Contents12 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
Twelve chisels in a case look like a complete kit. At the workbench, though, it is always the same three or four that end up in use. If you are looking for a chisel set, pay attention to steel, handle and the right widths first, and only after that to the number of pieces. For getting started with wood joinery, we consider the six-piece set 1101 from Kirschen the most sensible start: six widths from 6 to 26 mm, 61 HRC according to the manufacturer, hornbeam handles and a wooden box.
What the hardness number tells you, and what it does not
HRC stands for Rockwell hardness. For the chisels in this guide, it ranges between 59 and 62. That does not sound like much of a spread. In reality, it is a trade-off: a harder edge stays sharp longer but takes more patience to hone and is less forgiving of sideways prying in the joint.
Narex specifies 62 HRC for the Richter line and, after hardening, cools the blades with liquid nitrogen to as low as −190 °C. According to the manufacturer, this increases hardness and toughness at the same time. Kirschen states 61 HRC, and specifically over two-thirds of the usable blade. That is not a footnote. Every chisel gets a little shorter with each regrinding, and only after years do you reach the softer remainder.
When it comes to the steel itself, each manufacturer goes its own way. Kirschen speaks of high-carbon tool steel; Narex uses forged chrome-manganese steel for the Wood Premium line and chrome-vanadium for Richter. Pfeil has its steel made specifically for its workshop in Langenthal and hardens its Schreiner-Stechbeitel (cabinetmaker’s chisels) to 59 to 60 HRC. Stanley describes hardened and tempered chrome-carbon steel; the brand does not give a Rockwell number for the Dynagrip set.
Six widths are enough if they are the right ones
A set with 6, 12, 20 and 26 mm covers chopping out mortises, cleaning up rabbets and chamfering edges. Without the narrow 6 mm blade, every tight mortise becomes a test of patience. In-between sizes such as 10 and 16 mm help when joints need to match one exact width.
Also pay attention to the measuring system. The Narex Richter chisels measure 6, 10, 13, 19 and 25 mm, which are inch widths. That suits plans in inches, not necessarily metric router bits and drill bits. Widths over 26 mm are more for surfaces and long chamfers; you will hardly need them in your first set.
Handle and striking: wood, plastic or steel cap
A chisel gets pushed, pressed and struck. The handle has to withstand all three. Kirschen relies on hornbeam with a striking ring and ferrule, Narex on stained hornbeam with a brass ferrule or, for Richter, on ash with a stainless steel ferrule and a leather washer meant to cushion hammer blows. Pfeil shapes octagonal elm handles with an oval cross-section. If you want to work with a steel hammer, only Stanley gives explicit approval: the Dynagrip handle, made of two plastics, has a steel cap on top. In our view, wooden handles call for a wooden mallet.
Five chisel sets and individual chisels compared
| Model | Widths | Steel and hardness (manufacturer specs) | Handle | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kirschen chisel set 1101 | 6, 10, 12, 16, 20, 26 mm | Tool steel, 61 HRC over two-thirds of the blade | Hornbeam, striking ring, ferrule | Getting started with furniture making and wood joinery |
| Narex Wood Premium, 4-piece | 6, 12, 20, 26 mm | Chrome-manganese steel, forged, 59 HRC | Stained hornbeam, brass ferrule | A first kit with just a few widths |
| Narex Richter, 5-piece | 6, 10, 13, 19, 25 mm | Chrome-vanadium, cryogenically treated, 62 HRC | Ash, stainless steel ferrule, leather washer | Fine work in hardwood, plans in inches |
| Pfeil Schreiner-Stechbeitel | individually from 4 to 40 mm | Special steel, 59 to 60 HRC, 25° with micro-bevel | Elm, octagonal, oiled | Dovetails, tight corners, your own selection |
| Stanley Dynagrip 2-16-885 | 6, 12, 18, 25, 32 mm | Chrome-carbon steel, no HRC specified | Two-component handle with steel cap | Renovation, doors, work with a steel hammer |
Kirschen 1101: six widths in a wooden box
According to Kirschen, the blades are polished and beveled on the sides, ground to 25° at the factory. The manufacturer recommends this angle for soft to medium-hard wood. The box measures 315 × 205 × 45 mm. That works well for pine, spruce and beech. Every width in the box has a job; there are no fillers. On Amazon, set 1101 is currently not on offer (as of November 9, 2026). Set 1108 has the same six widths in a wooden box, according to the listing also with 61 HRC and a 25° grind, but with a two-component handle instead of hornbeam.
Narex Wood Premium: four chisels to start with
At 59 HRC, the Narex set is somewhat softer than Kirschen. That need not be a drawback, because the edge can be honed again more quickly. According to the manufacturer, the sides are ground particularly thin, which helps in corners. Narex also offers the same set in 8, 10, 16 and 32 mm. For a first kit, we would take the version with 6 mm.
Narex Richter: harder, finer, in inches
With Richter, Narex goes to even greater lengths. Chrome-vanadium, 62 HRC, a cold treatment after hardening, finely ground and polished sides. The five chisels come in a wooden case. If you cut dovetails in oak or walnut, you will benefit from the edge life. For occasionally fitting a door frame, the set is more tool than you need.
