Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Deutsch

Smart Radiator Thermostats: tado, Eve, FRITZ!, Homematic

Buying smart radiator thermostats: wireless standard, hub, adapters, batteries and subscriptions. Six models from Homematic IP to Eve and Matter at a glance.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Homematic IP flex HmIP-eTRV-F radiator thermostatImage: ELV (Pressebild)
Contents12 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

Before you compare thermostats, go out into the hallway and look at your router. If there is a FRITZ!Box with DECT, the router from AVM that is common in Germany, the FRITZ!Smart Thermo 302 is the shortest route. If you are planning an open Matter home with Apple Home, Google Home or Alexa, the Thread devices from Eve, tado X and Bosch are the candidates. Homematic IP offers seven models and lists no subscription. And with tado, a look at the ongoing costs for add-on features belongs before the purchase.

First the wireless standard, then the device

This is where the systems differ most. AVM communicates via DECT ULE, Homematic IP via its own protocol, Bosch via a Zigbee variant. Eve, tado X and Bosch [+M] use Thread and speak Matter. If you want to mix devices from different brands, Matter gives you the most freedom later on.

It almost never works without a base. That can be the FRITZ!Box, an access point, a controller, a relay or a Thread border router, which is often already built into a HomePod mini or Echo. Which hub suits which household is explained in the article on hubs for the connected home.

That leaves the subscription. Find out in advance which features cost extra. With tado, these include automatic shutoff when a window is open and presence detection.

The valve trips up more people than you would think

Many valves have an M30 x 1.5 thread. Adapters for Danfoss valves are usually included; for other makes, you have to buy one separately. So before ordering, crouch down briefly and read the name on the valve base. It only takes a moment and saves you a return.

Many thermostats notice open windows from the rapid drop in temperature and then throttle the valve. According to the manufacturers, a window contact works more precisely and faster. Power usually comes from AA batteries, for which the manufacturers state a running time of about two to three years. One exception is tado X, with a rechargeable battery that you charge via USB-C.

Controls on the device itself are underestimated. Not everyone in the household wants to open an app for two degrees more. A clearly legible display and buttons on the thermostat then matter more than any automation.

How much do you really save on heating costs?

Less than some advertising suggests. For programmable thermostats that replace old mechanical ones, the German advisory organization co2online cites an average of about ten percent lower heating costs. Its overview also lists 9 to 14 percent according to the Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center) and 10 percent according to Stiftung Warentest, Germany’s leading consumer testing organization. These are sample calculations and not a guarantee, as co2online itself notes. How much you end up saving depends on the building, the heating system and your heating habits.

You rent? According to co2online, you may replace the thermostats at your own expense. The old heads belong to the landlord, though. So keep them. When you move out, they go back on the radiator.

Six systems side by side

ModelWireless standard and hub according to the manufacturerPowerSubscriptionBest for
Homematic IP Heizkörperthermostat flexHomematic IP; usable on its own, app with Access Point or Home Control Unit2 x AA, typically 3 yearsno subscription listedlarge system, many rooms
tado Smartes Heizkörperthermostat XThread, Matter; Bridge X or another Thread border routerrechargeable battery, USB-Cadd-on features by subscriptionapp convenience, Matter
FRITZ!Smart Thermo 302DECT ULE; FRITZ!Box with DECT3 x AAnoFRITZ!Box households
Bosch Heizkörper-Thermostat II [+M]Thread, Matter; or Bosch Controller II2 x AA, up to 2 yearsHome+ optionalBosch system or Matter
Eve Thermo (5th generation)Thread, Matter; Matter controller with Thread border router2 x AAnoApple Home and Matter
Netatmo Smarte Heizkörperthermostaterelay in the starter pack, Wi-Fi to the router2 x AAno subscription listedapartment with central heating

Many rooms, no subscription: Homematic IP flex

According to the manufacturer, the flex also regulates without any hub at all. The app and advanced features only come with an Access Point or Home Control Unit. A rotatable e-paper display is built in, and adapters for Danfoss RA, RAV and RAVL are in the box. It detects open windows from the temperature drop or via a window contact. If you are equipping a whole house and do not need every convenience in every room, you can switch to Homematic IP’s cheaper basic and kompakt models.

Automation via app: tado X, but with ongoing costs

The X series communicates via Thread and supports Matter. It needs the tado Bridge X or another suitable Thread border router. The old Internet Bridge of the V3+ series does not work. So anyone switching from an older tado system is buying new hardware. Instead of batteries, the device has a removable rechargeable battery.

According to tado, automatic open-window shutoff and presence detection are part of the paid subscription; without a subscription, the app only reports an open window. That is a basic function you would normally expect from a thermostat at no extra charge. We take a critical view of this.

