Black Friday week from 19.11.: our pick in each buying guide
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,744 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Buying a deodorant: deodorant or antiperspirant, aluminum according to BfR and SCCS, baking soda, fragrances and six products for normal and sensitive skin.

We tested it ourselves: fussy Deodorant Refill Cloud Nine, 40 g, mit Case

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026

Editorial selection based on research, not tested by us. Reasons and limitations are in the text.

Contents15 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

Is it odor, or is it wetness? For odor, an aluminum-free deodorant such as Dove Fresh Care+ or Weleda Citrus is enough. If you quickly get damp underarms, you need an antiperspirant, and for sensitive skin we think NIVEA Derma Control Sensitive is the sensible place to start. Many bad purchases happen because someone buys a pure deodorant to deal with wetness and is then surprised.

What is the difference between a deodorant and an antiperspirant?

Fresh sweat barely smells. The typical odor is produced by bacteria on the skin that break it down. A deodorant targets exactly that: it slows down these bacteria or masks the odor with fragrance, but lets the sweat itself flow.

An antiperspirant goes further. According to the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), its aluminum salts, usually aluminum chlorohydrate, temporarily block the sweat pores and also have an antibacterial effect. According to a review in the International Journal of Cosmetic Science (2023), the salts combine with components of sweat to form small gel plugs in the pores. Skin only stays drier where the product has been applied.

If the package says „antiperspirant“ or the ingredient list includes an aluminum salt, that is what it is. „0% aluminum salts“ means a pure deodorant with no protection against wetness.

So are aluminum salts a concern or not?

In 2014, the BfR still had concerns because the data were contradictory. In its opinion 045/2023 of October 6, 2023, the BfR concludes that, based on current knowledge, the likelihood of health impairment from the regular use of aluminum-containing antiperspirants is very low. According to the study it relied on, only around 0.002 percent of the applied amount enters the body through the skin.

On breast cancer and Alzheimer’s, the BfR writes in the same opinion that there is no reliable data supporting a causal link with aluminum. In its opinion SCCS/1613/19 of March 2020, the EU’s Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) considers aluminum compounds safe at up to 6.25 percent aluminum in roll-ons, sticks and creams and up to 10.6 percent in sprays. In the SCCS’s assessment, the epidemiological studies do not support the assumption that such cosmetics increase the risk of breast cancer.

That leaves one point. We take in aluminum mainly through food, and the BfR stresses that the total amount is what counts. If you want to reduce your intake, deodorant is the easiest place to cut back. As things stand today, that is a personal preference, not a medical necessity.

Spray, roll-on, stick or cream?

Sprays dry quickly and do not come into direct contact with the skin. Many, however, contain alcohol; in Weleda Citrus, it is first on the ingredient list. On freshly shaved skin, that can sting.

Roll-ons spread a liquid emulsion. NIVEA advises applying it after showering and letting it dry completely before getting dressed. Sticks and cream sticks need no waiting time. Deodorant creams are applied with a finger. In its deodorant cream test (June 2022), Öko-Test, a German consumer magazine, considered a pea-sized amount per underarm to be enough at most. Most of the 30 creams tested relied on baking soda, as does the small manufacturer Wolkenseifen.

My underarms burn after using deodorant. What helps?

First, change the order. Stiftung Warentest, the German consumer testing organization, recommends shaving in the evening and only applying deodorant in the morning, sparingly and on freshly washed skin. If that does not help, fragrance and alcohol are the next suspects, and the testers then recommend fragrance-free and alcohol-free products. More on gentle shaving is in our guide to women’s razors.

With baking soda deodorants, it pays to look closely. Baking soda is slightly alkaline in water. Ben & Anna offers its own Sensitive line without baking soda, and Wolkenseifen points out in its product descriptions that too much cream can irritate the skin.

Even NIVEA Derma Control Sensitive, which according to the manufacturer is meant to soothe irritated skin after shaving, carries the warning „Do not use on irritated or damaged skin.“ We would take it seriously. If redness or itching persists for days, see a dermatologist.

What do fragrances on the ingredient list reveal?

More than they used to. Until now, 26 allergenic fragrances had to be named individually, for leave-on products from 0.001 percent. With Regulation (EU) 2023/1545, the list grows to 82 substances, according to the Austrian agency AGES. Goods newly placed on the market must be labeled this way since July 31, 2026, and older stock may be sold until July 31, 2028.

For people with allergies, that means names such as limonene, linalool, citral or geraniol on the list are a warning sign, even if they come from essential oils. Weleda Citrus lists several of them. Natural fragrance is not automatically better tolerated. If you prefer to apply perfume separately anyway, you will find ideas in our perfume advisor (in German).

What does a natural cosmetics seal tell you?

A seal describes the raw materials, not the effectiveness. According to NATRUE, it excludes silicones, parabens, microplastics, synthetic fragrances, mineral oils and substances from genetically modified organisms, among other things. COSMOS, run by an association in Brussels co-founded by the German BDIH among others, awards the COSMOS ORGANIC and COSMOS NATURAL labels. None of these labels tells you whether a deodorant lasts until evening.

