Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Three centimeters of water in the basement, the new pump standing right in the middle of it, and it does not budge. Usually it is not broken. On several models in this comparison, the float switch, according to the data sheet, only kicks in at a water level of 26 to 42 centimeters; it is designed for a pump sump, not for a shallow puddle on the screed. If you have a sump, the Gardena Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 16000 (submersible dirty water pump) is a solid choice; if you mostly need to get wet floors dry, you need a flat-suction combination pump such as the Kärcher SP 16.000 Dual.
Liters, meters, millimeters: three numbers that count
The first thing on every box is the flow rate. It is a maximum figure, measured without any significant delivery head and without long hoses. In practice, though, the water has to get up out of the basement into the garden or the sewer. T.I.P. publishes a performance curve for the Maxima 300 IX that shows this well: 18,000 liters per hour as the peak, still 13,500 at a height of 3 meters, only 8,500 at 5 meters and just 3,000 at 7 meters. A basement window is often a good two meters above the floor, and on top of that comes the resistance in the hose. So plan with considerably less than the figure on the packaging.
The same applies to pond and well pumps. With the T.I.P. Multifunktionspumpe WPF S from our hands-on test, too, the maximum figures refer to a free outlet; every meter of height, a long hose and narrow connections cost performance.
The particle size decides whether leaves, gravel or sludge get through. According to the Gardena manual, clear water pumps handle at most 5 millimeters, while the dirty water pumps in this comparison handle 20 to 38. After a heavy downpour, enough debris floats in the window well to clog a clear water pump. Basements and excavation pits therefore call for a dirty water pump.
Then there is the residual water. A classic dirty water pump leaves 25 to 40 millimeters behind because its impeller needs clearance from the floor. Combination pumps with an adjustable foot or filter basket suction down to 1 millimeter according to the manufacturers, but then only clear water. Otherwise, a wet vacuum or mop takes care of the rest.
Float, sensor or continuous operation?
The float switch turns the pump on when the water rises and off again before it runs dry. On the Gardena 16000, the switch-on point is between 26 and 42 centimeters according to the manual, and on the T.I.P. Maxima 300 IX it is 39 centimeters. That suits a pump sump in which groundwater collects. On a flat basement floor, by contrast, you have to run the pump in manual mode and stay next to it, because without the float there is no dry-run protection. Gardena states this explicitly in the manual.
Electronic sensors start earlier. According to the manufacturer, the Gardena 20000 Aquasensor starts running from just 42 millimeters. An improvement over the float, but still too much for a screed floor with a few millimeters of water.
Power, water and what does not belong in the pump
The Gardena manual requires a residual current device (RCD) with a tripping current of no more than 30 mA. If the basement circuit is not protected this way, portable RCD adapters are available as plug-in units. According to the manufacturer, salt water, oils, heating oil, gasoline and other flammable or corrosive liquids are off-limits. If the water smells of heating oil, the pump stays off. Also: water no warmer than 35 degrees Celsius, store the pump frost-free and do not use it as a permanent circulation pump. There are dedicated devices for the garden pond; more on that in the guide to pond pumps.
Six dirty water pumps side by side
| Model | Max. flow rate / delivery head | Particle size / residual water | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gardena Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 9000 | 9,000 l/h / 6 m, 300 W | 25 mm / 25 mm | Occasionally emptying a rain barrel, pit or sump |
| Gardena Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 16000 | 16,000 l/h / 7 m, 450 W | 35 mm / 35 mm | Pump sump in the basement, excavation pit |
| Kärcher SP 16.000 Dual | 16,000 l/h / 9 m, 550 W | 20 mm / 1 mm (flat) | Wet basement floors, laundry room, garage |
| Einhell GE-DP 7535 N LL ECO | 18,500 l/h / 9 m, 750 W | 35 mm / 1 mm (flat) | Sludge and shallow leftovers with one pump |
| T.I.P. Maxima 300 IX | 18,000 l/h / 8 m, 700 W | 30 mm / 40 mm | Permanent installation in a sump, stainless steel |
| Metabo SP 220-35 S Inox | 22,000 l/h / 8 m, 790 W | 35 mm / not specified | Large volumes of water, floods, construction sites |
Gardena Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 9000
The smallest Gardena dirty water pump gets by on 300 watts and, according to the data sheet, moves 9,000 liters per hour at a maximum delivery head of 6 meters. Small stones up to 25 millimeters pass through, and 25 millimeters of water remain. In the Gardena online shop, it costs considerably less than the 16000. For a flooded basement with a long way up, it gets tight.
Gardena Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 16000
If there is a pump sump in the basement, this is the one we reach for. 450 watts, 16,000 liters per hour, 7 meters of delivery head and foreign objects up to 35 millimeters, all according to the manufacturer. The float can be hooked into three positions on the housing, and the connector for 25, 32 and 38 millimeter hoses simply clicks on. Gardena gives a five-year warranty after online registration. It cannot suction flat: 35 millimeters of residual water.
Kärcher SP 16.000 Dual
The clever part is the adjustable filter basket. In the dirty water setting, particles up to 20 millimeters get through; in the flat setting, the pump suctions down to 1 millimeter, according to Kärcher. With 550 watts and 9 meters of delivery head, it has enough pressure for the route out of the basement. If you often have leaves and gravel in the water, the 35 millimeters of the Gardena serve you better.
