Contents14 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Tap water in Germany does not need a filter. That is the view of the German Environment Agency and the German consumer advice centers, and ours too. If you still want to filter, for example because of limescale in your tea, a small pitcher kept in the refrigerator is the most sensible choice. Under-sink systems and reverse osmosis cost more and need maintenance.
Do I need a filter at all?
Usually not. In its guide „Trinkwasser aus dem Hahn“ („Drinking water from the tap“), the German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) writes that additional purification or treatment inside the building of water from the public supply is not necessary in normal cases. The agency goes even further and advises against such devices. Its reasoning: bacteria can multiply in filters that are not replaced in time, and overloaded filters can release retained substances again, in the worst case even in higher concentrations.
The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) also considers filters unnecessary from a health perspective, including for young children and people who are ill. Hard water is no argument against this. The German Environment Agency regards calcium and magnesium as positive, not as a burden. According to the consumer advice center, Stiftung Warentest, the German consumer testing organization, summed up a test of eight filters in July 2022 as „superfluous to harmful.“
Old lead pipes are a special case. No filter helps here. The German Environment Agency requires the pipes to be replaced completely; until then, pregnant women, infants and children up to six years old should drink bottled water. According to the consumer advice center, houses built after 1973 no longer have lead pipes. If you are unsure, ask your landlord or have the water tested.
So why do so many people filter anyway?
For convenience. At 20 °dH (degrees of German hardness), a white layer quickly builds up in the electric kettle, and tea gets a film on its surface. It makes no difference to your health; it is just annoying. A cartridge with an ion exchanger reduces hardness, and activated carbon binds the taste of chlorine. Anyone who wants to „energize“ or „harmonize“ water is selling esoterica. According to the consumer advice center, such terms have no scientific basis.
If your concern is the coffee machine, first check whether it has its own filter cartridge in the tank. Many do; see our overview of fully automatic espresso machines (in German). And if all you want is sparkling water, you do not need a filter but a countertop soda maker (in German).
Pitcher, under-sink filter or reverse osmosis: what is the difference?
The pitcher is the simplest route. Pour water in at the top, it runs through the cartridge, done. No installation, no plumber, and after four weeks a new cartridge goes in.
An under-sink filter sits in the sink cabinet on the cold water angle valve and works with larger cartridges that last several months. In return, you are interfering with the drinking water installation. Under the German water supply regulation AVBWasserV, significant work may only be carried out by the water utility or registered installation companies, the consumer advice center points out. It also recommends devices with a DVGW (German gas and water association) or DIN test mark.
Reverse osmosis is the most thorough and at the same time the most controversial option. A membrane separates out dissolved substances, including the minerals. That is why manufacturers such as Waterdrop offer their own models with remineralization. On top of that, it produces wastewater. For normal tap water, we consider it overkill.
How quickly does a cartridge become contaminated with germs?
Faster than many people think. Drinking water is a perishable food, writes the consumer advice center. Germs can grow in it if it stands in a container for a long time or comes into contact with old filters. Its advice for pitchers: follow the instructions, change the cartridge regularly, clean the pitcher regularly and store it in the refrigerator. A pitcher on a sunny windowsill is exactly the opposite.
One more point from the German Environment Agency’s guide that applies even without a filter. Water that has stood in the pipes for more than four hours should not be drunk or used for cooking; let it run until it comes out noticeably cooler. In the morning, that applies to filling the pitcher too.
How much do filters cost in the long run?
The purchase price is misleading. Calculate over two years. For a pitcher with a four-week cartridge, that comes to around 26 cartridges. An under-sink filter changed every four months needs six. With the Waterdrop reverse osmosis system, according to the manufacturer, three filter types with service lives of six, twelve and 24 months add up. And with Grohe Blue Home, CO₂ cylinders are part of the consumables alongside the filter; according to Grohe, a 425-gram cylinder is enough for a maximum of 60 liters of sparkling water. Pitchers cost little. Under-sink filters sit in the middle of the price range, while reverse osmosis systems and filter faucets with a chiller play in a different league.
Which devices are currently available?
| Model | Type | Key data (manufacturer specs) | Filter change | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BRITA Style Essential | Pitcher | 2.4 l total, 1.4 l filtered, LED change indicator | approx. 4 weeks or 150 l | Singles and couples, fits in the refrigerator door |
| BRITA Style Essential XL | Pitcher | 3.6 l total, 2.3 l filtered | approx. 4 weeks or 150 l | Families with room in the refrigerator |
| Dafi filter pitcher with Unimax cartridge | Pitcher | Cartridge with activated carbon from coconut shells | monthly or 150–200 l | If you are looking for an alternative to Brita |
| Alb Filter Active Plus under-sink | Under-sink filter | Stainless steel housing, germ barrier down to 0.7 µm, approx. 6 l/min | 4 months, 3,000–5,000 l | Lots of drinking water, no carrying pitchers around |
| Waterdrop G3P600 | Reverse osmosis, tankless | 600 gallons per day, pure water to wastewater 2:1 | 6, 12 and 24 months per filter stage | If you deliberately want low-mineral water |
| GROHE Blue Home Starter Kit | Filter faucet with chiller and CO₂ | still, medium and sparkling, chilled | S-size filter 600 l, at least every 12 months | If you are replacing the kitchen faucet anyway |
BRITA Style Essential
The smaller pitcher has an advantage that has to do with hygiene. At 23.9 by 27.3 centimeters, according to Brita it fits in a typical refrigerator door and therefore actually ends up in the cold. According to the manufacturer, the included Maxtra Pro Pure Performance is intended for soft to medium-hard water. For hard water, Brita sells a version with extra limescale protection. The LED in the lid has to come out before the pitcher goes in the dishwasher.
