Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A warm night, the window open, and the fan still hums too loudly for the bedroom even on its lowest setting. That is often how it ends with a cheap device that has an AC motor and three speed settings. For sleeping, you need a DC motor with many fine settings. That is why, for most households, we consider a quiet DC pedestal fan such as the Duux Whisper Flex 2 the more sensible solution than a tower that looks stylish but moves less air.
Incidentally, a fan cannot cool a room. It moves air, and that air passes over your skin. If you really want the attic a few degrees cooler, only a device with an exhaust hose will help; more on that in our guide to the portable air conditioner.
Tower, pedestal or desk?
The pedestal fan has a large propeller, moves a lot of air and is usually height-adjustable. It needs space, but gives a noticeable cooling effect over several meters. For living rooms and bedrooms, it is the first choice.
A tower is slim, fits into corners and looks tidier. Its airflow is wider but softer. It rarely delivers a strong breeze to the bed. Desk fans belong on desks and nightstands, and some pedestal fans can be placed on a table without their extension pole. That saves you a second device.
The real difference lies in the motor. DC motors run much more economically on low settings and allow 12, 16 or even 100 speed settings; AC motors are cheaper but have coarser steps. If the device runs at night, a remote control is a must. An app only helps if you will actually use schedules or voice control.
What the decibel figures really tell you
The advertising almost always shows the quietest value. 13 dB, 20 dB, 32 dB: these figures apply to the lowest setting or a night mode, measured under conditions the manufacturer chooses itself. They are hardly comparable. The maximum value, if it is stated at all, tells you more. Where a manufacturer gives it, it lies between 55 and 64 dB for the devices in our list. That roughly corresponds to a conversation in the same room.
Our rule of thumb for the bedroom: count the fine settings below the halfway point. That is where the fan runs for hours on warm nights.
Power consumption: the fan is cheap, the heating function is not
The two DC fans in our list state their maximum power as 21 watts (Duux) and 24 watts (Xiaomi), and on a low setting it is only a fraction of that. A quick calculation: 21 watts over eight hours comes to 0.17 kWh per night, so at an electricity price of around 35 euro cents per kWh, roughly six cents. Even a whole summer barely registers.
Once you heat, the math flips. A 2,000-watt fan heater uses 2 kWh in one hour at full power, about the consumption of an economical fan in just under twelve nights. Combination devices that cool in summer and heat in winter are therefore intended for the transitional seasons and small rooms. They are not suitable for heating a whole home, and that also applies to the Dyson in our list. If you regularly want to keep a room at a comfortable temperature, an oil-filled radiator is often the better choice.
Five fans you can currently get
| Model | Type | Noise according to manufacturer | Power according to manufacturer | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Duux Whisper Flex 2 | Pedestal and desk fan, DC | 13–55 dB(A) | 21 W, standby 0.5 W | Bedrooms, battery operation possible |
| Rowenta Turbo Silence Extreme+ VU5890 | Pedestal fan, 40 cm | 32–58 dB(A) | no wattage stated | Large rooms, classic controls |
| Rowenta Eole Silence Force VU7050 | Tower fan, brushless motor | 20–64 dB(A) | no clear wattage stated | Narrow corners, remote control instead of app |
| Xiaomi Smart Tower Fan 2 | Tower fan, DC | 28.7–59.3 dB(A) | 24 W rated power | Narrow corners, app control |
| Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool HP1 | Fan, air purifier, fan heater | up to 63 dB | Heating with ceramic plates | If you want one device for the whole year |
Duux Whisper Flex 2: the quiet one for the bedroom
Duux quotes 30 speed settings for this Dutch fan, plus a maximum power draw of 21 watts and 0.5 watts in standby. According to the user manual, it also works as a desk fan without the extension pole. Depending on the version, a battery pack is included; otherwise it is available as an accessory. The Smart variant can also be controlled via an app. The stated 13 dB apply to the lowest setting; at full power, Duux quotes 55 dB(A). Some color variants are temporarily unavailable on Amazon, while others are offered.
Rowenta Turbo Silence Extreme+ VU5890: classic with a remote
An old-school pedestal fan. 40 centimeters in diameter, 16 speed settings, three automatic modes, remote control. According to Rowenta, the height ranges from 1.30 to 1.45 meters, and the timer goes up to twelve hours. An absolute wattage is missing; Rowenta only compares it with an older 55-watt model, against which the motor is said to save 65 percent. In the Rowenta shop, the device is currently marked as unavailable, while Amazon lists it as new.
