Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet
This page in 6 more languages

DeutschNederlandsFrançaisItalianoEspañolPolski

Buying a Power Tool Battery 2026: Original, Capacity, Charger

Buying a power tool battery: original or knockoff, which capacity, how fast to charge? Bosch, Makita, Milwaukee, DeWalt and Einhell compared.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
DeWalt DCB184Image: Coolblue (Pressebild)
Contents14 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

A replacement battery belongs to a system. And that system has long been sitting in your workshop. Our advice is therefore simple: buy the original battery from your brand and choose the capacity by weight and task rather than by the highest number printed on it. Cheap „compatible“ batteries from online marketplaces may fit mechanically. Why we still advise against them is spelled out in the manufacturers‘ own warnings.

No tool yet? Then first read how the battery systems differ. With your first tool, you commit yourself for years.

Three questions before you click

First: fitting does not mean compatible. Makita explains in its FAQ that the battery, charger and tool communicate with each other electronically. That does not work with third-party products and knockoffs, and it can lead to dangerous accidents or fires.

Second: every amp-hour adds weight. According to the manufacturer, Bosch’s ProCORE18V with 8.0 Ah tips the scales at 955 g, Makita’s BL1850B with 5.0 Ah at 630 g. On an angle grinder, you will gladly take the longer runtime. Overhead with a drill driver, you feel every gram.

Third: the charger. A large battery on a slow charger brings work to a halt. Charging times also only ever apply to a specific combination of battery and charger. Newer batteries with 21700 cells reach the same capacity with fewer cells. For its 4.0 Ah Plus battery, Einhell states five instead of ten cells and 12 percent less weight.

Why we advise against knockoffs

Knockoffs usually give themselves away in the listing title with „compatible“ or „for Makita.“ On its page about counterfeit tools and batteries, Makita warns that such products can quickly catch fire and damage chargers. The manufacturer is even clearer about the warranty: anyone who uses a counterfeit battery loses all warranty claims for the tool and charger. Makita recommends specialist dealers and lists online marketplaces, social networks and shops without a legal notice as typical sources of counterfeits.

Einhell says much the same. On its UK page about knockoff batteries, the manufacturer lists fire and explosion hazards, inferior cells and exaggerated capacity claims. According to Einhell, an original battery shuts down via active battery management as soon as it detects a problem. Most knockoffs lack this, the company says. Here, too, the tool’s warranty is void if a knockoff is used in it.

Of course, manufacturers want to sell their own batteries. We are not aware of reliable independent accident figures for third-party power tool batteries. What is on record in writing, however, is the loss of warranty, and that affects not just the battery but also the tool and charger. Whether a „compatible“ battery is well built is something you cannot see before you buy it anyway.

Charging and storing without things getting dicey

The Umweltbundesamt (German Environment Agency) has clear rules on this. Charge lithium batteries only with the matching charger, away from anything flammable and never overnight while you sleep. Ideally where there is a smoke detector. For daily use, the agency advises charging only to about 90 percent, and to roughly half before longer breaks. Store them at 10 to 25 degrees. So neither in the refrigerator nor in a hot car. A damaged or swollen battery has no business in a tool anymore: tape over the terminals and take it to a collection point.

7 original batteries and chargers compared

ModelKey data according to the manufacturerCharging according to the manufacturerBest for
Bosch Professional ProCORE18V 8.0Ah18 V, 8.0 Ah, 955 g, AMPShare-compatiblefully charged in 44 min with GAL 18V-160Saws, grinders, long jobs
Bosch Professional Starter-Set 2x ProCORE18V 8.0Ah + GAL 18V-160two 8.0 Ah batteries, charger with 16 APower Boost: 50% in 15 minSwitching to large batteries
Makita BL1850B18 V LXT, 5.0 Ah, 90 Wh, 630 g, charge indicator45 min with fast chargerMakita LXT users, all-round
Makita DC18RCCharger for 14.4 and 18 V LXT, battery cooling5.0 Ah in 45 minReplacement or second LXT charger
Milwaukee M18 B5M18, 5.0 Ah, REDLINK overload protection, down to -20 °C59 min on the M12-18 FCM18 users, winter work
DeWalt DCB18418 V XR, 5.0 Ah, LED charge indicatornot stated on the product pageDeWalt XR users
Einhell Power X-Change Plus 18V 4,0Ah4.0 Ah, 590 g, five 21700 cellsdepends on the PXC chargerEinhell DIYers, light work

Which system do you already have?

From here on, the brand in your tool case decides.

You work with Bosch Professional: ProCORE18V 8.0Ah

Bosch specifies 18 V, 8.0 Ah and 955 g. According to the manufacturer, the battery fits all tools and chargers in the Bosch Professional 18 V system as well as those of the cross-brand AMPShare alliance. The 87 percent more power and 135 percent longer service life that Bosch advertises refer to unspecified standard batteries. On a circular saw or angle grinder, a chunk like this makes sense. For a small drill driver, it is too heavy.

