The interesting part is what it contains. We will not tell you which insurer is right for you; we are not allowed to, and we do not want to. We show you how to recognize good terms.
What the policy should include
| Item | What it is about | Benchmark according to consumer protection |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage limit | Maximum amount per claim | at least 10 million euros combined, preferably 50 or 100 million euros |
| Default coverage | Your insurer pays if the person who caused the damage cannot pay | up to at least 10 million euros |
| Damage to rented property | Damage to rented premises | property damage up to at least 1 million euros |
| Children below the age of legal responsibility | Damage caused by small children | inclusion explicitly stated in the policy |
| Loss of keys | other people’s private and work keys | amount and type of keys |
In May 2026, Stiftung Warentest examined 401 policies and only awards good grades if its basic protection is met. Besides the limit, this includes damage that develops gradually, volunteer work, vacation rentals and a longer stay abroad. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, a higher limit often costs only a few euros more.
Saving money here achieves little.
For tenants, one point deserves special attention because the sources set it at different levels. For damage to rented rooms and buildings, the Verbraucherzentrale speaks of at least half a million euros, including vacation rentals and rented event spaces, while Stiftung Warentest requires 1 million euros for its basic protection and excludes glass and heating damage. So if you damage the sink in a vacation rental or cause water damage in your rented apartment, you should have read what your policy says about it and where the limits lie.
When children live in the household
This is probably the best-known gap. Under Section 828 BGB, children under seven are not liable; in road traffic the threshold is ten. If the parents have not breached their duty of supervision, the injured party is left with the damage. That sounds like an advantage, but it is often the start of a dispute with neighbors or friends. A policy that includes children below the age of legal responsibility can defuse this. Look at the limit of this inclusion. The same question is worth asking for people with dementia or disabilities.
Adult children usually stay on the family policy until the end of their first vocational training or degree. The Verbraucherzentrale mentions policies that provide cover until one year after completing all training. Anyone starting a career then needs a policy of their own, and it is exactly this transition that tends to get overlooked.
Couples, blended families, shared apartments
Married couples and partners living together as if married can make do with one policy. For unmarried couples, the partner should be named in the policy. Also keep apart two things that are often confused. Damage that co-insured persons cause each other is often excluded. If your partner steps on your smartphone, liability insurance usually does not pay. Some policies can be extended here, in some cases at no extra cost.
The favor for a friend
You help with a move, and the TV breaks. In cases of simple negligence, according to the Verbraucherzentrale there is usually no obligation to pay damages, since courts assume a tacit exclusion of liability. If the helper has private liability insurance, however, things are different according to the GDV (German Insurance Association): then the damage is covered. Sounds contradictory? It depends on the policy. Ask about damage caused while doing favors before you start carrying boxes. According to the GDV, around 15 percent of households had no personal liability insurance at all in 2023.
What is not included
Intent is never covered, but gross negligence is, according to the Verbraucherzentrale. Liability insurance does not pay for your own damage. If you keep a dog or a horse yourself, you need separate animal owner’s liability insurance. Looking after other people’s dogs, on the other hand, is covered, which affects more people than you might think.
Incidentally, liability insurance also fends off unjustified claims and then takes over the dispute, in court if necessary. This is called passive legal protection. It does not enforce your own claims, though; that is what legal expenses insurance is for.
So do not admit fault after a mishap. And do not pay out of your own pocket before the insurer has examined the case, or you may end up stuck with the costs.
Default coverage in numbers
Imagine the reverse case. Someone else injures you and has no insurance and no money. A judgment against them is then of little use to you. Default coverage steps in, according to Stiftung Warentest up to at least 10 million euros, if the person responsible does not pay despite enforcement through the courts. A minimum claim amount applies; it should be in the low four figures. This component takes little attention when you sign up and can mean a great deal when it matters.
Review older policies
A policy your parents took out twenty years ago comes from a different era. Check coverage limits, volunteer work, cover abroad and default coverage. Take the insurance certificate out of the folder and lay it next to the table above. It takes a quarter of an hour. But do not switch until the new cover is firmly in place.
What the comparison is good for
The calculator at Tarifcheck is free of charge and run by an external partner. The site does not state how many providers it covers, and it does not guarantee completeness. According to its own statement, Tarifcheck itself is neither a broker nor an intermediary. Some of the minimum limits listed there are below the consumer advocates‘ benchmark, so look for the 10 million euros, not for the bare minimum. A comparison is no substitute for advice. If a contract is concluded via our link, we may receive a commission; we are not allowed to advise you.
If you keep a four-legged friend, read on in our guide to dog liability insurance by German state. When you are out on your bike, a bike helmet offers additional protection, and for your home there is home contents insurance (in German).
Horses are not covered by personal liability insurance; for that there is horse liability insurance, and anyone who rents out property usually needs homeowner and landowner liability insurance.
Frequently asked questions
What coverage limit does personal liability insurance need?
Consumer advocates name a combined limit of at least 10 million as the benchmark, preferably 50 or 100 million. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, a higher limit often adds only a small amount to the premium. Saving money here achieves little, because a serious injury can cause costs for a lifetime.
Does liability insurance pay if my small child damages something?
Under Section 828 of the German Civil Code (BGB), children under seven are not liable; in road traffic the threshold is ten. If the parents have not breached their duty of supervision, the injured party is left with the damage. A policy that includes children below the age of legal responsibility can defuse this; check the limit of this inclusion.
What is default coverage (Forderungsausfalldeckung)?
It helps in the reverse case: someone damages you but has neither insurance nor money. Then your own insurer pays, according to Stiftung Warentest up to at least 10 million, if the person responsible does not pay despite enforcement through the courts. The minimum claim amount should be in the low four figures.
Is damage caused while helping someone move covered?
That depends on the policy. In cases of simple negligence, according to the Verbraucherzentrale there is usually no obligation to pay damages, since courts assume a tacit exclusion of liability. If the helper has private liability insurance, however, the damage is covered according to the GDV (German Insurance Association). Ask about damage caused while doing favors beforehand.
What does personal liability insurance not pay for?
Intent is never covered, but gross negligence is, according to the Verbraucherzentrale. Liability insurance does not pay for your own damage, and anyone who keeps a dog or a horse needs separate animal owner's liability insurance. Damage that co-insured persons cause each other is often excluded.
Until when are children covered by family liability insurance?
Adult children usually stay on the family policy until the end of their first vocational training or degree. The Verbraucherzentrale mentions policies that provide cover until one year after completing all training. Anyone starting a career after that needs a policy of their own.
Sources
- Section 823 BGB: Liability in damages
- Section 828 BGB: Minors
- Verbraucherzentrale: Personal liability insurance
- Stiftung Warentest: Basic protection for personal liability insurance
- GDV: What is damage caused while doing a favor?
- Tarifcheck: Liability insurance
- Tarifcheck: Passive legal protection
Where to buy
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: DeckungssummeView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: ForderungsausfallView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: MietsachschädenView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: Deliktunfähige KinderView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: SchlüsselverlustView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
