Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet
This page in 6 more languages

DeutschNederlandsFrançaisItalianoEspañolPolski

Buying Eyeliner 2026: Liquid, Gel or Kohl?

Buying eyeliner in 2026: felt-tip, brush, gel pencil or kohl? What helps beginners, when waterproof makes sense and what eye doctors advise about the waterline.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Contents12 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

If you want to draw an eyeliner line for the first time, you will often reach for a liquid liner with a brush, because the line looks so sharp in photos. That very brush is not very forgiving. To start out, we recommend a felt-tip pen such as the L’Oréal Paris Infaillible 27H Grip Precision Felt Liner, whose firm tip can be guided like a ballpoint pen. If you prefer soft shading or want to bring color into play, a gel pencil is the better choice.

Liquid, gel or kohl: what is behind them?

The difference starts with the formula. According to the explanation from haut.de, a German skincare information portal, liquid eyeliners are thin mixtures of color pigments and film formers, applied with a fine brush. They make very thin lines possible. A clean line just above the lash line takes practice, though, and haut.de says so as well. Felt-tip pens follow the same idea, only the tip is stiffer.

Kohl pencils have a firm core of waxes, oils and pigments. They glide on softly and can be smudged. Gel pencils sit in between: they are applied like kohl, but according to Maybelline they are meant to last as long as a gel liner from a pot.

And waterproof? haut.de names sweat and water, at the swimming pool for example, as typical reasons why eye makeup smudges. A waterproof formula helps against that. In the evening, you will then need an eye makeup remover. For its gel pencil, Maybelline explicitly names its own remover.

Which tip forgives an unsteady hand?

A soft brush responds to every bit of pressure. Applied lightly, the line is whisper-thin; with more pressure, it gets wide. For experienced users that is an advantage, for beginners a trap, because every twitch shows up on the eyelid. Felt tips give less. L’Oréal specifies a 0.4 mm tip for the Precision Felt Liner.

For technique, a trick that L’Oréal describes in its tutorials helps. Place a dot at the outermost base of the lashes, then more small dots along the lash line up to the inner corner of the eye. Only then connect the dots into a line. According to L’Oréal, resting your elbow on the table also helps. haut.de additionally recommends pulling the skin on the outer upper lid slightly taut with your fingers and, if you are not very practiced, applying the line before the eyeshadow, because small wobbles then disappear under the color.

Hooded eyes need their own strategy. L’Oréal advises looking into the mirror with your eyes open and keeping the line thin, because a wide line disappears into the lid crease or transfers. According to the same tutorial, a line all the way around the eye makes it look smaller.

Six eyeliners, sorted by use

ModelType and tipWear according to manufacturerBest for
L’Oréal Paris Infaillible 27H Grip Precision Felt LinerFelt-tip pen, 0.4 mm tipup to 27 hours, waterproof and smudge-proofBeginners, a clean line on the upper lid
L’Oréal Paris Infaillible 36H Grip Micro-Fine Linerliquid, flexible brush tipup to 36 hours, waterproof and smudge-proofExperienced users, very fine lines and wings
Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel PencilGel pencil, creamy coreup to 36 hours, waterproof and smudge-proofintense color, including bright shades
L’Oréal Paris Infaillible Grip Gel Automatic LinerTwist-up gel pencil with blender and sharpenerall day, waterproof and smudge-proofSmoky eyes, soft lines
essence Long-Lasting Eye Penciltwist-up kohl, 0.28 gup to 18 hours, waterproofwaterproof twist-up kohl
essence Kajal Pencilclassic kohl pencil, firm core, 1 gdescribed as long-lasting, not as waterproofa first kohl for everyday wear

The starter: L’Oréal Paris Infaillible 27H Grip Precision Felt Liner

A felt-tip pen with a fine 0.4 mm tip and a grip section that L’Oréal calls „Easy Grip.“ The formula is said to last up to 27 hours and not smear even with sweat or tears. For a first eyeliner line, it is easier to guide than a brush. A brush is still better at very thin, hairline strokes.

For fine wings: L’Oréal Paris Infaillible 36H Grip Micro-Fine Liner

Here, a flexible brush tip works with liquid color. L’Oréal promises up to 36 hours of wear, waterproof and smudge-proof, and is aiming for very fine lines, including curved ones. This exact liner appears in the manufacturer’s tutorial for hooded eyes. If you have not mastered the brush yet, start with the felt-tip pen.

Color with staying power: Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil

Maybelline describes this gel pencil as its longest-lasting eyeliner, with up to 36 hours of color. According to the manufacturer, the core is creamy and highly pigmented, as well as waterproof and smudge-proof. It comes in 12 colors, including blue alongside black and brown. Thanks to the soft core, a mistake is easier to correct than with a liquid liner, which dries immediately.

For smudging: L’Oréal Paris Infaillible Grip Gel Automatic Liner

A twist-up gel pencil with a built-in sharpener and a blender on the other end. With it, a line turns into a smoky frame in just a few strokes. L’Oréal describes the formula as waterproof and smudge-proof, with all-day wear, and offers the pencil in five colors. According to the manufacturer, it also works as an eyeshadow.

Twist-up kohl: essence Long-Lasting Eye Pencil

The twist-up kohl holds 0.28 g. essence claims up to 18 hours of wear, waterproof, opaque, vegan and free of perfume, alcohol and parabens. The color range runs from black through brown and gray to turquoise. If you like to experiment, it is a sensible route before moving on to a more elaborate liner.

The simple pencil: essence Kajal Pencil

A classic kohl pencil with a 1 g firm core that, according to essence, applies precisely and effortlessly. Vegan, without alcohol, parabens and perfume. essence does not market it as waterproof. For the office, an evening without rain or simply for practice, that is enough. A tip from haut.de: warmed briefly in your hand, the core glides more easily, and a pencil straight from the fridge sharpens more cleanly.

Kohl on the waterline? What eye doctors advise

The waterline is the moist inner rim of the eyelid where the lid margin, mucous membrane and tear film meet. Cosmetics brands like to show kohl applied right there, and haut.de also mentions coloring the inner rim of the lower lid as an option. Eye doctors are more cautious. In their patient brochure on contact lenses, the Berufsverband der Augenärzte (BVA, the professional association of German ophthalmologists) and the Deutsche Ophthalmologische Gesellschaft (DOG, the German Ophthalmological Society) advise generally not applying cosmetics such as kohl to the lid margins and drawing the line outside the lash line instead. Put your lenses in before applying makeup and take them out before removing it.

For dry or sensitive eyes, BVA and DOG recommend low-irritant products, because cosmetics can also irritate the tear film. Maybelline itself advises removing a liner immediately if it burns, and considers liquid liners unsuitable for the waterline because they easily run into the eye. If discomfort persists, have it checked by a doctor.

Eyeliner is not something you share. Maybelline recommends sharpening kohl regularly and throwing it away after an eye infection. How long an opened product can be used is shown by the open jar symbol on the package: according to the explanation from the German Federal Office of Consumer Protection and Food Safety (BVL), „12 M“ stands for twelve months. According to haut.de, germs can settle in products such as mascara after opening.

Which liner suits you?

  • First eyeliner line, a steady line on the upper lid: L’Oréal Infaillible 27H Grip Precision Felt Liner.
  • Very fine wings once your hand is steady: L’Oréal Infaillible 36H Grip Micro-Fine Liner.
  • Color instead of black, and long wear: Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil.
  • Smoky eyes without a brush set: L’Oréal Infaillible Grip Gel Automatic Liner.
  • Waterproof kohl to try out: essence Long-Lasting Eye Pencil; for everyday wear without water, the essence Kajal Pencil is enough.

An eyeliner line only works with the lashes beneath it. Which mascara suits which lashes is covered in our mascara guide. The brows frame it from above; more on that in the guide to eyebrow kits, and if you combine liner with color on the lid, you will find palettes in the eyeshadow palette guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between liquid eyeliner, gel pencil and kohl?

According to haut.de, liquid eyeliners are thin mixtures of pigments and film formers, applied with a fine brush, and allow very thin lines. Kohl pencils have a firm core of waxes, oils and pigments and can be smudged. Gel pencils are applied like kohl but, according to Maybelline, are meant to last as long as a gel liner.

Which eyeliner is best for beginners?

A felt-tip pen. A soft brush responds to every bit of pressure, and every twitch shows up on the eyelid. Felt tips give less; L'Oréal specifies 0.4 mm for the Precision Felt Liner. A brush is still better at very thin, hairline strokes, but it takes a steady hand.

How do you draw a straight eyeliner line?

L'Oréal describes a trick: place a dot at the outermost base of the lashes, add more small dots along the lash line up to the inner corner of the eye, then connect them. Rest your elbow on the table. haut.de advises pulling the skin on the outer upper lid slightly taut and applying the line before the eyeshadow.

Which eyeliner works for hooded eyes?

L'Oréal advises looking into the mirror with your eyes open and keeping the line thin, because a wide line disappears into the lid crease or transfers. The Infaillible 36H Grip Micro-Fine Liner with a flexible brush tip appears in these instructions. A line all the way around the eye makes it look smaller.

Can kohl go on the waterline?

Eye doctors are cautious. In their brochure on contact lenses, BVA and DOG advise against applying cosmetics such as kohl to the lid margins and recommend drawing the line outside the lash line. Maybelline considers liquid liners unsuitable for the waterline. If it burns, remove the liner immediately, and have persistent discomfort checked by a doctor.

How long does eyeliner keep after opening?

The open jar symbol tells you; according to the BVL, 12 M stands for twelve months. According to haut.de, germs can settle in eye products after opening. Maybelline recommends sharpening kohl regularly and throwing it away after an eye infection. Eyeliner is not something you share.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.