Black Friday Woche läuft bis 30.11.: our pick in each buying guide
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,746 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Buying blush and bronzer: powder or cream, the right undertone, which brush. Six products from NARS, Catrice and Charlotte Tilbury put in context.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026

Editorial selection based on research, not tested by us. Reasons and limitations are in the text.

Contents12 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

Powder or cream? That question has more influence on the result than the brand. As a basic kit, we recommend a powder blush with a refill pan, such as the Powder Blush from NARS, and a matte bronzer that leans neutral rather than orange. If you want to spend little, Catrice offers the same basic types for a fraction of the price, with a somewhat smaller choice of shades.

Highlighter comes last. It is the product that most quickly becomes too much.

Powder, cream or liquid: what suits your skin

Powder sits on the surface and takes away some shine. On combination skin that gets shiny on the forehead and nose by midday, that is an advantage. On dry cheeks, however, powder can look powdery, especially over a foundation that has already been mattified. Cream and liquid formulas tend to melt into the skin and look fresher, but slip more easily when there is a lot of oil underneath. As a rule of thumb: cream on cream, powder on powder. If you wear a liquid foundation and set it with powder, apply your blush afterward as a powder, not a cream. Which base suits your skin is covered in our foundation guide.

Bronzer, by the way, is not a self-tanner. It only colors as long as it sits on the skin and comes off again when you remove your makeup. If you want a tan that lasts for days, you will find the differences in our self-tanner guide (in German).

Which shade? The undertone decides

With bronzer, the mistake often lies in the undertone: the shade is too warm and tips into orange. NARS gives a useful direction for its Laguna range: for fair complexions, choose a bronzer with a neutral or warm undertone, and for deeper skin one with a red or neutral undertone, so that you get depth instead of a gray veil. For contouring, the manufacturer recommends a shade one to two levels darker than your own skin. No more than that.

Blush is more forgiving. In NARS’s shade guide, coral shades such as Obsession (matte papaya coral) and Orgasm X (deep coral with gold shimmer) appear equally for fair, medium and deep skin. So with coral or peach, the risk is small. Strong berries, fuchsia or red are more a matter of taste. Don’t test blush on the back of your hand, but on your cheek. And in daylight.

Six products for cheeks and complexion compared

ModelForm and finishContent and shadesBest forOffer (affiliate link)
NARS Powder Blush (e.g. Orgasm)Powder, matte, satin or shimmer4.8 g, over 20 shades, some available as refill pansEveryday blush, all skin types with a powder routine
Catrice AirBlush GlowPowder, natural with shimmer5.5 gGetting started with powder blush, little moneyAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
NARS Laguna Bronzing PowderPowder, natural finish, talc-free11 g, nine shades from 00 to 08Bronzer and contour, precise shade choiceAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Catrice Melted Sun Cream BronzerCream, matte, buildable9 g, two shadesDry skin, quick application with the fingersAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Beauty Light Wandliquid, pearlescent glow12 ml, NuderosaBlush and highlighter in oneAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Catrice More Than Glow Highlighterpressed powder, metallic shimmer5.9 g, four shadesStrong glow for the eveningAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Want a second opinion before buying?Ask via WhatsApp

NARS Powder Blush

NARS has reformulated its powder blush and claims up to 16 hours of wear, based on a study with 35 women. The range extends from matte shades such as Orgasm Edge (matte peachy pink) to Orgasm, a peachy pink with golden shimmer. Talc is not on the ingredient list, and according to the manufacturer the formula is vegan. Refill pans are available for several shades, which saves packaging on the second purchase. Our favorite among the blushes here, because the range of shades is large enough to really find your own.

Catrice AirBlush Glow

A light powder blush with subtle shimmer, according to Catrice free of fragrance and microplastic particles. Here, talc is listed first among the ingredients. Since the list is sorted by quantity, it is the main component. If you want to avoid it, go for NARS. Otherwise, it is a sensible way to try out a new color before spending more.

NARS Laguna Bronzing Powder

Nine talc-free shades, each labeled with its undertone: Laguna 00 is very light and neutral, Laguna 07 deep with a red undertone. This labeling is the real reason to choose this bronzer, because it makes picking a shade predictable. According to the manufacturer, transparent microspheres visually smooth the skin’s texture. NARS recommends sweeping what is left on the brush over the neck and décolleté so that no edge remains at the jaw.