Bosch without a fast charger: starter set with GAL 18V-160

The set contains two ProCORE18V 8.0Ah batteries and the GAL 18V-160 charger. Bosch specifies a charging current of 16 A, and in Power Boost mode 15 minutes to 50 percent and 44 minutes to full. If you want two large batteries anyway, you get the charger thrown in.

You work with Makita LXT: BL1850B

This is the standard battery in the LXT system and our recommendation for Makita users. 18 V, 5.0 Ah, 90 Wh and, according to Makita, 630 g, plus a built-in charge level indicator. On the fast charger, Makita states 45 minutes. Check older tools first. According to the Makita FAQ, an 18 V battery fits tools with a yellow contact plate or an embossed star.

Makita, but the charger is struggling: DC18RC

This fast charger takes 14.4 V and 18 V LXT batteries. According to Makita, it cools the battery while charging and displays the charge level and errors; 45 minutes are stated for 5.0 Ah. It works well as a second charger or a replacement. We do not consider a third-party charger a way to save money here, for the same reasons as with the battery.

You work with Milwaukee M18: M18 B5

Milwaukee builds a digital overload protection called REDLINK into its 5.0 Ah battery, which monitors individual cells. According to the manufacturer, it works down to -20 °C. On the M12-18 FC fast charger, charging takes no more than 59 minutes, according to Milwaukee. The same charger also charges M12 batteries.

You work with DeWalt XR: DCB184

DeWalt describes the DCB184 as an 18 V XR battery with 5.0 Ah, an LED charge level indicator and protection against overload, overheating and deep discharge. According to the manufacturer, it fits all 18 V XR tools. DeWalt does not state the charging time or weight online. Watch out with FlexVolt tools. They need their own FlexVolt batteries.

You work with Einhell Power X-Change: 4.0 Ah Plus

According to Einhell, the Plus battery with item number 4511553 does with five 21700 cells what the older 4.0 Ah battery needed ten cells for, and it weighs 590 g. It fits all tools in the Power X-Change family, and two of them can be combined for 36 V tools. If you do DIY work in the Einhell system, this is the one to pick. Look for „Plus“ and the item number in the listing, because the older 4511396 looks confusingly similar.

And how much battery for which job?

Drill drivers, jigsaws, anything overhead: here an original with 4 to 5 Ah is enough, such as the Makita BL1850B, DeWalt DCB184 or Einhell 4.0 Ah Plus. Our cordless drill driver guide shows which drivers go with them.

For angle grinders, saws and long cuts, 8.0 Ah is worth it, as with the Bosch ProCORE18V, and that together with a fast charger. Suitable tools are listed in our cordless angle grinder guide (in German). In the cold and on construction sites, the Milwaukee M18 B5 is a good choice, provided you already work in the M18 system.

Is the old charger actually the problem? Then replace it first and think about a second battery afterward. We advise against cheap knockoffs. Makita and Einhell have stated in writing that using them voids the warranty for the tool and charger.

One more word on buying. If you need a battery and charger at the same time, compare the manufacturer’s starter set against the individual parts before ordering two packages separately.

Frequently asked questions

Are compatible knockoff batteries for power tools safe?

Makita warns that knockoffs can quickly catch fire and damage chargers; Einhell cites fire and explosion hazards and inferior cells. According to Makita, anyone who uses a knockoff loses all warranty claims for the tool and charger. Whether a knockoff is well built cannot be seen before you buy it.

How many Ah does a power tool battery need?

For drill drivers, jigsaws and overhead work, 4 to 5 Ah is enough, because every amp-hour adds weight. For angle grinders, saws and long cuts, 8.0 Ah is worth it, together with a fast charger. According to Bosch, the ProCORE18V with 8.0 Ah weighs 955 g; the Makita BL1850B with 5.0 Ah weighs 630 g.

How do you charge and store lithium batteries safely?

The Umweltbundesamt (German Environment Agency) advises charging only with the matching charger, away from anything flammable and never overnight while you sleep. In everyday use, charge only to about 90 percent, and to roughly half before longer breaks, stored at 10 to 25 degrees. Swollen batteries belong at a collection point with their terminals taped over.

Does a new Makita battery fit older tools?

According to the Makita FAQ, an 18 V battery fits tools with a yellow contact plate or an embossed star. So check older tools first. With Makita, the battery, charger and tool communicate with each other electronically.

Which battery is suitable for working in winter?

According to the manufacturer, the Milwaukee M18 B5 with 5.0 Ah works down to -20 °C and monitors individual cells with its REDLINK overload protection. On the M12-18 FC fast charger, charging takes no more than 59 minutes. It is worthwhile for anyone already working in the M18 system.

How can you tell the new Plus version of the Einhell battery?

By the Plus suffix and the item number 4511553. According to Einhell, this battery achieves 4.0 Ah with five instead of ten 21700 cells and weighs 590 g. The older 4511396 looks confusingly similar.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.