Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Buying a Rain Barrel 2026: Size, Lid and Frost Protection

Buying a rain barrel: how big it needs to be, why the lid should lock child-safe and what has to happen before the frost. Six models compared.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Contents12 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

A rain barrel fills up faster than most people think. Where things fall short is rarely the volume but everything around it: a lid no child can open, a rain diverter with overflow stop and a plan for the first frost. For an ordinary home garden, we consider a round barrel with child lock such as the Garantia Barrica Regenfass with 260 liters plus a downspout diverter such as the Garantia Speedy the most sensible start.

How big does the barrel need to be?

One millimeter of precipitation equals one liter per square meter, as defined by the German Weather Service (Deutscher Wetterdienst). If 40 square meters of roof drain into your downspout, just 10 millimeters of rain mathematically yield 400 liters. A 300-liter barrel is full after that. So roof area almost never limits the size.

What matters is how many dry days you want to bridge. Count honestly: if you spread 15 ten-liter watering cans over beds and pots every evening, you need 150 liters a day, and 300 liters last for two evenings. Two barrels on two downspouts give you more reserve, as Gardena also suggests in its garden magazine. The diverters have limits too. Garantia recommends the Speedy for roof areas up to about 80 square meters and the simple filling device for up to 50.

Lid closed, and in a way that it stays closed

An open barrel is life-threatening for small children. The German child safety association Bundesarbeitsgemeinschaft Mehr Sicherheit für Kinder advises buying only rain barrels with a lockable lid that only adults can open, and removing stools or other climbing aids. Children climb in or fall in headfirst and cannot get out on their own. The German Federal Institute for Public Health (Bundesinstitut für Öffentliche Gesundheit) also names a tightly closed lid. It does not replace supervision.

A lid in the box is far from being a child lock. According to the manufacturer, the child lock is not included with Garantia’s standard round barrel, but it is with the Barrica. Garantia describes amphorae and slim wall tanks as fundamentally child-safe because of their closed shape. Incidentally, the same tight lid keeps mosquitoes from laying eggs; in addition, the manufacturer names a net with a mesh size of less than one millimeter at the inlet.

Four tanks, one diverter, one pump

ModelVolume and dimensionsLid, tap, drainingBest for
Garantia Barrica 260 l260 l, Ø 65 cm, 93 cm high (also 420 l)Lid with child lock included, tap as accessoryNormal garden, families with small children
Garantia Nordic 300 l300 l, Ø 59 cm, 118 cm highRemovable lid, low connection for complete draining, tap extraNarrow corner next to the downspout
Garantia Regen-Amphore 240 l240 l, Ø 59 cm, 118 cm high (also 300 and 500 l)Closed shape, connection for complete draining, 5-year warrantyTerrace, where the barrel is on view
Garantia Elegance Wandtank 400 l400 l, 60 × 60 × 180 cmWind anchor included, connection for complete draining, tap extraLots of water on a small footprint
Garantia Regensammler SpeedyDownspouts 70 to 100 mm, roof up to approx. 80 m²Overflow stop, winter mode, filter insertAny barrel on a downspout
Gardena Regenfasspumpe 4700/2 inox automaticup to 4,700 l/h, 2.3 barAutomatic mode, dry-run protection, telescopic tube 76 to 96 cmHose and sprinkler instead of a watering can

Garantia Barrica 260 l

It looks like an old wooden barrel. In the 260-liter version, the Barrica measures 65 centimeters in diameter and 93 centimeters in height; if you have more roof area, take the 420-liter version. According to Garantia, the removable lid has a built-in child lock, and the warranty is five years. You buy the tap separately, and before the frost, the rule here too is to drain and tip it out.

Garantia Nordic 300 l

With a diameter of 59 centimeters, the Nordic fits where a wide barrel would block the garden path. The 300-liter version has a removable lid; Garantia does not mention a child lock. The low connection is well designed: with the hose set from the accessory range, the barrel drains almost completely before winter. You buy the tap separately.

Garantia Regen-Amphore 240 l

If you look at the barrel from your lounge chair, you often end up with an amphora. Garantia gives a five-year warranty on the Regen-Amphore (rain amphora) and calls it fundamentally child-safe because of its integrated cover. According to the Amazon listing, the complete set includes a plastic tap and a downspout connector for roofs up to 50 square meters.

