Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
You do not buy a shade sail by color. You buy it by the three points it is supposed to hang from. For an ordinary patio, we would choose a breathable rectangular or square HDPE sail, such as the Windhager Capri, and would rather put the money into solid mounting than into a denser fabric. The three-step path below shows why.
Step one: triangle or rectangle?
The shape determines the shaded area, and this is where many people misjudge. A triangle with 3-meter sides looks generous in the catalog. But it only covers around 3.9 square meters, and even a little less once you subtract the inward-curved hem. A 3 x 4 meter rectangle manages a good three times as much. Even the large triangle with 5-meter sides comes to just under 10.8 square meters, and so does not quite reach the 3 x 4 rectangle.
Still, the triangle has its place. It needs only three mounting points, and two hooks on the house wall plus a single post are often enough. Two or three triangles stretched offset above one another also look livelier than a flat sheet. If you want to shade a seating area for four people, though, you almost always end up with a four-cornered sail.
An example: a dining table for six, chairs pushed back, takes up about 3.5 x 2.5 meters. Above it belongs a sail that overhangs a little on every side, because the afternoon sun comes in at an angle. So more like 4 x 5 meters than 3 x 4.
Step two: let rain through or keep it out?
When it comes to fabrics, there are essentially two camps. HDPE is a coarse-mesh plastic knit that lets air and water pass through. Less heat builds up underneath, and no water pocket forms in a thunderstorm. Coated polyester, by contrast, keeps out light rain. In return, it has to be tensioned with a clear slope; otherwise water collects in the fabric and pulls on the eyelets and hooks with considerable weight.
For its water-repellent sails, Windhager requires a slope of at least 15 degrees, measured from the lowest mounting point. That sounds like little. Over a length of four meters, though, it means more than one meter of height difference, and that only works if one post stands considerably higher than the other or the wall hooks sit high up.
Our position: a shade sail is sun protection. If you want a rain roof, you need a sturdy gazebo (in German). And if you only want to shade a deck chair, you often do not need a sail at all, but a good patio umbrella (in German).
One more word on the UV figures. They come from the manufacturers throughout, and they are not uniform. For the Cannes polyester sail, Windhager states a protection factor of 50+, while for the Capri HDPE sail it states „about 90 percent“ of UV radiation blocked. The two figures cannot be compared directly, and none of the suppliers cites an independent test.
Step three: what will it be tensioned to?
This is what decides whether the sail is still hanging after two summers. In wind, a shade sail acts like the sail of a boat, and the forces end up entirely in the corners. The manufacturers reveal little about structural loads, so what counts is what they write themselves.
Pina, a specialist in sail systems, publishes a table for its posts with a diameter of 70 millimeters. According to it, such a post can carry a four-cornered sail of up to 30 square meters with fabric up to 200 grams per square meter, but a triangle only up to 20. With heavier fabric, the permissible area decreases. Windhager specifies sails up to 25 square meters for its Premium mast and, according to the listing, up to 20 for the simpler Basic set. For the wall, Pina recommends injection mortar, mesh sleeves or special anchors for insulated facades, depending on the masonry. Simple plastic wall plugs are not mentioned there.
Three things tend to get overlooked in planning. Between the sail corner and the mounting point, you need room for retensioning: 35 to 60 centimeters according to Windhager, often 50 to 90 at Pina. For the post itself, Windhager recommends an incline of 10 to 15 degrees. And in strong wind, both manufacturers advise taking the sail down. According to Pina, a safety clamp does not make it storm-proof.
Tenants should clarify drilling into the facade with the landlord beforehand. With insulated walls, all the more so.
Seven sails and posts side by side
| Model | Shape and fabric | Specifications according to manufacturer or listing | For whom |
|---|---|---|---|
| Windhager Capri | Square, rectangle, triangle; HDPE 225 g/m² | air- and water-permeable, about 90% UV protection, metal eyelets | Patio in summer, low maintenance |
| Windhager Cannes Dreieck (triangle) | Triangle 3, 4 or 5 m; coated polyester 180 g/m² | water-repellent, UV 50+, at least 15 degrees of slope | if you want to keep out light rain |
| Sol Royal SolVision HS9 | Triangle and rectangle; HDPE | wind- and water-permeable, up to 90% UV, ropes included | small budget, balcony and garden |
| Sol Royal SolVision PS9 | Triangle and rectangle; polyester 160 g/m² | water-repellent, up to 85% UV | affordable entry with rain protection |
| Floracord Vierecksonnensegel HDPE (four-cornered shade sail) | Square, e.g. 2.5 x 3 m; HDPE 180 g/m² | wind- and water-permeable, about 85% UV, elastic tension straps | small area without tensioning tools |
| Windhager Sonnensegelmast Premium (shade sail post) | Aluminum, up to 242.5 cm high | Sails up to 25 m², height-adjustable slider, ground sleeve sold separately | freestanding corner in the garden |
| Pina Design Sonnensegelpfosten V2A (stainless steel shade sail post) | Stainless steel, 3-point height adjustment | 4:1 pulley system, ground sleeve 0.75 m | larger sails that should stay taut |
Windhager Capri
This is how we would equip the typical patio. According to Windhager, the HDPE fabric weighs 225 grams per square meter and lets air and water through. Thanks to the concave cut, it tensions with few wrinkles. The square version is offered in 4 x 4 and 5 x 5 meters. Washable at 30 degrees Celsius.
