Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A projector screen is almost always bought by size. What really matters, though, is where the projector sits. If you run an ultra-short-throw projector on a TV stand, you need a contrast screen made for exactly that design, such as the Elite Screens Aeon CLR 3 or the celexon CLR HomeCinema UST V2.0. If a classic projector hangs from the ceiling, on the other hand, these screens are useless. Then a white or gray frame screen belongs on the wall.
Why the projector chooses the screen
A short-throw unit sits just a few centimeters in front of the wall and casts its light steeply upward from below. The contrast screens for it are called CLR, which stands for „Ceiling Light Rejecting.“ Their surface has a fine, sawtooth-like structure. Light arriving at an angle from below is directed toward the sofa. Light from above, that is, from ceiling lamps, is mostly absorbed. Elite Screens puts this at around 90 percent of ceiling light for the Aeon CLR 3.
That leads to a hard rule. A screen like this only works in one direction. In the manual for its CLR frame screen, celexon states explicitly that the projector must always sit below the screen. Elite advises against simply hanging the screen upside down for a ceiling projector. The ceiling light would then be reflected instead of absorbed.
The reverse is true, too. Put a white screen in front of a laser TV and in daylight you get a washed-out picture with gray blacks. And a normal ceiling-mounted projector hits the wrong side of the microstructure on a CLR screen. So ask yourself first: where does my device sit? Only after that do the inches come into play. Which short-throw projectors are available is covered in our projector guide to 4K, laser and short throw (in German).
Gain, gray and format: the three numbers on the spec sheet
Gain describes how brightly a screen reflects light, measured against a matte white reference surface with a value of 1.0. Higher values look brighter in the center of the image but can narrow the zone in which the picture looks even. Whether that is the case shows in the viewing angle on the spec sheet. The gray Elite CineGrey 3D, for example, reaches a gain of 1.2 with a viewing angle of only 90 degrees, according to the manufacturer. If you look at it from the side, you see a darker picture.
Contrast screens for short throw are almost always below 1. That sounds like a loss. And in absolute terms, it is. But because the distracting room light is dampened much more strongly than the image, the result still looks clearer in a bright living room. For the Aeon CLR 3 in ambient light, Elite cites up to 75 times the contrast of a matte white screen, a manufacturer figure from its own measurements.
The format is simpler: 16:9 for movies, series and sports. The wide cinema format 2.35:1 is only worth it if you watch almost nothing but feature films and can live with black bars for everything else. 4:3 and 1:1 are office tools.
Then the size, worked out. A 100-inch screen in 16:9 format measures about 221 by 125 centimeters, a 120-inch screen 266 by 149 centimeters. Elite recommends placing the wall brackets of its frames at least 10 to 15 centimeters below the ceiling so the frame can be hooked in. In an older building with a ceiling height of 2.40 meters, a 120-inch image then starts only 70 to 75 centimeters above the floor. Tight. Whether a short-throw projector on a TV stand fits that is revealed in its manual: it states how far above the top edge of the unit the image begins.
Frame, roll-up or tripod?
A frame keeps the screen permanently taut. With contrast screens that is a must, because every ripple distorts the way the light is directed. A roll-up screen disappears when the TV is needed. A tripod is meant for the garden, a community hall and occasional movie nights. For short-throw projectors, roll-up screens and tripods are practically ruled out: Elite approves the roll-up and tripod models in this comparison only for projectors with a normal throw distance.
Six projector screens compared
| Model | Design | Gain / viewing angle | Suitable projector | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elite Screens Aeon CLR 3 | Frame, almost borderless | 0.8 / 170° | ultra-short throw only, placed below | Living room with a laser TV and light from above |
| celexon CLR HomeCinema UST V2.0 | Frame, 15 mm border | 0.5 / up to 170° | ultra-short throw only | Laser TV when children or pets are nearby |
| Elite Screens Sable Frame 2 | Frame with velvet border | 1.3 / 180° | all designs | darkened home theater |
| Elite Screens Sable Frame CineGrey 3D | Frame with velvet border | 1.2 / 90° | normal throw only | Ceiling projector in a room with some residual light |
| Elite Screens Manual | Roll-up, wall or ceiling | 1.1 / 180° | normal throw only | Living room where the TV stays |
| Elite Screens Tripod | Tripod with bag | 1.1 / 180° | normal throw only | Garden, club, office |
All values according to the manufacturer; for celexon, according to the product description at retail. Not every size is available from every retailer.
Elite Screens Aeon CLR 3
The Aeon CLR 3 is tailored to laser TVs in the living room. A gain of 0.8 and a 170-degree viewing angle mean that even the seats at the ends of the sofa see an even picture. The frame sits behind the screen, leaving only a border of about one centimeter visible. Elite itself points out that the steep beam of a short-throw projector can create a bright halo around the frame. A darker wall or a velvet strip softens it. It does not disappear completely. According to the manufacturer, the surface requires particular care when cleaning.
celexon CLR HomeCinema UST V2.0
With a gain of 0.5, celexon goes one step further toward contrast. Toward the edge, the value drops to a maximum of 0.4, according to the product description. So the screen needs a bright projector. In return, according to the product description, it is waterproof, can be wiped with a damp cloth and is coated against mold, a real argument in households with children. The border measures 15 millimeters, and the 92-inch version weighs 15 kilograms. The manual calls for two people for assembly, prohibits alcohol and solvent-based cleaners, and advises against locations next to a radiator or air conditioner.