Einhell GE-DP 7535 N LL ECO
Einhell combines both: foreign objects up to 35 millimeters and a dial for the suction level with settings of 1, 15, 25 and 35 millimeters. According to the manufacturer, the pump starts at a water level of just 15 millimeters, moves up to 18,500 liters per hour and manages a height of 9 meters. The housing is made of stainless steel, and the hose connection rotates 360 degrees.
T.I.P. Maxima 300 IX
On this pump, the housing, motor shaft and motor casing are made of stainless steel, and according to T.I.P., there is a spare parts availability guarantee of up to ten years. It handles dirt up to 30 millimeters. The float switches on at 390 millimeters and off again at 200, a figure for a real sump. It weighs 7 kilograms. On Amazon, it is often offered as a set with a hose, so check what is included.
Metabo SP 220-35 S Inox
At 22,000 liters per hour according to Metabo, it has the highest flow rate in this comparison, with a power input of 790 watts. Particle size up to 35 millimeters, stainless steel housing, double sealing system and overload protection. For a basement that only rarely gets damp, that is plenty. It is more of a pump for flood-prone areas, cisterns or excavation pits. Metabo does not list residual water or switching points online.
How we would decide
- Basement with a pump sump or an excavation pit: Gardena 16000. Enough power, large particle size, adjustable float.
- Level basement floors, laundry rooms, garages: Kärcher SP 16.000 Dual or, for muddy water, the Einhell GE-DP 7535 N LL ECO.
- Only occasionally emptying a pit or barrel: the Gardena 9000 is enough.
- Recurring floods or a high delivery head: Metabo SP 220-35 S Inox or T.I.P. Maxima 300 IX.
A submersible pump is no substitute for an irrigation pump. With a maximum pressure of 0.6 to 0.9 bar, the devices here are built for pumping water out. If you need pressurized rainwater for watering, you will find suitable devices in the guide to domestic water stations. And if you want to notice early that water is collecting in the basement, place a detector on the floor. Which devices are suitable for that is covered in the guide to water leak detectors.
So that a pump sump filling up in a vacation home does not go unnoticed, a device from the guide to the GSM auto dialer (in German) reports the fault by text message.
What is left of the liters at 10 degrees Celsius is shown in the guide to the dehumidifier for the basement.
Whether water in the basement after heavy rain or a sewer backup is insured depends on natural hazards cover (Elementarschutz); more on that in the guide to German residential building insurance (in German).
Frequently asked questions
Why doesn't my submersible pump start when there is only a little water?
Usually it is not broken. On several models, the float switch only kicks in at a water level of 26 to 42 centimeters, because it is designed for a pump sump. On a flat basement floor, the pump has to run in manual mode, and you need to stay next to it because there is then no dry-run protection.
How much does a submersible pump really move?
Considerably less than it says on the box. The flow rate is a maximum figure without any significant delivery head. For the T.I.P. Maxima 300 IX, the performance curve shows 18,000 liters per hour as the peak, still 13,500 at a height of 3 meters and only 8,500 at 5 meters. On top of that comes the resistance in the hose.
Clear water pump or dirty water pump for the basement?
Basements and excavation pits call for a dirty water pump. According to the Gardena manual, clear water pumps handle a particle size of at most 5 millimeters, while the dirty water pumps in this comparison handle 20 to 38. After a heavy downpour, enough debris floats in the window well to clog a clear water pump.
How low can a submersible pump suction down?
A classic dirty water pump leaves 25 to 40 millimeters of water behind because its impeller needs clearance from the floor. Combination pumps with an adjustable foot or filter basket, such as the Kärcher SP 16.000 Dual, suction down to 1 millimeter according to the manufacturer, but then only clear water. A wet vacuum or mop takes care of the rest.
What do you need to keep in mind when operating a submersible pump?
The Gardena manual requires a residual current device (RCD) with a tripping current of no more than 30 mA; otherwise a portable RCD adapter helps. Salt water, oils, heating oil and gasoline are off-limits, and if the water smells of heating oil, the pump stays off. The water may be no warmer than 35 degrees Celsius, and the pump is stored frost-free.
Can you water the garden with a submersible pump?
Not really. With a maximum pressure of 0.6 to 0.9 bar, the devices in this comparison are built for pumping out water, not as irrigation pumps. If you need pressurized rainwater for watering, a domestic water station serves you better. According to Gardena, submersible pumps should not be used as permanent circulation pumps either.
Sources
- Gardena: Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 16000
- Gardena: Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 20000 Aquasensor
- Gardena: Operating manual for clear and dirty water submersible pumps (art. 9030 to 9046)
- Gardena: Drainage pumps
- Kärcher: SP 16.000 Dual
- Einhell: Dirty water pump GE-DP 7535 N LL
- T.I.P.: Dirty water submersible pump Maxima 300 IX
- Metabo: SP 220-35 S Inox
Where to buy
- Gardena Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 16000Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Gardena Schmutzwasser-Tauchpumpe 9000Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Kärcher SP 16.000 DualCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.deView at CoolblueAvailable in Germany: Coolblue
- Einhell GE-DP 7535 N LL ECOCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- T.I.P. Maxima 300 IXCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Metabo SP 220-35 S InoxCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