Garantia Elegance Wandtank 400 l

A square column 1.80 meters tall. On 60 by 60 centimeters, this wall tank holds 400 liters, considerably more than a round barrel on a similar footprint. You should actually install the supplied wind anchor, because the tank weighs only 18 kilograms when empty. A tap is not included.

Garantia Regensammler Speedy

The Speedy rain diverter sits in your existing downspout, and Garantia supplies the hole saw for the opening. When the barrel is full, the overflow stop sends the water back into the pipe; in winter mode, nothing flows in at all. For pure 100-millimeter pipes, the Speedy Flexx variant with coarse and fine filters has been available since 2026.

Gardena Regenfasspumpe 4700/2 inox automatic

Water flows from the barrel tap by gravity alone. A garden hose and sprinkler need pressure. According to Gardena, the 4700/2 inox automatic rain barrel pump delivers up to 4,700 liters per hour at 2.3 bar, starts by itself when you open the spray nozzle and switches off again afterward. For a barrel you only fill watering cans from, that is too much pump; then the smaller Akku-Regenfasspumpe 2000/2 18V P4A (cordless rain barrel pump) with 2,000 liters per hour is enough.

Frost, roof and drinking water

Garantia is unequivocal about winter. Above-ground containers must be emptied completely. To do so, the manufacturer recommends switching the diverter to winter mode or disconnecting it from the downspout, letting the barrel drain and leaving the outlet tap open.

Rainwater from the barrel is not drinking water. The German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) considers it hygienically safe for watering, but says its quality is not comparable to drinking water, and Garantia explicitly describes its above-ground tanks as unsuitable for storing drinking water. Also take a look at the roof. According to the UBA, metal compounds can wash off copper and zinc roofs, and bitumen membranes sometimes contain herbicides such as mecoprop. Metal gutters and downspouts, on the other hand, are generally considered unproblematic.

How we would decide

  • Small children in the house, normal garden: Garantia Barrica with the Speedy on the downspout.
  • Little space by the house wall: the Nordic if it has to be slim, the Elegance if it needs to hold a lot. Check the openings beforehand and secure them if necessary.
  • Barrel in view of the terrace: the Regen-Amphore, ideally as a set right away.
  • Watering with a hose or automatically: add the Gardena pump, controlled by a watering timer.

Leaves in the downspout also clog the inlet to the barrel. How to protect the gutter and drain is covered in the guide on gutter guards.

Frequently asked questions

How big should a rain barrel be?

Roof area almost never limits the size: if 40 square meters of roof drain into the downspout, 10 millimeters of rain mathematically yield 400 liters. What matters is how many dry days you want to bridge. If you spread 150 liters every evening, 300 liters last you two evenings. Two barrels on two downspouts give you more reserve.

How do I make a rain barrel child-safe?

With a lockable lid that only adults can open, as recommended by the German child safety association Bundesarbeitsgemeinschaft Mehr Sicherheit für Kinder. Stools and other climbing aids should be removed. A lid in the box is not yet a child lock: according to the manufacturer, it is not included with Garantia's standard round barrel, but it is with the Barrica. The lid does not replace supervision.

What does a downspout rain diverter do?

It channels water from the downspout into the barrel. When the barrel is full, the overflow stop on the Garantia Speedy sends the water back into the pipe, and in winter mode nothing flows in at all. Garantia recommends the Speedy for roof areas up to about 80 square meters and the simple filling device for up to 50.

What do I need to do with my rain barrel in winter?

According to Garantia, above-ground containers must be emptied completely. Switch the diverter to winter mode or disconnect it from the downspout, let the barrel drain and leave the outlet tap open. Barrels with a low connection such as the Garantia Nordic drain almost completely.

Do I need a pump for my rain barrel?

Only for a garden hose and sprinkler, because water flows from the barrel tap by gravity alone. The Gardena Regenfasspumpe 4700/2 inox automatic starts by itself when you open the spray nozzle. If you only fill watering cans, the smaller Akku-Regenfasspumpe 2000/2 18V P4A will do.

Is rainwater from the barrel drinkable?

No. The German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) considers it hygienically safe for watering, but says its quality is not comparable to drinking water. Pay attention to the roof as well: according to the UBA, metal compounds can wash off copper and zinc roofs, and bitumen membranes sometimes contain herbicides such as mecoprop.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.