BRITA Style Essential XL
Same cartridge, more volume. 2.3 liters of filtered water is better suited to four people. According to retailer information, it no longer fits in the door and needs a spot on a shelf.
Dafi filter pitcher with Unimax cartridge
Polish manufacturer Dafi makes pitchers in several sizes, all of which use the Unimax cartridge. Dafi states 150 to 200 liters per cartridge and a monthly change, with activated carbon from coconut shells as the filter material. Dafi also offers a magnesium cartridge. We are skeptical of its benefit.
Alb Filter Active Plus under-sink
This filter from Baden-Württemberg comes in a stainless steel housing and is connected to the cold water supply under the sink. According to Alb, the Active Plus cartridge has a germ barrier down to 0.7 micrometers and lasts 3,000 to 5,000 liters. It is nevertheless replaced after four months, mainly for hygiene reasons according to the manufacturer. We like that honesty. One buyer, however, reports a declining flow rate after only three months.
Waterdrop G3P600
A tankless reverse osmosis system for the sink cabinet. Waterdrop states two parts pure water to one part wastewater, or less depending on pressure and temperature. According to retailer information, it significantly reduces the proportion of dissolved substances. If you want to keep the minerals, choose the version with remineralization.
GROHE Blue Home Starter Kit
Essentially a kitchen faucet with a second water channel. The chiller sits in the sink cabinet or up to 2.5 meters away; according to Grohe, even a 40-centimeter-wide base cabinet is enough. The S-size filter handles 600 liters and should be replaced at least every twelve months. This only becomes interesting if a new faucet is due anyway. For sparkling water alone, a countertop device is enough.
How we would decide
- You like the taste of your tap water and the limescale does not bother you: no filter.
- Limescale in the kettle, off taste in your tea, single or couple: BRITA Style Essential, kept in the refrigerator door.
- Larger household with plenty of room in the refrigerator: the XL version.
- Already going through three pitchers a day: an under-sink filter such as the one from Alb Filter, installed by a plumber.
- New kitchen and a wish for chilled sparkling water from the tap: Grohe Blue Home.
- Reverse osmosis only with a specific reason, not out of worry about tap water.
Loose-leaf teas we brew regularly are described in our long-term family test of teas from TeeGschwendner.
Frequently asked questions
Do you need a water filter in Germany?
Usually not. The German Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt) considers additional treatment of water from the public supply unnecessary in normal cases and even advises against such devices. The German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale) also considers filters unnecessary from a health perspective, including for young children and people who are ill. Calcium and magnesium are regarded as positive.
Can a water filter be harmful?
It is possible. According to the German Environment Agency, bacteria can multiply in filters that are not replaced in time, and overloaded filters can release retained substances again. The consumer advice center recommends changing the cartridge regularly, cleaning the pitcher and storing it in the refrigerator.
Does a filter help against lead from old pipes?
No. With lead pipes, the German Environment Agency requires the pipes to be replaced completely. Until then, pregnant women, infants and children up to six years old should drink bottled water. According to the consumer advice center, houses built after 1973 no longer have lead pipes.
What is the difference between a pitcher, an under-sink filter and reverse osmosis?
A pitcher needs no installation, and the cartridge is changed after four weeks. An under-sink filter sits on the cold water angle valve and lasts several months; installation is a job for a plumber. Reverse osmosis uses a membrane that also removes the minerals and produces wastewater; for normal tap water, we consider it overkill.
How much does a water filter cost in the long run?
The purchase price is misleading; it is better to calculate over two years. A pitcher with a four-week cartridge needs around 26 cartridges in that time, an under-sink filter changed every four months needs six. Reverse osmosis systems add several filter stages, and Grohe Blue Home also needs CO₂ cylinders.
Which filter pitcher fits in the refrigerator door?
According to Brita, the BRITA Style Essential measures 23.9 by 27.3 centimeters and therefore fits in a typical refrigerator door; it filters 1.4 liters. The XL version with 2.3 liters is better suited to four people but needs a spot on a shelf.
Sources
- German Environment Agency: Drinking water from the tap (guide, German)
- Verbraucherzentrale: Water filters – are they necessary from a hygiene perspective? (German)
- Verbraucherzentrale: Water treatment in the household (German)
- BRITA: Style Essential
- BRITA: Style Essential XL
- BRITA: Maxtra Pro Pure Performance
- Dafi: Unimax cartridge
- Alb Filter: Active Plus
- Waterdrop: G3P600
- GROHE: Blue replacement filter S-size
- GROHE: Blue Home brochure
Where to buy
- BRITA Style EssentialCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- BRITA Style Essential XLCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Dafi Filterkanne mit Unimax-KartuscheCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Alb Filter Active Plus UntertischCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Waterdrop G3P600Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- GROHE Blue Home Starter KitCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