Elite Screens Sable Frame 2
A classic home theater, shutters down, projector on the ceiling: that is what the Sable Frame 2 is built for. According to Elite, the white CineWhite UHD-B material has a gain of 1.3, a 180-degree viewing angle and a black back against light shining through. The velvet border, about six centimeters wide, absorbs light that falls beyond the image area. The wall brackets can be slid sideways, which makes alignment easier. In a bright living room, this screen is the wrong choice.
Elite Screens Sable Frame CineGrey 3D
The gray version is a compromise for rooms that never get completely dark. According to the manufacturer, it rejects around 65 percent of ceiling light and reaches a gain of 1.2. In return, you accept the narrow viewing angle of 90 degrees. On a wide corner sofa, the outer seats see a darker picture. It is not approved for short-throw projectors. According to Elite, the screen is easy to clean.
Elite Screens Manual
The roll-up screen hangs on the wall or ceiling and locks every two centimeters as you pull it out. The MaxWhite 2 material has a gain of 1.1 and a 180-degree viewing angle, with a black border all around. Elite advises rolling the screen back up after the movie. If you leave it pulled out for weeks, you risk the material coming loose from the roller, and according to the manufacturer that is not covered by the warranty. It is not suitable as a sunshade in front of a window, either.
Elite Screens Tripod
A tripod with a bag, extendable, with the same material as the roll-up screen. A built-in keystone correction mechanism helps when the projector sits lower than the center of the image. It is meant for a summer evening in the garden or a talk at the clubhouse, not for a permanent home theater. If you first need a small projector for that, you will find suggestions in our guide to mini projectors.
How we would decide
- Laser TV in the living room, ceiling lights on: Elite Screens Aeon CLR 3; with a very bright projector and children in the house, the celexon CLR V2.0.
- Home theater in a darkened room: Elite Screens Sable Frame 2.
- Ceiling projector, but never completely dark: Sable Frame CineGrey 3D, provided everyone sits close in front of the screen.
- The TV stays, the projector comes out on weekends: the Elite Screens Manual roll-up screen.
- Outdoors or changing locations: the tripod.
One last tip. With short-throw projectors, the projector sits exactly where the soundbar would otherwise go. Plan both together; tips on that are in our soundbar guide (in German).
When a large TV replaces the projector is covered in our guide to the 85-inch TV (in German).
What a TV stand, wall distance and screen require for a laser TV is worked out in our guide to the ultra-short-throw projector.
What residual light does to contrast and what a curtain achieves is explained in our guide to the projector in a bright living room.
Why the HDMI input on the projector matters more than ARC is explained in our guide to the soundbar with a projector (in German).
Frequently asked questions
What is a CLR screen?
CLR stands for Ceiling Light Rejecting. The surface has a fine, sawtooth-like structure: light arriving at an angle from below is directed toward the sofa, while light from ceiling lamps is mostly absorbed. Elite Screens puts this at around 90 percent of ceiling light for the Aeon CLR 3. But it only works in one direction.
Can you use a CLR screen with a ceiling-mounted projector?
No. celexon states explicitly in its manual that the projector must always sit below the screen. Elite also advises against hanging the screen upside down for a ceiling projector, because the ceiling light would then be reflected instead of absorbed. A ceiling projector belongs in front of a white or gray screen.
What does gain mean for a projector screen?
Gain describes how brightly a screen reflects light, measured against a matte white reference surface with a value of 1.0. Higher values look brighter in the center but can narrow the viewing angle. The gray Elite CineGrey 3D, for example, reaches a gain of 1.2 with a viewing angle of only 90 degrees. Contrast screens for short throw are almost always below 1.
What screen size fits my living room?
A 100-inch screen in 16:9 format measures about 221 by 125 centimeters, a 120-inch screen 266 by 149 centimeters. Elite recommends placing the wall brackets at least 10 to 15 centimeters below the ceiling. With a ceiling height of 2.40 meters, a 120-inch image then starts only 70 to 75 centimeters above the floor.
Frame screen, roll-up screen or tripod?
A frame keeps the screen permanently taut, which is a must for contrast screens. A roll-up screen disappears when the TV is needed, but should be rolled back up after the movie. A tripod is meant for the garden, clubs and occasional movie nights. For short-throw projectors, roll-up screens and tripods are practically ruled out.
Which screen format makes sense?
For movies, series and sports, 16:9 is the right fit. The wide cinema format 2.35:1 is only worth it if you watch almost nothing but feature films and do not mind black bars with everything else. 4:3 and 1:1 are office tools.
Sources
- Elite Screens: Aeon CLR 3
- Elite Screens: Comparison of CLR and ALR frame screens (PDF)
- Elite Screens: Sable Frame 2
- Elite Screens: Manual
- Elite Screens: Tripod, spec sheet (PDF)
- celexon: User manual for the CLR HomeCinema UST frame screen V2.0
- visunext: celexon CLR HomeCinema UST V2.0, product description (retailer information)
Where to buy
- Elite Screens Aeon CLR 3 (100 Zoll, 222 x 125 cm)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- celexon CLR HomeCinema UST Rahmenleinwand V2.0Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Elite Screens Sable Frame 2Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Elite Screens Sable Frame CineGrey 3DCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Elite Screens Manual M100XWHCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Elite Screens Tripod T100UWHCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