Catrice Melted Sun Cream Bronzer

A cream bronzer in a metal tin that dries down to a matte finish. It only comes in two shades, Beach Babe and Pretty Tanned. That is too few for very fair or very deep skin. Catrice recommends applying it with a bronzer brush or your fingers to the bridge of the nose and the cheekbones. On dry skin, cream is the more pleasant option, and based on the manufacturers‘ recommended retail prices, the tin costs about a tenth of the Laguna powder.

Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Beauty Light Wand

Half blush, half highlighter. The water-based liquid formula in Nuderosa comes in a tube with a cushion applicator. You place one or two dots on the apple of the cheek and blend. The manufacturer describes the finish as a pearlescent glow. On large pores and oily skin, we consider this the wrong effect, because shine emphasizes texture. On dry, rather matte skin, on the other hand, a shimmer like this looks lively. The manufacturer advises screwing the applicator closed tightly after use.

Catrice More Than Glow Highlighter

Pressed powder with an intense, metallic shimmer in four shades, including a cool platinum (Ultimate Platinum Glaze) and a gold (Beyond Golden Glow). This is not a product for low-key office days. Catrice recommends a fluffy brush and only the highest points: cheekbones, bridge of the nose, brow bone. A touch is enough.

Which brush for what?

Powder blush needs a loose, round brush. NARS points out a detail worth remembering: most of the color ends up where the brush first touches the skin. So start where you want the color to be most intense, usually on the apple of the cheek, and sweep outward toward the temple. For bronzer, use a larger brush than for blush, otherwise you get patches instead of warmth. Creams work with your fingers or a dense synthetic brush. Which shapes exist and how to clean them is covered in our makeup brush guide.

A word on shelf life. The Verbraucherzentrale, Germany’s consumer advice center, explains the open-jar symbol: the number next to it, such as 12 M, indicates how many months the product lasts after opening. Write the date of first opening on the packaging. In case of redness or a rash, keep the product and have a doctor clarify what caused it.

How we would decide

  • Buying only one product: a powder blush in peach or coral, such as NARS Powder Blush in Orgasm Edge (matte) or Orgasm (with shimmer).
  • First trying out whether blush suits you at all: Catrice AirBlush Glow.
  • Bronzer for fair to deep skin with a deliberate choice of undertone: NARS Laguna, for contouring one to two levels darker than your skin.
  • Dry skin, little time in the morning: Catrice Melted Sun applied with the fingers, provided one of the two shades suits you.
  • A fresh glow on matte skin without a second product: the Pillow Talk Beauty Light Wand.
  • Oily skin and large pores: skip the highlighter or use only a touch on the brow bone.

Frequently asked questions

Powder or cream: which blush suits which skin?

Powder sits on the surface and takes away shine, which is an advantage on combination skin. On dry cheeks, it can look powdery. Creams tend to melt into the skin but slip more easily on oily skin. As a rule of thumb: cream on cream, powder on powder.

Which bronzer shade suits fair skin?

For fair complexions, NARS recommends a bronzer with a neutral or warm undertone, and for deeper skin one with a red or neutral undertone, so that you get depth instead of a gray veil. For contouring, the manufacturer recommends a shade one to two levels darker than your own skin.

Which blush color is easy to wear?

Coral and peach. In NARS's shade guide, coral shades such as Obsession and Orgasm X appear equally for fair, medium and deep skin. Strong berries, fuchsia or red are more a matter of taste. Test on the cheek in daylight, not on the back of your hand.

What is the difference between bronzer and self-tanner?

Bronzer only colors as long as it sits on the skin and comes off again when you remove your makeup. A self-tanner, on the other hand, gives you a tan that lasts for days. When applying bronzer, use a larger brush than for blush, otherwise you get patches instead of warmth.

How do you apply powder blush correctly?

With a loose, round brush. According to NARS, most of the color ends up where the brush first touches the skin. So start where you want the color to be most intense, usually on the apple of the cheek, and sweep outward toward the temple. Creams work with your fingers or a dense synthetic brush.

How long does blush last after opening?

The open-jar symbol tells you: according to the Verbraucherzentrale, Germany's consumer advice center, the number next to it, such as 12 M, indicates how many months the product lasts after opening. Write the date of first opening on the packaging. In case of redness or a rash, keep the product and have it checked by a doctor.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Still undecided?

Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.

Share this guide