Contents10 sections
This guide was first published in German on handgetestet.de.
A large back payment hurts, and a large credit is money that sat with your supplier for a year. You can avoid both if you check the annual bill and set your monthly payment correctly. According to the German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale), some errors can be spotted simply from missing information.
What has to be on the bill
If the supplier’s address, the opening or closing meter reading or the price information is missing, an error is very likely. Compare the standing charge and the price per kilowatt-hour with your contract confirmation or the last letter about a price change. Use your bank statements to check whether all monthly payments have been credited. And compare consumption with the previous year. If it jumps sharply for no apparent reason, for example when nothing has changed in the household, it is worth asking the supplier for a detailed explanation and, if necessary, having the meter checked.
For gas, a rule of thumb from the Verbraucherzentrale helps: cubic meters times ten gives you roughly the kilowatt-hours. Errors are easiest to spot if you note down the meter readings regularly, for example once a month.
| Bill | No later than | Due at the earliest | Credit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electricity: annual bill | six weeks after the end of the period | two weeks after receipt | have it paid out immediately on request |
| Gas: annual bill | six weeks after the end of the period | two weeks after receipt | have it paid out immediately on request |
Estimated instead of read?
A bill is supposed to be based on actual meter readings. The supplier may only estimate in exceptional cases, for example if no one was able to read the meter, the self-reading was not submitted or the meter was defective. Estimated values must be highlighted, and the reason and basis for the estimate must be stated alongside them. Is the estimate too high? Then simply report the actual meter reading, ideally with a photo of the meter in which the date and meter number can be seen, so that the supplier can correct the bill without further queries.
But be careful. According to the German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof), an impermissible estimate alone does not entitle you to refuse the entire bill. You may only withhold the part that is overcharged.
Wrong bill: how to file a complaint
Pay first. Pay the disputed part expressly under reservation; that way you keep your right to reclaim it. File your complaint in writing, ideally by registered mail, with your customer and invoice numbers. Give the supplier a deadline of at least four weeks. Claims normally become time-barred after three years. The period begins at the earliest when the bill falls due, that is, two weeks after you receive it.
Setting the monthly payment correctly
The supplier sets the monthly payment, and it must be based on your most recent annual consumption. Do the math yourself: annual consumption times the unit price, plus the standing charge for the year, divided by twelve. If your consumption has credibly decreased, for example because someone has moved out, the supplier must adjust the payment. But do not reduce it on your own; that can lead to default and interest. Instead, request the adjustment in writing with a deadline.
Consumption suddenly twice as high?
An inexplicable jump (the Verbraucherzentrale gives ten times the previous year’s consumption as an example) can be grounds for partially refusing payment. For basic supply (the default tariff), this right is set out in law; for special contracts, it depends on the terms and conditions. The Verbraucherzentrale advises getting legal advice beforehand and paying at least your previous average consumption.
If consumption is more than double the previous year’s, you can request an official meter inspection (Befundprüfung). If it finds no fault, you bear the costs. The right to refuse payment then only applies until the inspection is complete. So do the math beforehand. Thoroughly.
Bill not arriving? Credit not paid?
The supplier must issue the annual bill no later than six weeks after the end of the billing period, as set out in Section 40c of the German Energy Industry Act (EnWG). A billing period may cover a maximum of one year. The same six weeks apply to the final bill after switching suppliers.
And if nothing arrives? Send a written reminder with a deadline of at least four weeks. The Verbraucherzentrale suggests announcing in the same letter that you will stop making further monthly payments. The supplier must offset a credit in full against the next monthly payment or pay it out within two weeks, and always pay it out with a final bill. If a promised bonus is missing, follow up. The supplier’s terms are what count.
If the supplier does not give in
Under Section 111a EnWG, the supplier must respond to complaints within four weeks. If it does not resolve the issue, it must state its reasons in text form and refer you to the Schlichtungsstelle Energie (the German energy arbitration board). There, the procedure is free of charge for private consumers, and the supplier must take part. Only for obviously abusive applications may the consumer be charged a fee, of no more than 30 euros. The route to court still remains open. Arbitration is not a waiver.
Step by step through the annual bill
- Compare the opening and closing meter readings with your own notes or photos.
- Check the standing charge and unit price against your contract or the last price notice.
- Match the monthly payments made against your bank statements.
- Check consumption against the previous year; for gas, multiply cubic meters by ten.
- Look for estimated values. They must be highlighted and justified.
- Recalculate the new monthly payment and, if necessary, request an adjustment in writing.
Frequently asked questions
May I pay nothing at all if the bill is estimated?
No. According to the Bundesgerichtshof (ruling of October 16, 2013, VIII ZR 243/12), you may only withhold the part that is overcharged.
Can the supplier later charge more if the estimate was too low?
Yes. According to the Verbraucherzentrale, with estimated consumption you must expect a correction throughout the entire limitation period.
Do I have to accept the estimate if I was not at home?
You can request an explanation in text form and set a deadline of four weeks for it. Then read the meter yourself, ideally with a photo or witnesses, and submit the reading.
How often should I read the meter?
The Verbraucherzentrale suggests once a month. That way, jumps are noticed early.
And what if the tariff is simply too expensive? Compare. How to avoid the typical pitfalls is explained in the guide Switching electricity suppliers. Where the electricity goes in your household is revealed by an energy meter.
What the new digital meter costs and when it is mandatory is explained in the guide Smart meters (in German).
When the supplier may raise the monthly payment is explained in the guide Monthly payment increased: what to do? (in German).
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell that an electricity bill is wrong?
If the supplier's address, the opening or closing meter reading or the price information is missing, an error is very likely, according to the German consumer advice center (Verbraucherzentrale). Also compare the prices with your contract or the last price notice, the monthly payments with your bank statements and consumption with the previous year.
May the supplier estimate my consumption?
Only in exceptional cases, for example if no one was able to read the meter, the self-reading was not submitted or the meter was defective. Estimated values must be highlighted, with the reason and basis given. If the estimate is too high, report the actual meter reading, ideally with a photo showing the date and meter number.
May I refuse to pay an incorrect bill?
Not entirely. According to the German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof), in the case of an impermissible estimate you may only withhold the part that is overcharged. Pay the disputed part expressly under reservation; that way your right to reclaim it is preserved. File a written complaint with your customer and invoice numbers.
What should I do if consumption is suddenly twice as high?
If it is more than double the previous year's, you can request an official meter inspection (Befundprüfung). If it finds no fault, you bear the costs. Before refusing to pay, the Verbraucherzentrale advises getting legal advice and paying at least your previous average consumption.
How do I calculate the right monthly payment?
Annual consumption times the unit price, plus the standing charge for the year, divided by twelve. If your consumption has credibly decreased, the supplier must adjust the payment. But do not reduce it on your own; that can lead to default and interest. Request the adjustment in writing with a deadline.
When must the annual bill arrive at the latest?
Under Section 40c of the German Energy Industry Act (EnWG), no later than six weeks after the end of the billing period, which may cover a maximum of one year. A credit must be offset against the next monthly payment or paid out within two weeks. If nothing arrives, send a written reminder with a deadline of at least four weeks.
Sources
- Verbraucherzentrale: Are your electricity or gas bill and monthly payments correct?
- Section 40c EnWG: Timing and due date of energy bills
- Section 111a EnWG: Consumer complaints
- Section 111b EnWG: Arbitration board
- Schlichtungsstelle Energie
Where to buy
- Strom: JahresabrechnungView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
- Gas: JahresabrechnungView at CHECK24Available in Germany: CHECK24