Already have a FRITZ!Box: FRITZ!Smart Thermo 302

The FRITZ!DECT 302 has become the FRITZ!Smart Thermo 302. It registers with the FRITZ!Box via DECT, from FRITZ!OS 6.83 onward. There is no need for a separate hub. According to the instructions, it detects open windows from the sudden temperature drop, and with an external window sensor this works more precisely. An adapter for Danfoss RA is included; for other valves, AVM recommends brass adapters.

Still undecided: Bosch Heizkörper-Thermostat II [+M]

According to Bosch, the [+M] variant goes directly into a Matter system or runs via the Smart Home Controller II. So you do not have to commit when you buy. The display is backlit and rotatable, and an LED ring shows whether it is currently heating. Adapters for Danfoss RA and RAVL are included. For „Smartes Lüften“ (smart ventilation), Bosch requires a door/window contact; without one, the thermostat reacts more slowly to the temperature drop.

Apple Home and Matter: Eve Thermo (5th generation)

Eve introduced the fifth generation in December 2025. It communicates via Thread, speaks Matter and requires a Matter controller with a Thread border router. Eve advertises operation without a subscription, without a cloud and without registration. According to the manufacturer, the thermostat stores schedules itself. The box contains an adapter set for Danfoss RA, RAV and RAVL.

Rented apartment with central heating: Netatmo

As a base, Netatmo sells a starter pack of two thermostats and a relay; additional thermostats are available individually. According to the manufacturer, they shut off the radiator as soon as a window opens and fit 90 percent of hot-water radiators. Be careful with existing devices. They are not compatible with the Thermostat ORIGINAL series.

The decision in one sentence per household

  • With a FRITZ!Box in the house, take the FRITZ!Smart Thermo 302 and save yourself any additional hub.
  • For the whole house with long battery life and no subscription, Homematic IP flex with an Access Point or Home Control Unit makes the case.
  • In Apple Home or an open Matter home, the fifth-generation Eve Thermo is the obvious choice.
  • If you are staying with Bosch Smart Home or want to switch to Matter later, go for the Bosch Heizkörper-Thermostat II [+M].
  • tado X offers plenty of automation via the app, provided you budget for the subscription for the convenience features.
  • In a rented apartment with central heating, the Netatmo starter pack fits. Keep the old heads in a safe place.

Besides consumption, your tariff determines your heating costs. What matters with price guarantees, bonuses and cancellation on the German market is explained in our guide switching gas suppliers.

If the thermostat does not fit the valve, an adapter usually helps. How to identify Danfoss, Vaillant, Herz or Oventrop is explained in the guide to valve adapters for radiator thermostats.

If you want neither an app nor a hub, you will find models in the guide to the programmable radiator thermostat; what fans on the radiator achieve is in the guide to the radiator fan.

If you are leaning toward Homematic IP, the guide to Homematic IP heating sets shows which set suits which apartment.

Frequently asked questions

Do smart radiator thermostats need a hub?

Almost always. That can be the FRITZ!Box, an access point, a controller, a relay or a Thread border router, which is often already built into a HomePod mini or Echo. One exception is the Homematic IP flex, which according to the manufacturer also regulates without any hub at all; the app and advanced features only come with an access point.

Does a smart thermostat fit every radiator valve?

Many valves have an M30 x 1.5 thread. Adapters for Danfoss valves are usually included; for other makes, you have to buy one separately. Read the name on the valve base before ordering; that saves you a return.

How much on heating costs does a smart thermostat save?

For programmable thermostats that replace old mechanical ones, co2online (a German nonprofit energy advisory organization) cites an average of about ten percent lower heating costs; its overview also lists 9 to 14 percent according to the Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center). These are sample calculations. How much you actually save depends on the building, the heating system and your heating habits.

Can renters install smart thermostats?

According to co2online, renters in Germany may replace the thermostats at their own expense. The old heads belong to the landlord, though, so keep them and put them back when you move out. For a rented apartment with central heating, the guide names the Netatmo starter pack of two thermostats and a relay.

Which features cost extra with tado X?

According to tado, automatic shutoff when a window is open and presence detection are part of the paid subscription; without a subscription, the app only reports an open window. tado X also needs the Bridge X or another Thread border router; the old Internet Bridge of the V3+ series does not work.

Do smart thermostats detect open windows?

Many notice open windows from the rapid drop in temperature and then throttle the valve. According to the manufacturers, a window contact works more precisely and faster. Bosch requires a door/window contact for its Smartes Lüften (smart ventilation) function; without one, the thermostat reacts more slowly.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.