Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Rental Car Accident or Damage: What to Do Now

Accident or damage with a rental car: secure the scene, inform the police and the rental company, who pays for what, and how to avoid disputes over pre-existing damage.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Contents6 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

A bump in the hotel parking lot, a stone chip on a country road, an accident at an intersection: with a rental car, this is doubly unpleasant, because an unfamiliar car, an unfamiliar country and often an unfamiliar language all come together. If you know the right order of steps, you still keep track. And if you booked fully comprehensive cover (Vollkasko) with no deductible, you pay no share of insured damage to the rental car yourself. Incidentally, according to the ADAC (automobile club), half of all damage to rental cars happens when parking or pulling out of a space.

Right after the accident

First secure the scene: hazard lights on, high-visibility vest on, warning triangle out. Passengers get out on the side away from traffic and wait behind the guardrail on highways and country roads. If anyone is injured, call the emergency number and give first aid. If another party is involved, call the police and ask for a police report. According to the ADAC, some countries and rental companies require this even for property damage only.

Photograph the scene and the damage. And inform the rental company. If you fail to do so, you risk your insurance cover, according to the ADAC. The emergency number, usually staffed around the clock, is in your rental agreement. If the car can no longer be driven, the rental company decides where it is taken. So do not have it towed on your own initiative.

Who pays for what?

If you were not at fault, the other party’s liability insurance pays. The rental company handles the claim. Injured passengers can also turn to the insurer of the party at fault. In the USA, rental companies offer additional cover for cases where the other party is uninsured or underinsured.

If you were at fault, the rental car’s liability insurance covers damage to others, such as other people’s cars, signs or guardrails. It does not pay for damage to the rental car itself. For that, you need fully comprehensive cover. The ADAC recommends fully comprehensive cover with a deductible of zero euros. Otherwise the deductible stays with you, and for each damage separately. Abroad, according to the ADAC, it is often due immediately, even if you did not cause the damage.

CoverPays in the event of damageDeductible
Rental car with fully comprehensive cover, no deductibleDamage to the rental car and theftnone for insured damage
Rental car with deductibleDamage to the rental car above the deductibleper claim
Rental car with glass and tire protectionWindows, tires, rims, often otherwise excludeddepending on the rate

Pay attention to the terms. According to the European Consumer Centre (EVZ), CDW, LDW and SCDW are not uniformly defined. CDW reduces your liability, usually leaving a deductible. SCDW reduces it further, often to zero. Tires, windows, underbody and roof are often excluded even with fully comprehensive cover. That is exactly what the glass and tire protection from the table is for. Check beforehand whether your credit card or an automobile club already provides cover. And do not buy super cover at the counter if your rate already reimburses the deductible, because according to the ADAC you will not get these costs back.

The rental car’s liability insurance often only covers the legal minimum of the destination country. In the EU, according to the EVZ, that is around 1.2 million euros for property damage; outside the EU, it can be considerably less. A Mallorca-Police (supplementary liability policy) raises the cover. The ADAC recommends at least one million abroad.

Pre-existing damage and return

Disputes also arise over scratches that were already there. At pickup, record every existing damage to paint, rims, tires and windshield in the report. At return, have a damage report issued and signed, even if everything is in order. Do not return the car outside opening hours. Otherwise, according to the EVZ, you have no influence on the report and may be liable for damage until the office opens.

Our advice: take one photo too many rather than one too few.

Two rulings described by the ADAC show that this pays off:

  • Regional Court of Lübeck (LG Lübeck) 2024, claim of around 5,500 euros (ADAC): dismissed because the rental company could not prove that the damage did not already exist before the rental.
  • Local Court of Castrop-Rauxel (AG Castrop-Rauxel) 2025, repair of 760 euros (ADAC) and flat fee of 95 euros (ADAC): dismissed because a report without a joint handover is no substitute for proof.

Clauses that shift the burden of proof onto you are inadmissible, according to the ADAC.

If a bill arrives later

  1. Object in writing and promptly. The EVZ advises requesting comprehensible damage documentation including the basis of calculation.
  2. Put your own photos and the return report next to it.
  3. If your credit card was charged without justification, have your bank check a chargeback.
  4. If you booked through a broker, according to the EVZ the broker is your point of contact for the insurance taken out there.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to call the police for every scratch?

That depends on the country and the rental company. If another party is involved, the ADAC always advises calling the police.

Does a dashcam help as evidence?

It can help, but it is not allowed everywhere. What the devices can do is covered in the dashcam guide. Check the rules of the country you are traveling to.

Does partial comprehensive cover pay for a stone chip?

According to the ADAC, glass breakage is part of partial comprehensive cover (Teilkasko), as are theft, fire, severe weather and collisions with game animals. Whether your rental agreement adopts this is stated in the terms and conditions.

What else to keep in mind when booking is covered in the guide Booking a rental car. Trips to the USA have their own rules, see Rental cars in the USA.

Whether legal expenses insurance applies to a dispute after the accident depends on the coverage modules and the waiting period; more on this in the guide Legal expenses insurance.

Frequently asked questions

What do I have to do after an accident with a rental car?

Secure the scene: hazard lights, high-visibility vest, warning triangle. If anyone is injured, call the emergency number and give first aid. If another party is involved, call the police and get a report. Photograph the scene and the damage and inform the rental company; otherwise, according to the ADAC, you risk your insurance cover.

Who pays for damage to the rental car?

If you were not at fault, the other party's liability insurance pays. If you were at fault, the rental car's liability insurance only covers damage to others. Damage to the rental car itself is paid by the fully comprehensive cover. Without a zero deductible, the deductible stays with you for each damage separately and, according to the ADAC, is often due immediately abroad.

What do CDW, LDW and SCDW mean?

According to the European Consumer Centre, the terms are not uniformly defined. CDW reduces your liability, usually leaving a deductible; SCDW reduces it further, often to zero. Do not buy super cover at the counter if your rate already reimburses the deductible; according to the ADAC, you will not get these costs back.

How do I protect myself from disputes over pre-existing damage?

At pickup, record every existing damage to paint, rims, tires and windshield in the report and take photos. At return, have a damage report issued and signed. Do not return the car outside opening hours; otherwise you may be liable for damage until the office opens.

What should I do if a damage bill arrives after the return?

Object in writing and promptly, and request comprehensible damage documentation including the basis of calculation; that is what the EVZ advises. Put your own photos and the return report next to it. Clauses that shift the burden of proof onto you are inadmissible, according to the ADAC.

Is the rental car's liability insurance enough abroad?

Often it only covers the legal minimum of the destination country; outside the EU, that can be considerably less. A Mallorca-Police (supplementary liability policy) raises the cover. The ADAC recommends at least one million abroad. Also check beforehand whether your credit card or automobile club already provides cover.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent.