Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Ten pieces in the starter set, three of them actually in use. That is how many a well-intentioned purchase ends when it comes to baking bread. For a good crust, what matters most is a heavy, tightly closing cast iron pot. If you only want to spend money once, get a round cocotte of around 24 centimeters that can go into the oven at up to 250 °C, and add a proofing basket and a dough scraper.
Everything else is optional. A baking steel helps with free-form loaves and pizza, and a sourdough jar makes feeding your starter easier to keep track of. Neither is necessary.
When the oven is set to maximum
Bread in a pot is usually baked at high heat, and the empty pot is often preheated along with the oven. This is exactly where the models differ. According to the manufacturers, Le Creuset and Staub specify 260 °C for their cast iron pots. At Le Creuset, this explicitly applies to the lid knob as well; at Staub, according to the manufacturer, the brass knob withstands 250 °C. For the Combekk pot, the Amazon listing states 240 °C. Many recipes work with that, but not all of them. If the recipe says „oven at maximum,“ you should know this number.
It is best to check the heat limit of the knob separately, because not every manufacturer states it. Large side handles are safer to grip with thick oven mitts than narrow tabs. Round pots of around 24 centimeters are the usual size for a round loaf; elongated loaves need an oval pot.
And then there is the weight. Four to five kilograms is normal, hot and empty. If lifting is difficult for you, choose a shallower model. Enamel is easier to care for on the inside. Raw, seasoned cast iron, on the other hand, is robust but needs to be washed by hand and oiled.
While the dough rests: the proofing basket
Rattan or wood pulp, that is the choice here. Rattan leaves the familiar ridged pattern on the bread. According to a guide from the German food magazine Lecker, wood pulp insulates somewhat better and produces a smooth surface. Neither material tolerates dishwater. Tap it out, let it dry, brush it out: it needs no more care than that, and it cannot take any more either.
Seven helpers with documented key data
| Model | Key data according to the manufacturer | Oven and care | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Staub La Cocotte round 24 cm | Enameled cast iron, 3.7 l, 4.7 kg, matte black enamel inside | Pot up to 260 °C, brass knob up to 250 °C, dishwasher-safe | If you want one pot for bread and braised dishes |
| Le Creuset bread oven 24 cm | Enameled cast iron, 1.6 l, flat base of 19.6 cm, large handles | up to 260 °C, knob up to 260 °C | If you bake round loaves regularly |
| Combekk Dutch Oven 24 cm | Recycled cast iron, 5 l, enameled, around 4.75 kg | up to 240 °C (retailer information) | If you want to spend less |
| Lodge Combo Cooker LCC3 | Pre-seasoned cast iron, around 3 l, 26 cm, lid doubles as a skillet | oven-safe, hand wash only | If you like raw cast iron |
| Birkmann proofing basket, round (Laib & Seele) | Rattan, handmade, without adhesives or dyes, up to 2 kg of dough | not for the oven, do not wash | Getting started with free-form loaves |
| Koch baking steel 40 x 30 cm | Steel plate, 6 mm thick | preheat for a long time, rack must bear the weight | If you also bake pizza and flatbreads |
| Kilner Sourdough Starter Set | 2 jars of 350 ml each, measuring lid, silicone spatula, marker bands | dishwasher-safe | If you make your own sourdough starter |
Staub La Cocotte round 24 cm
Not a specialty device, and that is exactly what speaks for it. According to Zwilling, Staub’s parent company, the pot is oven-safe up to 260 °C and the brass knob on the lid up to 250 °C, and it is suitable for all types of stovetop, including induction. At 3.7 liters, there is enough room for the loaf to rise. During the week, it braises your goulash. Our guide to roasters and cocottes describes in more detail how to choose pots like this.
Le Creuset bread oven 24 cm
Essentially, an upside-down pot. The dough sits on a flat base, and the tall dome goes over it. That makes it easier to get the loaf in and out again without your hand coming near hot walls. Le Creuset specifies 260 °C for pot and knob, as well as large handles for oven mitts. There are two drawbacks, however: at 1.6 liters, it is hardly suitable for stews, and it belongs in the top price range. For elongated loaves, there is an oval version measuring 29 centimeters.
Combekk Dutch Oven 24 cm
According to the Dutch company itself, its pots are cast from 100 percent recycled cast iron, and the coating is said to be free of PFAS. At five liters, the pot is roomier than the Staub cocotte. On Amazon, it is noticeably cheaper than Staub and Le Creuset. The trade-off is the lower oven limit of 240 °C, according to retailer information.
Lodge Combo Cooker LCC3
Two parts, both made of pre-seasoned cast iron: a deep pot and a lid that, turned upside down, serves as a shallow skillet. The dough goes onto the shallow half, and the deep part goes over it as a dome. The dishwasher is off-limits. One buyer notes that the pot gets tight for large elongated loaves, and the long handle needs space in the oven.
