Contents8 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
People rarely buy a second bike bag because the first one broke. Usually it simply does not suit the bike or their daily routine: the hooks do not grip around the rack tube, the laptop slides around loose, the groceries are too heavy for one side. For commuters and touring cyclists, a pair of classic roll-top panniers with a hook system is still the solid basic setup, such as the Ortlieb Back-Roller. If you only go shopping or only ride gravel with light luggage, a different type of bag serves you better.
Before buying a bag: check the rack, tube and weight
A bag is only as good as its connection to the bike. So the rack comes first. It normally states the permitted load, and that must not be exceeded, even if each individual bag could take more. In its data sheets, Ortlieb explicitly advises weighing loaded bags before a tour. The rack manufacturer Racktime limits its racks to 25 kg. The reason is in its FAQ: under the ISO 11243 standard, racks rated from 27 kg are considered suitable for child seats, and Racktime wants to avoid giving that impression.
Then the mounting. Hook systems such as Ortlieb Quick-Lock (QL2.1) or Vaude QMR 2.0 grip around the rack tube and therefore fit almost any standard rack. For QL2.1, Ortlieb specifies tubes up to 16 mm, with inserts for 8, 10 and 12 mm; for thicker tubes on some e-bikes, 18 and 20 mm hooks are available as accessories. Vaude specifies 8 to 16 mm for QMR 2.0. Platform systems such as MIK, Racktime Snapit or Klickfix work differently. They click onto a plate or adapter and can sometimes be locked, but they require a matching rack. Racktime points out that the lock versions of Snapit and Snapit 2.0 are not compatible with each other. So the order is clear. First the rack, then the bag.
When it comes to water protection, only the manufacturer’s specification counts. Ortlieb gives IP ratings and ties them to conditions: IP64 for the Back-Roller only with the closure rolled three to four times. Vaude and Basil call their bags waterproof but give no IP rating. Reflectors on both sides make sense on panniers. Otherwise the bag tends to cover what already reflects on the bike.
Seven bags sorted by use
| Model | Type, volume, load | Mounting | Water protection according to manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ortlieb Back-Roller (Classic) | Pair of rear panniers, 2 × 20 L, 9 kg per bag, 1,900 g | Quick-Lock 2.1, tube up to 16 mm | IP64 (closure rolled 3–4×) | Commuters, touring bikes |
| Vaude Aqua Back | Pair of rear panniers, 48 L, 25 kg combined, 1,940 g | QMR 2.0, 8–16 mm, lockable | welded, no IP rating | Touring bikes, heavy shopping |
| Vaude Aqua Commute Single | Single bag, 24 L, 13 kg, laptop compartment up to 13.3 inches | QMR 2.0, 8–16 mm, lockable | welded seams, no IP rating | Commuters with a small laptop |
| Basil Miles MIK | Double pannier, 34 L, 10 kg total, 5 kg per side | MIK adapter plate 2.0 | waterproof, no IP rating | Shopping on a MIK bike |
| Vaude Aqua Box | Handlebar bag, 6 L, 7 kg, 680 g | Klickfix plate mounted, adapter sold separately | welded seams, no IP rating | Valuables, food, camera |
| Topeak BackLoader X 10 L | Saddle bag, 10 L, 5 kg, 575 g | Seatpost and seat stays | Inner bag with 10,000 mm water column | Bikepacking without a rack |
| Ortlieb Frame-Pack | Frame bag, 4 or 6 L, 3 kg | Velcro straps, top tube 30–70 mm | IP67 with zipper closed | Bikepacking, heavy small items |
The commuter: every day, in any weather
Twelve kilometers to the office, in November in steady rain too. The bag has to go on and come off in seconds. And stay dry inside.
Ortlieb Back-Roller (Classic)
Ortlieb now simply lists the pair as the Back-Roller; in stores, it is usually still called the Classic. According to the data sheet, each bag holds 20 liters, the pair weighs 1,900 g, and the hooks close automatically when you hang the bag on. For a laptop, Ortlieb offers a separate Commuter-Insert with a padded compartment (35 × 22/30 × 3 cm), which is not waterproof itself but does not need to be inside the bag.
Vaude Aqua Commute Single
If you do not want to buy an insert separately, go for the office bag with fixed interior organization. Vaude builds in a padded laptop compartment but only specifies it for devices up to 13.3 inches. 15 inches will not fit. The bag holds 24 liters, carries up to 13 kg and can be secured to the QMR hook with a lock; the lock is not included.
If the computer often has to come along on the train anyway, a backpack is more convenient. Our guide to laptop backpacks (in German) sorts out the models.
The shopper: lots of volume, little fiddling
Basil Miles MIK
This double pannier lies across the rack and hangs down on the left and right. With the preinstalled MIK plate, it clicks onto matching racks in one motion. Basil specifies 34 liters, a roll-top closure and reflectors. Watch the load, though: no more than 10 kg in total, 5 kg per side. A six-pack of water on one side is already too much. So it is not suited to the weekly shop with drinks, but it is fine for bread, fruit and drugstore items.
Vaude Aqua Back
If you carry heavier loads, go for the pair with more reserve. Vaude specifies 48 liters and 25 kg for both bags, welded seams and a roll-top closure. The bags are made in Germany and can be locked directly on the QMR hook. The rack still sets the limit.
The bikepacker: light, narrow, no rack
On a gravel bike without eyelets, the rack is out. The luggage moves to the frame, saddle and handlebar, and each bag carries only a few kilos.
