Black Friday Woche ab 19.11.: unsere Wahl je Ratgeber
Independent buying adviceEvery claim with a sourceNo paid verdictsIn 36 countries1,734 guides and reviews in German How we test
handgetestet

Package Holiday Defects: How to Get Money Back

Defects on a package holiday: what counts as a defect, why you should report it immediately on site and how to claim back part of the price after the trip.

handgetestet editorial team · Updated November 17, 2026
Contents6 sections

This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.

The construction crane in front of the balcony was not in any catalog. The pool is closed, and the room goes uncleaned for days. If you booked a package holiday, you do not simply have to put up with this. Part of the travel price can be claimed back. What matters is what you do while still on site: report the defect to the tour operator immediately, set a deadline and secure evidence. If you fail to do this, you can lose your claim.

What counts as a defect

The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) lists typical examples (as of August 2026). Construction noise entitles you to a price reduction if the tour operator did not point out the construction site or if the disturbance actually lasts more than one to two hours a day. Noise from a lively neighborhood mentioned in the brochure or from the hotel’s own disco, on the other hand, is not a defect. Nighttime noise until midnight is often considered normal for the country in southern destinations, unless the description promises a quiet location.

Occasional ants or insects have to be tolerated in simple accommodations in the south. An unreasonable infestation that is not eliminated is a defect. If an advertised facility at the hotel itself is not available, such as the pool, the spa area or the cinema, you can claim a price reduction. You can also do so if rooms are not cleaned during a strike by hotel staff, and in the case of worse replacement accommodation after overbooking. External offerings, such as a nearby dive center, do not count.

Circumstances that no one can prevent, such as a lack of snow or a storm, are not defects. But if a facility is unavailable because of poor maintenance or a staff shortage, that is the tour operator’s responsibility.

SituationWhat you do
Package holiday with construction noise at the hotelreport the defect immediately, note and record the noise times
Package holiday with a closed poolreport the defect, take photos of the closed area
Package holiday with a replacement hotel after overbookingdocument the differences from the booked hotel

On site: report immediately

The most important step. Section 651o of the German Civil Code (BGB) requires you to report a defect without undue delay. If you culpably fail to do so and thereby make a remedy impossible for the tour operator, you lose your right to a price reduction and damages. So report the defect to the tour guide or the tour operator, ideally in writing and with witnesses or with a confirmation that the report was received. Hotel staff are usually not the right contact. If no tour guide can be reached, call the tour operator in Germany, preferably with a witness next to you.

Set a deadline for a remedy. If the tour operator does not respond, Section 651k BGB allows you to remedy the problem yourself and claim back the necessary costs, for example for comparable accommodation. A deadline is not required if the tour operator refuses to provide a remedy or immediate action is needed. You only have to accept a replacement room if it is equivalent or better and reasonable. If you accept it, the price reduction for the remedied defects no longer applies. Secure evidence with photos, videos and witnesses. To keep your phone going until the evening for this, a power bank helps; more in the power bank guide.

If the trip is significantly impaired and the tour operator does not help despite the deadline, you may terminate the contract under Section 651l BGB. The operator must then bring you back without undue delay and in an equivalent manner, and bears the additional costs. You owe nothing for services no longer provided.

After the trip: how much money back?

After the trip, you assert your claims in writing and in a verifiable way, for example by email or by registered mail. There is no fixed rate. Section 651m BGB calculates it like this: the price is reduced in proportion to the value of the defect-free trip compared with its actual value, and only for the duration of the defect. If the pool was closed on four of 14 days, the reduction therefore relates to those four days. As a guide for the rate, the Verbraucherzentrale cites the Frankfurter Tabelle (Frankfurt table), the Kemptener Reisemängeltabelle (Kempten travel defects table) and the ADAC table.

Additional costs, for example for a taxi to the new accommodation or a doctor’s visit, can be claimed as damages. If the trip is thwarted or significantly impaired, Section 651n BGB also provides for appropriate compensation for vacation time spent in vain. There are no damages if you caused the defect yourself or if unavoidable, extraordinary circumstances caused it.

You have time for this. Under Section 651j BGB, claims only become time-barred two years after the agreed end of the trip. What matters when booking your next trip is covered in the guide Booking a package holiday.

Step by step

  1. Photograph or film the defect, note down witnesses, and with noise write down the times.
  2. Inform the tour guide or tour operator and have the report confirmed.
  3. Set a reasonable deadline for a remedy.
  4. After the deadline expires, remedy the problem yourself and keep all receipts.
  5. Back home, submit your claims in writing, with receipts and the confirmation of your report.

Frequently asked questions

Is it enough to tell the reception desk?

Usually not. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, hotel operators are not responsible unless the tour operator’s terms and conditions provide for it.

What if the hotel food makes me ill?

For gastrointestinal illnesses caused by the catering, there is a price reduction and damages, according to the Verbraucherzentrale. Proof is difficult, but many affected guests support your case.

What happens if the tour operator goes bankrupt?

Then the insolvency protection provider steps in, often the Deutscher Reisesicherungsfonds (German travel insolvency fund). The security certificate (Sicherungsschein) serves as proof.

I canceled before the trip. Does this apply?

No, in that case it is about cancellation fees. More on this in the guide Canceling a package holiday.

Frequently asked questions

What counts as a travel defect on a package holiday?

For example, construction noise the tour operator did not warn you about, a closed pool, no room cleaning during a strike, or a worse replacement accommodation after overbooking. Not defects: noise from the hotel's own disco, occasional insects in southern countries, or circumstances such as a lack of snow and storms.

Is it enough to report the defect at the reception desk?

Usually not. According to the German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale), hotel operators are not responsible unless the tour operator's terms and conditions provide for it. Report the defect to the tour guide or the tour operator, in writing and with witnesses or a confirmation. If no tour guide can be reached, call the tour operator in Germany.

How much money do I get back for travel defects?

There is no fixed rate. Under Section 651m of the German Civil Code (BGB), the price is reduced in proportion to the value of the defect-free trip compared with its actual value, and only for the duration of the defect. As a guide, the Verbraucherzentrale cites the Frankfurter Tabelle, the Kemptener Reisemängeltabelle and the ADAC table.

May I remedy the problem myself if the tour operator does not respond?

Yes, once a deadline has expired. Section 651k BGB then allows you to remedy the problem yourself and claim back the necessary costs, for example for comparable accommodation. A deadline is not required if the tour operator refuses to provide a remedy or immediate action is needed. Keep all receipts.

Do I have to accept a replacement room?

Only if it is equivalent or better and reasonable. If you accept it, the price reduction for the remedied defects no longer applies. So document precisely beforehand how the replacement differs from the room you booked.

How long do I have to assert claims for travel defects?

Under Section 651j BGB, claims only become time-barred two years after the agreed end of the trip. Assert them in writing and in a verifiable way, for example by email or by registered mail, with receipts and the confirmation of your defect report on site.

Sources

Where to buy

Shop in:

Sale, delivery, warranty and product safety are the sole responsibility of the respective retailer and manufacturer. All information without guarantee; prices and availability may change.

Links marked as affiliate links earn us a small commission if you buy through them. The price stays the same for you, and our verdict stays independent.