Rowenta Eole Silence Force VU7050: a tower without an app
If you do not want an app but are looking for a slim tower, take a look at this one. Rowenta quotes 12 speeds, a timer of up to twelve hours, wide automatic oscillation and a brushless motor. A remote control and a dust cover are included, plus a drawer for room fragrance. The 20 dB(A) apply to silent mode; at the highest setting, Rowenta states 64 dB(A). That is the loudest figure in our list. In the Rowenta shop, the tower is marked as unavailable outside the season, while Amazon offers it.
Xiaomi Smart Tower Fan 2: finely adjustable via app
There is a figure for both ends of the scale: 28.7 dB(A) in the quietest mode and at most 59.3 dB(A) at full power, according to the retailer’s spec sheet. Rated power is 24 watts, and at setting 1 without oscillation it is only 1.5 to 3.5 watts according to the spec sheet. The 100 speed settings and several wind profiles are available through the Xiaomi Home app. Without the app, you give up most of the fine control.
Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool HP1: three devices in one
Fan, air purifier with HEPA H13 and activated carbon filter, fan heater with ceramic plates. It is controlled via the MyDyson app or voice assistants such as Alexa, Google Assistant and Siri. The spec sheet lists up to 63 dB, plus ten speed settings and 350 degrees of oscillation. If you only want to move air in summer, you are paying too much here. The Dyson becomes interesting once you are looking for an air purifier anyway; background on that is in our air purifier guide.
How we would decide
For the bedroom, quiet and economical, our choice is the Duux Whisper Flex 2: many fine settings, low power draw, and it can go on a table if you like. In a large living room with no need for an app, the Rowenta Turbo Silence Extreme+ with remote control is enough, provided it is available.
Little space, but no interest in an app? Then the Rowenta Eole Silence Force with remote control. The Xiaomi Smart Tower Fan 2 offers a slim tower with fine control from your phone. And if you want just one device for summer and winter, air purification included, you end up with the Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool HP1. It is not suitable as a main heater.
One more note on the season. In fall and winter, many pure fans disappear from store shelves, and prices and availability fluctuate widely. So compare the exact model designation. Rowenta has several similarly named devices, for example the Eole Silence Force as the VU7050 and as the weaker VU7025.
Frequently asked questions
Which fan is quiet enough for the bedroom?
For sleeping, you need a DC motor with many fine speed settings; cheap AC fans with three settings often hum even on the lowest one. A rule of thumb: count the fine settings below the halfway point, because that is where the fan runs for hours on warm nights. A remote control is a must.
Tower fan or pedestal fan: which is better?
A pedestal fan has a large propeller, moves a lot of air and gives a noticeable cooling effect over several meters, but it needs space. A tower is slim, fits into corners and looks tidier. Its airflow is wider but softer, and it rarely delivers a strong breeze to the bed.
How meaningful are the decibel figures for fans?
They are hardly comparable. Figures like 13 dB or 20 dB apply to the lowest setting or a night mode, measured under conditions the manufacturer chooses. The maximum value, where stated, tells you more. For the devices presented here, it lies between 55 and 64 dB, about as loud as a conversation in the same room.
How much electricity does a fan use?
Very little. The DC fans in the list state 21 watts (Duux) and 24 watts (Xiaomi) as their maximum power, and on a low setting it is a fraction of that. 21 watts over eight hours comes to 0.17 kWh per night. Only the heating function of combination devices gets expensive.
Is a combination device with a heating function any good as a heater?
Only for the transitional seasons and small rooms. A 2,000-watt fan heater uses 2 kWh in one hour at full power, about as much as an economical fan in just under twelve nights. Devices like this are not suitable for heating a whole home, and that includes the Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool HP1.
Does a fan need an app?
Only if you will actually use schedules or voice control. On the Xiaomi Smart Tower Fan 2, however, the 100 speed settings and wind profiles run through the Xiaomi Home app. If you do not want an app, the Rowenta Eole Silence Force is a tower with a remote control.
Sources
- Duux: Whisper Flex 2 user manual
- Rowenta: Turbo Silence Extreme+ VU5890
- Rowenta: Eole Silence Force VU7050
- wlan-shop24 (German retailer): Xiaomi Smart Tower Fan 2 EU, spec sheet (retailer information)
- ElectroCity (Irish retailer): Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool HP1, spec sheet (retailer information)
Where to buy
- Duux Whisper Flex 2 (Smart mit App)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Rowenta Turbo Silence Extreme+ VU5890Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Rowenta Eole Silence Force VU7050Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Xiaomi Smart Tower Fan 2Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool HP1Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