Windhager Cannes Dreieck
The counterpart in coated polyester. According to the manufacturer, it keeps out wind and water, and it comes in three equilateral sizes. If you buy it, you must actually be able to build the required slope. Otherwise, the rain protection turns into a tub.
Sol Royal SolVision HS9
A plain HDPE sail in many formats, from 2 x 3 meters to the large triangle. According to the listing, tensioning ropes are included. That is enough to get started, although for larger areas the ropes should soon be swapped for stainless steel tensioners.
Sol Royal SolVision PS9
The water-repellent polyester version at 160 grams per square meter. Lighter than the Windhager Cannes. According to retailer information, water pockets can still form in heavy rain if the slope is missing.
Floracord Vierecksonnensegel HDPE
Floracord includes permanently elastic tension straps. They absorb gusts somewhat and make mounting on existing hooks easy. For small balconies and seating corners, that is convenient; for large areas, we would prefer rope tensioning with a turnbuckle.
Windhager Sonnensegelmast Premium
An aluminum post with a rail on which the sail corner moves up or down in small steps via a slider. This lets you change the slope later. A ground sleeve for setting in concrete or a patio bracket costs extra.
Pina Design Sonnensegelpfosten V2A
Pina supplies the stainless steel post with height adjustment, a 4:1 pulley system and a ground sleeve. According to the listing, 15 kilograms of hand force become around 60 kilograms of pull on the sail. The more expensive solution, but the one that actually keeps a large sail taut.
Polyester sails from the brand hanSe are also available on Amazon. Reliable manufacturer data is missing, which is why they are missing from the table.
How we would decide
- Patio with a house wall and one open corner: Windhager Capri as a square, two solidly anchored wall hooks, and in the garden a Windhager Premium mast with a ground sleeve set in concrete.
- Seating area that should stay dry even in drizzle: Windhager Cannes or Sol Royal PS9, provided the slope is right.
- Balcony or small corner on a tight budget: Sol Royal HS9 or Floracord with tension straps.
- Large sail over 20 square meters: plan the posts first, for example with the Pina post, then buy the fabric.
An order that has proven itself: measure the anchor points first, then decide on shape and size, and only at the very end the color. If you like to read underneath it on a sun lounger (in German), you will notice the difference immediately.
Frequently asked questions
Triangle or rectangle: which shade sail gives more shade?
The rectangle, and by a wide margin. A triangle with 3-meter sides covers only around 3.9 square meters, while a 3 x 4 meter rectangle covers a good three times as much. Triangles, on the other hand, need only three mounting points. For a seating area for four people, you almost always end up with a four-cornered sail.
What is the difference between HDPE and polyester in a shade sail?
HDPE is a coarse-mesh knitted fabric that lets air and water through, so less heat builds up underneath and no water pocket forms. Coated polyester keeps out light rain, but has to be tensioned with a clear slope; otherwise water collects and pulls heavily on the eyelets and hooks.
How much slope does a water-repellent shade sail need?
Windhager requires at least 15 degrees, measured from the lowest mounting point. Over a length of four meters, that means more than one meter of height difference. That only works if one post stands considerably higher than the other or the wall hooks sit high up.
How large can a shade sail on a post be?
That depends on the post. For posts with a diameter of 70 millimeters and fabric up to 200 grams per square meter, Pina gives a four-cornered sail up to 30 square meters, but a triangle only up to 20. Windhager specifies sails up to 25 square meters for its Premium mast. With heavier fabric, the permissible area decreases.
What should you look for when mounting on a house wall?
Depending on the masonry, Pina recommends injection mortar, mesh sleeves or special anchors for insulated facades; simple plastic wall plugs are not mentioned. Between the sail corner and the hook, you need room for retensioning, 35 to 60 centimeters according to Windhager. Tenants should clarify drilling with the landlord beforehand.
Can a shade sail stay up in a storm?
Both manufacturers advise taking the sail down in strong wind. A shade sail acts like the sail of a boat, and the forces end up entirely in the corners. According to Pina, a safety clamp does not make it storm-proof.
Sources
- Windhager: Sun Sail Cannes Dreieck
- Windhager: Sun Sail Capri Quadrat
- Windhager: Sonnensegelmast Premium
- Pina: Mounting planning guide
Where to buy
- Windhager CapriCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Windhager Cannes DreieckCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Sol Royal SolVision HS9Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Sol Royal SolVision PS9Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Floracord Vierecksonnensegel HDPECheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Windhager Sonnensegelmast PremiumCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Pina Design Sonnensegelpfosten V2ACheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