Topeak BackLoader X 10 L
This saddle bag consists of a semi-rigid holder and a removable inner bag, which Topeak rates at a 10,000 mm water column. A valve pushes the air out as you pack. Maximum 5 kg. So measure before ordering. What matters is the clearance at the rear triangle: Topeak gives minimum dimensions of more than 23 cm and more than 13 cm. On small frames or full-suspension bikes, it quickly gets tight.
Ortlieb Frame-Pack
In the frame triangle, the weight sits low and centered, which is why tools, food or tent poles belong here. Ortlieb specifies IP67, meaning protection during temporary submersion, provided the zipper is fully closed. More than 3 kg is not intended. According to the data sheet, the Velcro straps fit top tubes from 30 to 70 mm.
A top tube bag is an affordable addition for small items. ROCKBROS offers one with 1.5 liters; the retailer describes it as waterproof and lists phones under 6.5 inches. No IP rating is given there. We have no independent testing, including on water resistance, so the specifications remain purely retailer information. For rides in the rain with valuables, we would not rely on it alone.
The touring cyclist: weeks on the road, everything on board
On long tours, you usually end up with two rear panniers, a handlebar bag and sometimes a pair on the lowrider. The bike’s handling changes noticeably, as Ortlieb itself points out. So heavy items go low and toward the front, not on top.
Vaude Aqua Box
This handlebar bag keeps within reach whatever does not belong in the panniers: wallet, phone, camera. Vaude specifies 6 liters, 680 g and up to 7 kg, and the seams are high-frequency welded. Vaude does not give an IP rating. The bag plate for Klickfix is already mounted; you buy the handlebar adapter to match your handlebar, for standard handlebars or for e-bikes. There is no built-in map pocket, but one can be attached to the lid. Before buying, it is worth checking whether the display and light on the handlebar still leave room.
For the large bags at the rear, the Back-Roller remains the obvious choice, and the Vaude Aqua Back offers more volume and load per side. Which bike goes with it is covered in our guide to trekking bikes.
How we would decide
- Commuting and everyday use on a standard rack: Ortlieb Back-Roller, with a Commuter-Insert for the laptop if needed.
- Small notebook, everything in one bag: Vaude Aqua Commute Single.
- Shopping by bike with a MIK rack: Basil Miles MIK, but only up to 5 kg per side.
- Heavy loads or long trips: Vaude Aqua Back or Back-Roller, plus the Vaude Aqua Box on the handlebar.
- Bikepacking without a rack: Topeak BackLoader X plus Ortlieb Frame-Pack.
One more thing about theft. Bags on a parked bike are easy prey, and hook systems come off with one pull. The lockable versions of QMR and Snapit help a little; only a good lock secures the frame, though, as described in our bike lock guide.
Frequently asked questions
What should you look for when buying a bike bag?
The rack first. It states the permitted load, which must not be exceeded, even if the bag could take more. Then the mounting: hook systems such as Ortlieb Quick-Lock or Vaude QMR 2.0 fit almost any standard rack, while platform systems such as MIK, Snapit or Klickfix need a matching rack.
Does a bike bag fit every rack?
Hook systems grip around the rack tube. For Quick-Lock 2.1, Ortlieb specifies tubes up to 16 mm, with inserts for thinner tubes; for thicker tubes on some e-bikes, 18 and 20 mm hooks are available as accessories. Vaude specifies 8 to 16 mm for QMR 2.0. With Snapit, according to Racktime, the lock versions of the different generations are not compatible with each other.
Which bike bag is suitable for a laptop?
The Vaude Aqua Commute Single has a padded laptop compartment, but only for devices up to 13.3 inches; 15 inches will not fit. With the Ortlieb Back-Roller, a separate Commuter-Insert with a padded compartment makes room for the computer. If the laptop often has to come along on the train, a backpack is more convenient.
How much can you put in a shopping bag on a bike?
As much as the bag and rack allow. The Basil Miles MIK holds 34 liters but carries no more than 10 kg in total and 5 kg per side; a six-pack of water on one side is already too much. For heavy shopping, Vaude specifies 25 kg for both bags of the Aqua Back, and then the rack sets the limit.
Which bags fit a gravel bike without a rack?
Then the luggage moves to the frame, saddle and handlebar. The Topeak BackLoader X 10 L attaches to the seatpost and seat stays and carries a maximum of 5 kg; measure the clearance at the rear triangle first. The Ortlieb Frame-Pack sits in the frame triangle, low and centered, for tools or food up to 3 kg.
How waterproof are bike bags?
Only the manufacturer's specification counts. Ortlieb gives IP ratings and ties them to conditions: for the Back-Roller, IP64 only with the closure rolled three to four times, and for the Frame-Pack, IP67 with the zipper closed. Vaude and Basil call their bags waterproof but give no IP rating.
Sources
- Ortlieb: Back-Roller data sheet
- Ortlieb: Commuter-Insert for Panniers data sheet
- Vaude: Aqua Box
- Ortlieb: Frame-Pack data sheet
- Vaude: Aqua Back
- Vaude: Aqua Commute Single
- Basil: Miles MIK double pannier
- Topeak: BackLoader X
- Racktime: FAQ on racks and Snapit
- ROCKBROS: retailer information on the top tube bag
Where to buy
- Ortlieb Back-Roller (Classic)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Vaude Aqua Back (Paar)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Vaude Aqua Commute SingleCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Basil Miles MIK DoppeltascheCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Vaude Aqua Box LenkertascheCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Topeak BackLoader X 10 LCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Ortlieb Frame-PackCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- ROCKBROS wasserdicht Oberrohrtasche 1,5L für Handys unter 6,5 ZollView at ROCKBROSAvailable in Germany: ROCKBROS