Six deodorants and antiperspirants compared

ModelType and active ingredientFormatBest forOffer (affiliate link)
NIVEA Derma Control SensitiveAntiperspirant, aluminum chlorohydrate, no ethyl alcoholRoll-on, 50 mlSweating with sensitive skinAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
NIVEA Derma Control Clinical Trockenes HautgefühlAntiperspirant, aluminum zirconium salt, no ethyl alcoholRoll-on, 50 mlHeavy sweatingAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Rexona Maximum ProtectionAntiperspirant, aluminum zirconium salt, no ethyl alcoholCream stick, 45 mlHeavy sweating, getting dressed quicklyAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Dove Fresh Care+ Fresh OriginalDeodorant without aluminum salts, zinc complex, no ethyl alcoholSpray, 150 mlEveryday odor protectionAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Weleda Citrus Fresh Deo SprayDeodorant without aluminum salts, essential oils, with alcoholSpray, 100 mlNatural cosmetics without a fragrance allergyAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Ben & Anna Sensitive Lemon & LimeDeodorant without aluminum salts, magnesium hydroxide instead of baking sodaStick in a paper tube, 40 gIf you do not tolerate baking sodaAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Want a second opinion before buying?Ask via WhatsApp

NIVEA Derma Control Sensitive

An antiperspirant with aluminum chlorohydrate, hyaluronic acid and vitamin E, with a hypoallergenic fragrance and 72-hour protection according to NIVEA. It contains no ethyl alcohol.

NIVEA Derma Control Clinical Trockenes Hautgefühl

The stronger version. NIVEA states 100-hour protection and uses an aluminum zirconium salt instead of aluminum chlorohydrate. It makes sense for anyone for whom a normal antiperspirant no longer does the job by midday; if you barely sweat, you do not need this strength.

Rexona Maximum Protection

A 45 ml cream stick with aluminum zirconium salt and no ethyl alcohol. In the product description, which the German drugstore chain Müller also reproduces, Unilever recommends two clicks per underarm before going to bed. The ingredient list includes silicones, paraffin and a good dozen declared fragrances. For sensitive underarms, we would rather start with NIVEA Sensitive.

Dove Fresh Care+ Fresh Original

Without aluminum salts and without ethyl alcohol, but with an antibacterial zinc complex. Dove states 72-hour odor protection and calls this spray its strongest protection without aluminum salts. It does not help against wet underarms.

Weleda Citrus Fresh Deo Spray

This certified natural cosmetics deodorant with the NATRUE label works with citrus and lavender oils and, according to Weleda, does not block the pores. Alcohol is first on the list. People with fragrance allergies should check the long list of declared fragrances beforehand.

Ben & Anna Sensitive Lemon & Lime

Instead of baking soda, Ben & Anna uses magnesium hydroxide in its Sensitive line, and there are no aluminum salts either. According to the manufacturer, the Lemon & Lime variety is NATRUE-certified and vegan and comes in a paper tube. Citrus oils and limonene are on the ingredient list.

Which deodorant suits whom?

  • You sweat noticeably and have sensitive skin: NIVEA Derma Control Sensitive.
  • A normal antiperspirant does not last until evening: NIVEA Derma Control Clinical or Rexona Maximum Protection.
  • Only the odor bothers you: Dove Fresh Care+ as an alcohol-free spray.
  • You want certified natural cosmetics and tolerate essential oils: Weleda Citrus.
  • Baking soda deodorants burn on your skin: Ben & Anna Sensitive Lemon & Lime.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a deodorant and an antiperspirant?

A deodorant slows down the bacteria that break down sweat and cause the odor, or masks it with fragrance, but lets the sweat flow. According to the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR), an antiperspirant temporarily blocks the sweat pores with aluminum salts. If an aluminum salt appears in the ingredient list, it is an antiperspirant; 0% aluminum salts means a pure deodorant.

Are aluminum salts in deodorant a health concern?

In its 2023 opinion, the German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) concludes that, based on current knowledge, the likelihood of health impairment from regular use is very low. It sees no reliable data supporting a causal link with breast cancer or Alzheimer's. Avoiding them remains a personal preference.

What helps if deodorant burns under the arms?

Stiftung Warentest, the German consumer testing organization, recommends shaving in the evening and only applying deodorant sparingly in the morning to freshly washed skin. If that does not help, fragrance and alcohol are the suspects, and fragrance-free and alcohol-free products are the choice. If redness or itching persists for days, see a dermatologist.

Why do some people not tolerate baking soda deodorants?

Baking soda is slightly alkaline in water, and too much cream can irritate the skin, as Wolkenseifen also writes. That is why Ben & Anna offers a Sensitive line without baking soda that uses magnesium hydroxide instead. The Lemon & Lime variety does, however, contain citrus oils and limonene.

What should people with allergies look for in deodorants?

The fragrances in the ingredient list. With Regulation (EU) 2023/1545, the list of fragrances that must be named individually grows to 82, according to the Austrian agency AGES. Names such as limonene, linalool, citral or geraniol are a warning sign, even if they come from essential oils. Natural fragrance is not automatically better tolerated.

What does a natural cosmetics seal tell you about a deodorant?

A seal describes the raw materials, not the effectiveness. According to NATRUE, it excludes silicones, parabens, microplastics and synthetic fragrances, among other things; COSMOS awards the COSMOS ORGANIC and COSMOS NATURAL labels. None of these labels tells you whether a deodorant lasts until evening.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Still undecided?

Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.

Share this guide