Contents16 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Count your radiators first, then look at the sets. For a rented apartment with four radiators, we consider the set with Access Point 2 and four pure thermostats the most sensible purchase. The pricier Heating Easy and Heating Professional sets sound like better heating, but they do not control any room more precisely. Their extra cost goes almost entirely into the hub.
What really sets the sets apart
In the online shop, the Homematic sets look like a ladder of tiers. Take the contents lists apart and two questions remain: which hub does the controlling, and which thermostat sits on the valve?
The Set Heizen Easy contains four HmIP-eTRV-3 thermostats. That is exactly the pure model that also comes in the set with Access Point 2. So: the same thermostats, just with a Home Control Unit instead of an Access Point. According to the Homematic IP price list, the hub alone costs five times as much as the Access Point, which is how the Easy set ends up at almost twice the price.
It is a similar story with the Professional. ELV (German retailer) advertises it with EEBUS and energy management, but that interface belongs to the Home Control Unit and is therefore also part of the Easy set. The real difference is the flex thermostats instead of pure. The flex is operated with buttons instead of a rotary dial, its display can be rotated in four directions, and it pairs directly with the wall thermostat, window contact and other thermostats at the push of a button. Heating profiles and battery life are listed identically in both data sheets: three profiles, 13 changes per day, typically three years.
Rented apartment with four radiators
This is the typical case, and here the Access Point is enough. Installation requires no work on the heating system; when you move out, you simply unscrew everything and take it with you. According to the data sheet, a Danfoss adapter comes with the thermostat. If you have a different valve, our guide to the valve adapter will help, and ideally before you buy.
A kitchen radiator behind the curtain or a bathroom with two heating surfaces changes the math. Count valves, not rooms. Five valves mean one extra thermostat.
Room Climate set: when a wall thermostat and contacts pay off
In addition to the Access Point, the Starter Set Raumklima contains four basic thermostats, a wall thermostat with a humidity sensor and two window contacts. We already recommended it in our Homematic IP overview, and for older buildings where you air out a lot, that still holds. The Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center) describes the problem: thermostats that only detect an open window from a sudden drop in temperature respond rigidly. Sometimes they pause for 20 minutes even though the window has long been closed, sometimes they kick back in too early. Separate contacts work more precisely.
The wall thermostat measures where you sit, not right next to the warm radiator. In a living room with the radiator under the windowsill, that is a gain; in a small bedroom, less so. Two contacts, however, only cover two windows. And the valves get the simpler basic models instead of pure.
Owner-occupied apartment with solar panels: do you need Easy or Professional?
Three reasons speak for the Home Control Unit. The data is stored locally, and within your home network the app even works offline. Instead of 120 devices it manages 350, although here too only 120 of them may be wireless devices. And it speaks EEBUS. For heat pumps, wall boxes or battery storage, the data sheet initially lists monitoring and measurement data; control is supposed to follow via a software update. So do not buy the hub for a promise that has not yet been delivered. What the three hubs can do in detail is shown in our comparison of the Homematic hubs (in German).
No cloud, no ifs and buts? Then Easy. We would only choose the Professional if you specifically want the button controls or direct pairing without the app.
Underfloor heating: no radiator set fits here
For underfloor and other surface heating systems, there is the set with six wall thermostats. Each one sits in a flush-mounted box, switches 230-volt actuators up to 230 watts and fits the 55 mm frames of common switch ranges. A rented apartment is rarely the right place for it, because it is connected to mains voltage. Also check whether your actuators really run on 230 volts and not 24 volts. The basics are explained in our guide controlling underfloor heating smartly.
What does it really achieve? A sample calculation
The data sheet promises up to 33 percent. That is the manufacturer’s upper limit, not a promise. The Verbraucherzentrale estimates around 6 percent energy per degree lower and also says: if you have always turned the heat down, you mainly gain comfort, and in very well insulated houses you can do without such thermostats.
Let us assume the temperature is lowered by 2 degrees for eight out of 24 hours. Averaged over the day, that is around 0.7 degrees, or about 4 percent of heating costs. If a set costs a quarter of your annual heating bill, it pays for itself after a little over six years. If it costs half, it takes more than twelve. And the Easy set comes in at almost twice the price of the set with Access Point. The figure varies greatly with your habits. But it shows why the hub is rarely a money-saving decision.
Sets and alternatives at a glance
| Set | Hub | On the valve or on the wall | Suits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Homematic IP Set Heizen Access Point 2 with 4 pure thermostats | Access Point 2 | 4 pure thermostats | Rented apartment, 4 valves |
| Homematic IP Starter Set Raumklima | Access Point 2 | 4 basic thermostats, wall thermostat, 2 window contacts | Older building, frequent airing |
| Homematic IP Set Heizen Easy | Home Control Unit | 4 pure thermostats | Local data |
| Homematic IP Set Heizen Professional | Home Control Unit | 4 flex thermostats | Local, button controls |
| Homematic IP Set Raumklima with 6 wall thermostats | Access Point 2 | 6 wall thermostats for brand-name switch ranges | Underfloor heating 230 V |
| Bosch Smart Home Starter-Paket Heizung | Smart Home Controller II | 3 Radiator Thermostats II | Getting started with Bosch |
| Eve Thermo | None of its own, Thread hub required | Single thermostat | Apple Home or Google Home |
Homematic IP Set Heizen Access Point 2 with 4 pure thermostats
The middle ground: a rotary dial on the device, an e-paper display that can be rotated left or right, and a whisper mode for bedrooms. Schedules and data live in the cloud, and without internet the if-then rules stop working. There is no window contact, so open-window detection works without one.
