Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
When a window sensor disappoints, it is rarely the sensor’s fault. Usually it simply does not talk to the thermostats or the alarm hub already installed in the home. Without an existing system, the optical contact from Homematic IP is the most hassle-free choice: long battery life, heating setback and alarm from a single source. If you already run Bosch, Ring or a Matter network, you are better off staying there.
What a contact can and cannot do
Open or closed. A door and window contact reports nothing more than that; what happens next is decided by the hub, and the hub depends on the wireless standard.
Homematic IP uses the 868 MHz band, Bosch uses Zigbee, Ring relies on Z-Wave, and Eve and Aqara P2 on Thread with Matter. Each standard needs its own hub or a Thread border router. Without it, the sensor stays silent. Turning the heating off while airing out only works if the contact and the radiator thermostat are in the same system or an automation links them. For burglary alerts, you also need a siren or an alarm system, because the contact alone makes no noise.
Batteries range from coin cells to CR123A to regular AAA cells. Sounds like a minor detail. With ten windows, though, it matters whether you replace them every three or every seven years and whether you can pick up the cell at the supermarket.
The design matters too: classic contacts consist of a sensor and a magnet that have to sit close together; Ring specifies a maximum gap of 2.54 cm (1 inch) for its contact. The optical Homematic contact does without a magnet entirely, which helps on frames where there is no room for one.
What turning down the heat while airing out really achieves
Manufacturers like to talk about lower heating costs but rarely give figures. Bosch, for example, only writes that the smart home can „help“ reduce consumption. Consumer advocates are more reliable here. The German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt, UBA) advises airing out vigorously for five to ten minutes in winter with the windows wide open and turning the radiator off while doing so; according to the UBA, windows left permanently tilted open waste heating energy and promote mold around the edges. For programmable thermostats, the UBA cites savings of around 10 percent. That figure applies to the thermostats, not to the contact alone.
So why a contact at all? Many thermostats only detect an open window by the drop in temperature and then pause for a fixed time. The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) describes the problem vividly. The heating may stay off for 20 minutes even though the window is closed again after five. A separate contact, by contrast, reliably reports opening and closing. As a rule of thumb, the Verbraucherzentrale also cites around 6 percent less energy for each degree of lower room temperature.
Six contacts, six systems
| Model | Wireless and hub | Battery according to manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Homematic IP Fenster- und Türkontakt optisch plus | Homematic IP (868 MHz), Access Point or CCU3 | 2× AAA, typically about 7 years | Newcomers focused on heating |
| Bosch Smart Home Tür-/Fensterkontakt II | Zigbee 3.0, Bosch Smart Home Controller | 1× CR123A, typically up to 5 years | Bosch households |
| Bosch Smart Home Tür-/Fensterkontakt II Plus | Zigbee 3.0, Bosch Smart Home Controller | 1× CR123A, typically up to 3 years | Ground floor, patio door |
| Aqara Tür- und Fenstersensor P2 | Matter over Thread, border router required | 1× CR123A, no runtime stated | Affordable entry into Matter |
| Eve Door & Window (Matter) | Matter over Thread, border router required | 1× ½ AA (ER14250) | Apple Home users, privacy |
| Ring Alarm Tür-/Fensterkontakt (2. Gen.) | Z-Wave, Ring Alarm Base Station | 2× CR2032 | Ring Alarm owners |
No system in the home yet: Homematic IP optisch plus
The HmIP-SWDO-PL-2, sold in Germany as Fenster- und Türkontakt optisch plus (optical window and door contact plus), detects the window’s state optically rather than with a magnet. According to the manufacturer, two AAA cells last about seven years in normal use and up to 15 years on rarely opened windows. With Homematic IP thermostats, it lowers the temperature to an adjustable value while you air out the room; with a Homematic IP siren, it triggers an alarm. You need an Access Point or a CCU3. The older CCU2 is not supported.
Bosch thermostats already installed: Tür-/Fensterkontakt II
Via its „Smartes Lüften“ (smart ventilation) service, Bosch links the Tür-/Fensterkontakt II (door/window contact II) with its own thermostats and automatically turns down the heating if you want it to. In the Bosch alarm system, it reports open doors. On top of that comes a built-in button that can be freely assigned to actions. The standard version only works with the Bosch Smart Home Controller; Bosch also offers a variant with Matter support.
Bosch and a vulnerable door: Tür-/Fensterkontakt II Plus
A vibration sensor with five sensitivity levels sets the Plus version apart. It triggers when someone pries at the window before it is open. In return, battery life drops, typically to up to three years. On a bathroom window on the second floor, that is overkill; on the patio door, it can make sense.
