Contents8 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A horse easily weighs 600 kilos or more, and it is a prey animal. If it gets spooked in the paddock, by the road or while being loaded, it can break loose and hit cars, fences and people on its way. The owner is liable for the consequences, even if they are not at fault. Even so, there is no obligation to insure against this in Germany. That contradiction is the heart of the matter.
We do not recommend any insurer or policy. This guide explains liability, typical gaps and the questions you should put to every offer. What ultimately applies is in the terms and conditions of your policy.
Do I have to insure my horse?
No. According to the Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center), horse liability insurance is not mandatory in any German federal state, and the GDV (German Insurance Association) says the same. Dogs are a different story. According to the GDV, at least six federal states have a general insurance requirement for them, while in other states it only applies to certain dogs. No state has passed a comparable rule for horses, even though a horse weighs many times as much as a dog. More on this in our guide to dog liability insurance (in German).
Voluntary does not mean unimportant, though. Both organizations strongly advise horse owners to take out their own animal owner’s liability insurance. The consumer advice center calls it an absolute must for dogs and horses.
Why is the owner liable without fault?
Because the law says so. Under Section 833 of the German Civil Code (BGB), whoever keeps an animal must compensate for the damage if the animal injures a person or damages property. The provision does not require any fault. There is only an exception for domestic animals that serve the owner’s profession, gainful employment or livelihood. In that case, the owner can be released from liability if they exercised the necessary care in supervising the animal. A leisure horse generally does not fall under this exception. Where the line lies in an individual case, for example at a breeding farm, is a legal question we do not decide here.
Alongside it is Section 834 BGB. Anyone who takes over the supervision of someone else’s animal by contract is also liable, but can be released from liability if they acted with due care. This concerns shared riding arrangements or livery stables, for example.
And personal liability insurance? It does not help here. According to the consumer advice center, dogs and horses are not covered by it. According to the GDV, personal liability insurance generally only pays for smaller animals such as cats, guinea pigs, birds or hamsters. What else it covers is explained in our guide to personal liability insurance (in German).
A hypothetical case shows how this fits together. At night, a horse breaks through a paddock fence and runs onto a country road; a car swerves and ends up in the ditch, and the driver is injured. Under Section 833 BGB, the owner is liable for the damaged car and for the injuries, regardless of whether the fence was in proper condition. With horse liability insurance, the insurer examines the claims, rejects unjustified ones and pays justified ones up to the agreed sum. Without insurance, the owner is on their own. Incidentally, the injured horse itself is not a liability claim; that would require animal health or surgery insurance. And if a livery stable had contractually taken over supervision, its responsibility under Section 834 BGB also comes into play, with the possibility of being released from liability by having supervised with due care.
How high should the coverage be?
At least five million euros as a lump sum, the GDV and the consumer advice center agree. The GDV adds that a higher sum need not cost much more than a low one. Anyone who rides along a road or a railway line quickly understands why. An accident with personal injury can lead to treatment costs, lost earnings and lifelong pensions.
The consumer advice center puts it plainly: if a horse injures a third party or causes property damage, the owner is liable without limit. An insured sum, by contrast, is always limited. You pay the rest out of your own assets. Saving on the coverage therefore achieves little. You hardly notice the difference in the premium, but you very much do when it matters.
Who is covered when someone else rides?
This is where policies differ. The GDV describes the usual group: besides the owner, people responsible for the horse are covered, such as a family member out on a ride. Then there are animal minders and other riders. By this, insurers mean acquaintances or friends who look after or ride the horse free of charge. The words „free of charge“ matter.
Because many owners offer a shared riding arrangement in return for money. In that case, the other-rider clause may not be enough. The consumer advice center advises explicitly including the shared rider in the cover. If the horse injures a passerby while the shared rider is in charge, responsibility lies with the owner.
The trickiest case is described by Stiftung Warentest (German consumer testing organization, May 2021). A shared rider was grooming a mare, the horse kicked out, and the woman suffered a torn cruciate ligament and medial ligament and demanded damages for pain and suffering and compensation. The owner argued that the shared riding agreement excluded liability. The Munich I Regional Court saw it differently (case no. 20 O 2974/19): such an agreement does not automatically exclude the owner’s liability. The testers draw a conclusion from this that many underestimate. For the insurer, the shared rider is not a third party. If the shared rider is injured, the insurer does not automatically step in. They advise explicitly including this, along with possible recourse claims by the health insurer.
| Situation | Who is liable | What the policy should say |
|---|---|---|
| Horse breaks loose | Owner, even without fault (Section 833 BGB) | Coverage of at least five million euros |
| A friend rides out free of charge | Owner, possibly the rider as well | Other riders and animal minders covered |
| Paid shared riding arrangement | Owner toward third parties | Shared riding arrangement explicitly named |
| Horse injures the shared rider | Owner; the agreement does not automatically exclude this | Personal injury to the shared rider included |
| Stallion covers someone else’s mare | Owner | Breeding damage covered |
| Horse tramples someone else’s meadow | Owner | Damage to land covered |
| A foal is born | Owner | Foal covered in its first months |
What does horse liability insurance not pay for?