Homematic IP Starter Set Raumklima
Worthwhile if you will actually use the contacts and the wall thermostat. Otherwise you are paying for parts that end up in a drawer.
Homematic IP Set Heizen Easy
Four radiators with a local hub. Remote access still runs through the cloud, just not in offline mode. For four radiators alone, that is a lot of technology.
Homematic IP Set Heizen Professional
Despite the name, it brings no better control, just the flex thermostats. The hub’s data sheet is the same as for the Easy set.
Homematic IP Set Raumklima with 6 wall thermostats
Six rooms, six wall thermostats, up to six heating profiles. They also measure humidity. If you heat with radiators, you do not need it.
Bosch Smart Home Starter-Paket Heizung
The obvious alternative if you already own Bosch devices. The package, however, contains only three thermostats. Bosch promises updates for at least four years after the last sale in its own shop; for Homematic, the manufacturer gives no such commitment.
Eve Thermo
Not a set, but a single device for Apple Home or Google Home via Thread and Matter. It stores schedules directly in the thermostat. It does not work without an existing hub, so it only makes sense if you already have one at home. An overview of all brands is provided in our guide to smart radiator thermostats (in German).
Which set for which home?
- Up to four valves in a rental, standard thread: set with Access Point 2 and four pure thermostats.
- Older building with frequent airing, keeping an eye on humidity: Starter Set Raumklima.
- Data stays in the house, rules without internet: Set Heizen Easy.
- Buttons instead of a dial, pairing without the app: Set Heizen Professional.
- Underfloor heating with 230-volt actuators in a home you own: set with wall thermostats.
What a classic thermostat without a schedule lacks is shown in our review of the Eberle RTR-E after eleven years.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the Heating Easy and Professional sets?
Both use the Home Control Unit, so both include EEBUS. Easy contains the pure thermostats with a rotary dial, Professional the flex thermostats with buttons, a rotatable display and direct pairing at the push of a button. According to the data sheets, heating profiles and battery life are identical: three profiles, 13 changes per day, typically three years.
Is the Access Point 2 enough for a rented apartment?
Yes, for the typical case with four radiators it is enough. Installation requires no work on the heating system, and when you move out you take everything with you. According to the data sheet, a Danfoss adapter is included. Count valves, not rooms: five valves mean one extra thermostat.
When are window contacts and a wall thermostat worth it?
In older buildings where you air out a lot. According to the Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center), thermostats that only detect an open window from a sudden temperature drop respond rigidly; separate contacts work more precisely. The wall thermostat measures where you sit. The Starter Set Raumklima includes both, but only two contacts and the simpler basic thermostats.
How much on heating costs does a smart thermostat set save?
The 33 percent in the data sheet is the manufacturer's upper limit, not a promise. The Verbraucherzentrale estimates around 6 percent energy per degree lower. If you have always turned the heat down, you mainly gain comfort, and in very well insulated houses you can do without such thermostats.
Which Homematic set works for underfloor heating?
Not a radiator set, but the set with six wall thermostats. Each one sits in a flush-mounted box and switches 230-volt actuators. Because it is connected to mains voltage, it rarely suits a rented apartment. Check whether your actuators really run on 230 volts and not 24 volts.
Sources
- ELV: Set Heizen Easy (retailer information)
- ELV: Set Heizen Professional (retailer information)
- ELV: Set with Access Point 2 and four pure thermostats (retailer information)
- ELV: Starter Set Raumklima (retailer information)
- ELV: Set with six wall thermostats (retailer information)
- Homematic IP: pure radiator thermostat data sheet (PDF)
- Homematic IP: flex radiator thermostat data sheet (PDF)
- Homematic IP: Home Control Unit data sheet (PDF)
- Homematic IP: comparison of the hubs (PDF)
- Homematic IP: wall thermostat with switching output data sheet (PDF)
- Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center): setting and replacing thermostats correctly
- Stiftung Warentest (German consumer testing organization): smart radiator thermostats
- Bosch: Starter-Paket Heizung
- Eve: Eve Thermo
Where to buy
- Homematic IP Set Heizen Access Point 2 mit 4 Thermostaten pureView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Homematic IP Starter Set RaumklimaView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELVCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Homematic IP Set Heizen EasyView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Homematic IP Set Heizen ProfessionalView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Homematic IP Set Raumklima mit 6 WandthermostatenView at ELVAvailable in Germany: ELV
- Bosch Smart Home Starter-Paket HeizungCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Eve ThermoCheck price at Amazon.deAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
