Contents11 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Going off-grid all year rarely fails because of the battery. It fails because of the December sun. For a cabin using around 600 watt hours a day, 800 watts of panels on a permanent 24-volt system are enough. A tiny house using 1.5 kilowatt hours a day already needs around 3,200 watts of panels. None of the stations compared here can handle that on its own. We are not making a single top recommendation, because we have no independent measurements for any of these components. We classify them by use case; the device data are specifications from manufacturers and retailers.
What really has to keep running when it is winter outside?
Start with a list, not a shopping cart. Our assumption for a cabin: a refrigerator using 150 kilowatt hours a year, so about 410 watt hours a day, plus 60 for LED lighting and 130 for a laptop and phones. That makes 600. In a lived-in tiny house, add half an hour of cooking at 1,200 watts and around 300 watt hours for the pump, router and small devices, for a total of 1,500.
Two items are easily forgotten. The inverter runs even when nothing is connected. At an assumed 15 watts of idle consumption, it eats 360 watt hours a day, more than half of the cabin’s demand. So switch it off when nobody is there. And heating: a 2,000-watt fan heater uses more in one hour than the tiny house does all day. Why that does not add up with batteries is calculated in our guide to the fan heater and power station. In an off-grid system, heat comes from wood or gas.
December determines the panel area
We ran the tiny house through the off-grid calculator in PVGIS, the European Commission’s solar tool. Assumptions: Frankfurt, panels facing south at a steep 60 degrees, a 5-kilowatt-hour battery of which 10 percent remains as a reserve, and a demand of 1,500 watt hours a day. What arrives in December:
- 800 watts of panels: around 730 watt hours a day; the battery runs empty on nine out of ten days
- 1,600 watts: around 1,280 watt hours, empty on 38 percent of days
- 3,200 watts: around 1,500 watt hours, empty on just under 4 percent of days
- 3,200 watts in Hamburg: around 1,410 watt hours, empty on 16 percent of days
More area beats more battery, as the counter-test shows. If you double the battery to 10 kilowatt hours at 1,600 watts, the share of empty December days drops from 38 to 18 percent. If you double the panels instead, you end up at just under 4 percent. So calculate the area first, then the battery.
The cabin fares better. With 800 watts, a 2.56-kilowatt-hour battery and a demand of 600 watt hours, PVGIS reports 570 watt hours a day for Frankfurt in December and an empty battery on 12 percent of days. You can live with that if the refrigerator is allowed to stay off in a pinch.
There is one compromise you have to accept. A system built for December often has to curtail its output by midday in summer, because nothing more fits in. With the 3,200 watts, around 80 percent of the possible yield goes unused on an annual average. That is not a planning error; it is the nature of off-grid systems. Trees, by the way, are not included in this calculation. If there is forest or a slope to the south, things get worse, precisely when the sun is low. Check your location in the same tool before you order. If a gap remains, a generator covers it for the dark weeks; the trade-offs are laid out in our comparison power station or generator.
Frost separates the station from the fixed battery
Here, a single line in the datasheet makes the difference. According to the manufacturer, Victron’s lithium batteries may only be charged between plus 5 and plus 50 degrees Celsius. Below that, the cells suffer permanent damage, which is why the battery management system blocks charging. In an unheated cabin, that means the sun shines in January, the panels deliver, and the battery accepts nothing. Discharging works down to minus 20 degrees, with losses. Of 100 amp hours, 80 remain at 0 degrees and 50 at minus 20 degrees.
If you heat continuously, that is not a problem. In the tiny house, the battery sits somewhere warm. For the unheated weekend cabin, things look different: according to the retailer, the Jackery Explorer 3600 Plus charges down to minus 20 degrees. We do not have a datasheet for this; the figure comes from the authorized retailer GreenDrive. Ask before buying if your plan depends on it.
Five components for a cabin and tiny house
| Model | Storage or output | Solar | Charges from | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Victron LiFePO4 Smart 25.6 V 100 Ah | 2,560 Wh, 28 kg, BMS separate | via charge controller | +5 °C | Tiny house, frost-free location |
| Victron SmartSolar MPPT 100/30 | 30 A charging current, 12 and 24 V | up to 100 V, around 800 W at 24 V on paper | depends on the battery | permanent system for a cabin |
| Jackery Explorer 3600 Plus | 3,584 Wh, 3,600 W, 35 kg | 1,000 W, 16 to 60 V | −20 °C | unheated cabin, weekends |
| Jackery Explorer 3000 v2 | 3,072 Wh, 3,600 W, 27 kg | 1,000 W, 16 to 60 V | 0 °C | cabin from April to October |
| BLUETTI AC200L | 2,048 Wh, 2,400 W, 28.3 kg | 1,200 W | not specified | frost-free location, lots of panel area |
Specifications according to the manufacturer, for Jackery according to the authorized retailer GreenDrive; the wattage at the charge controller is our calculation from 30 amps and 25.6 volts.
Victron LiFePO4 Smart 25.6 V 100 Ah
According to the datasheet, the battery stores 2,560 watt hours; two in parallel give the 5 kilowatt hours from our calculation. Victron states 2,500 cycles at 80 percent depth of discharge and 5,000 at 50 percent, each down to 80 percent remaining capacity. One drawback surprises many people: it does not work on its own but requires an external battery management system that switches off chargers and loads. It also weighs 28 kilograms and is 65 centimeters wide. This is technology for people who can read a wiring diagram or will pay a specialist. We are not aware of any independent testing of these figures.
