Contents14 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A camera that pings your phone twenty times a night because of the neighbor’s cat will eventually get muted. And that is exactly when you miss the one alert that matters. Higher resolution does not stop false alarms; what helps is detection that tells people and cars apart from branches, shadows and animals. For a house with an outlet on the exterior wall, we consider the Imou Cruiser Triple the most well-thought-out choice, because it detects people and vehicles in the camera itself and also supports lines and exclusion zones.
Why does my camera alert me about every cat?
Because it only pays attention to motion. Simple motion detection compares frame with frame and triggers as soon as enough pixels change. Rain in front of the spotlight, swaying hedges and cloud shadows do that too. Battery cameras usually use a passive infrared sensor, PIR for short, which reacts to changing heat radiation. It triggers for no reason less often, but reports every warm animal.
Only the image analysis that follows sorts things out. It checks whether the shape in the image is a person, a car or an animal and reports only what you have selected. Imou calls its method IMOU SENSE; for the Bullet 3C, the manufacturer states a range of 22 meters for people and 44 meters for cars. eufy takes a different approach with the eufyCam S3 Pro: radar and PIR work together, which according to the manufacturer cuts false alarms by 99 percent. That is the manufacturer’s own measurement, not an independent one.
Does the camera do the processing itself, or do I need a subscription?
That is the question to settle before you buy. Reolink explicitly states for the RLC-810A that person, vehicle and animal detection work without a subscription fee. TP-Link also describes detection on the Tapo C530WS as free. Imou uses two tiers: the detection built into the camera runs without a contract. According to the manufacturer, Imou Protect is optional and adds cloud detection on top, which also recognizes packages and even makes cameras without their own detection smarter. It also includes 7 days (Basic) or 30 days (Plus) of cloud storage.
Local processing has an advantage you only notice when the internet goes down. The camera keeps filtering; only the notification arrives later. And the footage never leaves the house. More on recording and storage space can be found in our guides to the right memory card (in German) and to the camera system with a recorder.
How do I set up detection zones sensibly?
Draw the zone where someone actually has to go: front door, garden gate, ground-floor windows. Leave out the sidewalk, and the street goes without saying. Lines work even more precisely. According to the manufacturers, the Cruiser Triple and the Tapo C530WS send an alert when a person or vehicle crosses a drawn line. Someone walking past the fence in the evening triggers nothing. Someone opening the gate does.
What about neighbors and passersby?
This is where technology ends and the law begins. According to the guidance of the German Data Protection Conference (DSK), edited by the state data protection commissioner of Baden-Württemberg, the right to monitor ends at your own property line. Private individuals may not monitor streets, sidewalks or parking lots. If a home camera also captures public space, the exemption for purely private purposes no longer applies, and the GDPR applies in full.
If the camera cannot be aimed so that only your own property is in the frame, the supervisory authorities require other areas to be permanently masked. A detection zone is no substitute. It usually only controls when an alert is sent, not what ends up in the image. So look for genuine privacy zones or masks. With pan-and-tilt cameras this is trickier, because the field of view changes.
Do I need facial recognition?
We advise against it. According to the manufacturer, eufy’s HomeBase S380 remembers up to 50 faces and separates family from strangers, and it even does so locally. It sounds practical. But a system like this inevitably also captures the faces of visitors, delivery drivers and children from the neighborhood. The German Data Protection Conference counts biometric data used for unique identification among the specially protected categories of data and explicitly lists biometric recognition among the camera functions that are generally not permitted. Good person detection with carefully set zones is entirely sufficient for a home.
Six cameras that can tell people from cats
| Model | Detection according to the manufacturer | Power and storage | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Imou Cruiser Triple | Person, vehicle, intrusion, line crossing, absence; local | 12 V power adapter; two microSD slots, up to 1 TB combined | Driveway and garden at the same time |
| Imou Bullet 3C | Person 22 m, vehicle 44 m; selectable detection area | 12 V power adapter; microSD up to 256 GB | A fixed view of a door or gate |
| Imou Cruiser Pano Z | Motion, person, vehicle; privacy mode | PoE (802.3at) or power adapter; up to 1 TB, NVR and cloud | Large properties with cabling |
| Reolink RLC-810A | Person, vehicle, animal; no subscription | PoE; microSD up to 512 GB | New builds with network cabling |
| TP-Link Tapo C530WS | Person, animal, vehicle, line crossing, tampering | Wi-Fi or LAN; microSD up to 512 GB | Pan-and-tilt camera with privacy mode |
| eufyCam S3 Pro | Radar plus PIR; facial recognition via HomeBase S380 | Battery with solar; HomeBase up to 16 TB | No power cable on the exterior wall |
Imou Cruiser Triple
Two fixed 3 MP lenses keep the overview, while a pivoting 5 MP lens rotates 355 degrees and follows. According to Imou, if you tap the fixed image in the app, the third lens pans to exactly that spot. Detection types can be added via AIgo Play, including intrusion and line crossing. Imou adds a caveat: not every algorithm is available in every country, and how many can run at the same time depends on the chip. Drawbacks: only 15 frames per second, a power adapter instead of PoE, and ONVIF is not listed in the data sheet. For multi-lens cameras, Imou offers its own, more expensive Protect licenses.