Your own injuries. If the horse throws you, according to the GDV that is not a case for liability insurance, which only covers damage to others. For your own risk there is private accident insurance, which we explain in our guide to accident insurance (in German).
Also not covered are fines and penalties and intentionally caused damage. And commercial use: if you use your horse as a riding school or therapy horse, you need a special policy, according to the GDV. Horse liability insurance for private individuals excludes this.
One point the consumer advice center explicitly mentions: cover even if you have breached owner duties. This refers to cases in which, for example, a fence was not secured as it should have been. Without this clause, the insurer can make deductions in the event of a claim. If you want to keep an eye on the stable at night, you will find the technology for it in our guide to security cameras for horse stables.
What about illness and surgery?
That is a different insurance. Liability insurance only pays for what the horse does to others. For veterinary costs, the GDV mentions horse health insurance and the cheaper surgery insurance, and for the value of the animal, horse life insurance. Whether you need something like this depends on the value of the horse and on your savings. That trade-off does not apply to liability insurance. There, it is about sums no one pays out of savings.
How do I compare offers?
With a checklist, not with the price alone. Hold every offer up against these points: coverage, other riders and animal minders, shared riding arrangement including the shared rider’s own injuries and recourse by the health insurer, breeding damage for stallions, foals for mares, damage to land, cover in case of breaches of owner duties. The consumer advice center points out that scope, price and exclusions vary from insurer to insurer. Reading the terms and conditions remains a must.
A comparison calculator such as that of our partner Tarifcheck (German comparison service) gives you an overview of the market. It does not replace advice and does not necessarily show all providers. According to its own information, Tarifcheck is neither a broker nor an intermediary; contracts are concluded through external partners. If a contract is concluded via our link, we may receive a commission.
Pay attention to the term as well. How long you are bound differs from policy to policy. There is no general notice period for horse liability insurance. It is stated in the insurance certificate.
If, besides the horse, you own a rented-out house or an undeveloped plot of land, our guide to homeowner and property owner liability insurance explains when personal liability insurance is no longer enough.
Frequently asked questions
Is horse liability insurance mandatory?
No, according to the German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale), not in any federal state. Because the owner is liable under Section 833 BGB even without fault, and personal liability insurance does not include horses, the consumer advice center and the GDV still strongly recommend it.
How much coverage does horse liability insurance need?
The GDV and the consumer advice center recommend at least five million euros as a lump sum. According to the GDV, a higher sum need not cost much more.
Are other riders covered by horse liability insurance?
Usually yes, if they ride or look after the horse free of charge, such as friends or acquaintances. A paid shared riding arrangement should be named explicitly in the policy.
Does the insurance pay if the horse injures the shared rider?
Not automatically. According to Stiftung Warentest, the shared rider is not a third party for the insurer. The Munich I Regional Court ruled that a shared riding agreement does not automatically exclude the owner's liability (case no. 20 O 2974/19). That is why personal injury to the shared rider should be explicitly included.
Does horse liability insurance pay if I fall off the horse myself?
No. Liability insurance only covers damage to others. Private accident insurance is meant for your own injuries.
What belongs in a good horse liability policy?
According to the consumer advice center, cover in case of breaches of owner duties, horse minders, damage to land and breeding damage. The GDV also mentions other riders and foals in their first months. Commercial use such as riding school horses requires a separate policy.
Sources
- Section 833 BGB: liability of the animal keeper
- Section 834 BGB: liability of the animal supervisor
- Verbraucherzentrale: liability insurance for pets
- GDV: What does horse owner’s liability insurance cover?
- Stiftung Warentest: insuring shared riding arrangements properly (05/26/2021)
- Tarifcheck: horse liability insurance
Where to buy
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: Pferd reißt sich losView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: Freundin reitet unentgeltlich ausView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: Reitbeteiligung gegen GeldView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: Pferd verletzt die ReitbeteiligungView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: Hengst deckt fremde StuteView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: Pferd zertrampelt eine fremde WieseView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: Fohlen kommt zur WeltView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck

