Contents13 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Many people buy the mascara with the loudest advertising slogan and a week later stand in front of the mirror with clumped lashes. The brush is what decides the result first. Full lashes call for a dense, full brush; for length, a slim one with comb-like bristles works better. If you are unsure, start with the Maybelline Lash Sensational: its fanning brush covers both, and it stays at a drugstore price.
That is why this guide is not sorted by brand. It is sorted by what you want.
Brush and formula: two questions before you reach the shelf
How much mascara ends up on the lash is determined by the brush. In its own overview, Maybelline distinguishes five basic types. Straight plastic brushes separate evenly and look natural. Rubber brushes also catch the short, fine little lashes at the edge. Thick or full volume brushes deposit a lot of product. Curved brushes follow the curve of the lashes and are meant to hold the lift, and the hourglass shape combines wide ends for fullness with a narrow middle for definition.
Then comes the formula. Classic mascara comes off with any common eye makeup remover. Waterproof versions stand up better to sweat and rain but take patience to remove, and that is exactly when many people rub their eyelids too hard. Tubing mascaras take a third route. They wrap around each individual lash like tiny sleeves and, according to Maybelline, can be slid off with warm water.
Claims such as „for sensitive eyes“ or „for contact lens wearers“ always come from the manufacturer. We label them accordingly.
Seven mascaras, sorted by what you want
Full lashes without practice: Maybelline Lash Sensational
The fanning brush works with two sides. Short bristles on the inside are meant to grab and separate each lash, long bristles on the outside to lengthen them. Maybelline describes the texture as creamy, with rosehip oil. For beginners, that is a sensible middle ground, because a pure volume brush quickly loads too much color onto fine lashes. Maybelline rates it as suitable for sensitive eyes.
More fullness, more budget: Lancôme Lash Idôle
Lancôme’s brush is curved and densely packed with fine bristles. Its inner curve is meant to build volume, the outer one to lift the lashes. Add to that a gel formula that, according to the manufacturer, neither clumps nor flakes. The premium over drugstore brands is considerable. Whether it pays off depends on how important the lifted curve is to you.
Density for the evening: Benefit BADgal BANG!
Benefit combines a slim brush with lightweight particles in the formula, plus pro-vitamin B5 and beeswax. The brand advertises very long wear. For an understated day at the office, that is rather a lot of black. In photos or on stage, it is a different story. A waterproof version is available as well.
Longer short lashes: L’Oréal Paris Telescopic Lift
Two sides, two steps. First the short bristles lift the lashes and draw them out, then the comb-like side separates them. L’Oréal claims up to 5 mm more length and up to 36 hours of wear and explicitly recommends the mascara for short lashes. In the customer reviews on L’Oréal’s site, however, buyers also write that the brush picks up a lot of product at first and quickly produces „spider lashes.“ Give it a few mornings to settle in before you judge. A waterproof version and a deeper Extra Black sit next to it on the shelf.
Nothing should smudge: Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky Tubes
Tubing is the answer to gray shadows under the eye in the afternoon. Sky Tubes has a brush with pyramid-shaped bristles and a small ball at the tip for the corners of the eyes. Maybelline describes the formula with shea butter and castor oil as smudge-proof and sweat-resistant; it is said to withstand cold water. Maybelline does not, however, describe it as waterproof.
To remove it, moisten your lashes with warm water, press them gently between two fingers and slide the sleeves down and off. No rubbing. The tubing classic Clinique Lash Power has been around for years; Clinique describes it as ophthalmologist-tested and suitable for contact lens wearers. In terms of price, though, it plays in a different league.
Waterproof with curl: Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl
Dior pairs a curved brush with a waterproof variant for which Dior states up to 24 hours of wear. On Amazon, it is available in brown and blue as well as black. It is the most expensive mascara in our table. What speaks for it is the curl on straight lashes that tend to grow downward, for example at the beach or at a summer wedding. What speaks against it is the evening: waterproof mascara needs to be removed thoroughly.
Small budget: essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect
The manufacturer’s recommended retail price is at the very bottom of the price range, and still the tube holds 12 ml. The conical fiber brush is meant to reach and fan out every lash. Essence describes the ingredients as vegan. If you first want to find out which brush shape suits your lashes, a miss costs you next to nothing here. The waterproof sister carries the same name with the addition Waterproof.
And if your eyes water easily?
Nobody can promise that a mascara will not cause irritation. Maybelline describes Lash Sensational and Sky Tubes as „suitable for sensitive eyes,“ and Sky Tubes additionally as ophthalmologist- and allergy-tested. These are manufacturer claims. If your eye burns or turns red, stop using the mascara and have it checked by a doctor. Tubing has a practical advantage for sensitive eyes: you rub the eyelid less when removing makeup.
How long does an opened mascara last?
The packaging provides the answer. If a cosmetic product keeps for longer than 30 months, according to the German Federal Office of Consumer Protection and Food Safety (BVL) it carries the symbol of an open cream jar with a number of months, for example „12 M.“ The period begins with first opening. The agency does not give a fixed number of months for all mascaras.
The German portal haut.de warns that germs can settle in opened mascara and advises closing the tube tightly after use and protecting it from sun and heat. Write the opening date on the tube with a felt-tip pen. If the mascara smells different or has visibly changed, throw it away.
Which mascara for whom?
- The Maybelline Lash Sensational delivers full lashes without much practice.
- If you want more density in the evening and price is no object, Benefit BADgal BANG! or Lancôme Lash Idôle are worth considering.
- Short, straight lashes look longer with the L’Oréal Paris Telescopic Lift, provided you bring a little patience when applying it.
- Tubing helps against smudging, such as Maybelline Sky Tubes; for contact lens wearers, Clinique explicitly describes its Lash Power as suitable.
- For sports, the beach and tears of joy, choose a waterproof version, at the high end from Dior or inexpensively from essence.
- For trying out different brushes, the essence Lash Princess is enough.
Mascara is usually the last step. For the base before it, we have a guide to finding the right foundation, and if you want a close look while applying mascara, you will find what you need among the magnifying makeup mirrors.
Frequently asked questions
Which mascara brush for which effect?
Straight plastic brushes separate evenly and look natural, while rubber brushes also catch the fine little lashes at the edge. Thick, full brushes deposit a lot of product for volume, and curved ones follow the curve of the lashes. The hourglass shape combines wide ends for fullness with a narrow middle for definition.
What is a tubing mascara?
Tubing wraps around each individual lash like tiny sleeves and therefore hardly smudges. To remove it, moisten the lashes with warm water, press them gently between two fingers and slide the sleeves off, without rubbing. The manufacturer describes Maybelline Sky Tubes as smudge-proof, but not as waterproof.
Which mascara for sensitive eyes?
Nobody can guarantee that. Maybelline describes Lash Sensational and Sky Tubes as suitable for sensitive eyes; these are manufacturer claims. Tubing has the advantage that you rub the eyelid less when removing makeup. If the eye burns or turns red, stop using the mascara and have it checked by a doctor.
Which mascara makes short lashes longer?
The L’Oréal Paris Telescopic Lift with its two-sided brush: the short bristles lift, the comb side separates. L’Oréal claims up to 5 mm more length. According to customer reviews, the brush picks up a lot of product at first, so give it a few days to settle in before judging.
How long does an opened mascara last?
The packaging tells you: the symbol of an open cream jar with a number of months, such as 12 M, states the period from first opening. You can write the opening date on the tube with a felt-tip pen. If the mascara smells different or has visibly changed, throw it away.
Waterproof mascara: when does it make sense?
For sports, the beach and tears of joy, because it stands up better to sweat and rain. Removing it takes patience, and that is exactly when many people rub their eyelids too hard. Waterproof versions are available at the high end from Dior, for example, or inexpensively from essence.
Sources
- Maybelline: Lash Sensational Mascara
- Maybelline: Lash Sensational Sky Tubes
- Maybelline: Which mascara brush is right for you?
- L’Oréal Paris: Telescopic Lift Mascara
- essence: Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
- essence: Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara Waterproof
- Lancôme: Lash Idôle Mascara
- Benefit Cosmetics: BADgal BANG! Mascara
- Dior: Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Waterproof
- Clinique: Lash Power Mascara
- German Federal Office of Consumer Protection and Food Safety: Labeling of cosmetics
- haut.de: Shelf life of cosmetics
Where to buy
- Maybelline Lash Sensational MascaraCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara (schwarz)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky TubesCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- L'Oréal Paris Telescopic Lift MascaraCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Lancôme Lash Idôle MascaraCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Benefit BADgal BANG! MascaraCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Dior Diorshow Iconic OvercurlCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Clinique Lash Power MascaraCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.