Victron SmartSolar MPPT 100/30
This charge controller suits the cabin. At 24 volts, around 800 watts get through on paper, with Bluetooth and an adjustable charging curve. For the tiny house’s 3,200 watts, it is too small. There, choose the more powerful 150 or 250 series, or connect several controllers in parallel, which Victron explicitly provides for. The maximum panel voltage must stay below 100 volts even in frost. So calculate series connections of panels in advance.
Jackery Explorer 3600 Plus
Battery, charge controller and inverter sit in a single housing, so you do not need a wiring diagram. Up to five battery packs expand it to 21.5 kilowatt hours. The limit is the solar input: 1,000 watts, no more. With 1,000 watts of permanently mounted panels and a demand of 1 kilowatt hour a day, PVGIS shows hardly any gaps for Frankfurt from March to October, but in December 830 watt hours a day and an empty battery on 42 percent of days. That is enough for weekends, because the battery fills up during the week. For continuous use in winter, it is not. It has no 12-volt socket, and you will not carry 35 kilograms up to a mountain cabin by yourself. What else the station can do is covered in our guide to the large power station (in German).
Jackery Explorer 3000 v2
Eight kilograms lighter and with a 12-volt socket, but it only charges from 0 degrees, cannot be expanded and, according to the retailer, reaches 4,000 instead of 6,000 cycles. For a cabin used from April to October, none of these weaknesses plays a major role. In summer, the problem is the surplus anyway.
BLUETTI AC200L
According to BLUETTI, at 1,200 watts it accepts more panel output than either Jackery station, and additional batteries expand it to 8,192 watt hours. That makes the case for a fixed location with a large panel area. We did not find any reliable information on charging in frost, so keep it somewhere warm.
Which component suits which use
- Lived-in tiny house, heated: a permanent system with about 3,200 watts and around 5 kilowatt hours of storage, for example two Victron LiFePO4 Smart 25.6 V 100 Ah, a controller from the more powerful series and a plan for the gap in December.
- Cabin in continuous use at around 600 watt hours, frost-free location: 800 watts, one Victron battery, Victron SmartSolar MPPT 100/30.
- Unheated cabin, weekends only: Jackery Explorer 3600 Plus with permanently mounted panels.
- Use only in the summer half of the year: the Jackery Explorer 3000 v2 is enough.
Folding panels do not belong permanently on the property in any of these cases, as our guide to the solar generator set explains. For a garden shed with occasional needs, all of this is too big; the plan from power in the garden shed (in German) is enough there. Permanent 230-volt wiring in the building should be installed by a licensed electrician. Whether a tiny house without a grid connection will be approved at all is something to clarify beforehand with your municipality’s building authority.
Frequently asked questions
How much solar power does a tiny house need all year round?
With a demand of 1,500 watt hours a day and a 5-kilowatt-hour battery, 3,200 watts of panels in Frankfurt deliver around 1,500 watt hours a day in December, and the battery runs empty on just under 4 percent of days. With 800 watts, the battery runs empty on nine out of ten December days. In Hamburg, at 3,200 watts, it is 16 percent.
More battery or more panels: what helps in winter?
More area beats more battery. If you double the battery to 10 kilowatt hours at 1,600 watts, the share of empty December days drops from 38 to 18 percent. If you double the panels instead, you end up at just under 4 percent. So calculate the area first, then the battery.
Can you charge a lithium battery in an unheated cabin?
According to the manufacturer, Victron's lithium batteries may only be charged between plus 5 and plus 50 degrees Celsius; below that, the battery management system blocks charging. For the unheated cabin, the Jackery Explorer 3600 Plus charges down to minus 20 degrees according to the retailer. Ask before buying if your plan depends on it.
Which loads are often forgotten in an off-grid system?
The inverter runs even when nothing is connected. At an assumed 15 watts of idle consumption, it eats 360 watt hours a day, more than half of the cabin's demand. And heating: a 2,000-watt fan heater uses more in one hour than the tiny house does all day. In an off-grid system, heat comes from wood or gas.
Is the Jackery Explorer 3600 Plus enough for winter?
For weekends, yes; for continuous use in winter, no. Its solar input tops out at 1,000 watts. With 1,000 watts of panels and a demand of 1 kilowatt hour, PVGIS gives 830 watt hours a day for Frankfurt in December and an empty battery on 42 percent of days. It has no 12-volt socket.
What needs to be clarified before building an off-grid system?
Check your location in the PVGIS calculator, because forest or a slope to the south reduces the yield, especially when the sun is low. Permanent 230-volt wiring in the building should be installed by a licensed electrician. Whether a tiny house without a grid connection will be approved is something to clarify beforehand with your municipality's building authority.
Sources
- European Commission: PVGIS, off-grid calculator (our own calculation for Frankfurt and Hamburg)
- Victron Energy: Lithium Battery Smart datasheet (PDF)
- Victron Energy: Lithium Battery Smart manual (PDF)
- Victron Energy: MPPT charge controller overview (PDF)
- GreenDrive: Explorer 3600 Plus (retailer information)
- GreenDrive: Explorer 3000 v2 (retailer information)
- Zajadacz (German retailer): Jackery E3000V2
- BLUETTI: AC200L
Where to buy
- Victron LiFePO4 Smart 25,6 V 100 AhCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Victron SmartSolar MPPT 100/30Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Jackery Explorer 3600 PlusView at JackeryAvailable in Germany: JackeryCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Jackery Explorer 3000 v2View at JackeryAvailable in Germany: JackeryCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- BLUETTI AC200LCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esAvailable in Germany: Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.se