Matter network and a tight budget: Aqara P2
The P2, listed in Germany as Tür- und Fenstersensor P2 (door and window sensor P2), communicates via Thread and speaks Matter, so it works with Apple Home, Google Home, Alexa or SmartThings, provided there is a Thread border router in the home. Aqara does not state a battery life; it says it depends on the router. Aqara has announced tamper alerts, adjustable sensitivity and the button for its own app, and that app only supports the P2 together with the Hub M3. For a simple „window open“ notification, you can do without all of that.
Apple Home and privacy: Eve Door & Window
No cloud, no registration, no subscription. That is how Eve describes its own concept. The sensor works via Thread with Matter and runs with Apple Home, Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings, Home Assistant and Homey. In the Eve app for iOS, you can see when and for how long a window was open, including monthly and yearly statistics. Turning off the heating while airing out is done here via an automation on the respective platform. In the Eve shop, the model was recently out of stock at times, but retailers continue to offer it.
Ring Alarm already installed: the Ring contact
A pure security sensor, built for the Ring alarm system. The Ring Alarm Tür-/Fensterkontakt (2. Gen.), the second-generation contact sensor, pairs via Z-Wave with the Ring Alarm Base Station and triggers an alarm when armed in „Zuhause“ (Home) or „Abwesend“ (Away) mode, according to Ring also when someone tampers with the contact. Ring makes no mention of a heating function. It is intended for indoor use only.
Useless without the base station, an inexpensive add-on with it.
The short path to a decision
If there is no system yet and heating is the main concern, take Homematic IP optisch plus; the long runtime on AAA cells saves work when you have many windows. If Bosch thermostats are already installed, the Tür-/Fensterkontakt II fits, with the Plus version for vulnerable doors. Apple Home with an emphasis on privacy leads to Eve Door & Window, a Matter network with a border router on a tight budget to the Aqara P2. If Ring Alarm is already installed, the Ring contact belongs with it. It is no use for heating.
Only mix systems if a platform such as Home Assistant brings everything together. Otherwise you end up with two apps and contacts that know nothing about each other.
How sensors, siren and hub come together to protect against burglary is explained in our guide to the home alarm system. If you are buying contacts mainly for the heating, choose the right smart radiator thermostats first. No control hub yet? Then the overview of the smart home hub will help.
If the window should not only be reported but also closed, see the guide Closing windows automatically.
Frequently asked questions
Does a window sensor work without a hub?
No. Homematic IP uses the 868 MHz band, Bosch uses Zigbee, Ring uses Z-Wave, and Eve and Aqara P2 use Thread with Matter. Each standard needs its own hub or a Thread border router; without it, the sensor stays silent. For burglary alerts, you also need a siren or an alarm system.
Does a window sensor save heating costs when airing out?
It helps make sure the heating is really off while you air out the room. Many thermostats only detect an open window by the drop in temperature and then pause for a fixed time, according to the German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) possibly 20 minutes, even though the window is closed again after five. The 10 percent cited by the German Environment Agency (UBA) applies to thermostats, not to the contact alone.
Which window sensor lasts longest on one battery?
The optical Homematic IP contact with two AAA cells: typically about seven years according to the manufacturer, up to 15 years on rarely opened windows. For the Bosch Tür-/Fensterkontakt II, Bosch states up to 5 years on a CR123A, and up to 3 years for the Plus version. With ten windows, that makes a difference.
Is a window sensor with a vibration sensor worth it?
On a vulnerable door, it can make sense. The Bosch Tür-/Fensterkontakt II Plus, with five sensitivity levels, triggers when someone pries at the window before it is open. In return, battery life drops to typically up to three years. On a bathroom window on the second floor, that is overkill.
Which window sensor works with Apple Home?
Eve Door & Window works via Thread with Matter and runs with Apple Home, without cloud, registration or subscription. In the Eve app, you can see when and for how long a window was open. The Aqara P2 is less expensive; both need a Thread border router in the home.
Sources
- Homematic IP: Fenster- und Türkontakt optisch plus
- Bosch Smart Home: Tür-/Fensterkontakt II and II Plus
- Aqara: Tür- und Fenstersensor P2
- Eve: Door & Window
- Ring: Alarm Tür-/Fensterkontakt (2. Gen.)
- German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt): Heating correctly
- Verbraucherzentrale: Setting and replacing thermostats correctly
Where to buy
- Homematic IP Fenster- und Türkontakt optisch plusView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELVCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bosch Smart Home Tür-/Fensterkontakt IICheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Bosch Smart Home Tür-/Fensterkontakt II PlusCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Aqara Tür- und Fenstersensor P2Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Eve Door & Window (Matter)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Ring Alarm Tür-/Fensterkontakt (2. Gen.)Check price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
