Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Booking a Rental Car: Insurance, Deposit, Fuel Policy

Booking a rental car without cost traps: full collision coverage with no deductible, liability abroad, credit card deposit, fuel policy and the handover report.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Contents11 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

At the counter in your vacation destination, things often get expensive: extra insurance, a fuel package, a second driver. If you book the rental car correctly at home, you can politely decline most of it. The most important decision concerns insurance coverage. Our clear recommendation, in line with the German automobile club ADAC, is to book full collision coverage with no deductible. The rest is care. Nothing more.

The deductible: the most expensive mistake

A low rental price is often the result of a high deductible. The renter then carries the financial risk, and for every single claim. A scratch while parking in a narrow old-town street can quickly cost more than the whole week’s rental.

And then there is the fine print. Read carefully what the collision coverage excludes. According to the ADAC, damage to tires, rims, the underbody or from stone chips is frequently not covered. That is exactly where a lot happens on vacation, for example on gravel tracks down to the beach.

Insurance optionWhat happens in case of damageAssessment
Rental car with full collision coverage and no deductibleno out-of-pocket share for covered damageour recommendation; still read the exclusions
Rental car with deductible reimbursementpay your share on site, claim it back from the booking agent latergood, but do not buy extra collision coverage at the counter
Rental car with deductibleyou carry the share for each claimlower price, higher risk

With a reimbursement rate, you first pay the deductible yourself and claim it back from the booking agent later. If you booked this way, you do not need an additional super collision waiver at the counter, the ADAC advises. That, however, is exactly what is often offered there. Stay friendly and decline.

Liability abroad: often too low

Abroad, the minimum coverage amounts of the destination country apply, and they are often considerably lower than in Germany. The ADAC recommends at least one million euros. If the rental agreement falls short of that, an add-on policy helps. The so-called Mallorca-Police (a German add-on liability policy) applies in Europe including the Canary Islands and Madeira, the Traveller-Police worldwide, usually with 500,000 euros. Some credit cards include similar protection.

Deposit, card, age

For the deposit, rental companies usually require a real credit card, typically in the name of the main driver. Debit cards are not accepted everywhere abroad, so you should check this before booking. Never sign a blank credit card slip, not even when there is a long line at the counter and the agent kindly points out that this is perfectly normal here and just a formality.

The usual minimum age is 21. Some rental companies charge a surcharge for drivers under 25 or for new drivers, and from 70, depending on the provider, there are restrictions or additional costs.

Fuel policy and timing

The fairest rule is full to full: you pick up the car with a full tank and return it with a full tank. Be careful with a prepaid tank of fuel; it is often more expensive than at the gas station. Fill up shortly before returning the car and keep the receipt.

According to the ADAC, if you return the car late, you may have to pay extra. Plan the return at the airport with a buffer, especially for early flights.

Photos at pickup and return

At pickup, walk around the car together with the staff and have every dent and every scratch noted in the report. Then it is your phone’s turn. Photograph the vehicle from all sides, including the rims and interior. At return, insist on a return report. If possible, return the car during opening hours. If that is not possible, photograph it in its parking space.

If you are planning a side trip across the border or by ferry, ask beforehand. Ferry crossings are sometimes excluded, and one-way rentals across national borders can come with high fees.

Who is actually your contract partner?

Online, you usually book only a reservation. According to the ADAC, the rental contract is only concluded when you sign at the counter, and there is no right of withdrawal. If you do not show up, you usually lose the rental price. Call if you are running late, even though, according to the European Consumer Centre Germany (EVZ), that is no guarantee.

The question becomes important when there is trouble. The rental company is responsible for everything that happens on site, meaning damage, accidents, add-on products and traffic fines. For problems with the reservation or a refund, contact the booking agent if one was involved. According to the EVZ, price comparison portals are usually not responsible. Also watch out for the abbreviations: according to the EVZ, CDW, LDW and SCDW are not uniformly defined.

Costs often missing from the offer

  • One-way fee: according to the EVZ, it is usually not stated in the reservation and can be very high across national borders.
  • Fee for traffic fines: according to the EVZ, many rental companies charge around 40 euros for passing your details on to the authorities. In Italy, the competition authority prohibited this in June 2022.
  • Age: surcharges often apply for drivers under 25 and for new drivers, and according to the EVZ an extra charge may also apply from 69.
  • Debit card: some rental companies refuse it, and the EVZ cites complaints about several providers. Ask beforehand.

If a bill arrives after the return

Complain promptly and in writing. The EVZ advises requesting traceable damage documentation including the basis of calculation and comparing it with your photos and the return report. If the rental company charges your credit card without justification, have your bank look into a chargeback. If you have documented everything as described above, you will be in a much stronger position.

Frequently asked questions

Can I withdraw from an online booking?

No, according to the ADAC there is no right of withdrawal. Some rates can, however, be canceled free of charge until the rental starts; this is the case with ADAC Autovermietung, for example. The terms and conditions are what count.

Is a GPS unit worth the extra charge?

Often your phone with offline maps is enough. If you want to bring your own device, you will find tips in our guide car GPS navigation (in German).

Do I have to rent the child seat?

No, you can also bring your own. What matters is explained in our child car seat guide.

Is a dashcam allowed in a rental car?

Each country sets its own rules, and you will find them in our country guides. Which devices are available is shown in our dashcam guide.

How we would book

Before your trip, compare rental cars at your destination with full collision coverage and no deductible, liability coverage of at least one million euros and a full-to-full fuel policy. Estimate the mileage in advance: according to the ADAC, exceeding a mileage limit gets disproportionately expensive. Whether a second driver is included in the price is stated in the rental terms. Then all that is left at the counter is a signature. If you are planning a road trip, you will find ideas in our guide to a USA road trip. And if you still need a flight and hotel: how to book a package vacation safely.

For renting on site: what LDW, CDW and SLI mean and why supplemental liability matters is explained in our guide rental cars in the USA.

Heading to Mallorca? Tips on pickup in Palma, mountain roads and parking are in our guide rental cars on Mallorca (in German).

If you do have a crash along the way, our guide accidents with a rental car (in German) helps step by step.

Young drivers do not only pay more when renting; how a first car insurance policy of your own can start out cheaper is shown in our guide to car insurance for new drivers.

Frequently asked questions

Is full collision coverage with no deductible worth it for a rental car?

Yes, the ADAC recommends it too. A low rental price is often the result of a high deductible that you pay for every single claim. A scratch while parking can then quickly cost more than the whole week's rental. Still, read what the collision coverage excludes.

Which damage is often not covered on a rental car?

According to the ADAC, damage to tires, rims, the underbody or from stone chips is frequently excluded. That is exactly where a lot happens on vacation, for example on gravel tracks down to the beach. Read the fine print carefully before you book.

Do I need extra collision coverage at the counter?

Not if you booked a rate with deductible reimbursement. You then pay your share on site first and claim it back from the booking agent later. According to the ADAC, an additional super collision waiver at the counter is unnecessary, but it is often pushed there.

Which credit card do I need for a rental car?

For the deposit, rental companies usually require a real credit card, typically in the name of the main driver. Debit cards are not accepted everywhere abroad, so check before booking. Never sign a blank credit card slip.

Which fuel policy is fair for a rental car?

Full to full: pick the car up with a full tank and return it with a full tank. A prepaid tank of fuel is often more expensive than at the gas station. Fill up shortly before returning the car and keep the receipt.

How do I protect myself against damage claims at pickup and return?

At pickup, walk around the car with the staff and have every dent noted in the report. Photograph the vehicle from all sides, including the rims and interior. At return, insist on a report. Outside opening hours, photograph the car in its parking space.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent.