Contents7 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Private accident insurance is one of the most overrated policies in the household, and at the same time a sensible choice for some people. Both are true. It pays primarily for permanent damage after an accident, not for a broken arm that heals, and not for illness. Once you know that, you can judge whether it fits your life before the first calculator runs.
We do not recommend plans or insurers here. You will find criteria and ways to calculate, not advice for your individual case.
What counts as an accident
The law is narrow. Under § 178 VVG (German Insurance Contract Act), a sudden event acting from outside must involuntarily damage your health. A fall from a ladder, yes. A herniated disc after years at a desk, no. Gradual overuse in sports does not count either, according to the Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center), and you have to prove that an accident happened. According to the GDV (German Insurance Association), exclusions include accidents under heavy influence of alcohol or drugs, intentional crimes, poisoning, infections and psychological reactions.
Under § 180 VVG, damage is permanent if it is expected to last longer than three years and no improvement is expected. If the knee gets better again, the disability component pays nothing. Stiftung Warentest (German consumer testing organization) described this back in 2017 as a common reason for disappointed customers.
Who it suits better and who less
In Germany, employees have statutory insurance at work and on the way to work, and children at school, at kindergarten and on the way to school. According to the GDV, however, most accidents happen during leisure time, in the household and in sports, and that is where this coverage does not apply.
The Verbraucherzentrale names self-employed people, people without an occupation, homemakers, people with a high accident risk and those who cannot get occupational disability insurance because of pre-existing conditions as groups with greater need. For employees, it is considerably more reserved. Its argument carries weight: more than 90 percent of occupational disability cases are due to illness, not accidents. Stiftung Warentest sees it similarly. So if you want to protect your income, an accident policy only covers a small part of the risk. It replaces nothing; at most, it supplements.
So ask yourself a simple question. How would you pay for converting your home or for an adapted car if a fall during your leisure time left you permanently impaired? That kind of one-off cost is exactly what the disability sum is meant for.
The components
| Component | What it provides | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Disability benefit | One-off payment based on the Gliedertaxe | Benefit from 1 percent disability, amount of the base sum |
| Progression | Disproportionately more for severe disability | The degree at which it kicks in |
| Accident pension | Lifelong pension for severe permanent damage | Minimum degree of disability |
| Death benefit | Payment to surviving dependents | Usually lower than the disability sum |
| Hospital daily allowance | Daily rate in the hospital | Maximum duration, usually up to two years |
How much money is paid is decided by the Gliedertaxe, a disability scale by body part. It assigns a degree of disability to each body part. Stiftung Warentest cites 5 percent for the big toe and 70 percent for an arm as examples, the Verbraucherzentrale 50 percent for an eye. These values differ from plan to plan. Pre-existing damage to the same body part can reduce the benefit.
Putting the base sum and progression in perspective
As a rule of thumb for the base sum, the Verbraucherzentrale suggests six times your gross annual income at age 30, five times at 40 and four times at 50. A sample calculation, with no statement about your premium: with a base sum of five times your annual salary and 20 percent disability, you receive exactly one annual salary without progression. That is how large, or how small, the payment is for permanent damage you will definitely feel.
Opinions differ on progression. Stiftung Warentest prefers plans with progression, because customers with severe disability receive a multiple of the base sum. In its test of 120 plans from issue 3/2026, the benchmark for basic coverage was three quarters of a million euros for full disability. The Verbraucherzentrale points out that progression rarely applies in practice and raises the premium. Both are right. You are paying for a rare case that is especially expensive when it happens. Ask to see the levels; it often only starts at around a quarter disability.
The deadlines are the sore spot
Standard terms provide for 15 months within which the disability must have occurred, been certified by a doctor and been claimed. According to Stiftung Warentest, more consumer-friendly plans offer at least 21 months for occurrence and 24 for certification and claiming.
Why does that matter? Many permanent injuries only show up late. So report an accident immediately, collect medical certificates and put the deadline in your calendar, even if everything looks harmless at first. According to the GDV, relatives must report a fatal accident within 48 hours.
When taking out a policy, care comes before speed. Answer health questions completely; incorrect information will cost you your coverage later. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, you should report a change of occupation and new risky hobbies right away. And it advises against policies with premium refunds, because they are expensive. Insurance and saving belong apart.
What a comparison can do
Out of 120 plans, Stiftung Warentest awarded “very good” only eight times. So there are plenty of differences, and they lie in deadlines, the Gliedertaxe and the minimum degree, not in the name of the plan. The comparison at Tarifcheck is free and non-binding; you enter persons, sums and components. The site does not state the number of providers, so you cannot tell from it whether the whole market is shown. According to its own information, Tarifcheck is neither a broker nor an intermediary; the brokering is handled by external partners. The guideline values there for base sum and progression are the portal’s own figures, not an independent assessment.
A comparison is no substitute for advice. Consumer advice centers and insurance consultants offer independent help. If a contract is concluded via our link, we may receive a commission; we are not permitted to advise you.
Protection starts before the accident, by the way. Our guides to bike helmets, ski helmets and motorcycle helmets fit right in.
For damage a horse causes to others, it is not accident insurance that is responsible but owner’s liability insurance; what it should cover is shown in the horse liability insurance guide.
Frequently asked questions
When does private accident insurance pay?
Under Section 178 of the German Insurance Contract Act (VVG), a sudden event acting from outside must involuntarily damage your health, such as a fall from a ladder. A herniated disc after years at a desk does not count. The disability component only pays out if the damage is expected to last longer than three years.
Do employees need accident insurance?
The Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center) is reserved when it comes to employees. More than 90 percent of occupational disability cases are due to illness, not accidents. If you want to protect your income, an accident policy only covers a small part of the risk. At work and on the way to work, there is also statutory coverage.
How high should the base sum be?
As a rule of thumb, the Verbraucherzentrale suggests six times your gross annual income at age 30, five times at 40 and four times at 50. With a base sum of five times your annual salary and 20 percent disability, you receive exactly one annual salary without progression.
What is the Gliedertaxe?
It assigns a degree of disability to each body part and thereby determines how much money is paid. Stiftung Warentest cites 5 percent for the big toe and 70 percent for an arm as examples. The values differ from plan to plan, and pre-existing damage can reduce the benefit.
Is progression worth it in accident insurance?
Opinions differ. Stiftung Warentest prefers plans with progression, because in cases of severe disability a multiple of the base sum is paid. The Verbraucherzentrale stresses that it rarely applies and raises the premium. Ask to see the levels.
Which deadlines apply after an accident?
Standard terms provide for 15 months within which the disability must have occurred, been certified by a doctor and been claimed. According to Stiftung Warentest, more consumer-friendly plans offer at least 21 months for occurrence and 24 for certification and claiming. Report accidents immediately and collect medical certificates.
Sources
- § 178 VVG: Insurer’s obligation to pay, definition of an accident
- § 180 VVG: Disability
- Verbraucherzentrale: Private accident insurance
- Stiftung Warentest: Private accident insurance compared
- Stiftung Warentest: Why it often doesn’t pay
- GDV: What is private accident insurance?
- Tarifcheck: Accident insurance
Where to buy
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: InvaliditätsleistungView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: ProgressionView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: UnfallrenteView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: TodesfallleistungView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
- Vergleich bei Tarifcheck: KrankenhaustagegeldView at TarifcheckAvailable in Germany: Tarifcheck