Birkmann Laib & Seele proofing basket, round
According to Birkmann, the round rattan basket holds dough for loaves of up to two kilograms. Before using it for the first time, the manufacturer recommends wiping it with lukewarm water and a little vinegar, drying it thoroughly and dusting it generously with flour. After that, clean it only when dry. For smaller loaves, Birkmann has a 20-centimeter version, which according to the listing holds a maximum of one kilogram of dough. Smooth loaves turn out better with wood pulp.
Koch baking steel 40 x 30 cm
A baking steel does not replace the pot. It helps if you want to bake baguettes, flatbreads or pizza directly on a hot surface. Another supplier states around six kilograms for a 38 by 33 centimeter plate at six millimeters thick, and around eight at eight millimeters. Can your oven rack bear that? Check beforehand. Gourmetrics, another maker of baking steels, advises preheating the steel at the bottom of the oven at full heat for at least 20 minutes. This overview does not include a classic baking stone, because reliable manufacturer data for one was lacking.
Kilner Sourdough Starter Set
Two wide-mouth jars of 350 milliliters each, a stainless steel measuring lid, a silicone spatula and rubber bands for marking how high the starter has risen. A simple screw-top jar can do the same. The set just makes it tidier. Kilner advises against pouring boiling water directly into the jars.
And the dough scraper?
Everyone needs one, and it costs little. A rigid stainless steel bench scraper, such as the Birkmann scraper measuring 14.8 by 12 centimeters, divides dough and pushes it across the work surface. A flexible silicone scraper gets the remnants out of the bowl. With both together, no third tool is needed. For exact amounts of flour and water, a digital kitchen scale with gram display (in German) helps.
What belongs in your kitchen
- One pot for everything: Staub La Cocotte round 24 cm, because it covers both bread and everyday cooking and, according to the manufacturer, withstands 260 °C, or 250 °C with the lid.
- Smaller budget: Combekk Dutch Oven 24 cm, as long as your recipes work at 240 °C.
- Only bread, and often: Le Creuset bread oven. If you rarely bake, you pay a lot here for a single purpose.
- Raw cast iron: Lodge Combo Cooker, if hand washing and oiling do not bother you.
- Basic equipment to go with it: a rattan proofing basket and a bench scraper. Baking steel and sourdough jar only once you know you will stick with it.
Prefer it at the push of a button? Our bread maker guide (in German) describes the alternative.
How much flour a machine can really knead is calculated in the guide to stand mixers for dough.
Frequently asked questions
What temperature does a bread pot need to withstand?
Bread in a pot is usually baked at high heat, and the empty pot is often preheated along with the oven. Le Creuset and Staub specify 260 °C, and Staub's brass knob withstands 250 °C. For the Combekk pot, the listing states 240 °C. If the recipe says "oven at maximum," you should know this number.
What size should a pot for baking bread be?
Round pots of around 24 centimeters are the usual size for a round loaf; elongated loaves need an oval pot. For elongated loaves, Le Creuset offers an oval version measuring 29 centimeters. Expect some weight: four to five kilograms is normal.
Proofing basket made of rattan or wood pulp?
Rattan leaves the familiar ridged pattern on the bread. According to a guide from the German food magazine Lecker, wood pulp insulates somewhat better and produces a smooth surface. Neither tolerates dishwater: tapping it out, letting it dry and brushing it out is all the care it needs.
What is the advantage of the Le Creuset bread oven?
The dough sits on a flat base, and the tall dome goes over it. That makes it easier to get the loaf in and out without your hand coming near hot walls. At 1.6 liters, however, it is hardly suitable for stews, and it belongs in the top price range.
Do you need a baking steel for baking bread?
It is not necessary, and it does not replace the pot. A baking steel helps with baguettes, flatbreads or pizza baked directly on a hot surface. Check beforehand whether your oven rack can bear the weight. Gourmetrics advises preheating the steel at full heat for at least 20 minutes.
Which dough scraper belongs in the basic equipment?
A rigid stainless steel bench scraper divides dough and pushes it across the work surface, for example the Birkmann scraper measuring 14.8 by 12 centimeters. A flexible silicone scraper gets the remnants out of the bowl. With both together, no third tool is needed.
Sources
- Le Creuset: Cast iron bread oven 24 cm
- Le Creuset: Oval cast iron bread oven
- Zwilling: Staub La Cocotte 24 cm, round, black (40500-241-0)
- Combekk: Dutch ovens made of recycled cast iron
- Birkmann: Round proofing basket, care instructions
- Kilner: Sourdough Starter Set
- Gourmetrics: Tips on preheating a baking steel
- Lecker: Proofing baskets made of rattan and wood pulp
Where to buy
- Staub La Cocotte rund 24 cm (schwarz)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Combekk Dutch Oven 24 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Le Creuset Brot-Bräter 24 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Lodge Combo Cooker LCC3Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Birkmann Gärkörbchen rundCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Koch Backstahl 40 x 30 cmCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Kilner Sauerteig-Starter-SetCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Birkmann Teigkarte EdelstahlCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