Imou Bullet 3C
The simple solution. Fixed mount, available with 3 or 5 MP, IP67 protection rating, Wi-Fi 6 and an Ethernet port, plus ONVIF for recorders from other brands. It distinguishes people and vehicles on its own, and the detection area is adjustable. The data sheet for the 3 MP version lists memory cards up to 256 GB. For a single front door, that is enough.
Imou Cruiser Pano Z
Two fixed 4 MP lenses together cover 158 degrees, and the pan module has focal lengths of 2.8 and 12 mm. Power comes via PoE to 802.3at or a power adapter, and according to Imou, a recorder and the cloud can be used in parallel. One tap hides the image in privacy mode. For a townhouse, this is too much camera.
Reolink RLC-810A
A classic 4K bullet camera for network cabling. It detects people, vehicles and animals without a subscription, motion zones can be drawn freely, and according to Reolink it works with Synology’s Surveillance Station. Nothing works without a PoE switch or injector. Reolink does not recommend third-party recorders.
TP-Link Tapo C530WS
A 5 MP pan-and-tilt camera that according to TP-Link distinguishes people, animals and vehicles and also reports tampering and line crossing. In privacy mode, the lens disappears into the housing. An honest signal to everyone who passes by. Cloud storage costs extra with Tapo Care.
eufyCam S3 Pro
A battery camera with a solar panel that combines radar and PIR. Recordings are stored on the HomeBase S380 with 16 GB, expandable to 16 TB, with no monthly fee. We would leave the facial recognition switched off.
Which camera suits my property?
- Driveway and garden with one camera, outlet available: Imou Cruiser Triple.
- Just the front door or carport, tight budget: Imou Bullet 3C.
- Large property, network cable already in place: Imou Cruiser Pano Z or Reolink RLC-810A.
- No power on the wall: eufyCam S3 Pro, or with a SIM card, a camera from our guide to the security camera with 4G.
If you also want the lights to come on when someone arrives, a smart motion sensor (in German) helps. The basics of batteries, Wi-Fi and mounting are covered in our guide to the outdoor security camera.
Frequently asked questions
Why does my security camera alert me about every cat?
Because it only reacts to motion or heat. Simple motion detection triggers as soon as enough pixels change, and a PIR sensor reports every warm animal. Only image analysis distinguishes people, cars and animals and reports just what you select.
Do I need a subscription for person detection?
Not necessarily. Reolink and TP-Link state that detection on the RLC-810A and Tapo C530WS is free. With Imou, detection runs in the camera without a contract; Imou Protect is optional and adds cloud detection and cloud storage. Local detection keeps filtering even without internet.
Is a security camera with facial recognition allowed?
We advise against it. Such a system also captures visitors, delivery drivers and neighbors' children. The German Data Protection Conference (DSK) counts biometric data among the specially protected categories and lists biometric recognition among the camera functions that are generally not permitted. Good person detection with zones is enough.
Can my camera film the sidewalk and street?
No. According to the guidance of the German Data Protection Conference, surveillance ends at your own property line. Other areas must be permanently masked, for example with a privacy zone or mask. A detection zone is no substitute, because it usually only controls when alerts are sent.
How do I set up detection zones correctly?
Draw the zone where someone actually has to go: front door, garden gate, ground-floor windows. Leave out the sidewalk and street. Lines, which the Cruiser Triple and Tapo C530WS support, are even more precise: someone walking past the fence triggers nothing, someone opening the gate does.
Which camera with person detection works without a power cable?
The eufyCam S3 Pro with battery and solar panel. It combines radar and PIR, and recordings are stored on the HomeBase S380 with no monthly fee. We would leave the HomeBase's facial recognition switched off.
Sources
- German Data Protection Conference (DSK): Guidance on video surveillance by non-public bodies (PDF)
- Imou: Cruiser Triple and data sheet
- Imou: Bullet 3C and data sheet
- Imou: Cruiser Pano Z and data sheet
- Imou: Imou Protect
- Reolink: RLC-810A
- TP-Link: Tapo C530WS
- eufy: HomeBase S380 and eufyCam S3 Pro
Where to buy
- Imou Cruiser TripleView at ImouAvailable in Germany: ImouCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Imou Bullet 3CView at ImouAvailable in Germany: ImouCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Imou Cruiser Pano ZView at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: CoolblueView at ImouAvailable in Germany: ImouCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Reolink RLC-810ACheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- TP-Link Tapo C530WSView at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: CoolblueCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- eufyCam S3 ProCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de