Pfeil Schreiner-Stechbeitel: choose them one by one
The Swiss workshop grinds the sides down deeply along the entire length of the blade. That makes it easier to work out corners. From the factory, the edge has 25° with a micro-bevel, and the flat back is ground flat. Pfeil makes widths from 4 to 40 mm. Our suggestion: buy two or three widths deliberately, say 6, 12 and 20 mm, instead of a set with pieces that just sit in the box.
Stanley Dynagrip: for the job site and the steel hammer
Stanley makes the set in Sheffield. The blades are kept short, which according to the manufacturer benefits power and control, and they are lacquered against rust. Each chisel comes with a blade guard. For mortising lock cases or reworking a door frame, that makes sense. We would not cut fine dovetails in hardwood with it.
Sharp from the factory does not mean sharp forever
Kirschen, Narex and Pfeil ship their chisels ground. After a few hours in hardwood, though, the edge still needs care. Honing on a stone is usually enough; regrind only when the bevel is visibly damaged. The flat back should stay flat in the process, otherwise the chisel will not track cleanly along the scribed line.
In its catalog, Pfeil warns of one mistake in dry grinding. If the steel at the edge turns yellow, blue or gray, it has gone soft there. The discolored section has to be ground away completely. According to Pfeil, a water-cooled grinder is preferable to a dry grinder. For the angle, it is best to stick with the 25° that Kirschen and Pfeil ship with.
Storage matters, too. Kirschen and Pfeil recommend a thin film of oil against rust. Pfeil suggests a tool roll, wooden box or wall rack; tools should not fall or knock against each other, to avoid damaged edges and injuries. So a chisel has no business lying loose in the toolbox. If you are just setting up your workshop, the guide to choosing a workbench (in German) has advice on height and clamping options. For clean tenons and slots before chopping, the guide to Japanese saws helps. For flat stock to start from, take a look at our guide to jointer-planers.
How we would decide
- You are starting out with tenons, rabbets and simple furniture: Kirschen 1101 with six metric widths. As long as it is not offered on Amazon, we would take set 1108 with the same widths in a wooden box and a two-component handle.
- You would like to start with just a few chisels: Narex Wood Premium in 6, 12, 20 and 26 mm.
- You work a lot in hardwood and from inch-based plans: Narex Richter, if the longer edge life is worth honing the hard edge to you.
- You only want the widths you really need: Pfeil Schreiner-Stechbeitel, bought individually.
- You renovate, install doors and strike with a steel hammer: Stanley Dynagrip.
Frequently asked questions
Which widths does a chisel set need?
A set with 6, 12, 20 and 26 mm covers mortises, rabbets and chamfers. Without the narrow 6 mm blade, every tight mortise becomes a test of patience. In-between sizes such as 10 and 16 mm help when joints need to match one exact width.
What does the HRC hardness tell you about chisels?
HRC stands for Rockwell hardness, which ranges from 59 to 62 for the chisels in this comparison. A harder edge stays sharp longer but takes more patience to hone and is less forgiving of sideways prying. Kirschen states 61 HRC over two-thirds of the usable blade.
Can you strike chisels with a steel hammer?
In this comparison, only Stanley explicitly allows it: the Dynagrip handle, made of two plastics, has a steel cap on top. In our view, wooden handles like those from Kirschen, Narex or Pfeil call for a wooden mallet.
What should you keep in mind with the Narex Richter chisels?
They measure 6, 10, 13, 19 and 25 mm, which are inch widths. That suits plans in inches, not necessarily metric router bits and drill bits. With 62 HRC and cryogenic treatment, they are mainly worth it for fine work in hardwoods such as oak or walnut.
How do you sharpen chisels properly?
Honing on a stone is usually enough; regrind only when the bevel is visibly damaged. The flat back has to stay flat. If the steel turns yellow, blue or gray during dry grinding, it has gone soft there, according to Pfeil, and must be ground away. Stick to 25° for the angle.
How should you store chisels?
Kirschen and Pfeil recommend a thin film of oil against rust. Pfeil suggests a tool roll, wooden box or wall rack so the tools do not fall or knock against each other. A chisel has no business lying loose in the toolbox.
Sources
- Kirschen: Chisel set in wooden box 1101000
- Narex (Mikov): Wood Premium 4-piece, 6 to 26 mm
- Narex (Mikov): Richter 5-piece in wooden case
- Pfeil: Catalog with cabinetmaker’s chisels, care and sharpening
- Pfeil: Quality and manufacturing
- Stanley: Dynagrip Wood Chisel Set 2-16-885
Where to buy
- Kirschen Stechbeitelsatz 1108 (Holzkasten, 2K-Heft)Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Kirschen Stechbeitelsatz 1101Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Narex Wood Premium, 4-teiligCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Narex Richter Stechbeitel 5-teiligCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Pfeil Schreiner-StechbeitelCheck price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
- Stanley Dynagrip 2-16-885Check price at Amazon.deCheck price at Amazon.co.ukCheck price at Amazon.nlCheck price at Amazon.com.beCheck price at Amazon.frCheck price at Amazon.itCheck price at Amazon.esCheck price at Amazon.plCheck price at Amazon.seAvailable in Germany: Amazon.de
