Contents8 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
According to the German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt), 809 electricity suppliers offered a green electricity tariff in 2024, just under 80 percent of all suppliers. Because the certificates behind it cost only a fraction of a cent, the surcharge is small. That sounds good. But it often does little for the climate. The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) is clear in its verdict: many green electricity tariffs bring no additional climate benefit, and the worthwhile ones are mainly tariffs with a recognized label. If you know this, switching can actually make a difference.
Why green electricity is often only green on paper
Every green electricity tariff is based on the guarantee of origin. The German Environment Agency keeps a register of these to prevent the same kilowatt hour from being sold twice as green electricity. A supplier may only label electricity as green if it cancels the corresponding guarantees. But a guarantee of origin is not a quality label. It only certifies the quantity, one megawatt hour per guarantee. According to the German Environment Agency, a good 221 million megawatt hours were canceled in 2024.
The sticking point is where they come from. In Germany, electricity from plants subsidized under the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG) does not receive a guarantee of origin. That is why, according to the consumer advice center, the guarantees usually come from abroad, for example from hydropower plants in Norway or Austria. That electricity is generated anyway. Whether you buy it or not. If a supplier only buys the guarantee on top, the electricity is assigned to you on paper, but the overall share of green electricity does not change. The guarantees cost only a fraction of a cent per kilowatt hour, which explains the low surcharge. At least since November 2023, suppliers have had to state which countries their guarantees come from.
How to recognize green electricity that makes a difference
The German Environment Agency and the consumer advice center name the same two labels: the Grüner Strom Label and the EnergieVision label, formerly known as the ok-power-Label. Both are meant to ensure that the tariff promotes the expansion of renewable energy. According to the consumer advice center, both rule out suppliers holding stakes in nuclear power plants and new coal-fired power plants. The Grüner Strom Label makes an exception for stakes acquired before 2015.
| Tariff | Basis | Climate benefit according to the consumer advice center |
|---|---|---|
| Green electricity with the Grüner Strom Label | guarantees of origin plus criteria for expansion | minimum benefit for the energy transition |
| Green electricity with the EnergieVision label | guarantees of origin plus criteria for expansion | minimum benefit for the energy transition |
| Green electricity without a label | usually guarantees of origin only | in many cases no climate benefit |
| Regional electricity | regional guarantees of origin for subsidized plants | no additional expansion |
Also look at the supplier itself. The German Environment Agency advises: if a company mainly sells electricity from coal or gas power plants, you are better off switching suppliers rather than just tariffs. The electricity disclosure label on your bill shows which sources are behind your electricity.
How much money really goes into new plants
Labels are no guarantee of much expansion, either. A look at the details helps. According to the consumer advice center, with some labels at most about 1 cent per kilowatt hour goes into new plants, often less. For an average household, that is around 30 euros a year, and at 0.2 cents still about 6 euros. Other labels also promote energy saving, tenant electricity schemes or storage. That is not bad. But it means less new capacity.
Regional electricity is a category of its own. Since 2019, there have been regional guarantees of origin that allow subsidized electricity from plants within a radius of 50 kilometers to be sold as regional. According to the consumer advice center, this does not lead to any new plants. So regional does not mean additional.
How to switch to green electricity that makes a difference
- Read the electricity disclosure label on your last bill. Since November 2023, it also states which countries the guarantees of origin come from.
- In the comparison, display only tariffs with the Grüner Strom Label or EnergieVision.
- Check whether the supplier itself mainly sells coal or gas power. If so, switch suppliers, not just tariffs.
- Subtract any bonus from the calculation and look for a contract term of about one year.
- Sign the new contract. According to the German Environment Agency, the new supplier handles the cancellation with the old one.
Frequently asked questions
Can my power go out when I switch?
No. According to the German Environment Agency, if supply cannot continue, the default supplier (Grundversorger) must keep supplying you.
Does green electricity mean I get electricity from Germany?
Usually not. According to the consumer advice center, the guarantees of origin mostly come from abroad, for example from Norway or Austria.
How large is the share of green electricity overall?
According to the consumer advice center, renewable energy accounts for around 50 percent of the German electricity mix. According to the German Environment Agency, the market share of green electricity tariffs was around 25.8 percent in 2024.
What has the biggest effect?
Saving energy. The consumer advice center calls this the most direct impact.
And the price?
Why is the surcharge so small? According to the consumer advice center, green electricity suppliers buy on the power exchange at the same prices as everyone else; the only addition is the guarantees of origin. That is why the price of green electricity rises when the gas price rises, because the most expensive power plant needed, usually a gas-fired one, sets the exchange price. According to the consumer advice center, though, the price alone says little about the benefit. The label is what counts. A tariff with a label can cost slightly more because part of the money is meant to go into new plants. Otherwise, the same rules apply as with any electricity contract: subtract the bonus from the comparison, choose a term of about one year and read the price guarantee carefully. Everything on this is in the guide switching electricity suppliers.
What is different with gas
For gas, there are no comparably reliable labels. There is little guidance there. Tariffs with biomethane often contain only 10 percent of it, sometimes only 1 percent. According to the consumer advice center, pure biomethane costs about twice as much as natural gas. It considers offsetting offers hard to verify and advises against them.
The most effective step remains using less energy or generating your own. A balcony solar system is a good start.
Has your supplier just raised its prices? Then you may cancel as of the date of the increase. How that works is explained in the guide electricity price increase: what to do?
Frequently asked questions
Why does green electricity often do nothing for the climate?
In Germany, electricity from plants subsidized under the EEG (the German Renewable Energy Sources Act) does not receive a guarantee of origin. The guarantees therefore usually come from abroad, for example from hydropower plants in Norway or Austria that generate electricity anyway. If a supplier only buys the certificate on top, the overall share of green electricity does not change.
Which green electricity labels are worthwhile?
The German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) and the consumer advice center name the Grüner Strom Label and the EnergieVision label, formerly the ok-power-Label. Both are meant to ensure that the tariff promotes the expansion of renewable energy and, according to the consumer advice center, rule out stakes in nuclear power plants and new coal-fired power plants, with one exception for the Grüner Strom Label.
What is the difference between green electricity and regional electricity?
Regional electricity comes from subsidized plants within a radius of 50 kilometers and is sold using regional guarantees of origin, which have existed since 2019. According to the consumer advice center, this does not lead to any new plants. So regional does not mean additional.
Why is green electricity hardly more expensive than regular electricity?
According to the consumer advice center, green electricity suppliers buy on the power exchange at the same prices as everyone else; the only addition is the guarantees of origin, at a fraction of a cent per kilowatt hour. A tariff with a label can cost slightly more because part of the money is meant to go into new plants.
How do I know where my electricity comes from?
From the electricity disclosure label on your bill. Since November 2023, suppliers must also state there which countries their guarantees of origin come from. According to the consumer advice center, these are usually countries such as Norway or Austria.
Are there reliable eco labels for gas as well?
For gas, there are no comparably reliable labels. Tariffs with biomethane often contain only 10 percent of it, sometimes only 1 percent. The consumer advice center considers offsetting offers hard to verify and advises against them.
Sources
- German Environment Agency: protecting the climate with green electricity
- German Environment Agency: electricity disclosure and guarantees of origin
- Verbraucherzentrale: does a green electricity and green gas tariff make sense?
Where to buy
- Ökostrom mit Grüner Strom LabelView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Ökostrom mit Siegel EnergieVisionView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Ökostrom ohne SiegelView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- RegionalstromView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
Still undecided?
Keep comparing at your own pace – every article in this category is checked monthly for new and discontinued models.








